Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 29(2) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 29(2) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a society claiming to represent agriculturists of villages in the Thiyagavalli Panchayat. The Government of Tamil Nadu issued G.O. Ms. No. 1986, Public Works Department, dated 8.8.1986, declaring that lands in the villages of Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu measuring 800.00.00 hectares out of a total 910.40.5 hectares were to be acquired for establishment of a Thermal Power Station by the first respondent Board. A draft scheme was published on 29.10.1986 under Section 29(2) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948, but no acquisition steps were taken and villagers continued to deal with their lands.

Certain land registrations were made by the third respondent in favour of a private company, M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd., by documents in January 2007. When a landowner (Thiru. Kennedy) presented a sale agreement dated 29.1.2007 in favour of the deponent to the affidavit, the third respondent refused registration citing a notice dated 23.10.2006 posted in its office, G.O. Ms. 1986 (8.8.1986) and a letter from the first respondent dated 8.9.2006. After a legal notice dated 1.2.2007, the fourth respondent communicated on 10.2.2007 that they had been advised to register only documents in favour of M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd.

On these averments, the petitioner filed a writ petition seeking certiorari and mandamus to quash the notice dated 23.10.2006 and the fourth respondent's letter dated 10.2.2007 and to direct the respondents to receive and register all documents presented for registration relating to the lands in Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu under the Registration Act. The writ petition was admitted on 26.4.2007 and an interim order directed the third respondent to register documents presented by the deponent to the affidavit. The State filed a counter-affidavit through the Inspector General of Registration. The second respondent tacitly admitted issuing orders to the third respondent not to consider conveyance deeds in light of communications from M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd. and the second respondent's office dated 21.11.2006 and 11.12.2006.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents could lawfully refuse to receive and register conveyance/sale documents executed by individual landowners in the villages of Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu and instead direct registration only in favour of M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd.
  2. Whether the impugned notice dated 23.10.2006 and the communication of 10.2.2007 (and related directions of the second respondent) had any legal basis under the Constitution, the Registration Act or any other statute, or whether they violated Article 300-A (right to property) and the rule of law.
  3. Whether, having regard to the Registration Act and any notifications thereunder (notably Section 22-A and G.O. Ms. 150, Commercial Taxes, dated 22.9.2000), the impugned directions could validly prevent registration of documents by private landowners in favour of parties other than the specified company.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner alleged that despite the 1986 G.O. and the draft scheme, no acquisition occurred and landowners continued to deal with their lands; yet respondents prevented registration of certain sale/transfer documents.
  • The petitioner contended that the third respondent refused to register a sale agreement (29.1.2007) presented by a landowner, relying on a notice (23.10.2006) and other communications, and that subsequent advice communicated on 10.2.2007 restricted registration only to documents in favour of M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd.
  • The petitioner sought writs of certiorari and mandamus to quash the notice and communications and to direct registration of all valid documents presented for registration under the Registration Act.

Respondents' Position (as reflected in the record)

  • The third respondent had affixed a notice dated 23.10.2006 and, in reply communications, stated that by virtue of proceedings of the second respondent (dated 11.12.2006) and G.O. Ms. No. 1986 (8.8.1986), the lands falling within the third respondent's jurisdiction were decided to be conveyed to M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd., and that only documents in favour of that company could be registered.
  • The fourth respondent, in communication dated 10.2.2007, informed the petitioner's counsel that they had been advised to register only documents in favour of M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd.
  • The second respondent tacitly admitted issuing orders to the third respondent directing non-consideration of conveyance deeds in light of communications from M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd. and office communications dated 21.11.2006 and 11.12.2006.
  • A counter-affidavit was filed by the Inspector General of Registration on behalf of the State; the content of that counter-affidavit is not described in the opinion excerpt.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bishambhar Dayal Chandra Mohan and others v. State of Uttar Pradesh and others, (1982) 1 SCC 39 Affirms the rule of law: the State or its executive officers cannot interfere with rights unless supported by specific rule of law; Article 162 cannot be used to deprive rights without legislative authority; Article 300-A protects against deprivation of property save by authority of law. The court relied on paragraphs 27 and 41 to hold that executive action depriving property must have legislative authority; used this principle to conclude the impugned executive directions lacked statutory basis and therefore were invalid.
State of M.P. v. Thakur Bharat Singh Authority for the proposition that executive action prejudicial to persons must be supported by legislative authority (as applied in the Bishambhar Dayal precedent). Cited within the reasoning quoted from Bishambhar Dayal to support the proposition that every prejudicial governmental act must be supported by legislative authority.
Satwant Singh Sawhney v. Dr. Ramarathnam, Assistant Passport Officer Government of India, New Delhi Reiteration of the principle that executive action cannot infringe rights without legal authority. Referred to as part of the chain of authorities emphasizing the need for legal authority for executive interference with rights.
Smt. Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain Reiterated principle that executive action must have legal backing and cannot violate rights by fiat. Referred to alongside other authorities supporting the same constitutional principle.
Wazir Chand v. State of H.P. and Bishan Das v. State of Punjab Authority for the proposition that an illegal seizure amounts to deprivation of property without the authority of law. Used to support the proposition that actions amounting to deprivation must be backed by law; cited in the quotation of authority applied to the facts.
Hindustan Times and others v. State of U.P. and another, 2003 (1) SCC 591 Followed the above constitutional principle that executive or administrative action affecting rights must have legal authority. Cited as a later decision which followed the principle relied upon by the court.
State of Bihar and others v. Project Uchcha Vidya, Sikshak Sangh and others, (2006) 2 SCC 545 Also followed the principle that deprivation of rights/property by executive action must be by authority of law. Referred to as subsequent authority supporting the principle applied by the court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the impugned notice dated 23.10.2006 and the fourth respondent's reply dated 10.2.2007. The reply made clear that, relying on the second respondent's proceedings dated 11.12.2006 and G.O. Ms. No. 1986 (8.8.1986), the lands within the third respondent's jurisdiction had been decided to be conveyed to M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd. and that only documents in favour of that company could be registered.

The court observed that such a categorical prohibition on landowners transferring their lands to parties other than the specified company and a refusal to register legitimately presented documents raises the question under what provision of law such a restriction was imposed. It noted the constitutional protection under Article 300-A of the right to own and retain property and the requirement that deprivation of property must be by authority of law.

Turning to statutory law, the court identified Section 22-A of the Registration Act (inserted with effect from 28.8.1997) as the only provision under which the State Government may, by notification in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette, declare registration of any document or class of documents opposed to public policy and empower a registering officer to refuse registration. The court noted that invoking Section 22-A, a notification (G.O. Ms. 150, Commercial Taxes, dated 22.9.2000) had declared documents relating to certain classes of property (Government, local authorities, religious institutions, Tamil Nadu State Government Bhoodan Yagna Board, and Tamil Nadu Wakf Board) as opposed to public policy. The court observed that outside such notified classes there was no other provision empowering the State or respondents to refuse registration of documents that are otherwise registrable under the Act.

Applying the constitutional principle from Supreme Court authority (that executive action interfering with rights must be traceable to positive law), and finding no statutory basis for the impugned prohibition affecting ordinary landowners in Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu, the court concluded that the directions issued by the second respondent and the impugned proceedings of the third respondent were without legal justification, infringed constitutional rights and were therefore legally unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The impugned proceedings (including the notice dated 23.10.2006 and related directions) are set aside as being without lawful authority. The respondents are directed to receive and register all documents presented for registration pertaining to the villages of Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu, provided such documents satisfy the stipulations contained in the Registration Act or any other enactment governing such registration.

Implications: The direct consequence is that the respondents must accept and register validly presented conveyance/transfer documents relating to the specified villages, and they cannot refuse registration on the basis of the impugned administrative directions that limited registration only to documents in favour of M/s Cuddalore Power Company Ltd. The opinion grounds this result on constitutional and statutory limitations on executive power; the court did not pronounce the creation of a novel legal rule beyond applying established Supreme Court principles that executive action depriving property must have legislative authority. The opinion does not purport to set down any broader precedent beyond the application of those existing principles to these facts.

Costs: No costs. Connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.

    Thiyagavalli Panchayathai Serntha Nochikkadu Grama Vivasayigal Pdthukappu Mattrum Makkal Pothunala Sangam v. Chairman, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board

    Order — F.M Ibrahim Kalifulla, J.

    The petitioner society claims to represent the agriculturists of the villages of Thiyagavalli Panchayat.

    2. According to the petitioner, the Government of Tamil Nadu issued a notification in G.O Ms. No. 1986, Public Works Department, dated 8.8.1986 declaring that the lands in the villages of Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu measuring an extent of 800.00.00 hectares out of the total extent of 910.40.5 hectares were to be acquired for the establishment of a Thermal Power Station by the first respondent Board.

    3. It is stated that subsequent to the said G.O, a draft scheme was also published on 29.10.1986 as per Section 29(2) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948. However, it is stated that no steps were taken and the villagers who owned their lands in the above referred to extent as mentioned in the notification were dealing with their lands by way of transfer, sale, etc. without any hindrance.

    4. The present grievance of the petitioner is that certain lands were registered by the third respondent in favour of a private company limited, called “Cuddalore Power Company Ltd.”, under document No. 26 of 2007, dated 4.1.2007 and document No. 156 of 2007, dated 18.1.2007 However, when one Thiru. Kennedy, who owned some lands in the said village presented a sale agreement, dated 29.1.2007 in favour of the deponent to the affidavit, the third respondent refused to register the document by referring to a notice displayed in the office of the third respondent, dated 23.10.2006, as well as by referring to G.O Ms. 1986, dated 8.8.1986 and the letter of the first respondent, dated 8.9.2006

    5. The petitioner would submit that when enquiries were made with the third respondent and when a legal notice was issued on 1.2.2007, objecting to the refusal of the third respondent to receive the documents for registration, the fourth respondent in his communication, dated 10.2.2007 informed the petitioner's counsel that they have been advised to register only such documents which are in favour of “M/s. Cuddalore Power Company Ltd.”.

    6. It is based on the above averments, the petitioner has come forward, with this writ petition seeking for issuance of writ of Certiorarified mandamus to call for the records in relation to the notice, dated 23.10.2006 affixed in the office of the third respondent and the letter of the fourth respondent, dated 10.2.2007, to quash the said proceedings and direct the respondents to receive and register all the documents presented to them for registration pertaining to the lands situated in the villages of Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu under the provisions of the Registration Act.

    7. When the writ petition was moved, the learned Government Pleader took notice. Subsequently, the writ petition was admitted on 26.4.2007 and an interim order directing the third respondent to register the documents presented by the deponent to the affidavit was ordered on the said date. On behalf of the State Government, counter affidavit has been filed by the Inspector General of Registration.

    8. In paragraph 6, the second respondent has tacitly admitted that he issued an order to the third respondent not to consider the conveyance deeds with respect to the lands situated in Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu villages in the light of certain communication from “M/s. Cuddalore Power Company Limited” and the office of the second respondent, dated 21.11.2006 and 11.12.2006 respectively.

    9. We perused the impugned proceedings, dated 23.10.2006 and reply notice of the fourth respondent, dated 10.2.2007 The impugned proceedings dated 23.10.2006 is stated to be a notice affixed in the office of the third respondent, which reads as under: —

    23.10.2006”

    10. In the reply notice, the fourth respondent has made it in no uncertain terms that as per the proceedings of the second respondent, dated 11.12.2006 and the G.O Ms. No. 1986 P.W.D, dated 8.8.1986, the lands in the villages, namely, Thiyagaalli and Kudikkadu, measuring an extent of 910.40.5 he ctares whch fall within the jurisdiction of the third respondent, have been decided to be conveyed to “M/s. Cuddalore Power Company Limited”, and that the documents relating to and in favour of the said company alone could be registered.

    11. Taking note of the categorical stand of the third respondent in the impugned proceedings, we are at a loss to understand as to how and under what provision of law such a prohibition came to be imposed by the respondents restraining any individual land owners in the above two villages from transferring their lands either by way of sale or by any other mode to any third party other than “M/s. Cuddalore Power Company Limited” and refuse to register such documents.

    12. Under Article 300-A of the Constitution, a right of a citizen to own a property and retain the same has been well protected and such right cannot be deprived of except by authority of law.

    13. If at all the respondents can seek protection for their action, it could have been under the provisions of the Registration Act. The only provision under which the prohibition from registration can be traced is Section 22-A of the said Act which specifically provides that the State Government may by notification in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette declare that the registration of any document or class of documents is opposed to public policy and notwithstanding anything contained in the Act, the registering officer can refuse to register any document to which a notification issued under sub-section (1) is applicable. The provision came to be inserted by way of an amendment with effect from 28.8.1997 Invoking the said provision, a notification came to be issued in G.O Ms. 150, Commercial Taxes, dated 22.9.2000 Under the said notification, the documents relating to conveyance of properties belonging to the Government, local authorities, religious institutions or conveyance of properties assigned to or held by the Tamil Nadu State Government Boodan Yagna Board and the Tamil Nadu Wakf Board have been declared as documents opposed to public policy. Therefore, it was notified that no registration of any document with reference to those properties can be entertained.

    14. That apart, there is no other provision under which the State Government or the respondents herein can validly issue any directions refusing to register any document for which registration is permissible under the provisions of the said Act. If that be so, it is shocking to note as to under what provision of law or any other authority, the second respondent issued such directions directing the third respondent not to register any sale deed in the villages of Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu except in favour of “M/s. Cuddalore Power Company Ltd.” Any such directions issued by the second respondent and the impugned proceedings of the third respondent based on such a directive of the second respondent clearly infringes the constitutional right of any land owner as a citizen of this country. In such circumstances, the impugned proceedings are wholly devoid of merits and are liable to be set aside.

    15. In this context, it is worthwhile to refer to the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in (1982) 1 SCC 39 (Bishambhar Dayal Chandra Mohan and others v. State of Uttar Pradesh and others), wherein, paragraphs 27 and 41 are relevant for our present purpose which read as under:

    “27. The quintessence of our Constitution is the rule of law. The State or its executive officers cannot interfere with the rights of others unless they can point to some specific rule of law which authorizes their acts. In State of M.P v. Thakur Bharat Singh, the Court repelled the contention that by virtue of Article 162, the State or its officers may, in the exercise of executive authority, without any legislation in support thereof, infringe the rights of citizens merely because the legislature of the State has power to legislate in regard to the subject on which the executive order is issued. It was observed:

    Every act done by the Government or by its officers must, if it is to operate to the prejudice of any person, be supported by some legislative authority.

    The same principle was reiterated by the Court in Satwant Singh Sawhney v. Dr. Ramarathnam, Assistant Passport Officer Government of India, New Delhi and Smt. Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain.

    41. There still remains the question whether the seizure of wheat amounts to deprivation of property without the authority of law. Article 300-A provides that no person shall be deprived of his property save by authority of law. The State Government cannot while taking recourse to the executive power of the State under Article 162, deprive a person of his property. Such power can be exercised only by authority of law and not by a mere executive fiat or order. Article 162, as is clear from the opening words, is subject to other provisions of the Constitution. It is, therefore, necessarily subject to Article 300-A. The word “law” in the context of Article 300-A must mean an Act of Parliament or of a State Legislature, a rule, or a statutory order, having the force of law, that is positive or State-made law. The decisions in Wazir Chand v. State of H.P and Bishan Das v. State of Punjab are an authority for the proposition that an illegal seizure amounts to deprivation of property without the authority of law.”

    16. The above proposition of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court was subsequently followed in the reported decisions in 2003 (1) SCC 591 (Hindustan Times and others v. State of U.P and another) and (2006) 2 SCC 545 (State of Bihar and others v. Project Uchcha Vidya, Sikshak Sangh and others).

    17. Applying the above said principle to the fact of this case, we have no hesitation to hold that the impugned proceedings of the respondents are liable to be set aside as non-est in law. Accordingly, setting aside the proceedings, the prayer of the petitioner stands allowed and the respondents are directed to receive and register all the documents present by them for registration pertaining to the villages namely, Thiyagavalli and Kudikkadu, if such documents satisfy the stipulations contained in the Registration Act or any other enactment governing such registration.

    The Writ Petition stands allowed. No costs. Connected M.Ps are closed.

    VCJ/VCS

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Thiyagavalli Panchay... v. Chairman, Tamil Nadu...
    (Mar 5, 2008)