Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 9 of the Delhi and Ajmer-Merwara Rent Control Act. 1947
  • rule 6 of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947
  • rule 9 of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947
  • 6(i) of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 9 of the Delhi and Ajmer-Merwara Rent Control Act. 1947
  • rule 6 of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947
  • rule 9 of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947
  • 6(i) of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision petitioner is the tenant of respondent No. 1, the landlord. The landlord obtained a decree for eviction against the tenant, but this decree became inexecutable on 24 March 1947 due to the coming into force of Section 9 of the Delhi and Ajmer-Merwara Rent Control Act, 1947. Despite this, the landlord executed the eviction decree and recovered possession of part of the premises from the tenant. The tenant was subsequently restored to possession as the eviction was contrary to Section 9 of the Act. Possession was taken piece-meal by the landlord from 1949 until 18 March 1955, after which the entire possession was restored to the tenant following an order of the lower appellate court. The tenant claimed mesne profits for the period of wrongful possession and damages, but both the trial and lower appellate courts dismissed these claims. The tenant filed the present revision application challenging the dismissal of mesne profits claims.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the tenant is entitled to mesne profits for the period during which the landlord was in wrongful possession of the premises.
  2. If entitled, on what basis should the mesne profits be calculated.

Arguments of the Parties

Tenant's Arguments

  • The tenant claimed entitlement to mesne profits at Rs. 200 per month for the period of wrongful possession by the landlord.
  • The tenant also claimed damages on other counts, although these were not ultimately considered maintainable.
  • The tenant contended that the lower courts erred in rejecting the claim for mesne profits on the basis that the tenant did not suffer loss due to dispossession.
  • The tenant argued that subletting was not prohibited, and thus the landlord's wrongful possession should attract payment of mesne profits based on the profits the landlord could have earned.
  • The tenant submitted that the principle underlying mesne profits is that the party in wrongful possession must pay profits actually received or reasonably receivable, not that the dispossessed party must prove loss.

Landlord's Arguments

  • The landlord relied on the lower courts' interpretation of section 144 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), asserting that the tenant had not suffered any loss as the tenant could not sublet the premises.
  • The landlord argued that since the tenant continued paying rent to the landlord, the tenant did not incur loss due to dispossession and thus was not entitled to mesne profits.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hari Shankar v. Rao Girdhari Lal Chowdhury, (1962) 64 Pun LR 1097 — AIR 1963 SC 698 Scope of revision under Rule 6(i) of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947 being wider than revision under section 115 of the CPC. The Court applied this precedent to justify interference with the impugned order on the basis that the revision scope is broad and to ensure the decision was according to law.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the issue of mesne profits in the context of wrongful possession by the landlord after the eviction decree became inexecutable under Section 9 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1947. It held that the order restoring possession to the tenant was passed under the Court's inherent jurisdiction in compliance with the Rent Control Act, not strictly under section 144 of the CPC. However, the principle underlying section 144 relating to mesne profits must be applied as a rule of justice, equity, and good conscience. The Court emphasized that mesne profits are payable based on what the wrongful possessor actually received or could have received with reasonable diligence, not on the loss suffered by the dispossessed party.

The Court found the lower courts erred in rejecting the tenant's claim by misconstruing the law and ignoring the definition of mesne profits under section 2 of the CPC. It rejected the lower courts' reasoning that the tenant's inability to sublet or the payment of rent to the landlord negated the claim. The Court clarified that subletting was not prohibited and that the landlord's wrongful possession entitled the tenant to mesne profits. The Court further held that the basis for calculating mesne profits is ordinarily the rent paid by the tenant, but if the landlord earned higher profits through other means, that higher amount should be the basis. The landlord bears the initial burden to prove the profits earned, which the tenant can rebut.

The Court noted that whether treated as a revision or a second appeal, the impugned decision was contrary to law due to the wrong approach to mesne profits and the basis for their determination.

Holding and Implications

The Court partly allowed the revision petition, setting aside the orders of the trial and lower appellate courts regarding mesne profits. It directed the trial court to determine the mesne profits payable by the landlord to the tenant in accordance with the principles outlined in the judgment.

The Court made no order as to costs but ordered refund of extra court fees wrongly collected from the petitioner. The parties were directed to appear in the trial court for further proceedings.

The decision directly affects the parties by entitling the tenant to mesne profits for the period of wrongful possession and clarifies the correct legal approach to mesne profits under the Rent Control Act and CPC. No new precedent was set beyond the application of existing principles.

    Rattan Lal v. Girdhari Lal And Another

    1. The revision petitioner is the tenant of respondent No. 1, the landlord. Respondent No. 2 is the subsequent transferee from the landlord against whom no relief is claimed. The landlord obtained a decree for eviction against the tenant but this decree became inexecutable on 24 March, 1947 and thereafter by virtue of Section 9 of the Delhi and Ajmer-Merwara Rent Control Act. 1947 which came into force on 24th March, 1947. Nevertheless, the decree for eviction was executed by the landlord against the tenant thereafter and possession of part of the premises was recovered by the landlord from the tenant. As this was contrary to Section 9 of the Act the tenant was restored back the possession. The possession of a part of the premises was taken by the landlord from the tenant piece-meal from 274-49 till 18th March, 1955 but the whole of the possession was restored to the tenant as a result of the order of the lower appellate court which is under appeal in other respects.

    2. The tenant claimed that he was entitled to recover mesne profits at the rate of Rs. 200/- per month for the period during which the landlord was in wrongful possession of the part of the premises. He also claimed damages on other counts. Both the trial court and the lower appellate court, however, dismissed the claim of the tenant for mesne profits on the ground that the tenant had not suffered any loss due to the dispossession according to the construction put by the learned lower courts on section 144 of the cpc. The learned lower courts also dismissed the claim of the tenant for damages on other counts.

    3. The tenant has purported to file the present application in revision under rule 6 of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947 inasmuch as R. 5 thereof precluded any second appeal from an order under the Act. Alternatively, Shri Yogeshwar Dayal, learned counsel for the tenant-petitioner prays that if the order appealed against is deemed to be one passed under section 144 of the cpc then this may be treated as a second appeal. Learned counsel pointed out that whether it is treated as a revision or a second appeal, it has been filed within limitation laid down under rule 9 of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947 or. alternatively. under the limitation prescribed by the Limitation Act and the court fee prescribed by item No. 11 of the Second Schedule of the Court Fees Act has been paid as laid down in paragraph 5 of Chapter 4 Part A (Vol. 4) of the High Court Rules and Orders. The claim in this petition is for the reversal of the lower appellate court's order. It may be pointed out at the outset that the tenant is not entitled to claim damages on other counts, such as mental suffering etc.

    4. The only question for decision therefore is whether the tenant is entitled to mesne profits and if so on what basis.

    5. The order by which the possession was restored to the tenant from the landlord was passed not under section 144 of the cpc as such but under inherent jurisdiction in compliance with Section 9 of the Act of 1947. The interest of justice requires for the same reason that the parties should be placed in the same position in which they would have been if the decree for eviction had not been executed by the landlord against the tenant. Therefore, whether the terms of section 144 of the cpc apply or not the principle underlying it has to be applied as a rule of justice, equity and good conscience. The principle is that the parties are to be; placed in the position which they would have occupied but for the execution of decree by the landlord against the tenant and consequently mesne profits have to be paid by the landlord to the tenant The principle underlying the definition of “mesne profits” in section 2 of the cpc is that the person in wrongful possession must pay to the person, who was wrongfully dispossessed, such profits which the former actually receives or might with ordinary diligence have received from the property together with interest on such profits. The test therefore is not what the tenant lost by being dispossessed but what the landlord got or could have got with reasonable diligence because of the dispossession.

    6. The learned lower courts were not well advised in rejecting the definition of “mesne profits” under section 2 of the cpc or at any rate the principle underlying it in determining whether the tenant could claim mesne profit from the land or not. They overlooked the fact that even section 144 of the cpc which they purported to construe requires the payment of mesne profits by the landlord to the tenant after the period of the wrongful possession of the landlord over the premises. The argument which appealed to the learned lower court was that the tenant could not have sublet the premises and therefore he did not suffer any loss due to dispossession. Firstly, there was no such prohibition as such on the subletting of the premises by the tenant either under the legislation of 1944 or under the Act of 1947, Subletting was not therefore either illegal or void though, in certain circumstances, it would have provided the landlord with a cause of action for the eviction of the tenant. Sub-letting by the tenant was therefore legal and the rent paid by the sub-tenant to the tenant could have been taken to be the measure of the profits of the property. Secondly, the mere fact that tenant was paving rent to the landlord for occupying the premises and that he did not pay rent to him during the period of dispossession does not mean that the tenant did not suffer any loss due to the dispossession. Such thinking is based on the approach that the mesne profits are payable only if the dispossessed party suffered a loss. This approach is wrong. The correct approach is whether the party In possession made profits or could have made profits with reasonable diligence during his occupation of the property. It is due to this wrong approach adopted by the learned lower courts that I am constrained to interfere with the impugned decision. I find therefore that the tenant was entitled to claim mesne profits from the landlord for the period of dispossession.

    7. The next aspect of the question is the basis on which the mesne profits are determined. Ordinarily, the rent which used to be paid by the tenant to the landlord could have furnished a good basis for the calculation of the mesne profits. If however, the landlord has earned profits from the premises at a higher rate whether by using the property himself or by letting it out to other persons then such higher rate of profits would be the basis for calculation of the mesne profits. The learned lower courts further failed to appreciate that the very nature of the basis for calculation of mesne profits implies that the landlord is in special knowledge of the profits earned by him or which could have been earned by him with reasonable diligence. Initially, therefore, it is for him to show what profits he earned from the property. The tenant can thereafter rebut that evidence.

    8. If this application is treated as revision then it would be under R. 6(i) of the Delhi Rent Control (Procedure) Rules, 1947 under which the High Court has to satisfy itself whether the impugned decision was according to law. In Hari Shankar v. Rao Girdhari Lal Chowdhury, (1962) 64 Pun LR 1097 — (AIR 1963 SC 698) the Supreme Court considered the scope of such a revision as being larger than the scope of revision under section 115 of the cpc. If this application is treated as a second appeal under section 100 of the cpc then the duty of this Court is to see whether the impugned decision was contrary to law. In either case the misconstruction of section 144 of the cpc the wrong rejection of the concept of mesne profits as defined in section 2 of the cpc and the wrong approach to the law of mesne profits as well as to the basis for their determination adopted by the learned lower courts would compel Interference with the impugned order.

    9. The revision petition is therefore partly allowed and the orders of the trial court and the first appellate court in respect of the mesne profits are set aside. The trial court is directed to determine the mesne profits payable by the landlord to the tenant in the light of the observations made above.

    10. Under the circumstances I make no order as to costs, but order that the extra court-fees wrongly realised from the petitioner under the orders of the learned lower appellate court shall be refunded to him. The parties are directed to appear in the trial court on 29th March, 1971.

    11. Petition Partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rattan Lal v. Girdhari Lal And Another
    (Mar 15, 1971)