Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The claimants, respondents no. 1 to 5, filed a claim application alleging that on 27.2.2000 the deceased, Sachida Nand Mishra, was traveling on a tractor driven by its owner, respondent no. 6, when the tractor turned turtle resulting in serious head injuries to the deceased, who died on 29.2.2000. The deceased was about 35 years old and employed as a supervisor earning Rs. 4,000 per month. The owner admitted driving the tractor and attributed the accident to a mechanical fault. The tractor was insured with the appellant, National Insurance Company Ltd. The Motor Accident Claim Tribunal directed the appellant to pay Rs. 1,27,000 with interest, after deducting an ad-interim compensation of Rs. 50,000. The appellant filed the present appeal challenging this award. The appeal was disposed of at the admission stage under Order 41 Rule 11 C.P.C.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Insurance Company is liable to pay compensation for a deceased who was a gratuitous passenger on a tractor used for agricultural purposes.
  2. Whether the liability of the insurer extends to passengers traveling on a goods vehicle or tractor not intended for carrying passengers.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The deceased was traveling as a gratuitous passenger on the tractor.
  • The tractor was not being used for agricultural purposes at the time of accident as per the case admitted by the parties.
  • The Insurance Company is not liable to indemnify the owner for passengers who are gratuitous and not covered under the insurance policy.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The tractor was insured with the Insurance Company, which makes the insurer liable to pay compensation.
  • No representative appeared on behalf of the owner in the appeal proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. v. Natthi Bai (Civil Appeal No. 1718 of 2007) Tractor used only for agricultural purpose and not for carrying passengers; insurer liability limited to third parties and not gratuitous passengers. The court relied on this precedent to hold that the insurance company is not liable for passengers traveling gratuitously on a tractor.
National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Bomnitha Subbhayamma (2005) 12 SCC 243 Clarification on insurer's liability excluding gratuitous passengers in goods vehicles. Supported the principle that gratuitous passengers are not covered under the insurance policy.
New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Vedawati (2007) 9 SCC 486 Insurer's liability excludes gratuitous passengers on goods vehicles. Reinforced the limitation on insurer's liability to third parties only.
United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Serjerao (2008 (1) PLJR 127 SC) Insurance company not liable for labourers traveling in trollies attached to vehicles. Applied to exclude insurer's liability for passengers in non-passenger compartments.
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. v. Brij Mohan (2007) 7 SCC 56 Limits insurer's liability concerning passengers traveling in goods vehicles. Used to support the exclusion of gratuitous passengers from insurance coverage.
National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Baljit Kaur (2004 (2) PLJR 59 SC) Effect of 1994 amendment does not extend insurer's liability to gratuitous passengers. Confirmed that insurance does not cover gratuitous passengers despite legislative amendments.
New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Asha Rani (2003 (1) PLJR 213 SC) Carrying passengers in goods vehicles is not contemplated under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. Reiterated that insurer is not liable for passengers traveling in goods vehicles.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the admitted facts that the deceased was traveling on a tractor used solely for agricultural purposes and driven by the owner. It noted that the capacity in which the deceased was traveling was not disclosed but inferred that he was a gratuitous passenger. The court referred extensively to binding Supreme Court precedents which consistently held that the liability of the insurer under the Motor Vehicles Act does not extend to gratuitous passengers traveling on goods vehicles or tractors not intended for carrying passengers. The court found that the Tribunal below had failed to consider this critical legal principle and had incorrectly fixed liability on the Insurance Company solely because the tractor was insured with it. Based on the settled law, the court concluded that the Insurance Company is not liable to pay compensation to the claimants and modified the award accordingly, directing that the claimants recover the compensation from the owner of the tractor instead.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed and the Judgment and Award of the Tribunal are modified to hold that the Insurance Company is not liable to pay compensation to the claimants for the death of the deceased who was a gratuitous passenger on the tractor.

The claimants are directed to recover the awarded compensation from the owner of the vehicle. The amount deposited by the Insurance Company is to be returned to it. This decision directly affects the parties by absolving the insurer from liability in such circumstances and does not establish any new precedent beyond reaffirming existing Supreme Court principles.

    National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Most. Sugandhi Devi & Ors.

    1. Heard the learned counsel for the parties under Order 41 Rule 11 C.P.C

    2. This appeal is being disposed of at the admission stage itself. The National Insurance Company Ltd. appellant, filed the present appeal against the Judgment and Award dated 22.6.2005 and, 1.2.2005 respectively passed by Sri Sanjay Kumar, 4th Additional District Judge-cum-Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, Motihari in Claim Case No. 34/2000/6/04 whereby and whereunder the learned court below has directed the appellant to pay Rs. 1,27,000/- after deducting Rs. 50,000/- as ad-interim compensation. The Tribunal also directed to pay the compensation with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of tiling of the case till the payment.

    3. The claimants respondents no. 1 to 5 filed the claim application alleging that on 27.2.2000 the deceased Sachida Nand Mishra was going on the tractor bearing Registration No. BR-05A/9773 from Motihari to Mananpur. In the way the trac tor turned turtle as a result of which Sachida Nand Mishra received serious head injury and ultimately died on 29.2.2000 At the time of accident the owner Dhrub Narayan Mishra was driving the tractor rashly and negligently. The owner is respondent no. 6 in this appeal. It is alleged that the deceased was aged about 35 years and was supervisor in Premier Markentile Company, Kolkata. He was earning Rs. 4000/- per month.

    4. The respondent no. 6 was O.P No. 1 in the court below, appeared and filed contesting written statement against the claim of the claimants. He admitted that he was driving the tractor at the time of accident. He also admitted the manner of accident. According to him due to me chanical fault the accident took place. He has filed the driving licence. It is stated by him that the tractor in question was insured with the National Insurance Company Ltd. As such the Company is liable to pay the compensation.

    5. The appellant, the National Insurance Company Ltd. was O.P No. 2, filed contesting written statement and stated that the owner has violated the terms of the policy. The vehicle was being plied without displaying any registration number.

    6. On the pleadings the learned Tribunal framed issues and after trial passed the impugned Judgment and Award.

    7. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that it is the case of the appellant which is admitted by the parties that the deceased was traveling on a tractor. It is not the case of either the owner or the applicants that at the time of the accident the tractor was being used for agricultural purposes. According to the claimants itself it was driven by the owner and the deceased was sitting on the tractor as a passenger. Therefore, according to the learned counsel the Insurance Company Ltd. is not liable at all to indemnify the owner. The learned counsel submitted that at best it can be said that the deceased was a gratuitous passenger on the tractor.

    8. On the other hand, the respondent no. 1 contended that since the tractor was insured with the Insurance Company, therefore, Insurance Company is liable to pay. It may be mentioned here that no body appears on behalf of the owner, respondent no. 6.

    9. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 1718 of 2007.S.L.P © No. 3900/2006 (Oriental Insurance Com pany Ltd. v. Natthi Bai) in similarly situ ated case has held that indisputedly the tractor was to be used only for agricultural purpose and not for carrying any passen ger. In that very case referring to the decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in (2005) 12 SCC 243 National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Bomnitha Subbhayamma) and (2007) 9 SCC 486 : 2007 (3) SCALE 397, (New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Vedawati) the Hon'ble Su preme Court has held that the liability of the insurer would be limited to a 3rd party and not to a gratuitous passenger. In this very decision the Hon'ble Supreme Court has also held that the passenger referred to the Insurance Company covered evi dently would mean the driver of the trac tor and not any passenger who can travel on the mudguard of the tractor. There would not be any seat for a passenger on the tractor which was to be used for agricultural purposes. Before the Hon'ble Supreme Court it was contended that in view of the Motor Vehicles Amendment Act, 1994 “any other person” would also be covered under the Insurance Policy to which the Hon'ble Supreme Court did not accept.

    10. In 2008 (1) PLJR 127 (SC) (United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Serjerao) the Hon'ble Supreme Court at paragraph 8 relying upon the earlier decision of the Hon'ble Court in Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. v. Brij Mohan reported in (2007) 7 SCC 56 : 2007 (7) SCALE 753 held that the Insurance Company has no liability regarding labourers traveling in trollies is concerned.

    11. In decision reported in 2004 (2) PLJR 59 (S.C) (National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Baljit Kaur) the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that inspite of the amendment of 1994 the effect of the provision contained in section 147 with respect to persons other than the owner of the goods or his authorized representative remains the same. Although the owner of the goods or his authorized representative would now be covered by the policy of insurance in respect of a goods vehicle, it was not the intention of the legislature to provide for the liability of the insurer with respect to passengers, specially gratuitous passenger, who were neither contemplated at the time of contract of insurance was entered into, nor any premium was paid to the extent of benefit of insurance to such category of people. In another decision reported in 2003 (1) PLJR 213 SC (New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Asha Rani) the Hon'ble Supreme Court while considering this aspect of the matter reiterated that carrying of passenger in a goods carriage is not contem-plated under the 1988 Act. As the provision of 1988 Act do not enjoin any statutory liability on the owner of a vehicle to get his vehicle insured for any passenger traveling in goods vehicle, insurer would not be liable. Therefore, in the present case at bur hand, it is admitted fact that the vehicle involved is a tractor which is used for agricultural purposes only. It is not the case of the applicant or the owner that it was used for other purposes also. It is also admitted case that the deceased was traveling on the tractor. In what capacity he was sitting on the tractor is not disclosed. Only the submission is that he was traveling and, therefore, at best he was a gratuitous passenger. In the various decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to above it has been clearly held that the insurance company is not liable to pay the compensation in the case of gratuitous passenger. Moreover, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the above referred decisions of Nathi Bhai has clearly held that the Insurance Company is not liable to pay compensation or the passenger, traveling in a tractor.

    12. In view of the above said decisions it appears that the present case is squarely covered by the settled principles of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court

    13. From perusal of the impugned Judgment it appears that the learned Tribunal has not at all considered this aspect of the matter that the deceased was traveling on the tractor which was being driven by the owner. The Tribunal has fastened the liability on the Insurance Company, the appellant, only on the ground that the tractor was insured with the appellant Company.

    14. In view of the above discussion I come to the conclusion that the deceased was traveling as gratuitous passenger on the tractor and, therefore, the Insurance Company, the appellant, is not liable to pay the compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal. In view of the above finding the Judgment and award passed by the teamed Tribunal is hereby modified to the extent that the claimants may recover the awarded amount from the owner of the vehicle. The statutory amount deposited by the appellant Rs. 25,000/- may be returned to the appellant. So far quantum is concerned no arguments were advanced.

    15. In the result, this Misc. Appeal is allowed and the Judgment and Award are modified to the extent, indicated above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Most. Sugandhi Devi & Ors.
    (May 4, 2010)