AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Revenue preferred a tax appeal under section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 against the order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Ahmedabad dated July 13, 2012, in the case of Gujarat State Fertilizers and Chemicals Ltd. The appeal raised substantial questions of law concerning the disallowance of expenses under section 14A of the Act related to exempt dividend income, treatment of corporate debt restructuring expenses, taxability of waived loan amounts, and disallowance under section 115JB of the Act. The matter had proceeded through the Assessing Officer, Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), and the Tribunal before reaching the present court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal was correct in restricting the addition under section 14A of the Act on an ad hoc basis to Rs. 5 lakhs without appreciating that the assessee maintained mixed funds and failed to furnish detailed cash-flow statements or prove surplus funds for investment in dividends.
  2. Whether the Tribunal erred in allowing corporate debt restructuring expenses of Rs. 2.57 crores as revenue expenditure by spreading it over six years, despite such expenses constituting capital expenditure excluded under section 37(1) of the Act.
  3. Whether the Tribunal was right in excluding the waived amount of Rs. 11.63 crores from total income, disregarding the inclusive definition of income under section 2(24) and profits and gains under section 28, and the precedent that loan waivers constitute taxable income under section 28(1).
  4. Whether the Tribunal was correct in restricting disallowance of interest expenses on exempt dividend income under section 115JB of the Act to Rs. 5 lakhs based on the ad hoc disallowance under section 14A.

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments

  • The Tribunal's finding that the assessee had discharged the burden of proving availability of interest-free funds was erroneous due to lack of material such as day-to-day cash-flow statements.
  • The calculation of disallowance under section 14A should have considered rule 8D, which though introduced later, provided a more appropriate method for determining expenditure related to exempt income.
  • Relied on the Delhi High Court decisions in Commissioner Of Income Tax v. Ms. Sushma Kapoor and Maxopp Investment Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax to support the approach that disallowance must be based on objective criteria and reasonable methods.
  • Asserted that corporate debt restructuring expenses represent capital expenditure and should be disallowed under section 37(1) of the Act.
  • Contended that the waived loan amount should be included as income under section 28(iv) and section 41(1) based on the inclusive definition of income and relevant judicial precedents.
  • Argued that disallowance under section 115JB should not have been restricted to Rs. 5 lakhs but should reflect the full disallowance under section 14A.

Respondent-Assessee's Arguments

  • Asserted that no disallowance under section 14A was warranted as the assessee had sufficient own funds exceeding the investment amount, thus no borrowed funds were used to earn exempt dividend income.
  • Submitted that rule 8D is prospective and not applicable to the assessment year in question.
  • Maintained that corporate debt restructuring expenses were revenue in nature, incurred wholly and exclusively for business purposes, and therefore allowable under section 37(1).
  • Relied on the decision in Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Chetan Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. to argue that waived loans do not constitute taxable income when the assessee is not in the business of obtaining loans.
  • Agreed to the spreading of corporate debt restructuring expenses over six years as per the Tribunal's order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner Of Income Tax v. Ms. Sushma Kapoor, [2009] 319 ITR 299 (Delhi) Verification of expenditure related to exempt income and requirement of objective criteria for disallowance under section 14A. Cited to emphasize the need for cogent reasons and objective evidence before disallowing expenditure under section 14A; court noted this was a factual determination.
Maxopp Investment Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, [2012] 347 ITR 272 (Delhi) Methodology for determining expenditure related to exempt income and the role of rule 8D. Referred to clarify that prior to rule 8D, Assessing Officer must verify the claim of the assessee and reject it only for disclosed reasons; method of apportionment must be reasonable.
CIT v. Walfort Share and Stock Brokers P. Ltd., [2010] 326 ITR 1 (SC) Scope and object of section 14A to disallow expenditure relating to exempt income. Used to explain that expenses incurred in relation to exempt income cannot be allowed as deduction; section 14A was inserted to curb such claims.
India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, [1966] 60 ITR 52 (SC) Distinction between capital and revenue expenditure. Relied upon by Assessing Officer to argue corporate debt restructuring expenses were capital in nature; ultimately distinguished by Tribunal.
Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1997] 225 ITR 802 (SC) Criteria for classifying expenditure as capital or revenue and spreading revenue expenditure over a period. Applied by the Tribunal and Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) to hold that CDR expenses are revenue in nature and spreading over six years is appropriate.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Chetan Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., [2004] 267 ITR 770 (Guj) Taxability of loan waivers and remission of unsecured loans. Followed to hold that waiver of loans in the normal course of business is not taxable income where the assessee is not in the business of obtaining loans.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined each substantial question of law by analyzing the facts, statutory provisions, and relevant precedents. On the first issue under section 14A, the court noted that the Assessing Officer disallowed Rs. 1,14,43,040 on an ad hoc basis (10% of dividend income) due to the assessee's failure to prove that borrowed funds were not used for investment. However, both the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal found that the assessee had sufficient own funds exceeding the investment amount and no evidence indicated use of borrowed funds for earning exempt dividend income. Thus, the disallowance under section 14A was rightly set aside except for an agreed disallowance of Rs. 5 lakhs for administrative expenses. The court emphasized the Supreme Court’s ruling in CIT v. Walfort Share and Stock Brokers P. Ltd. that only expenses relatable to taxable income are deductible, and section 14A prevents deduction of expenses related to exempt income.

Regarding the second issue on corporate debt restructuring expenses, the Assessing Officer treated the Rs. 2.57 crores paid to financial consultants as capital expenditure. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal, relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd., held these expenses to be revenue in nature and allowed spreading the expenditure over six years. The court found no error in this approach, particularly as the assessee did not object to spreading the expenses.

On the third issue concerning the waived loan amount of Rs. 11.63 crores, the court referred to the precedent set in Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Chetan Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., where loan remission was held not to be taxable income when the assessee was not engaged in loan business. Both the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal applied this reasoning to hold the waived amount non-taxable, and the court found no reason to interfere.

Finally, the fourth issue related to disallowance under section 115JB of the Act mirrored the first issue. Since the disallowance under section 14A was restricted to Rs. 5 lakhs, the Tribunal confirmed the same amount for addition under section 115JB. The court upheld this approach, noting the direct correlation between the two provisions and found no fault in the authorities’ reasoning.

Overall, the court found that the Revenue failed to establish the basis for the disallowances and additions sought, and the Tribunal’s decisions were consistent with the facts and law.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The court upheld the Tribunal’s decisions on all substantial questions of law, confirming that:

  • Disallowance under section 14A of Rs. 1,14,43,040 was not justified except for an agreed Rs. 5 lakhs related to administrative expenses.
  • Corporate debt restructuring expenses of Rs. 2.57 crores are revenue in nature and may be spread over six years.
  • The waived loan amount of Rs. 11.63 crores is not taxable income under sections 28(iv) or 41(1) of the Act.
  • Addition under section 115JB is limited to Rs. 5 lakhs consistent with the section 14A disallowance.

No new precedent was set; the decision affirms the application of established principles relating to disallowance of expenses against exempt income, classification of expenditure, and taxability of loan waivers. The direct effect is the confirmation of the Tribunal’s order in favor of the assessee, rejecting the Revenue’s appeal.

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Gujarat State Fertilizers And Chemicals Ltd.

    Sonia Gokani, J.:— Aggrieved by the order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Ahmedabad (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”) dated July 13, 2012—since reported in Gujarat State Fertilizers and Chemicals Ltd. v. Asst. CIT, [2013] 1 ITR (Trib)-OL 540 (Ahd), the present tax appeal is preferred by the Revenue under section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”), proposing the following substantial questions of law for our consideration:

    “(I) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in law in restricting the addition under section 14A of the Act towards interest and other expenses incurred in relation to exempted income of dividend on ad hoc basis of Rs. 1,14,43,040 being 10 per cent, of the total income to Rs. 5 lakhs without appreciating that the assessee was maintaining mixed funds and failed either to furnish day-to-day cash-flow statement or to establish that it had its own surplus funds for investment in dividends?

    (II) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in directing to allow corporate debt restructuring expenses of Rs. 2.57 crores on payment to financial consultants in connection with waiver of loans, by spreading it over a period of 6 years disregarding the fact that such expenditure in relation to capital assets constitutes capital expenditure, which is specifically excluded in section 37(1) of the Act?

    (III) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in directing to exclude the waived amount of Rs. 11.63 crores out of the principal loans, from the total income, disregarding the inclusive definition of income under section 2(24) and the profits and gains of business in section 28 and the ratio settled in the land mark decision in the case of CIT v. T.V Sundaram Iyengar and Sons Ltd., [1996] 222 ITR 344 (SC), holding that waiver of such loans received in the course of business constitutes income receipt on being written off, by virtue of section 28(1) itself?

    (IV) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in restricting the disallowance of interest expenses on exempted income of dividend on ad hoc basis of Rs. 1,14,43,040 being 10 per cent, of the total income in computation of income under section 115JB of the Act to Rs. 5 lakhs without appreciating that the assessee was maintaining mixed funds and failed either to furnish day-to-day cash-flow statement or to establish that it had its own surplus funds for investment in dividends?”

    2. We have exhaustively heard Shri K.M Parikh, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Revenue and Shri Manish J. Shah, learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent-assessee and with their assistance examined the orders of the Revenue authorities and other material brought on record. The first question concerns disallowance made by the Assessing Officer of the sum of Rs. 1,14,43,040 under section 14A of the Act towards interest and other expenses incurred in relation to exempted income of dividend. The Assessing Officer on the ground that the respondent-assessee utilised the interest bearing borrowed funds for non-business purpose disallowed such expenses to the tune of 10 per cent, of the dividend income. The Assessing Officer was of the opinion that the onus was not discharged by the respondent-assessee to establish that the investment from where dividend has been received during the assessment year 2004-05, was out of its own funds and no borrowed funds have been utilised for making such investment on the basis of cash/fund flows statement and, therefore, on estimated basis it deducted 10 per cent, of the total dividend income as expenditure including the interest in relation to earning of exempt income and the sum of Rs. 1,14,43,040 was disallowed as per the provisions of section 14A of the Act.

    3. Being aggrieved by such decision, the respondent-assessee moved the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals). The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) held that the Assessing Officer has failed to clearly show that any particular expenditure was incurred by the assessee to earn exempt dividend income, ad hoc disallowance made of Rs. 1,14,43,040 is deleted.

    4. The Revenue challenged this ground before the Tribunal. The Tribunal was of the firm opinion that the respondent-assessee's own funds were higher than the investment made by the respondent-assessee and, therefore, it was not possible to hold that the interest bearing funds were diverted for making investment in shares and, therefore, under section 14A of the Act, it held that there was no question of disallowance in respect of interest expenditure. For other expenses, the request was made for restoring the matter back to the Assessing Officer, however, the respondent-assessee with a view to put an end to the entire dispute had agreed with disallowance of Rs. 5 lakhs, which, according to the Tribunal, was meeting the ends of justice and, therefore, the Tribunal had confirmed the disallowance of Rs. 5 lakhs in respect of administrative expenses.

    5. The learned counsel, Shri K.M Parikh, appearing on behalf of the Revenue, has vehemently submitted before us that in the absence of any material to indicate that the assessee had discharged his burden of establishing that it had interest-free funds available with it, the Tribunal's finding requires interference. He also urged this court that as far as the calculation is concerned, in the assessment year 2004-05, the rule 8D which has come into being subsequently and it being prospective in nature, the authorities ought to have considered the judgment of the Delhi High Court while calculating such expenses. He has relied on the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of Commissioner Of Income Tax v. Ms. Sushma Kapoor reported in [2009] 319 ITR 299 (Delhi), wherein the assessee had taken a loan from the bank on which she paid interest of huge amount, but she had granted interest-free advances. The Assessing Officer held that there was no business transaction to those whom the assessee gave loan and he disallowed the proportionate interest which had been paid to the assessee by the bank. The Tribunal held that to the extent it could be proved that investment was made from the borrowed funds, the expenses had been disallowed under section 14A of the Act. When the Revenue carried it in appeal, the High Court dismissed it on the ground that the issues raised by the Revenue were factual in nature where findings of facts were recorded in favour of the assessee. The court also held that the investment was made in the preceding year and no part of the investment was correlated with the borrowed funds.

    6. The Delhi High Court in the case of Maxopp Investment Ltd…. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, New Delhi reported in [2012] 347 ITR 272 (Delhi), was examining the provision of section 14A of the Act and sub-rule (2) of rule 8D qua the method for determining the expenditure in relation to exempt income. It held thus (page 295):

    “… section 14A, even prior to the introduction of sub-sections (2) and (3) would require the Assessing Officer to first reject the claim of the assessee with regard to the extent of such expenditure and such rejection must be for disclosed cogent reasons. It is then that the question of determination of such expenditure by the Assessing Officer would arise. The requirement of adopting a specific method of determining such expenditure has been introduced by virtue of subsection (2) of section 14A. Prior to that, the assessing was free to adopt any reasonable and acceptable method.

    … So, even for the pre-rule 8D period, whenever the issue of section 14A arises before an Assessing Officer, he has, first of all, to ascertain the correctness of the claim of the assessee in respect of the expenditure incurred in relation to income which does not form part of the total income under the said Act. Even where the assessee claims that no expenditure has been incurred in relation to income which does not form part of total income, the Assessing Officer will have to verify the correctness of such claim. In case, the Assessing Officer is satisfied with the claim of the assessee with regard to the expenditure or no expenditure, as the case may be, the Assessing Officer is to accept the claim of the assessee in so far as the quantum of disallowance under section 14A is concerned. In such eventuality, the Assessing Officer cannot embark upon a determination of the amount of expenditure for the purposes of section 14A(1). In case, the Assessing Officer is not, on the basis of objective criteria and after giving the assessee a reasonable opportunity, satisfied with the correctness of the claim of the assessee, he shall have to reject the claim and state the reasons for doing so. Having done so, the Assessing Officer will have to determine the amount of expenditure incurred in relation to income which does not form part of the total income under the said Act. He is required to do so on the basis of a reasonable and acceptable method of apportionment.”

    7. Per contra, the learned counsel, Shri Manish Shah, appearing on behalf of respondent-assessee, has submitted that there would not arise any question of deduction of any expenditure incurred in relation to the income under total income, nor would arise the question of applying the method for determining the amount of expenditure in relation to the income not includible in total income under rule 8D. He has also argued that this court has held that rule 8D is prospective in nature and even otherwise considering the availability of funds, this would not have any application.

    8. On thus having heard both the sides, it can be said that the object behind the insertion of section 14A is amplified by the Supreme Court in the case of CIT v. Walfort Share and Stock Brokers P. Ltd. reported in [2010] 326 ITR 1 (SC), which clarifies that the expenses incurred can be allowed only to the extent they are relatable to the earning of taxable income. In the absence of section 14A, the expenditure incurred in respect of exempt income was also being claimed against the taxable income and such practice since was to be curbed, section 14A has been inserted. It is clarified that sub-section (1) of section 14A of the Act clearly stipulates that for the purpose of computing the total income under Chapter IV, no deduction is permissible in respect of the expenditure incurred in relation to the income which does not form part of the total income under the said Act.

    9. In the case of an income, like dividend income, which does not form part of the total income, any expenditure incurred by the assessee in relation to such non-taxable income, the claim of deduction of such expenses incurred cannot be allowed.

    10. The moot question here is as to whether the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal were right in setting aside the order of the Assessing Officer, whereby it disallowed the sum of Rs. 1,14,43,040, applying the provisions of section 14A of the Act on the ground that the assessee had used interest bearing borrowed funds for earning dividend during the assessment year under question. The dividend income earned was of Rs. 1,14,43,040 and the estimate of expenditure was assessed at the rate of 10 per cent, of the total income. Had the Revenue been successful in establishing that the assessee had incurred the expenses to earn the dividend income from the borrowed funds, the entire discussion of application of section 14A of the Act could be understood. However, when both the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal have noted that the assessee had sufficient funds available with it, which was more than the amount it invested for earning the dividend income, both these authorities have correctly approached the issue by setting aside the order of disallowance under section 14A of the Act in respect of interest expenditure. When the very basis for employing section 14A of the Act on factual matrix is lacking, the disallowance to the extent of 10 per cent, of dividend income was not permissible. When it transpires from record that the assessee's own funds were at higher, then the investment made by it and with nothing to indicate that the borrowed funds were utilised for the purpose of investment in shares and for earning dividends, the Tribunal committed no error in disallowing the sum of Rs. 1,14,43,040.

    11. As far as the other administrative expenses are concerned, the Revenue had requested to restore the matter back to the Assessing Officer. However, to put an end to the entire dispute with regard to other expenses, the assessee permitted the disallowance of Rs. 5 lakhs. The Tribunal considering the volume and the quantum of investment disallowed the said amount of Rs. 5 lakhs, which though is on estimated basis, it is a reasonable base and, therefore, the first question merits no consideration.

    12. Needless to specify at this stage that when from the facts that have emerged from record, the employment of section 14A of the Act is not found correct, there does not arise any question of determining the amount of expenditure in the absence of rule 8D, on the basis of reasonable and acceptable method of apportionment as pressed into service by the Revenue basing on the judgment of the Delhi High Court.

    13. In so far as the second question is concerned it pertains to corporate debt restructuring (hereinafter referred to as “the CDR”) expenses of Rs. 2.57 crores on payment to financial consultants in connection with the waiver of loans, the Assessing Officer noted that the respondent-assessee paid the sum of Rs. 2.57 crores to the financial consultant, M/s. Brescon Corporate Advertisers Ltd., who provided their professional services in connection with the scheme of the CDR by negotiating with the banks and financial institutions, which eventually helped the reduction of interest burden of the assessee. They were claimed to be the revenue expenditure aimed at reduction of recurring revenue expenditure of interest. The Assessing Officer held that the assessee would derive the benefit of enduring nature as a result of the CDR exercise and, therefore, it was of the opinion that all the expenses are to be treated as capital expenditure and the same were needed to be disallowed and added to the income of the assessee. The Assessing Officer relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Madras. reported in [1966] 60 ITR 52 (SC) and dismissed the plea of the assessee.

    14. The assessee on being aggrieved by such order travelled to the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), which considered this issue in detail. It noticed that the amount of Rs. 60.13 crores had been waived under the CDR and interest had also been reduced for the financial year 2003-04. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) on discussing various cases held that the same cannot be considered to be having an enduring benefit.

    15. The Tribunal on this very issue relied on the decision of Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. v. CIT reported in [1997] 225 ITR 802 (SC), wherein the question arose, whereby the Supreme Court was deciding whether a particular expenditure was revenue expenditure incurred for the purpose of business or capital in nature. It held that such question needs to be determined on a consideration of all the facts and circumstances of the case and by application of the principle of commercial trading. While holding the expenditure as revenue in nature, it spread the same over a period. The Tribunal further held that (page 559 of 1 ITR (Trib)-OL):

    “We have considered the rival submissions, perused the materials on record and gone through the orders of authorities below and various judgments cited by learned authorised representative of the assessee. We find that the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) has decided this issue in favour of the assessee by following these very judgments of the hon'ble apex court which are cited by the learned authorised representative of the assessee before us and considering the facts of the present case, we do not find any good reason to interfere in the order of the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) on this issue. We, therefore, decline to interfere in the order of the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) on this issue. This ground of the Revenue is also rejected.”

    16. In the present case also, the CDR expenses to the tune of Rs. 2.57 crores have been rightly held by both the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal as revenue in nature and the same has rightly not been held to be capital in nature. For the waiver of the loan, the payment has been made to the financial consultants. This was for the purpose of business and the same was held to be allowable under section 37(1) of the Act. Having held the said amount to be revenue in nature applying the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. (supra), when the amount has been spread over a period of six years, no error is committed by both the authorities. Once the expenditure is held to be revenue in nature incurred wholly and exclusively for the purpose of business, it can be allowed in its entirety in the year in which it is incurred. However, considering the decision in the case of Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. (supra), when the spreading is done for over a period of six years and as the assessee-respondent has no objection to such revenue expenditure being spread out, though it could have insisted for this amount allowed in the year under consideration, with no such objection having been raised, the Revenue would not succeed in this issue as the expenditure is held to be revenue in nature. Thus, the second question also does not merit any consideration.

    17. The third question pertains to excluding the waived amount of Rs. 11.63 crores out of the principal loans. What is found is that the Assessing Officer dismissed the claim of the respondent-assessee of Rs. 11.63 crores as a capital receipt essentially on two grounds. Firstly, that the waiver of the principal amount of loan had made the assessee richer by that amount and the liability to pay had seized. Therefore, this being a benefit or perquisite arising from the business, this has to be construed as an income under section 28(iv) of the Act. A strong reliance was placed by the assessee on the decision of this court rendered in the case of Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Chetan Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., [2004] 267 ITR 770 (Guj).

    18. In the case of Chetan Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. (supra), during the course of his business of inorganic chemicals procured unsecured loans from various creditors. Due to financial crunch of the company, the creditors arrived at a compromise before the competent court and they remitted the unsecured loans amounting to Rs. 1.77 lakhs along with interest that had accrued in its favour. The interest was an income liable to tax but not the remission of loan. This loan amount was taxed by invoking the provisions of section 28(iv) of the Act. The Tribunal held in favour of the assessee. On a reference, this court upheld the version of the Tribunal by holding (headnote):

    “it is an admitted position that there had been no allowance or deduction in any of the preceding years and, hence, there was no question of applying the provision as such. Section 28 of the Act deals with profits and gains of business or profession and clause (iv) thereof says that the value of any benefit or perquisite, whether convertible into money or not, arising from business or the exercise of a profession shall be chargeable as income under head ‘Profits and gains of business or profession’.”

    19. As the assessee-company was not found to be carrying on the business of obtaining loan, the court held that the remission of such loan by the creditors was a benefit arising out of such business and, therefore, such remission of unsecured loan was not taxable at the ends of the assessee.

    20. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) upheld in favour of the assessee by holding thus:

    “5… I have gone through the appeal order for the assessment year 2004-05. The facts of the assessment year 2005-06 being identical to the assessment year 2004-05, I am in agreement with my predecessor learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) that the decision of the Gujarat High Court in the case of Chetan Chemicals P. Ltd., [2004] 267 ITR 770 (Guj) and the Mumbai Tribunal's decision in the case of Helios Food Improvers Pvt. Ltd. fully apply to the appellant's case and the amount of loan of Rs. 11.63 crores waived by the financial institution cannot be brought to tax as the appellant's income under section 28(iv) and/or section 41(1) of the Income-tax Act. Addition of Rs. 11.63 crores is deleted.”

    21. This issue was carried to the Tribunal. The Tribunal also concurred with the findings of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) in the following manner (page 574 of 1 ITR (Trib)-OL):

    “We have considered the rival submissions and perused the materials on record and gone through the orders of the authorities below. We find that we have decided identical issue in the assessment year 2004-05 while deciding ground No. 5 of the Revenue's appeal in that year. Since no difference in the facts could be pointed out by the learned Departmental representative of the Revenue in the present year, we do not find any reason to take a contrary view in the present year. Hence, this ground of the Revenue's appeal is also rejected.”

    22. On a thorough examination of the issue, we are of the firm opinion that the issue is squarely covered by the decision of this court rendered in Chetan Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. (supra). In the present case also, the facts are almost identical and, therefore, the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal have rightly held in favour of the respondent-assessee. No error is committed requiring any indulgence from this court.

    23. So far as the fourth question is concerned, it pertains to the addition of Rs. 1,14,43,040 under section 115JB of the Act being the expenditure estimated on earning of dividend income under section 14A of the Act.

    24. The Assessing Officer on referring to the said provision of section 115JB(2) of the Act added the said amount considering that any amount of expenditure relatable to the income exempted under section 10 of the Act shall need to be added in the profit shown in the “Profit and loss account”.

    25. When the matter travelled to the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), since it deleted the addition of Rs. 1,14,43,040 while deciding question No. 1, it consequently deleted such addition under section 115JB of the Act on the ground that this would not serve any purpose.

    26. The Tribunal decided the said issue as follows (page 576 of 1 ITR (Trib)-OL:

    “We have considered the rival submissions and we find that a similar issue was raised by the Revenue as per ground No. 3 above in respect of regular assessment of income and while deciding that ground, we have already upheld that disallowance of Rs. 5 lakhs in respect of administrative expenses will meet the ends of justice and no disallowance is called for in respect of interest expenditure. Hence, for the purpose of computing the book profit under section 115JB of the Act also, we hold accordingly and confirm the addition of Rs. 5 lakhs. This ground of the Revenue's appeal is partly allowed.”

    27. As rightly held by both, the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal, this issue has a direct correlation with the first question. It was argued by the Revenue that while computing the book profit under section 115JB of the Act, the disallowance of interest expenditure on exempt income was wrongly negatived by both the authorities on the ground that it was not the liability for expenses, but a liability relating to assets. We find no fault in the approach adopted by both the authorities. The addition under section 115JB of the Act of a sum of Rs. 1,14,43,040 when was made as an expenditure estimated on earning of dividend income under section 14A of the Act, without reiterating the rationale of confirming deletion of such amount as has been elaborately done at the time of deciding question No. 1, this deletion requires to be confirmed.

    28. Resultantly, no question of law much less any substantial question of law arises and the present tax appeal is, accordingly, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Gujarat State Fertilizers And Chemicals Ltd.
    (Jun 25, 2013)