K.D Shahi, J.:— This petition has been filed by Shri Suresh Chandra Tiwari, hereinafter called ‘petitioner’, bus conductor, an employee of Respondent No. 2 for quashing the orders dated 31.7.1995, Annexure-17 to the writ petition, dated 6.12.1995, Annexure-18 to the writ petition, and the orders dated 5.2.1994, Annexure-14 and 15 to the writ petition and for a direction commanding the Respondent No. 4 to reinstate the petitioner w.e.f 6.2.1994
2. By order dated 6.12.1995, Annexure 18 to the writ petition the revision preferred by the petitioner against the order of removal from his service, has been dismissed by the Revisional authority, the Chairman of U.P.S.R.T.C By order dated 31.7.1995, Annexure-17 to the writ petition, the appeal of the petitioner against his removal order has been rejected as time barred.
3. By order dated 5.2.1994 two punishment orders have been passed against the petitioner removing him from service separately. By both the orders, the petitioner has been removed from his service as a punishment on the basis of the enquiry reports regarding two incidents.
4. The two incidents are dated 7.2.1992 and 5.10.1993 respectively.
5. The petitioner was appointed as a bus conductor in January, 1979, and posted at Pratapgarh. According to the respondents, on 7.8.1993 the petitioner was on duty as bus conductor in Bus No. UMP 9307 and the bus was coming from Pratapgarh to Allahabad. At Bhupiamau, the Assistant Regional Manager, Sri A.K Singh alongwith A.T.I, Shri Chandra Bhan got the bus stopped for checking purpose. The petitioner refused to give the way-bill and the tray then the A.R.M has to take two constables from the police chauki and then on checking all the passengers were found without ticket. Thirtyeight passengers were from Faizabad and twentytwo from Sultanpur, thereafter, from the passengers their ticket fares was collected. The driver of the bus was Nisar Ahmed. The tickets were issued by the checking authority and the amount recovered from the petitioner was deposited in the accounts of U.P.S.R.T.C, hereinafter referred to as ‘corporation’. The petitioner refused to sign at the way-bill. The petitioner was drunk and when he was tried to be taken out from the bus, the driver was dashed down from the bus by him and controlling himself the driving seat tried to run away towards Allahabad. Near Bakula river the bus was apprehended and was sent to Allahabad being driven by the driver of the Car. Some of the passengers travelling in bus were injured while they jumped out looking the driving by the bus conductor. On the report of A.R.M dated 18.2.1992, this enquiry was initiated and the petitioner was suspended on 22.2.1992
6. I will discuss regarding the second enquiry later on but the enquiry of present incident was conducted by Shri Rahul Saxena, A.R.M (P). At the enquiry, the petitioner denied the entire allegations and has alleged that he was ill at Faizabad and he did not proceed with the bus.
7. The enquiry report is dated 13.12.1993 I have gone through the enquiry report. Shri. A.K Singh, A.R.M has been examined on 13.9.1993 ex-parte. The informant, name not given, has been examined on 8.10.1993 The statement of Shri. Chandra Bhan A.T.I was recorded and on 18.10.1993 the driver of the bus was examined. I do not want to comment on the merit of the enquiry report.
8. The petitioner alleges that he was not given fair opportunity to participate in the enquiry and on the basis of secret statement of Chaukidar (peon) of the corporation, who is none else but the junior most employee at the bottom of the corporation and may not have courage to give statement against the corporation, it should not have been held that the petitioner was not co-operating with the enquiry.
9. Earlier the petitioner was on medical leave and on 15.7.1997 he was reinstated provisionally pending departmental enquiry. He continued to work in the corporation but in the meantime the incident dated 5.10.1993 took place. On 6.10.1993 and 7.10.1993 he was on medical leave. It is alleged that he could not recover, therefore, he applied for extension of medical leave upto 10.10.1993 and again on 10.10.1993 he applied for further medical leave till recovery.
10. From the perusal of the records, it is clear that 7.10.1993 was the date fixed for enquiry and again 18.10.1993 was fixed. It is alleged that on 18.10.1993 the petitioner came to the office of corporation.
11. The statement of A.R.M was taken on 13.9.1993 There is nothing on record to show that the petitioner was on duty on that particular date and had got knowledge of this date. The only observation of the enquiry officer was, regarding the date, the petitioner must have known on arrival in the depot (corporation). This cannot be said to be a finding that the petitioner has got knowledge of the date that there was a date of 7.10.1993 There is specific evidence that on 7.10.1993, the petitioner was ill and was on medical leave. There is nothing on record to show that the petitioner was actually not ill and his leave application has been rejected. However, the final date 18.10.1993 was given.
12. It is alleged for this date that there was an effort by the corporation to serve notice on the petitioner informing him the date of 18.10.1993 This effort of the respondents in itself shows that the petitioner has got no knowledge of the date 18.10.1993 otherwise, had the petitioner got knowledge, there was no need of making this effort. However, the notice is said to be sent by Registered Post and side by side the notice was published in daily newspapers like ‘Dainik Jagran’ or ‘Amar Ujala’, a paper of wide publication.
13. The registered letter was sent on totally wrong address. A judicial notice of the fact can be taken that the Allahpur is a very big Mohalla rather biggest in Allahabad consisting of several sub-mohallas with different names. The correct address of the petitioner is 53-B/3, Tilak Nagar, Allahpur, Allahabad. This is the address which is in the record of the corporation. Annexure SA-3 with the supplementary affidavit shows this address on which the Interview letter was sent in the name of the petitioner. Assistant District Magistrate has also given a certificate vide Annexure-SA-4 that Shri Suresh Chandra Tiwari son of Late Shri. A.B Tiwari is residing in house No. 53-B/3, Pura Dalel, Tilak Nagar, Allahpur, Allahabad. Earlier also the petitioner was suspended in the year 1990 and then he had sent some applications on 2.4.1990 and it was rejected and he was informed about the rejection order on this address 53-B/3, Tilak Nagar, Allahpur, Allahabad. All these papers are from the records of the corporation. In the earlier enquiry also a notice was published in the newspapers dated 16.6.1990 on the address 53-B/3 Tilak Nagar Baghambari, Allahabad as is clear from Annexure SA-2 but in this enquiry the Registered letter was sent on the address 22-B/103, Tilak Nagar, Daraganj, Allahabad. The newspaper publication was also on this address of 22-B/103 Tilak Nagar, Daraganj, Allahabad. Admittedly, this is not the correct address of the petitioner. It was argued by the learned counsel for the respondents that even if this address is incorrect then also there is also no other man as bus conductor with the name of Suresh Chandra Tiwari son of Late Sri A.B Tiwari. Nobody can say that this fact has certainty. Otherwise also it is settled principle of law that the notice if not personally received, cannot be presumed to have been served if it was sent on wrong and incorrect address. The address of 22-B/103, Tilak Nagar, Baghambari Daraganj, Allahabad is poles away with correct address 53-B/3, Tilak Nagar, Allahpur, Allahabad and it can not be said that both these addresses are one and the same address. It is not said that the registered letter was actually received by the petitioner and it can not be presumed that the petitioner has actually read the newspaper treating it as notice to him on this wrong address. If everything is correct and according to rules, there can be presumption, if the act is done incorrectly in a wrong way, there can not be any presumption as such.
14. Now the respondents have tried to prove that the petitioner has actually got knowledge and, therefore, he came to the depot (corporation) on 18.10.1993 From the office of A.R.M Shri A.K Singh and Assistant Account Officer Shri J.B Singh were coming out from the Office of Regional Manager, the petitioner was at the door of Officer of Regional Manager and when he saw Shri A.K Singh and J.B Singh immediately he slipped away. Munna Lal Chaukidar (peon) has been examined to prove this fact. Depot is not a place where only a chaukidar or Regional Manager seats, there may be 100 of drivers, conductors even superior officers and if the petitioner was waiting there he must have been seen by others as well. If it is possible that the petitioner saw Shri. A.K Singh and Shri J.B Singh then it is also possible that these two officers must have seen the petitioner as well but except this chaukidar no other person has been examined to show that the petitioner was present in the depot on 18.10.1993 and if he was there to see a superior officer what was the necessity of his fleeing away, has not been explained. This Munna Lal Chaukidar could not be cross-examined by the petitioner. He was not a witness in the enquiry. He was only a witness of knowledge that the petitioner had come in the depot on 18.10.1993 The petitioner denied that he was present on that day in the depot. The petitioner should have been given opportunity to cross-examine this witness who actually proved whether the petitioner was there in the depot or not, on the said particular date. On corroborated statement of any unconcerned person, it should not have been held by the enquiry officer that actually the petitioner had got knowledge of the date. Every sane mind will presume that if the petitioner has got the knowledge of 18.10.1993, as the date of enquiry, he will not go to the depot unless he had to attend the enquiry. He will not go to the depot to show that he has got knowledge of the date of enquiry. This fact in itself will go to show that the petitioner did not go to the office on 18.10.1993 and the chaukidar is a got up witness only to hold knowledge to the petitioner.
15. This court is not to go to in the correctness of the enquiry report but these factual positions were to be discussed only to show whether the petitioner got a fair opportunity to contest the enquiry and whether principles of natural justice have been complied with or not.
16. Apparently, the corporation proceeded knowingly on wrong address to inform the petitioner mala fide shall be presumed and in these circumstances the ex-parte enquiry is to be set aside and a fair opportunity is to be given to the petitioner to contest the allegations on merits.
17. Then the second enquiry in respect of alleged misconduct dated 5.10.1993 It is alleged that on 5.10.1993, the petitioner went at the bus station. One bus No. 9944 was allotted to Shri Madan Mohan, bus conductor. The petitioner entered in this bus and started to issue tickets. Incharge of the Bus Station Shri Dubey asked him not to do so and on this the bus conductor (petitioner) started to misbehave with him. He informed this fact to the Regional Manager on telephone. The Regional Manager directed Shri S.N Tripathi to visit the bus station and to set the matter at rest. An enquiry was initiated against the petitioner. The enquiry was conducted by Shri Rahul Saxena, A.R.M and vide his report dated 20.10.1993 Sri Saxena found the petitioner guilty of the charges levelled against him. This court has no right to enter into the evidence but the statement of Shri. V.P Dubey who has reported the matter, clearly shows that there was no such misconduct by the petitioner. In reply to question No. 22 which was ‘kindly tell what misbehaviour I did’. The reply was ‘nothing’. In reply to question No. 27, Shri V.P Dubey specifically replied that in his report there is no allegation of misconduct. The report of Shri. S.N Tripathi, Annexure-11, also shows that as soon as he asked him to return the tickets and the way-bill the petitioner immediately complied his order. It may be true that the petitioner might not have been allotted the bus and in a zeal to join the duty, he may have done so getting that Madan Mohan had not arrived at bus station at that time. He might have also thought that Madan Mohan may not come on duty or may not come to take the bus. At any rate in the teeth of the above report and the statement, the charges are not such on which the petitioner could have been removed from service. Sri S.N Tripathi was a best witness of the case, has not at all been examined. He would have been the best witness to tell what was the misbehaviour done by the petitioner, but the finding that the petitioner consented that Sri S.N Tripathi may not be examined is of no value. It was the duty of the enquiry officer to examine the best witness and to take best evidence. Without formal proof the report of Sri S.N Tripathi could not have been read into evidence. Particularly this report is not against the petitioner when he reported that the petitioner immediately complied with his orders.
18. Regarding this enquiry, the petitioner has been removed from his service. The punishment must commensurate to the charges and the charges are not such for which he could have been removed from his service. A person can not be hanged for a trifling offence.
19. I do not want to go into the orders passed by the Appellate authority. The appellate authority dismissed the appeal of the petitioner only as time barred. The revisional court cannot go into the merits and decide the revision as an appeal. If the appellate order alone was challenged, the revisional authority should have given a finding whether the appeal was time barred or not and if the appeal was not time barred and if he was pleased/interested to condone the delay, the revisional authority should have remanded the matter for fresh hearing of the appeal on merits. I fully agree with the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the appellate order was not on merit instead the revisional order was on merits, thus prejudice has been caused to the petitioner.
20. As discussed above, the enquiry did not meet fair trial and the petitioner has been deprived of his rights, inherent into the provisions of natural justice. I do not want to go into the details of the merits of the enquiry but the learned counsel for the petitioner argued that if enquiry reports are set aside, the petitioner should be put into service and back wages etc. should be given to him and the enquiry proceeding should be quashed. I do not agree with this argument. The allegations of the first enquiry are so serious in nature that it shall not be proper to drop the enquiry. This is the petitioner who himself says that he has not been afforded any opportunity to participate in the enquiry and, therefore, enquiry report is incorrect.
21. The petitioner should be given an opportunity to participate in the proceedings and if the corporation on fresh enquiry finds that actually the petitioner was guilty, suitable punishment may be given to him but it can not be said here in this court that the petitioner was innocent and he should be outright exonerated. The only remedy which remains open to the petitioner is that he should face both the enquiry and charges against him. He may challenge the charges and may contest the charges levelled against him but in this petition he can not be said to be not guilty or innocent.
22. The writ petition is hereby allowed. The enquiry report dated 24.11.1993 and 13.12.1993 and the consequent punishment orders dated 5.2.1994 are hereby set aside. Consequently the appellate order dated 31.7.1995 and the revisional order dated 6.12.1995 are also hereby quashed. The respondents are directed to conduct a fresh enquiry regarding both the misconducts in accordance with law and also the observations as contained in the body of the judgment.
23. It shall remain open to the Corporation to consider and pass a speaking order whether the petitioner should be reinstated during the enquiry or not. As regards the payment of back wages and salary and other service benefits it shall also depend upon the ultimate result of the enquiry. However, there is no direction of this Court whether the petitioner should be reinstated and given back wages and salary etc. of the earlier period or not. It is upto the Corporation to pass suitable orders according to their own discretion.
24. Petition Allowed.