Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Central Health Services (Amendment) Rules, 1966,
  • Central Health Services Rules, 1963,
  • Central Health Services Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Central Health Services (Amendment) Rules, 1966,
  • Central Health Services Rules, 1963,
  • Central Health Services Rules
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an office order (annexure 1) promoting respondent 4, Dr. R.B. Sinha, as Additional Medical Superintendent (Super Time Grade II). Annexure 1A is the letter rejecting the petitioner's representation against that promotion.

The petitioner joined Heavy Engineering Corporation Hospital in 1963 as G.D.M.O. Grade II, changed her name after marriage, and was promoted to G.D.M.O. Grade I in 1970. A seniority list circulated in 1972 showed the petitioner as the senior-most G.D.M.O. Grade I, with respondent 4 three places junior. Respondent 4 joined in January 1966 and was promoted to G.D.M.O. Grade I in 1971.

The petitioner's grievance was that respondent 4, though junior in seniority, had been promoted in preference to her. An acting appointment of respondent 4 to Super Time Grade II took place on 30 May 1980 and was not challenged at the time. When the post was later filled on a regular/selection basis (office order dated 27 March 1981), the petitioner represented that she, being senior, should have been promoted. Her representation was rejected by letter dated 14 December 1981 (annexure 1A), and she filed the present writ petition challenging the promotion order as illegal and violative of Articles 14 and 16 and principles of natural justice.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the promotion of respondent 4 to Super Time Grade II (Additional Medical Superintendent) in preference to the petitioner was illegal or without authority in law.
  2. Whether the promotion violated Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India or principles of natural justice.
  3. Whether allegations of mala fide and bias against the Chief Medical Officer (respondent 5) were made out with the requisite proof to invalidate the promotion.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The promotion order dated 27 March 1981 (annexure 1) was illegal and without authority.
  • The promotion contravened Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India (equal protection and equality of opportunity in public employment).
  • The promotion violated the principles of natural justice.
  • Allegations of mala fide and bias were raised against the Chief Medical Officer (respondent 5).

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondents 2 and 3 stated that, from 1 January 1974, the Corporation adopted the Central Health Services Rules, 1963, as amended (including amendments of 1966), for pay, recruitment and promotion of medical officers; relevant provisions for promotion to Super Time Grade II were set out (Rule 8(3) and Second Schedule requirements).
  • The applicable rule provided that 50% of Super Time Grade II vacancies are filled by promotion on recommendation of the D.P.C. on the basis of merit and seniority, with specified eligibility criteria (e.g., minimum years of service) and the remaining 50% by direct recruitment.
  • Annexure 1 to the Second Schedule specified that post-graduate qualifications were the minimum qualification for promotion to Super Time Grade II (and post-graduate qualification was treated as an important factor in assessing merit).
  • The screening committee considered the petitioner in May 1980 and found her unfit for acting promotion because she lacked hospital administration experience, relevant training, had average A.C.R., and lacked post-graduate qualification; respondent 4 had post-graduate qualification, superior A.C.R., training and administrative experience and was promoted on acting basis from 30 May 1980 (an acting appointment not challenged by petitioner at that time).
  • For the regular/selection promotion in 1981 a Departmental Promotion Committee (D.P.C.) assessed candidates (petitioner, respondent 4, and Dr. S. Das Gupta) on merit and seniority; respondent 4 was found more suitable based on specific qualifications, trainings, higher A.C.R., prior acting experience and postgraduate degree.
  • The Chief Medical Officer (respondent 5) denied bias and mala fide, stating the selection board (three members) unanimously found the petitioner not suitable and respondent 4 suitable; the selection post is to be filled by merit and seniority and the selection board acted accordingly.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the factual matrix and the selection process as recorded in the respondents' affidavits and the material placed before the Departmental Promotion Committee (D.P.C.). The court's analysis proceeded in these steps:

  1. Identification of the applicable rules: The court noted that the Corporation had adopted the Central Health Services Rules (1963) as amended, including provisions relevant to promotion to Super Time Grade II. Rule 8(3) provides that 50% of vacancies are by promotion on the basis of recommendation of the D.P.C. on merit and seniority, and the Second Schedule requires post-graduate qualifications as minimum for Super Time Grade II.
  2. Distinction between acting appointment and regular selection: The court observed that respondent 4 had been promoted on acting basis in May 1980—a step the petitioner did not challenge at that time—and that the subsequent 1981 appointment was a regular selection to be made on the basis of merit and seniority.
  3. Evaluation of comparative merit: The D.P.C. considered qualifications, trainings, administrative experience, A.C.R. ratings and prior acting experience. The court recorded the committee's findings that respondent 4 possessed a Master Degree in Surgery, multiple administration and management trainings, superior A.C.R., and prior acting service as Additional Medical Superintendent—whereas the petitioner held only an M.B.B.S., had been G.D.M.O. Grade I from April 1970, lacked post-graduate qualification, had average A.C.R., and did not have comparable hospital administration training or experience.
  4. Conclusion on the legality of selection: Because the post was a selection post and the criteria were merit and seniority, the court accepted the D.P.C.'s assessment that respondent 4 was the better and more suitable candidate. The court found no basis to treat the selection as violative of Articles 14 or 16 or of natural justice.
  5. Assessment of mala fide/bias allegation: The court emphasized that allegations of mala fide and bias require strong proof. The Chief Medical Officer denied bias and the selection board was unanimous in its assessment. The petitioner had not discharged the heavy burden of proving mala fide or that respondent 5 influenced other members improperly.

The court's analysis is confined to the material and arguments discussed in the record: adoption of the Central Health Services Rules by the Corporation, the D.P.C.'s consideration of qualifications and experience, and the absence of convincing proof of mala fide or breach of natural justice.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED. The writ application is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that respondent 4's promotion to the post of Additional Medical Superintendent (Super Time Grade II) stands and the petitioner's challenge to quash that promotion fails.
  • The court found that the departmental selection process, conducted on the basis of merit and seniority as provided by the applicable rules, properly preferred respondent 4 over the petitioner. The petitioner's allegations of violation of Articles 14 and 16, of natural justice, and of mala fide by respondent 5 were not established on the record.
  • The opinion does not discuss broader legal consequences or establish any new legal precedent beyond the adjudication of the parties' dispute; the decision resolves the parties' rights under the facts and record presented.

There will be no order as to costs.

    Minakshi Bose (Dr.) (Smt.) v. Union Of India And Others

    1. The petitioner has challenged the order contained in annexure 1, whereby respondent 4, Dr. R.B Sinha, was promoted as Additional Medical Superintendent. Annexure 1A is the letter rejecting the petitioner's representation.

    2. The petitioner, then named, as Dr. (Miss) Thelma Hayward, joined the Heavy Engineering Corporation Hospital in 1963 as G.D.M.O Grade II. After her marriage in 1968 she changed her name as Minakshi Bose. In 1970, she was promoted as G.D.M.O Grade I. In the seniority list of the doctors circulated by the Corporation (annexure 2) she was shown as senior-most G.D.M.O Grade I in the service. Respondent 4 was three places junior to her in the aforesaid seniority list. He joined the hospital of the Corporation in January 1966 as an Assistant Surgeon. He worked in different departments and was promoted in the year 1971 to the post of G.D.M.O Grade I.

    3. The petitioner's grievance is that although respondent 4 was junior to the petitioner in the seniority list of the year 1972, he was wrongly promoted as Additional Medical Superintendent (Super Time Grade II) in preference to the petitioner. Since the said appointment was purely on ad hoc basis, the petitioner considered it only as a local arrangement and did not protest against the same. According to her, this did not affect the seniority list and did not create any light and any superiority over the petitioner. Sometime, in July 1980, she learnt that promotions on permanent basis would be made from G.D.M.O Grade I to Super Time Grade II in the scale of Rs. 1500–2000. Accordingly, she made an application and drew the attention of the Chairman of the Corporation to the facts that she was seniormost and was entitled to prior consideration for promotion to Super Time Grade II. However, the promotion of respondent 4 was effected by office order, dated 27 March 1981. She then made a representation to the Chairman against the said order of promotion. By letter, dated 14 December 1981, she was informed by the Junior Manager (P) of the Corporation that on careful consideration of her case, the management was unable to agree to her request. The said letter is contained in annexure 1A.

    4. Sri B.C Ghosh, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner contended that the order, dated 27 March, 1981 (annexure 1) by which respondent 4 was promoted to Super Time Grade II was illegal, without authority in law and in contravention of Arts. 14 and 16 of the Constitution and the principles of natural justice.

    5. In the counter-affidavit filed by respondents 2 and 3, the statement is categoric that with effect from 1 January 1974, the Chairman of the Corporation decided that in the matter of pay-scale, dearness allowance, N.P.A, recruitment and promotion, the Medical Officer of the Corporation will be governed by the Central Health Services Rules, 1963, as amended by the Central Health Services (Amendment) Rules, 1966, as amended from time to time. The said rule was further amended on 9 September, 1966 and known as Central Health Services (Amendment) Rules, 1966. The relevant rules may be noticed:

    “Rule 8(3): Super Time Grade II.

    (a) Fifty per cent of vacancies in Super Time Grade II shall be filled up by promotion.

    (i) General Duty Officers Grade I with not less than ten years of service in that category.

    (ii) Specialists Grade Officer with not less than 8 years of service in that category; in ratio of 2:3 on the recommendation of the D.P.C on the basis of merit and seniority of officer concerned, provided that no person shall be eligible for appointment to any such post unless he possesses the qualification and experience requisite for appointment to such posts.

    (b) The remaining fifty per cent of the vacancies shall be filled up by direct recruitment in the manner specified in the Second Schedule.”

    Annexure 1 to the Second Schedule states that the post-graduate qualifications be minimum qualification for promotion to the post of super Time Grade II.

    6. In May 1980, occasion arose for filling up the post of Additional Medical Superintendent on acting basis (Super Time Grade II). The screening committee was constituted consisting of D.G.M (Administration and Personnel), Chief Medical Officer and Manager (Finance). The screening committee also considered the case of the petitioner and did not find her fit on the ground that she did not possess experience in hospital administration nor trained in hospital administration management development, etc., her A.C.R was average and she did not have post-graduate qualification. On the other hand, respondent 4 was found having high qualification of post-graduate, better A.C.R training in hospital administration as also experience in hospital administration. Accordingly, on 30 May, 1980 respondent 4 was promoted on acting basis to the Super Time Grade II which was never challenged by the petitioner. Thereafter when again the said post was decided to be filled up on regular basis in the year 1981 it was to be filled up on selection basis irrespective of seniority and criteria-were merit and seniority. For the purpose of promotion by selection a departmental promotion committee was constituted which was headed by the General Manager, H.M.B.P, Chief Medical Officer and Senior Deputy General Manager (Administration and Personnel).

    7. The case of the petitioner was considered along with respondent 4 and one Dr. S. Das Gupta. Amongst the three candidates, the respondent 4 was found more suitable than the petitioner and Sri Gupta because of his following qualification and experience:

    (a) A Master Degree in Surgery.

    (b) Has done course of Management Development from Central Training Institute of H.E.C

    (c) Has done a course on Developing Skill in Problem Solving from the Management.

    (d) All India Semiral of Hospital Administration Organisation of Armed Force Medical College, Pune, Indian Hospital Association as attained by him.

    (e) Attendance of 4 weeks' course on Hospital Administration organised by National Institute of Health and Family Planning Welfare, Delhi.

    (f) Attended or entered training course in Family Welfare Planning Organisation organised by Indian Medical Association.

    (g) Acting as Additional Medical Superintendent (Super Time Grade II) with effect from 30 May 1980.

    (h) A.C.R above average.

    (i) G.D.M.O Grade I given on 14 January 1971.

    On the other hand the qualification and experience of the petitioner was:

    (i) M.B.B.S and no other qualification..

    (ii) G.D.M.O Grade I given on 29 April 1970.

    8. After considering the better qualifications, experience and A.C.R and other activities, the departmental promotion committee found respondent 4 more suitable and better hand than the petitioner. The D.P.C found that the petitioner had no qualification of post-graduate, no experience in administration of training and had average A.C.R Sri S. Das Gupta was also not found fit for the same reason. Thus, the case of the petitioner was fully considered along with others and the selection board found that respondent 4 was better and more suitable candidate for promotion than the petitioner. The statement made in Para. 4 of the supplementary affidavit was controverted and it was stated that the petitioner had no experience in hospital administration. The petitioner's main function was professional job only. She being the seniormost in dispensary concerned, she was made incharge of the particular dispensary and hence she was incharge of very small group of medical officers and staff working there for co-ordinating the day to day activities carried out in the dispensary. It was stated that in the Heavy Engineering Corporation, there are six small dispensaries and the petitioner was incharge of only one such dispensary. In reply to the amendment petition filed on behalf of the petitioner it was stated that the petitioner must prove that she is a tribal although at the time of selection her case was considered.

    9. The allegation of mala fide and bias pleaded against the Chief Medical Officer of the Corporation (respondent 5) has been denied, in his category statement in the counter-affidavit, the Chief Medical Officer has stated that he was never biased against the petitioner nor did he act mala fide, since the petitioner failed to be appointed to the post in question, she made all baseless allegations against him. The petitioner's case was fully considered by the selection board in which he was one of the members and she was not found fit for promotion. The post in question was a selection post. In a selection post always the suitable persons are appointed. It was to be filled up by merit and seniority. All the three members of the selection board including him were unanimous while considering the case of the petitioner that she was not suitable to the post in question. The respondent 4 was found suitable by the selection board. Respondent 4's performance, qualification, experience and other activities were superior to the petitioner, hence the selection board rightly appointed him after considering the case of the petitioner. It has also been stated by the Chief Medical Officer of the Corporation that the Central Health Services Rules have, in practice, been adopted by the Corporation. The rule may not prescribe the post-graduate qualification but while considering the merit between the two persons, it always gives an additional, point. Respondent 4 having post-graduate qualification, had better qualification and experience than the petitioner who did not possess the postgraduate qualification. The selection board found him suitable in every respect. Further respondent 4 had ten years experience for the purpose of appointment to the post in question.

    10. Considering the facts of this case, it must be held that the petitioner has failed to make out any case for interference by this Court, the impugned order, therefore, cannot be quashed as violative of Arts. 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India or the principle of natural justice. Her case was fully considered on its own merit by the Departmental Promotion Committee. The criteria for promotion to the post of Super Time Grade II were merit and seniority. The selection board was a duly constituted body and after properly considering the respective suitability of the candidates, it found respondent 4 more suitable for the said post. Therefore, the contention raised by the petitioner's counsel must fail. The allegation of bias and mala fide raised against respondent 5, the Chief Medical Officer, for the first time in the supplementary affidavit, has been categorically denied and it is difficult to assume that he must have influenced the other two members of the selection board. In the matter of filling a Selection Grade Post, the question of seniority alone is not relevant and I find no reason to interfere with the selection actually made on the basis of merit. The allegation of mala fide is often more easily made than proved and the very seriousness of such allegation demands proof of high order of credibility. The burden of establishing mala fide is very heavy on the person who alleges it. Here, the petitioner has failed to discharge the burden of establishing mala fide against respondent 5.

    11. In the result, this writ application is dismissed but there will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Minakshi Bose (Dr.) (Smt.) v. Union Of India And Others
    (Aug 12, 1986)