AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 105 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • sec. 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 105 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • sec. 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
Smart Summary

Analytical Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

These appeals challenge orders made by a Special Judge under Chapter X of the Bengal Tenancy Act in proceedings described as being under section 105 for settlement of a fair and equitable rent for excess lands. Although the proceedings were nominally framed under section 105, issues were raised and decided which the Court considered to fall appropriately within the scope of section 106.

The landlord (Respondent) raised preliminary objections that the appeals were incompetent and that the Appellants ought to be restricted to the specific question for the consideration of which the appeals were admitted under rule 12 of Order XLI of the Code of 1908. The appeals were then argued before the Appellate Court which considered the competence of a second appeal as well as the substance of grounds relating to assessment of additional rent under section 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a second appeal is admissible as to questions properly falling within section 105 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
  2. Whether an Appellate Court may, under rule 12 of Order XLI, restrict the grounds on which an appeal (admitted under that rule) may be finally heard.
  3. Whether the Special Judge properly considered all elements required by section 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act before assessing additional rent for excess lands (a contention characterised as falling within the scope of section 166).
  4. Whether a deduction (10%) from the measured excess area was improper, given section 52's entitlement to additional rent for lands proved by measurement to be in excess.
  5. Whether the landlord was entitled to costs in the court of first instance for making and serving applications under section 105.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • One principal ground (characterised as within section 166) was that the Special Judge had not properly considered all the elements required by section 52 before assessing additional rent for excess lands.
  • The Appellants contended that because the kabuliyats described land as lying within certain specified boundaries, section 52 did not apply (relying on the authority cited as Annada v. Mathura).

Respondent (Landlord) Arguments and Cross-Objections

  • Preliminary objection that the appeals were incompetent and, alternatively, that the Appellants should be restricted to the single question for which the appeals had been admitted under rule 12 of Order XLI.
  • Cross-objection 1: Under section 52 the landlord is entitled to additional rent for all lands proved by measurement to be in excess of the area for which rent had previously been paid; therefore the courts below erred in allowing a 10% reduction from the measured area.
  • Cross-objection 2: The landlord had been denied costs in the Court of first instance and therefore should be awarded at least the costs incurred in making the section 105 applications and serving them on the tenants.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pitthee Chand v. Basarat Ali The opinion names this authority in its preliminary discussion of objections; no explicit rule or principle from this case is set out in the provided text. The case is mentioned but the provided opinion does not state a specific way in which its principle was applied to the decision described.
Ratan Lall Biswas v. Jadu Hahana Recognises that if a landlord cannot prove the area previously held under the original lease and there is no material to determine whether the rent was a consolidated rent, the landlord is not entitled to increase of rent under section 52. The Court cited this principle but found it inapplicable to the present cases because, here, the landlord had established the elements required by clause (a) of sub-section (1) of section 52.
Gouri Pattra v. H.R. Reily Supports the proposition that recitals in leases or rent receipts are not conclusive proof of the area previously held and that comparisons of area require proof that measurements were made by the same standard. The Court distinguished the present facts from such cases because here the landlord showed prior measurement by a known standard and entry in the kabuliyats; thus the recitals were supported by a prior scientific measurement.
Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chunder Bhusan Goswami Similar to Gouri Pattra: indicated that recitals alone may be insufficient and same-standard measurement is required before comparing earlier and present areas. The Court relied on the contrast with the present facts—where prior measurement according to a known standard had been proved—and therefore did not apply the restrictive principle from these authorities to deny additional rent.
Rajendra Lal v. Chunder Bhusan; Suijakant v. Banesar; Rajkumar v. Ram Lal These cases were cited as authorities supporting the conclusion that the elements required by section 52 can be established by the landlord on facts similar to those here. The Court noted that the courts below correctly held that the elements mentioned in section 52 had been established by the landlord, and these authorities were cited in support of that conclusion.
Annada v. Mathura Authority relied on by Appellants to contend that where land is described as lying within specified boundaries in the kabuliyats, section 52 may not apply because the description could be an approximate statement as to boundaries rather than an exact measured area. The Court considered this principle but rejected its application on the facts: because prior area had been ascertained "by scientific methods" and recorded, the mention of boundaries did not exclude section 52 in the present cases.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two principal analytical strands: first addressing procedural objections and then the substantive issues under section 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act and the landlord's cross-objections.

Procedurally, the Court accepted the correctness of the submission that no second appeal is admissible in respect of any question properly falling within the scope of section 105; the Appellants, however, did not press any such question. The Court then analysed the objection that the Appellants should be restricted to the single ground for which the appeals had been admitted under rule 12 of Order XLI. The Court held that it was not competent for an Appellate Court, under rule 12 of Order XLI, to restrict the grounds on which an appeal admitted under that rule is to be finally heard. The restrictive order made earlier under rule 11 (when the cases were heard under rule 11) was characterised as ultra vires. The Court relied on the text of rule 11 and rule 12: rule 11 permits dismissal without serving notice in certain circumstances; rule 12 provides that unless dismissed under rule 11, the Appellate Court shall fix a day for hearing the appeal—i.e., the whole appeal, not any selected ground. Consequently the Court concluded that all grounds in the memorandum of appeal were open for final consideration.

Substantively, the Appellants argued (labelled as within section 166) that the Special Judge had not properly considered all the elements required by section 52 before assessing additional rent. The Court addressed the relevant legal test in clause (a) of sub-section (1) of section 52: the landlord must prove (1) the area for which rent has previously been paid, (2) the present area held by the tenant (via measurement), and (3) that the excess falls outside exceptions (e.g., additions previously belonging to the tenure lost by diluvion, etc.). The Court described the landlord's evidential position: prior measurement according to a known standard, assessment of rent upon that area, and entries in the kabuliyats; further measurement according to the same standard showing excess in occupation. Given those facts, the Court concluded that the landlord had established the elements required by section 52 and was entitled to claim additional rent unless the rent had been shown to be a consolidated rent for an area governed by specified boundaries irrespective of quantity.

The Court considered the authorities cited by the parties. It distinguished Ratan Lall Biswas (which disallowed increase where landlord failed to prove prior area or consolidation of rent) on the ground that those conditions were not present here. It also distinguished cases that treated recitals in leases or rent receipts as inconclusive unless measurements used the same standard; here the landlord had shown prior scientific measurement and entries in the kabuliyats consistent with that measurement.

The Appellants' contention that the mere mention of boundaries in the kabuliyats precluded the application of section 52 (by analogy to Annada v. Mathura) was rejected because the facts established prior scientific measurement; therefore the logical inference was that the lands measured and described as lying within certain boundaries had been let out with reference to measured area and not merely approximate boundary description.

Turning to the landlord's cross-objections: first, the landlord submitted that no reduction (the 10% deduction) should have been allowed from the measured area because section 52 entitles the landlord to additional rent for all lands proved by measurement to be in excess. The Court found that, on closer examination, the deduction was not improper. The Special Judge had found that the prior measurement was not absolutely accurate and made a 10% deduction to allow for possible errors. The landlord's own conduct—an expressed willingness to allow an 8% deduction—undermined a serious contestation of the accuracy of prior measurement. On that basis, the Court could not hold that the lower courts contravened section 52 by permitting the deduction.

Second, on costs, the Court found merit in the landlord's submission that some costs in the Court of first instance should have been allowed. The Court therefore allowed the landlord costs at the rate of Rs. 2 for each tenant for the costs incurred in making the applications under section 105 and in serving them upon the tenants, unless such costs had already been paid.

Finally, the Court recorded the parties' agreement that questions concerning pasture land would be left open, and that nothing decided in these proceedings would affect title, possession, or user of such land.

Holding and Implications

Holding:
APPEALS DISMISSED. The Court dismissed the appeals and allowed the cross-objections in part.

Immediate consequences and practical implications:

  • The appeals are dismissed; the decisions of the courts below (as to the matters considered) are affirmed in substance.
  • The landlord's cross-objection concerning the denial of costs in the Court of first instance is allowed in part: the landlord is awarded costs of Rs. 2 per tenant for making and serving the section 105 applications unless already paid.
  • The Court upheld the lower courts' conclusion that the elements required by section 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act were proved by the landlord on the facts before it; the Appellants' main substantive ground therefore failed.
  • The deduction of 10% from measured area by the Special Judge was not treated as a contravention of section 52 in the circumstances (given findings as to measurement accuracy and the landlord's concessions).
  • Questions as to pasture land (title, possession or user) are expressly left open and are unaffected by this judgment.
  • There is no affirmative statement in the provided opinion that it establishes any new, general precedent beyond the application of existing principles to the facts; the decision resolves the appeals and partially allows cross-objections as described above.

Costs in this Court: There will be no order as to costs in this Court.

Appeals dismissed:
Cross-objections allowed in part.

    Lukhi Narain Serowji And Ors. v. Sri Ram Chandra Bhuiya And Others

    These appeals are directed against orders made by a Special Judge under Chapter X of the Bengal Tenancy Act in proceedings under sec. 105 for settlement of fair and equitable rent for excess lands. Although the proceedings have been nominally described as framed under sec. 105, questions have been raised and decided which appropriately fall within the purview of sec. 106. Pitthee Chand v. Basarat Ali. Preliminary objections have been taken on behalf of the landlord Respondent that the appeals are entirely incompetent and that at any rate the Appellants ought to be restricted to the specific question for the consideration of which alone the appeals were admitted under r. 12 of Or. XLI of the Code of 1908.

    In so far as the objection is taken that no second appeal is admissible in respect of any question properly falling within the scope of sec. 105 of the Bengal Tenancy Act it is obviously well-founded. Indeed the learned Vakil for the Appellants has not argued any question of that description in support of the appeal. But in so far as the objection is taken that the Appellants should be restricted to the one ground for the consideration of which the appeals were admitted, we are of opinion that it ought not to prevail. It is not competent to a Court of Appeal under r. 12 of Or. XLI of the Code to restrict the ground or grounds upon which the appeal admitted under that Rule is to be heard finally; in other words, the restrictive order of this Court made at the time when the cases were heard under r. 11 of Or. XLI was ultra vires. R. 11 provides “that the Appellate Court after sending for the record, if it thinks fit so to do, and after fixing a day for hearing the Appellant or his pleader and hearing him accordingly if he appears on that day, may dismiss the appeal without sending notice of the appeal to the Court against whose decree the appeal is made and without serving notice on the Respondent or his pleader.” R. 12 then provides that “unless the Appellate Court dismisses the appeal under r. 11 it shall fix a day for hearing the appeal.” It is worthy of note that a day is to be fixed for bearing the appeal, that is to say, the whole appeal and not any selected ground out of those specified in the memorandum of appeal. Consequently all the grounds taken in the memorandum of appeal by the Appellants are open for consideration at this the final hearing, and we now proceed to examine them.

    In support of the appeals one ground has been urged which falls within the scope of sec. 166, namely, that the Special Judge has not considered properly all the elements which must be established under sec. 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act before additional rent can be assessed in respect of the excess lands. Reference has been made to the case of Ratan Lall Biswas v. Jadu Hahana(2) which recognises the principle that in a suit brought by the landlord for increase of rent on account of increase in the area of the holding, if it is found that the tenant is holding land without any variation of the boundaries and the landlord fails to prove what the area was under the original lease of the tenant, and further if there are no materials before the Court for the determination of the question whether the rent is a consolidated rent or not, the landlord is not entitled to any increase of the rent under sec. 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. That principle in our opinion has no application to the circumstances of the present cases in which the elements mentioned in cl. (a) of sub-sec. (1) of sec. 52 have been established by the landlord. That clause provides that every tenant shall be liable to pay additional rent for all land proved by measurement to be in excess of the area for which rent has been previously paid by him, unless it is proved that the excess is due to the addition to the tenure or holding of land which having previously belonged to the tenure or holding was lost by diluvion or otherwise, without any reduction of the rent being made.” In order to bring the case within this rule, it is necessary for the landlord to prove that there is land held in excess of the area for which rent has been previously paid by the tenant. Consequently the landlord must establish the area for which rent has previously been paid by the tenant; he must next establish the present area held by the tenant; he is then enitled to claim additional rent in regard to the excess area. In this class of cases, the chief difficulty of the land-lord is that he is not able to establish the area for which rent has been previously paid by the tenant. In the case to which reference is made ss also in the cases of Gouri Pattra v. H.R Reily and Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chunder Bhusan Goswami reliance was placed by the landlord upon recitals in documents like leases and rent receipts to prove the area previously held by the tenant; it was held by the Court that such recitals were by no means conclusive and that at any rate before a comparison could be made between the area previously held and the area at present found to be in occupation of the tenant, it must be shewn that the measurement on the two occasions was made according to the same standard. In the case before us, however, the landlord is in a position of considerable advantage. He is able to show that these lands were measured according to a known standard on the previous occasion, that the rent was assessed upon area so determined, and that the area as well as the rent payable were entered in the kabuliy is executed by the tenants. The landlord further shows by measurement according to the previously adopted standard, that the lands now in occupation of the tenants are in excess of the areas entered in the kabuliyats. Obviously, unless it is established that the rent was a consolidated rent for an area within specified boundaries irrespective of its precise quantity, the landlord is entitled to claim additional rent for the excess lands. The landlord has further shewn that there is good ground to explain the increase in the area in most instances, for example, it has been shown that either the tenant had in the neighbourhood waste land upon which he made encroachment or the measurement on the previous occasion was fraudulent or erroneous. Under the circumstances, the Courts below have correctly held that the elements mentioned in sec. 52 have been established by the landlord [Rajendra Lal v. Chunder Bhusan, Suijakant v. Banesar and Rajkumar v. Ram Lal]. But the learned Vakil for the Appellants has contended that as the land is described as lying within certain specified boundaries in the kabuliyats, sec. 52 has no application [Annada v. Mathura(7)]. In our opinion, there is no foundation for this contention. No doubt, in casts where the history of the tenancy is not known and we have no information as to the circumstances under which the area of the land was mentioned in the contract between the parties, it may be contended that the land as lying within certain specified boundaries was intended to be let out, and the description of the area was merely an approximate statement. Here, however, as we have already stated, it is specifically known that the area was ascertained by scientific methods, consequently the only inference which could be legitimately drawn was that the lands measured and described as lying within certain boundaries were let out to the tenants. The contention of the Appellants that the mere mention of the boundaries in the kabuliyats excludes the operation of sec. 52 cannot therefore be sustained. The main ground upon which the appeals have been sought to be supported thus fails.

    On behalf of the landlord Respondent two cross-objections have been urged. It has been contended in the first place that under sec. 52 the landlord is entitled to additional rent for all lands proved by measurement to be in excess of the area for which rent has been previously paid by the tenant and that consequently the Courts below were not entitled to allow a reduction of 10 per cent, from the area as ascertained by measurement. Primâ facie, this contention appears to be well-founded, but upon a closer examination it turns out to be unsubstantial. The Special Judge has held in effect that although on a previous occasion the lands were measured the measurement was not absolutely accurate and he has practically made a deduction of 10 per cent, to allow for possible errors in the measurement. The objection of the tenants to the accuracy of the measurement was considerably strengthened when the landlord expressed his willingness to allow a deduction of 8 per cent. This concession, if it be called a concession, shows that the landlord was not prepared seriously to contest the position taken up by the tenants that the measurement on the previous occasion was not absolutely accurate and ??? cannot, therefore, held that the Courts below have contravened the provisions of sec. 52. The second ground urged in support of the cross-objections is that the landlord has not been allowed any costs in the Court of first instance. In our opinion there is some force in this contention and the landlord ought to have been allowed, at any rate, the costs incurred by him in making the applications under sec. 105 and in serving them upon the tenants. We therefore allow the landlord costs at the rate of Rs. 2 for each tenant unless such costs have already been paid.

    It is finally agreed between the patties that in so far as the pasture land is concerned, the question will be left open and that nothing that has been held or decided in these proceedings will affect the question of title, possession or user thereof.

    The appeals are therefore dismissed and the cross-objections allowed in part. There will be no order as to costs in this Court.

    Appeals dismissed:
    Cross-objections allowed in part.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lukhi Narain Serowji And Ors. v. Sri Ram Chandra Bhuiya And Others
    (May 29, 1911)