Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Art. 179 of the Limitation Act of 1877
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Art. 179 of the Limitation Act of 1877

    C. Sarvothama Rao v. C. Raja Rao Sahib

    Spencer, J. — The Subordinate Judge's observation in his judgment “the 5th defendant, though he is the purchaser of the right of redemption of the mortgagors, cannot except by consent of the 2nd mortgagee redeem him” is clearly an erroneous statement of the law. The case of Het Ram v. Shadi Rami(1) was one of a decree becoming inoperative and ineffective under Art. 179 of the Limitation Act of 1877 owing to the decree-holder's failure for 3 years to take any steps to execute it. It does not support the Subordinate Judge's proposition. In the face of the District Judge's observations in his judgment dated 29th July 1918 in the connected appeal (C.M.S.A 60 of 1919) that the 5th defendant was clearly entitled to redeem the prior mortgage in his position of purchaser of equity of redemption, it should not have been possible for the Subordinate Court to fall into this error of law on 17th October 1918.

    I agree with my learned brother that the appeal should be allowed on the terms as to interest and costs proposed by him and the case remanded to the Lower Court for working out the respective rights and liabilities of the parties in the light of his judgment.

    Ramesam, J.—This is an appeal arising in execution proceedings in O. S. No. 6 of 1913 on the file of the Court of the Subordinate Judge of North Arcot. The appellant before us is the 5th defendant and the respondent is the assignee of the plaintiff-decree-holder. The 5th defendant is the prior mortgagee, under two deeds dated 1st March 1890 and 6th August 1891 of 4-7th share in the Villages of Sevoor and Kolathur. The plaintiff is the puisne mortgagee of 2-7th share of these and other villages under a deed dated 15th September 1895 the 2-7th share mortgaged being included in the 4-7th share mortgaged to 5th defendant, as far as Sevoor and Kolathur villages are concerned. The 5th defendant obtained decrees on his mortgages without making the plaintiff a party and himself purchased the mortgaged properties in execution. The plaintiff then brought the suit, O. S. No. 6 of 1913, making the prior mortgagee—purchaser a party (5th defendant) and obtained a decree for sale subject to the prior mortgage. The preliminary decree, dated 18th August 1913 directed the defendants (including the 5th defendant) to pay the amount due to the plaintiff and the final decree directed a sale, On 22nd January 1918, the 5th defendant deposited the amount due to the plaintiff under his decree and sought to redeem his mortgage. Notice of this application was served on the plaintiff who appeared on the 5th February 1918 and resisted the application. The Subordinate Judge has dismissed the application. No authority has been cited by the Subordinate Judge or before us to support his statement that a prior mortgagee who is also a purchaser of the equity of redemption cannot redeem the puisne mortgagee without his consent. At one stage of the argument Mr. Ganapathi Aiyar contended that the prior mortgagee purchased nothing by his purchase and relied on Sivaraman Chetty v. Kuppumuthu Chetty, and Ponnambala Chetti v. Muthusami Pillai(2). But he, afterwards having first conceded that’ (1) a mortgagor can assign his equity of redemption (2) that for such assignment the consent of a mortgagee is not necessary, (3) that such assignment may be by private transfer or by sale in court auction and (4) that the sale in court auction may be in execution of a money decree or of any other decree, also conceded that the prior mortgagee-purchaser may be entitled to redeem. Indeed it is well settled that all that is meant by the proposition that the position of a puisne mortgagee is not affected by the suit, decree and sale in execution at the instance of a prior mortgagee who has not made the puisne mortgagee a party to his suit is that the former retains at his option both the remedies which were available to him before such a suit viz., to redeem the prior mortgagee and to sell the properties for the amount due on both the mortgages, and (2) to sell the property subject to the 1st mortgage (see Mulla Vittil Seethi v. Achvthan Nair, Chinnu Pillai v. Vencatasami Chettiar, and Het Ram v. Shadi Ram(3), and it was never laid down that the mortgagor's equity of redemption does not pass to the purchaser who is also prior mortgagee, merely because this puisne mortgagee was not made a party. The sentence in Ponnambala Chetti v. Muthusami Pillai(4), taken with the context does not support the respondent.

    The respondent's vakil then contended that he is first entitled to redeem the prior mortgage and then only the 5th defendant can redeem him. In view of the decree he was content to obtain in this case, it is doubtful if he can now redeem the prior mortgagee. But, even if it is permissible to him to do so, the actual formality need not be gone through. The effect of granting the appellant's prayer is as if the respondent pays a certain amount to the appellant for redemption of the prior mortgage and the appellant returns the said amount plus the amount due on the second mortgage for redemption of both the mortgages. Apart from this, there is no reason to support the proposition that the redemption by a puisne mortgagee of a prior mortgage is a condition precedent to the exercise of the right of redemption of the puisne mortgage itself, by an assignee of the mortgagor's equity of redemption. The appeal is therefore allowed.

    The respondent now says that he is not willing that the 5th defendant should redeem his mortgage except as to two-seventh share of Sevodr and Kolathur which can be done by paying the proportionate part of the mortgage amount that may be chargeable on two-seventh share of these villages. The appellant, though he has deposited the whole amount due to the respondent, is agreeable to this course. In my opinion, as the respondent has resisted the appellant's petition and has not stated his willingness on 5th February 1918, he is entitled to interest only up to that date. The part of the mortgage amount due to the plaintiff proportional to two-seventh share of Sevoor and Kolathur will now be ascertained and the respondent will draw the amount so settled. The balance of the appellant's deposit will be returned to him. The two-seventh share of Sevoor and Kolathur will be declared free of the mortgage of the plaintiff. The plaintiff will be permitted to draw the amount deposited by him on 24th January 1918. As it does not appear that the notice of this deposit was served on the appellant earlier than 5th February 1918, the respondent is not entitled to interest on the amount deposited by him up to that date and is not in any event entitled to interest after that date. The respondent will bear the costs of the appellant in this Court. Each party is to bear his own costs in the Court below. The case will be remitted to the Court below for ascertaining the amount mentioned supra.

    C. K.Case remanded.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    C. Sarvothama Rao v. C. Raja Rao Sahib
    (Feb 4, 1921)