Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Dowlat Rai v. Khub Lal Singh

    Coxe, J.:— The plaintiff in this case claimed to have purchased the land in suit in the execution of a mortgage decree obtained by one Seo Deni against Mangni and others. The suit was dismissed by the Munsif but decreed in appeal by the Subordinate Judge. The defendants appeal to this Court.

    2. First, it is contended that the Subordinate Judge should have come to a finding on the validity of the plaintiff's purchase. The Munsif held that the mortgage and the decree and sale following on it were all fraudulent and colorable transactions. The Subordinate Judge came to no finding on this point and, I think, the case must go back for a decision of it. It is argued on the authority of what is litte more than a casual observation in the case of Achal Ram v. Kazim Husain Khan . [1905] 27 All. 271 that the defendants are not entitled to question the purchase.

    3. This contention seems to me quite unsustainable. All that was said in the case cited was that the question, whether the whole or a part of the consideration of a transaction, that was admitted by the parties to it had passed, was no concern of a stranger to it. The decision is not and could not be an authority for holding that a defendant cannot question the title of the plaintiff in a suit for recovery of possession, if the plaintiff's alleged vendor supports him.

    4. Secondly, the Munsif found that the judgment-debtors whose rights were bought by the plaintiff, had cosharers and were not entitled to the whole of the interest that purported to pass. The Subordinate Judge has not found whether the plaintiff's purchase covered the whole interest or not. This point also must be decided.

    5. The Subordinate Judge has also relied on certain entries in what is called a thak map and field book. It is argued that these entries are only admissible against proprietors, as tenants had nothing to do with the preparation of the thak maps. But it is laid down generally in Jagadindra Nath Boy v. Secy. of State . [1903] 30 Cal. 291 that these papers are evidence and the scope of their Lordships observations is not restricted to cases in which proprietors only are parties. As to the assertion that tenants had nothing to do with the thak maps we can only gather the facts from the maps themselves. The present map is quite unlike an ordinary thak map. It shows a village divided into numerous little plots and obviously it was the intention of the surveyor to record not only proprietors' interests but also those of tenants.

    6. The map indeed closely resembles the khasra field map which appears opposite p. 366 in Khullur's Manual of Surveying (Edn. 3) That map refers to the district from which this appeal comes. The preparation of a map of this kind is described on the following pages of the Manual and certainly appears to be conducted with publicity. I find a foot note on p. 7 of a work recently published by Major Hirst, Director of Surveys, Bengal and Assam, on the revenue surveys that runs: “In the early days of the revenue surveys the khasra survey was used as a thakbust a well as a khasra survey, later on, sometimes both were made but it will be generally found that if a thakbust map was prepared no khasara was compiled, and vice versa.” It seems to me that this map and field book could not have been compiled at all unless the possession of the persons holding the plots shown in it had then been asserted and; that the entries are therefore evidence under Section 13 of the Evidence Act. Reliance has been placed on the decision of Jarao Kumari v. Lalonmoni . [1891] 18 Cal. 224. It was held in Abdul Hamid Mian v. Kiran Chandra Boy . [1903] 7 C.W.N 849. that it was not decided in Jarao Kumari's case that maps were not evidence but merely that the map filed in that case was of no weight. But in any case the decision is easily distinguishable. The fact of the defendant's possession in that case apparently was not disputed and the question was whether the lands which they possessed at the time of the survey were recorded as rebutter or not. Now the character of the possession was no concern of the surveyor and therefore his record with regard to it would be of no value. I think therefore that the Subordinate Judge was right in holding that the map and its explanatory field book were admissible in evidence and it is for him and not for us to weigh its value. But I cannot find that the Judge has directed his mind to the actual entries before him. As they have been laid before us they show that two plots were in sir possession of Ramdeni Singh. The effect of the word “sir” may be disregarded under the authority of the decision of Jarao Kumari v. Lalonmoni, but the entry of the land as in the possession of Ramdeni Singh is, in my opinion, admissible in evidence. The other plots are shown as in the possession of Dalib Koeri and Hal want Singh. How these entries support the plaintiff's case has not been explained to us and the Subordinate Judge does not apparently address his mind to the point.

    7. The judgment of the Court below seems to me defective and not in accordance with the requirements of O. 20, R. 4.

    8. The appeal must be allowed, the order of the Subordinate Judge set aside and the case sent back for re-hearing of the appeal with regard to the foregoing observations. Costs will abide the result.

    D. Chatterjee, J.:— I agree.

    V.B/R.K

    9. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dowlat Rai v. Khub Lal Singh
    (Feb 10, 1914)