Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Acts
  • S. 25, P.S.C.C. Act
  • S. 25 of Central Act, IX of 1887.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Acts
  • S. 25, P.S.C.C. Act
  • S. 25 of Central Act, IX of 1887.

    Kanhayalal v. Surajmal

    ORDER

    Atma Charan, J.C.

    1. Heard the parties. This is a defendant's application in revision from the order of the trial Court decreeing the plaintiff's suit for recovery of a certain sum of money. The only question that arises in this application is whether the claim before the trial Court was barred by time, or not. It is an admitted case of the parties that the claim was barred by time in case the plaintiff is not allowed 2-4 days benefit according to the rules as said to have been framed by the Commercial Exchange, Ajmer. No such rules, however, are forthcoming. Oral evidence has been led on behalf, of the plaintiff to the effect that according to the market practice payment could be made within 2-4 days after delivery is due. Even if the oral evidence to the effect be relied on, it would in no way extend the period if limitation. The oral evidence just means this that the delivery may be made within 2-4 days after it is due i. e., the party to whom delivery is to be made ordinarily would keep quiet and ask for no interest in case the delivery is made to him within such a short period.

    2. It has then been argued by the counsel for the plaintiff that the Court should not interfere on the revisional side just on a question of limitation under S. 25 of Central Act, IX of 1887. The Court certainly could revise a decision of a Small Cause Court on a question of limitation, where such decision is wrong and has resulted in an injustice to a party. The rulings to the effect that a wrong 'decision on a question of limitation is not a ground for interference should not be taken as laying down a sound proposition of law as those cases were mainly decided under the impression that the grounds for interference under S. 25, P.S.C.C. Act were the same as those under S. 115, Civil P.C. The application in revision accordingly is allowed, the order of the trial Court decreeing the suit for recovery of a certain sum of money is set aside and the plaintiff's suit is dismissed with costs of the two Courts.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kanhayalal v. Surajmal
    (Dec 26, 1951)