AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The present suit is for recovery of immoveable land. There was a previous suit between the plaintiff's vendor and the 2nd defendant concerning mesne profits of the same land, in which the first suit was dismissed on the ground that the person in possession (the 2nd defendant) had title and was not liable for profits. The plaintiff in the present suit derives title from the vendor who was party to the earlier suit. The lower courts had allowed the present suit; on appeal the question is whether the present suit is barred by the doctrine of res judicata (section 11, Civil Procedure Code) and by lis pendens (section 52, Transfer of Property Act).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the present suit for recovery of immoveable land is barred by section 11 (res judicata) of the Civil Procedure Code by reason of the prior suit concerning mesne profits in which title to the same land was directly and specifically in question.
  2. Whether the doctrines of lis pendens (section 52, Transfer of Property Act) and res judicata operate to bind the plaintiff who derived title pendente lite from the plaintiff's vendor.
  3. Whether precedents concerning moveable property (notably Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb) or earlier decisions involving distinct immoveable properties (notably Niaz-Ullah Khan… v. Nazir Begam…) are applicable to bar the present suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant / 2nd Defendant

  • The suit is barred by section 11, Civil Procedure Code (res judicata) because the first suit directly and specifically raised the title to the same immoveable property and decided against the plaintiff's vendor.
  • The doctrine of lis pendens (section 52, Transfer of Property Act) applies to immoveable property and prevents the vendor from divesting rights pendente lite so as to defeat the prior adjudication.

Respondents / Plaintiff

  • Reliance on Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb: where moveables were involved, a subsequent purchaser pendente lite was treated as a stranger and the former decree was not res judicata.
  • Reliance on Niaz-Ullah Khan…(Defendant); v. Nazir Begam…(Plaintiff): where prior adjudication concerned immoveable property other than the property in the later suit, section 11 did not bar the second suit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb Held that a former decree as to moveables was not res judicata against a subsequent bona fide transferee pendente lite; lis pendens (s.52 Transfer of Property Act) inapplicable to moveables; s.11 CPC did not apply where title to transferee arose before final decision. Distinguished: the present case involves immoveable property and the title to the same immoveable was directly and specifically in question in the prior suit, so Govind Baba does not govern this case.
Niaz-Ullah Khan…(Defendant); v. Nazir Begam…(Plaintiff).* Where a former adjudication related to immoveable property other than that which is the subject of the later suit, section 11 (then s.13) CPC was held not to bar the later suit. Distinguished: in the present case the prior suit directly and specifically raised title to the very same immoveable property, so Niaz-Ullah Khan is inapplicable.
Wigram v. Buckley Cited for the inapplicability of the doctrine of lis pendens to moveable property. Referenced as authority relied on in Govind Baba; used to explain why moveables are treated differently from immoveables.
Deo dem. Foster v. The Earl of Derby Illustrates that evidence in one suit is not automatically part of the proceedings in another suit between different parties absent agreement; supports treating a purchaser of moveables pendente lite as a stranger. Referred to in discussion of Govind Baba to explain limits on applying adjudications across distinct suits and parties.
Brinsmead v. Harrison Principle that a judgment against one of two joint tort-feasors is a bar to a subsequent suit against the other; finality of litigation (transit in rem judicatam). Quoted (Lord Blackburn) to support the general principle of finality and to justify invoking res judicata when appropriate.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined whether section 11, Civil Procedure Code and section 52, Transfer of Property Act operated to bar the present suit. Both judges analysed precedents relied upon by the respondents and distinguished them from the present facts.

Sadasiva Ayyar, J.: Noted Govind Baba concerned moveables and rested on two propositions—lis pendens does not apply to moveables (s.52 T.P. Act) and s.11 CPC did not apply where title arose before final determination. He held the present case involves immoveable property and the title to the very same property was directly and specifically in question in the prior suit; consequently the principles underlying s.52 and s.11 apply and the earlier decision is res judicata against the plaintiff. He also observed Niaz-Ullah was distinguishable because the prior suit there did not directly and specifically raise title to the property in the later suit.

Tyabji, J.: Concluded prima facie that s.11 CPC applies because the prior suit decided that the person in possession (2nd defendant) had title; he reviewed Govind Baba and the English authorities relied upon, explaining their reasoning and limits (inapplicability to immoveables where lis pendens applies). He found both Govind Baba and Niaz-Ullah inapplicable to the present facts and held sect.11 directly applicable, so the suit is barred. Both judges therefore reversed the lower courts and dismissed the suit.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED — Appeal allowed.

Holding: The earlier adjudication that the plaintiff's vendor had no title and that the 2nd defendant was owner of the land is res judicata against the plaintiff; the lower courts' decrees are reversed and the suit is dismissed with costs to be paid by the plaintiff to the 2nd defendant.

Implications: The direct consequence is dismissal of the plaintiff's suit and an order for costs in favour of the 2nd defendant. The court applied established doctrines of lis pendens (s.52, Transfer of Property Act) and res judicata (s.11, CPC) to immoveable property where the title to the same property was directly and specifically in issue in the prior suit. The opinion distinguishes earlier authorities concerning moveables and cases where the prior adjudication concerned different property; no expansion of doctrine beyond these applications is announced.

    Talari Kavoli Nagadu . v. Visvanatham Pedda Govindappa And Others

    JUDGMENT

    Sadasiva Ayyar, J.—In the case in Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb quoted for the respondents, the question was whether a former decree adjudging the right to moveables in A's favour against B was res judicata in the second suit by A against C who got a pledge of moveables from B during the pendency of the first litigation; and it was held that the question was not res judicata. The reasons given for this decision are (a) the doctrine of lis pendens does not apply to moveables (compare section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act); (b) section 11, Civil Procedure Code does not apply because the final determination of the first suit was after the pledge, and C, though he claimed under A, claimed under a title created before the determination of the first suit though after it was instituted (and had probably become contentious).

    In the present case the property in dispute is immoveable property and it was alienated pending a suit about its profits between the present plaintiff's vendor and the 2nd defendant in which suit the title to the property was “directly and specifically in question'’, the question having been the subject of a direct issue in the first suit as well as in the second suit. Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb might thus be distinguished. I might, however, be permitted to say that the fact that section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act relates only to immoveable property should not make us blind to the consideration that the legal principle underlying it might appropriately be applied to moveables also in cases where the alienee of the moveables is proved to have had notice of the pending litigation at the time of the alienation. It is not unconditionally extended to moveables because (among other reasons) it is considered that, where a pending litigation as regards immoveables might very well be presumed to be enquired into by intending purchasers pendente lite the same cannot be presumed as regards pending litigation about moveables which usually pass from hand to hand and the litigation about which does not usually end in a decree for the return of specific moveables but in the award of pecuniary damages and compensation’ either as the only relief or an adequate alternative relief. Reliance is further placed on the case in Niaz-Ullah Khan…(Defendant); v. Nazir Begam…(Plaintiff).* by the respondents' learned vakil. In that case, the first litigation related to a house, and the second related to another distinct immoveable property which was sold pendente lite by the party in the first suit who was unsuccessful. Though a question was raised in the first case which involved the title of the unsuccessful party to the house and to other properties (which she claimed as heir of a deceased person), the immoveable property in question in the second suit was not specifically mentioned and was not the subject of an issue which directly and specifically raised the title to it in the first suit and in that view, that case might also be distinguished. In the present case, the issue in the first suit directly and specifically raised the question of title to the very same immoveable property which is in dispute in this second suit, though the subject-matter of the first suit was only the crops raised on that property. I might be permitted to finally remark (with great deference) that some of the English cases which unduly whittle down the beneficient principles which underlie the doctrines of lis pendens and res judicata by rather subtle refinements need not be too much relied on by Indian Courts.

    In the result, I would hold that the decision in the former suit between the plaintiff's vendor and the 2nd defendant that the plaintiff's vendor had no title to plaint land and that the 2nd defendant is the owner thereof is res judicata against the plaintiff and in favour of the 2nd defendant in this case; and reversing the decree of the lower Courts I would dismiss the suit with costs throughout to be paid by the plaintiff to the 2nd defendant (appellant).

    Tyabji, J.—The question involved in this appeal is whether the suit out of which it arises is barred by the doctrine of res judicata (sect. 11 of the Civil Procedure Code). The facts are as follows. There was a previous suit in which the question at issue was as to the right to mesne profits accrued due on the land that is the subject-matter of the present suit. The present suit is for recovery of the same land. The first suit was dismissed, it having been held that the person in possession (the second defendant in the present proceedings), had title to the land and was not liable to account for its profits to the then plaintiffs. It is admitted that the plaintiff cannot succeed in the present suit unless it is decided that the second defendant has no title to the land in opposition to the decision in the first suit. The provisions of section 11, Civil Procedure Code, seem to be satisfied and prima facie it would seem that the suit is barred.

    It is argued, however, that there are two cases which support the view of the lower Courts that the present suit is maintainable. The respondents' argument will be best considered on examination of those cases and the grounds (if any) on which the present case can be distinguished from them.

    The first of the cases relied upon is Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb. The reasoning on which that decision proceeded I understand to be as follows. The question was whether or not a previous decision declaring an adoption to be invalid was binding as res judicata on the defendant. It was held that the decision was not binding, inasmuch as the decision was pronounced after the defendant derived his title to the property in question (consisting of certain ornaments), and that though the said decision was pronounced in a suit which had already been instituted at the date when the defendant's title arose, yet the actual decision being after the said date the decision could not be made to relate back to the time when the suit was instituted and could not thus be made to affect the title of the defendant, because the doctrine of lis pendens (sect. 52 of the Transfer of Property Act) was inapplicable to cases in which the property involved is moveable. The authorities cited for the inapplicability of the doctrine of lis pendens were Wigram v. Buckley and other English decisions. The Court in Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb evidently considered that by this distinction a person who purchases moveable property pendente lite is placed in the same position as a stranger. He is not privy to the action and is not bound by what transpires in it. The case of Deo dem. Foster v. The Earl of Derby(3) is referred to. There, two persons A and B were owners of two different closes (though originally A was owner of both), A and B each instituted suits in ejectment against C in regard to the two closes. In the suit B v. C evidence of B's title was given, and the suit decreed against C. On that, C consented to a decree against himself in the other suit A v. C. It was held that in the absence of proof that there was any agreement between A and C that the evidence in the suit between B and C should be evidence in the suit between A and C that evidence could not be considered to have been part of the proceedings in the suit of A v. C. The Court in 36 Bom., 189 considered that the inapplicability of the doctrine of lis pendens to immoveable property rendered the person through whom the party to the 2nd suit was claiming a person in a position similar to that existing between A and B in Deo dem. Foster v. The Earl of Derby. It may therefore be stated shortly that the decision in Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb is that if A derives his title to moveable property from B at a time when a suit is pending against B in which B's title is questioned (and in which the decision is ultimately against B's title) then A's predecessor-in-title is B of the dubious title, and not B of the title as destroyed by adverse adjudication,

    The decisions in Brinsmead v. Harrison, [1871] L. R., 6 C. P., 584 and [1872] L.R 7 C. P., 547. also cited in Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb refer to the doctrine that when there are two joint tort-feasors a judgment (though unsatisfied) against one of them is a bar to a subsequent suit against the other. The reason being thus stated by Lord Blackburn in Brinsmead v. Harrison(4).

    “The question raised upon this record is whether the claim of the plaintiff against two joint wrong-doers is put an end to by a Judgment recovered in an action against one of them without showing that the Judgment has been satisfied. I apprehend that it is on the ground that transit in rem judicatam, or upon the general principle of convenience which is expressed in the maxim “Interest republice ut sit finis litium.” It is for the general interest, that having once established and made certain his right by having obtained a Judgment against one of several joint wrong-doers, a plaintiff should be allowed to bring a multiplicity of actions in respect of the same wrong. I apprehend it is not and that, having established his right against one, the recovery in that action is a bar to any further proceedings against others.”

    There seem to be very clear grounds therefore for holding that the decision in Govind Baba Gurjar v. Jijibai Saheb does not apply to the present case. Here the first suit was for mesne profits. It seems to me to be clear from the Judgment in the first suit that there the right to immoveable property was directly and specifically in question within the terms of section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act. So that here the doctrine of lis pendens applies and the plaintiff cannot say “I purchased from him whose title was under adjudication and not from him whose title has been adjudicated upon against him, from him of the dubious title and not from him whose title is set at rest.”

    The decision in Niaz-Ullah Khan…(Defendant); v. Nazir Begam…(Plaintiff).* is the second case relied upon by the respondent. There the facts were as follows. The previous adjudication was pending when the plaintiff in the latter suit derived his title. It had reference to immoveable property but it was property other than the property which was the subject-matter of the latter suit. The court in effect held that the matter directly and substantially in issue in the former suit was title to property other than that which was the subject of latter suit, and that therefore section 11 (then section 13) of the Civil Procedure Code was no bar to the second suit. The decision in Niaz-Ullah Khan…(Defendant); v. Nazir Begam…(Plaintiff).* is also therefore inapplicable to the present case.

    For these reasons sect. 11 seems to me to be directly applicable. The suit should therefore have been dismissed with costs. The appeal will consequently be allowed with costs throughout.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Talari Kavoli Nagadu . v. Visvanatham Pedda Govindappa And Others
    (Jul 24, 1914)