AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an application under Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for anticipatory bail made by the petitioner, who was the Manager (under suspension) of the Ernakulam branch of Dhanalakshmi Bank. A spurious bank draft for Rs. 1 crore purporting to have been issued by that branch was presented in Andhra Pradesh; the Bank was authorized to issue drafts only up to Rs. 9 lakhs. The petitioner was the exclusive custodian of the draft book, though he says the peon had access in practice. The petitioner says a missing sheet was exploited by others (Krishna Kumar, Dhananjayan and associates) and that he is being falsely implicated. The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) disputed this and, relying on investigative facts, contended that the petitioner was complicit and that arrest, questioning, search and seizure were necessary. The Magistrate/High Court was asked to decide whether anticipatory bail should be granted. The petitioner also asked that his lawyer be permitted to be present during questioning.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether this is a fit case for the grant of anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC given the facts and material on record.
  2. Whether the petitioner should be permitted to have his lawyer present when he is questioned, in light of constitutional protections (Art. 22(1)) and related principles.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner denies involvement in the creation of the spurious draft and contends that others (Krishna Kumar, Dhananjayan and associates) created the draft and are attempting to implicate him through influence and money.
  • As Manager, he explains that the peon had practical access to the draft book; a sheet was found missing when he attended to a request for a small draft and the office/head office were informed and the missing sheet noted.
  • The petitioner asserted willingness to cooperate with the investigating agency and offered assurance that he would not abscond or interfere with the investigation.
  • The petitioner requested that his lawyer be permitted to be present while he is questioned.

Respondent's (Director of Public Prosecutions') Arguments

  • Investigation indicates complicity of the petitioner with others in presenting the spurious draft; therefore arrest, questioning, search and seizure are necessary.
  • Investigative facts pointed to by the DPP include: absence of a proper code number on the draft; the code number present not matching an Andhra Pradesh bank branch but a branch at Karakulam in Trivandrum District; incorrect power-of-attorney numbers shown on the draft; travel by the Assistant Manager, the peon Radhakrishnan and others to Andhra Pradesh on the same flight with tickets apparently booked by an Abkari contractor; and numerous trunk calls from the hotel in Vizag to the petitioner’s residence number in Ernakulam.
  • There is a risk that release on anticipatory bail would prevent segregation of documents, permit tampering with evidence and hinder investigation; public interest demands refusal of anticipatory bail.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurbaksh Singh v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 565; AIR 1980 SC 1632 That the High Court and Court of Session should exercise jurisdiction under Section 438 CrPC by a wise and careful use of discretion; courts should be trusted to act objectively rather than be bound by inflexible rules. The court invoked this principle to emphasize the wide but judicially controlled discretion available under S. 438 and to frame the analysis that anticipatory bail must be granted sparingly and on the facts of the case.
Nandini Satpathy v. P.L. Dani, (1978) 2 SCC 424; AIR 1978 SC 1025 The availability of a lawyer for consultation to an accused in near-custodial interrogation; the lawyer's presence promotes observance of the right against self-incrimination under Art. 20(3) and Art. 22(1). The court relied on this precedent to hold that the petitioner’s counsel must be permitted to be present when the petitioner is questioned.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by articulating and applying the legal principles governing anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC:

  1. Legal framework and discretion:

    The court explained that anticipatory bail is effective at the moment of arrest and that the express prohibition in Section 437(1) (regarding offences punishable with death or life imprisonment) is not present in Section 438 and cannot be read into it. Thus S. 438 confers a wide discretion on the High Court and the Court of Session to grant or refuse anticipatory bail, which should be exercised wisely and in light of the particular facts and circumstances. The discretion must be exercised sparingly and only in exceptional cases; an order under S. 438 is exceptional and requires a special case.

  2. Material on record and considerations relevant to refusal:

    The court emphasized the necessity of considering the material on record against the accused and stated that grant of anticipatory bail is not to be routine. The relevant considerations include potential prejudice to investigation, risk of tampering with evidence, risk of absconding, public interest, and any possible ulterior motive of harassment. The court noted that it must not intrude upon investigational powers of the police.

  3. Application of principles to the facts:

    The court summarized the competing factual narratives: the petitioner’s account that a missing sheet was misused by others, and the DPP’s account based on investigative findings indicating the petitioner’s complicity. The court listed investigative points relied upon by the DPP (missing/incorrect code numbers, incorrect power-of-attorney numbers, coordinated travel arrangements, trunk calls to the petitioner’s residence and other investigational facts referred to but not fully disclosed in the opinion).

    The petitioner’s explanations (business canvassing trip, calls relating to official business and willingness to cooperate) were noted, but the court found the DPP’s apprehensions not baseless on the available material.

  4. Balancing of interests and conclusion:

    Considering the above, and bearing in mind the need to avoid prejudice to investigation and to protect public interest, the court concluded that the particular facts and circumstances — including the difficulties likely to be faced by the investigating agency — deterred the court from exercising its discretion in favour of the petitioner. Therefore, anticipatory bail should be refused at this stage.

  5. Request for lawyer's presence:

    Separately, the court addressed the petitioner’s request that his lawyer be permitted to be present during questioning. Relying on Article 22(1) of the Constitution and the principle from Nandini Satpathy that lawyer presence is fundamental for near-custodial interrogation and promotes the right against self-incrimination, the court concluded that the petitioner’s lawyer must be allowed to be present when the petitioner is questioned.

Holding and Implications

APPLICATION FOR ANTICIPATORY BAIL DISMISSED.

Direct consequences:

  • The petition for anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC was dismissed; the petitioner will not receive anticipatory bail on the present record.
  • The petitioner’s lawyer is, however, to be permitted to be present when the petitioner is questioned by the investigating agency.

The opinion does not purport to establish any broader legal precedent beyond applying existing principles (notably those in Gurbaksh Singh and Nandini Satpathy) to the facts; its practical effect is the denial of anticipatory bail in this specific case while safeguarding the petitioner’s right to consult and have counsel present during questioning.

    V. Nandanan v. Dig Of Police (Crime), Hyderabad And Another

    1. The question that poses for consideration is whether this is a fit case for the grant of anticipatory bail. Anticipatory bail is granted in anticipation of arrest and it is effective at the very moment of arrest unlike ordinary bail which is granted after arrest. The prohibition in S. 437(1) that a person against whom there are reasonable grounds for believing that he is guilty of an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life shall not be released on bail is not there in S. 438 and it cannot be read into that section also. The discretion in granting anticipatory bail is very wide. But that judicial discretion has to be exercised only if the Court of Session or the High Court considers it fit so to do on the particular facts and circumstances of the case and on such conditions as the case may warrant. Discretion to refuse anticipatory bail is also there if the circumstances of the case so warrant, on considerations alike those mentioned in S. 437 or which are generally considered to be relevant under S. 439. The Court is free to refuse anticipatory bail if the materials on record justify such refusal. It is true that Art. 21 of the Constitution provides that no person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to the procedure established by law. In order to meet this challenge the grounds for refusal of anticipatory bail must be fair, just and reasonable. The Court has also to see that investigation is the province of the police and an order for anticipatory bail should not operate as an inroad into the investigational powers of the police. In this connection it is relevant to note the observation of the Supreme Court in Gurbaksh Singh v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 565 : AIR 1980 SC 1632 : (1980 Cri LJ 1125):

    “Therefore the High Court and the Court of Session should be left free to exercise their jurisdiction under S. 438 by a wise and careful use of their discretion which, by their long training and experience, they are ideally suited to do. The ends of justice will be better served by trusting these courts to act objectively and in consonance with principles governing the grant of bail which are recognised over the years, than by divesting them of their discretion which the legislature has conferred upon them, by laying down inflexible rules of general application”.

    2. The prayer in this case will have to be considered in the background of the principles mentioned above. It has to be further borne in mind that a direction under S. 438 need be given only “if it thinks fit”. The Court is required to consider the material on record against the accused. Anticipatory bail is not to be granted as a matter of course in all cases where the applicant has reason to believe that he may be arrested on an accusation of having committed a non-bailable offence. Grant or refusal of such bail must depend upon variety of circumstances, cumulative effect of which must enter the judicial verdict. The power under the section has to be exercised sparingly and in exceptional cases using the discretion on the facts of each case. An order under S. 438 being an exceptional type there must be a special case made out for passing such an order. It should not be allowed to circumvent the normal procedure of arrest and investigation. Ulterior motives of harassment and reasonable possibility of the accused not absconding are only some of the considerations. Some little facts may be necessary in the exercise of the discretion to grant or refuse the prayer.

    3. Petitioner is the Manager (under suspension) of the Ernakulam branch of the Dhanalakshmi Bank. A draft for Rs. One crore was issued purporting to be from that branch at a time when the petitioner was the manager. Petitioner and the respondent have two different versions regarding the draft and the circumstances under which it came into existence. Anyhow it is common ground that it is a spurious draft. The Bank had authority to issue draft only up to rupees nine lakhs while the impugned draft is for rupees one crore.

    4. As Manager the petitioner was admittedly the exclusive custodian of the draft book. But he says that as a matter of practice access to the book is given to the peon who used to take them to the Manager whenever necessary. Petitioner's case is this. One Krishna Kumar approached him for a draft for Rs. 5,000/-. When the peon brought the draft book one sheet was found missing and he was told about this by the peon whose name is Radhakrishnan. Draft was issued to Krishna Kumar in the next sheet and the office was instructed to make note of the missing sheet. Head Office was also informed. Thereafter Krishna Kumar wanted refund of the draft amount to be paid to peon Radhakrishnan and the papers also to be returned to him. It was the missing sheet that was utilised for creating the spurious draft which was produced, in Andhra Pradesh by one Dhananjayan, who is said to be rich and influential. It is the further case of the petitioner that he has no hand in the transaction and Krishna Kumar, Dhananjayan and their associates are now attempting to use their influence to implicate him.

    5. On the other hand the Director of Public Prosecutions had a different story to say and it is this. Dhananjayan is a man of little means but one with bad antecedent and some influence. Early this year he went to Andhra Pradesh apparently to procure some rice. There he happened to meet one Prabhas Reddi who is doing Abkari business. From him Dhajanjayan learned that Abkari contract is lucrative there. From there he alerted his Abkari friends at Cochin and persuaded them to participate in Abkari auction to be held by the District Collector, Vizag. Krishna Kumar and others are also his associates. As a condition precedent to the participation in auction there rupees one crore which is a equivalent of the monthly rent for the previous year had to be remitted. For that purpose they procured the disputed draft and presented it before the Collector, Vizag on 22-8-1985. That was issued by the Ernakulam branch of Dhanalakshmi Bank of which petitioner was the Manager and it contains the signatures purporting to be those of the petitioner who was the Manager as well as those of Asst. Manager, Cashier etc. It proved suspicious and crime 321 of 1985 of the Vizag Police Station was registered and it is now under investigation.

    6. The Director of Public Prosecutions said that investigation so far conducted points to the complicity of the petitioner also along with others and hence his arrest, questioning, search, seizure etc. are necessary. In support of these statements he pointed out certain facts brought out by investigation and they are. In a draft there must be the code number which is absent in this case. The number shown in the draft is not intended for any Bank in Andhra Pradesh but to a branch at Karakulam in Trivandrum District. The Manager and Asst. Manager are having power of attorney numbers, but those numbers shown in the draft are not correct. In the same flight in which the person who carried the draft went to Andhra Pradesh the Asst. Manager of the Ernakulam branch of Dhanalakshmi Bank, peon Radhakrishnan and others left for Andhra Pradesh with flight tickets booked for them by an Abkari Contractor at Ernakulam from his company account. They have not claimed any I.A from the bankj. That Contractor did not go because his mother died. From Dolphin Hotel at Vizag where these people were staying there were a number of Trunk Calls to 37547 which is the residence number of the petitioner at Ernakulam. From these and other facts which cannot be divulged at present it was contended that involvement of the petitioner is assured by investigation.

    7. Petitioner's counsel says that the officials of the Bank went to Andhra Pradesh only to canvass business and I.A will be claimed only if their errand is successful. According to him the Trunk Calls from Dolphin Hotel were by the Bank Officials and they were contacting him only in connection with the said official business. It is not necessary for me at this stage to deal further into these matters regarding a case which is only at the stage of investigation. Anyhow from these facts I could only say that the apprehension entertained by the Director of Public Prosecutions cannot be said to be baseless. Though the petitioner says that Krishna Kumar, Dhananjayan and others are using their influence and money to implicate him falsely, the argument of the Director of Public Prosecutions was that they are actually his associates. I was told that over and above questioning of the petitioner and effecting search and seizure, another possible difficulty, if the petitioner is released on bail, is that prevention of segregation of documents by him will become impossible and there is also the risk of himself tampering investigation. It is said that now there are six or seven suspects and many more are likely to have involvement and public interest demands refusal of anticipatory bail.

    8. S. 438 of the Code was introduced on the recommendations of the Law Commission in its report which made mention of the rich and influential persons trying to implicate their opponents in false cases for political and other reasons and trying to get their detention in custody by way of harassment. It is true that one of the objects of S. 438 is to avoid such harassment in appropriate cases. But in this case I do not think that I will be justified at this stage in accepting the contention of the petitioner that he is being falsely implicated on account of the influence of Krishna Kumar, Dhananjayan and others. According to the investigating agency petitioner and all these persons are associates in this venture. It is also true that another consideration that has to weigh with the court in granting anticipatory bail is the conviction that the person may not abscond or misuse the bail. Even though the counsel for the petitioner said that his client is prepared to co-operate with the investigating agency to any extent I cannot act on that statement alone ignoring all the apprehensions entertained on behalf of the investigating agency. If what is said by the Director of Public Prosecutions is correct this is a case which evolves public interest and the release of the petitioner at this stage is likely to affect the investigation and thereby public interest adversely. In exercising the judicial discretion in granting anticipatory bail the Court should not be unmindful of the difficulties likely to be faced by the investigating agency and the public interest likely to be affected thereby. Investigation is the field of the police and not the province of court and the actions of the Court should not be allowed to prejudice the investigation. I think that the particular facts and circumstances of the case mentioned above including the difficulties likely to be experienced by the investigating agency must definitely deter the Court in exercising the judicial discretion, on the basis of the principles enumerated earlier, in favour of the petitioner.

    9. Finally the counsel for the petitioner requested that the investigating agency may be directed to permit his lawyer to be present when he is questioned. Art. 22(1) of the Constitution provides that no person who is arrested shall be denied the right to consult, and to be defended by, a legal practitioner of his choice. That is a fundamental rule of law and the assistance of a lawyer cannot be denied not only to those who are arrested but to those who are not under arrest also. That request cannot be denied and it was not objected also. In Nandini Satpathy v. P.L Dani, (1978) 2 SCC 424 : AIR 1978 SC 1025 : (1978 Cri LJ 968) the principle was laid down thus:

    “The spirit of Art. 22(1) is that it is fundamental to the rule of law that the services of a lawyer shall be available for consultation to any accused person under circumstances of near-custodial interrogation. Moreover, the observance of the right against self-incrimination is best promoted by conceding to the accused the right to consult a legal practitioner of his choice.

    10. Lawyer's presence is a constitutional claim in some circumstances in our country also, and, in the context of Art. 20(3), is an assurance of awareness and observance of the right to silence. Art. 20(3), and Art. 22(1) may, in a way, be telescoped by making it prudent for the Police to permit the Advocate of the accused, if there be one, to be present at the time he is examined. Overreaching Art. 20(3) and S. 161(2) will be obviated by this requirement. If an accused person expresses the wish to have his lawyer by his side when his examination goes on, this facility shall not be denied, without being exposed to the serious reproof that involuntary self-crimination secured in secrecy and by coercing the will, was the project”.

    11. The application for anticipatory bail is dismissed, but it is directed that the lawyer of the petitioner will be permitted to be present when he is questioned.

    12. Application dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    V. Nandanan v. Dig Of Police (Crime), Hyderabad And Another
    (Oct 11, 1985)