Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rent Control) Act, 1965
  • Rent Control Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rent Control) Act, 1965
  • Rent Control Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff let a building to the defendant under Ext. A1 lease dated 25-3-1955 for an initial ten-year term with a further ten-year renewal option. The contractual rent for the first period was Rs. 3,000 per year and for the subsequent period Rs. 3,600 per year. The tenant continued in occupation through both contractual periods and thereafter. The second period expired on 30-6-1975.

On 31-8-1975 proceedings under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 were started for eviction of the tenant under S. 11(2)(b) and S. 11(4)(iv). The claim for eviction on the ground of arrears of rent was not pressed before the Rent Control Court, which ordered eviction under S. 11(4)(iv). That eviction order was ultimately confirmed by the Supreme Court. The tenant vacated the premises on 18-8-1980.

The present suit (for arrears of rent and accounts) was instituted on 31-10-1978. The plaintiff claimed arrears at Rs. 1,696.25 per month from 1-9-1975 to 31-3-1977 and Rs. 2,875 per month from 31-3-1977 to 31-8-1978, based on S. 8(2)(a) of the Rent Control Act. The plaintiff's position (accepted by both lower courts) was that the contractual tenancy had expired on 30-6-1975 (subject to an additional two months under the contract), so that for the subsequent period the rent payable should be determined under S. 8(2) with reference to S. 5(2) (i.e., by reference to the municipal assessment), and the amounts claimed were so calculated.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, upon expiry of the contractual lease (by efflux of time or by forfeiture), the agreed contract rent ceases to operate for the period of occupation after expiry and the rent payable for that period must be determined solely under S. 8(2) (with reference to S. 5(2)), or whether the agreed rent continues to subsist until the tenancy is terminated under the Rent Control Act (S. 11).
  2. Whether alterations and additions made by the lessee, under a contractual clause permitting such works, altered the identity of the subject matter of the lease so as to displace the operation of the agreed rent for the posterior period.
  3. Whether the lower courts correctly construed S. 8(2) and applied it to award arrears calculated by reference to municipal assessment pursuant to S.5(2).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Defendant / Tenant) — Shri. T.S. Venkataswara Iyer

  • Contended that the courts below wrongly construed S. 8(2) and failed to appreciate the legal nature of the parties' relationship.
  • Argued that the contractual rent continued to subsist beyond the expiry of the contractual term until the tenant was duly evicted under the statutory machinery (S. 11), and therefore the tenant remained liable to pay the agreed contractual rent during the posterior period.
  • Maintained that the statute protects the tenant by keeping the landlord-tenant relationship alive beyond the contractual period, so the contractual terms (including rent) continue to apply unless terminated in accordance with the Act.

Respondent (Plaintiff / Landlord) — Shri. Vyasan Potti

  • Submitted that upon expiry of the contractual lease the concept of agreed rent no longer survives and that the tenant becomes liable to pay only such rent as is computed with reference to S. 5(2), as provided by S. 8(2).
  • Argued that the rent stipulated under the contract had no application to the period after termination of the contract and therefore the plaintiff was entitled to claim rent calculated with reference to S. 5(2).
  • Further contended alternatively that the subject matter lost its identity because of alterations and additions made by the lessee under Clause (7) of Ext. A1 lease, so that the contract-rent did not subsist for the posterior period.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
D.N. Sanghavi v. A.T. Das, (1974) 1 SCC 708 : A.I.R. 1974 S.C. 1026 Cited for the proposition that determination of a contractual tenancy does not automatically terminate the landlord-tenant relationship and that statutory protection keeps the tenancy alive. Relied upon as authority supporting the view that the agreed rent continues to subsist post-contractual expiry until eviction under the Rent Control Act.
Damadilal v. Parashram, (1976) 4 SCC 855 : A.I.R. 1976 S.C. 2229 Cited for the same general principle about the statutory continuation of tenancy and protection of tenant's position. Used to reinforce the court's position that contractual rent remains effective unless displaced by operation of S. 8(2) where the S.5(2) computation is lower.
V. Dhanapal Chettiar v. Yesodai Ammal, (1979) 4 SCC 214 : A.I.R. 1979 S.C. 1745 Cited as authority concerning the effect of rent-control legislation on contractual tenancies and related landlord-tenant rights. Cited to support the analysis that statutory tenancy preserves the estate and the contractual terms until termination under the statute.
Mani Subrat Jain v. Raja Rant Vohra, (1980) 1 SCC 1 : A.I.R. 1980 S.C. 299 Cited for the principle that the Rent Control Act affects the sanctity of contract by keeping tenancy relationships alive beyond the contractual term. Applied as precedent consistent with the court's conclusion that the agreed rent continues to operate post-contractual expiry.
Gain Devi v. Jeevan Kumar, (1985) 2 SCC 683 : A.I.R. 1985 S.C. 796 Cited for the same general rule on the effect of rent-control statute on the landlord-tenant relationship and the continuity of tenancy. Relied on to support the finding that the agreed rent survives the expiry of the contractual period unless S.8(2) yields a lower rent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by setting out the text and structure of S. 8 of the Rent Control Act and explaining the interface between S. 8(2) and S. 5(2). It noted:

  • S. 8(1) applies only where a fair rent has been determined. Where no fair rent has been determined, S. 8(2) applies.
  • S. 8(2)(a) prescribes that, for certain buildings where property or house tax has been fixed on a rental basis, the rent payable (notwithstanding any contract) shall be the maximum rent that may be fixed by reference to S. 5(2) or the agreed rent, whichever is less; where no such tax is fixed, the agreed rent applies.
  • S. 5(2) provides the method for determining fair rent in buildings with property/house tax fixed on a rental basis and prescribes a maximum uplift (15%) over the municipal basis rent for that determination.

The court accepted that S. 8(2) gives the tenant the benefit of paying either the rent computed with reference to S. 5(2) (at the maximum rate allowed by S. 5(2)) or the agreed rent, whichever is less. The court then examined the respondent's contention that upon expiry or forfeiture of the contractual lease the agreed rent ceases to operate and only the S.5(2)-referenced rent would be payable.

The court rejected that contention as a fallacy because it failed to recognize that the landlord-tenant relationship does not cease on expiry of the contract; it continues statutorily until terminated in accordance with the Rent Control Act (principally S. 11). The court reasoned that the Rent Control Act makes a substantial inroad into freedom of contract: a landlord cannot simply terminate the relationship by efflux of time or forfeiture. The quality of the tenant's estate remains; therefore there is no change in the tenant's status or in the obligation to pay the agreed rent as between contractual and statutory tenancy. The court concluded that the agreed rent therefore continues to operate for the posterior period unless the alternative S.5(2)-computed rent happens to be less than the agreed rent.

The court then addressed the respondent's alternative argument that alterations and additions made by the lessee under Clause (7) of Ext. A1 lease caused the subject-matter to lose its identity and so the contract rent did not subsist. The court examined Clause (7) and the practical outcome: the lessee was permitted to make alterations and additions at his cost and to remove them within two months of termination failing which they would vest in the lessor; there was no provision for any additional rent for such works and no entitlement on the lessee to claim value for them if forfeited.

Having considered this, the court found that the additions did not alter the contractual rent obligation. The lease expressly permitted the works and provided the lessee could remove them (subject to the time limit). Because there was no contractual provision entitling the landlord to additional rent arising from the alterations or additions, and no claim by the lessee for value, those works did not operate to displace the agreed rent for the posterior period. The court also noted there was no case that the agreed rent had not been paid in full until eviction.

On the combined analysis the court held that the lower courts were in error to hold additional sums were due for the period in suit by applying the S.5(2)/S.8(2) calculation in place of the agreed rent.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; the preliminary decree and the judgments of the courts below are set aside.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The decree awarding arrears computed by reference to S. 5(2) / S. 8(2) was set aside; the courts below were held to have erred in substituting that computation for the agreed rent in the circumstances of this case.
  • No additional rent was held payable by the lessee for the posterior period on the basis of the alterations and additions clause in Ext. A1, and there was no finding that agreed rent was unpaid until eviction.
  • The appeal was allowed and the court made no order as to costs.

Broader implications: The opinion applies and reiterates existing precedent that the Rent Control Act may keep tenancy relations and contractual rent obligations alive beyond a contractual term until termination under the statute; the decision concerned the application of those principles to the facts and did not purport to lay down a new rule of general application beyond the factual conclusions reached.

This summary is based exclusively on the contents of the provided opinion and does not add facts or inferences beyond the text.

    P. John Zacharia & Co. v. Ittycheriah

    1. The defendant in a suit for arrears of rent and accounts is the appellant. The suit was decreed by both the courts. The claim for arrears is in respect of a building which had been let out to the defendant by the plaintiff under Ext. A 1 indenture of lease dated 25-3-1955. The lease provided for a period of 10 years subject to renewal for another period of 10 years. The rent payable for the first period was at Rs. 3,000/- per year and for the subsequent period at Rs. 3,600/- per year. The tenant continued in occupation of the building for both the periods and subsequently. The second period expired on 30-6-1975. On 31-8-1975 proceedings were initiated under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 for eviction of the tenant on the grounds postulated under S. 11(2)(b) and 11(4)(iv). The claim for eviction on the ground of arrears of rent was not pressed before the Rent Control Court. That court ordered eviction under S. 11(4)(iv). That order was confirmed finally by the Supreme Court. The appellant-tenant vacated the premises on 18-8-1980. The present suit was instituted on 31-10-1978 claiming arrears of rent at the rate of Rs. 1,696.25 per month from 1-9-1975 to 31-3-1977 and Rs. 2,875/- per month from 31-3-1977 to 31-8-1978. The claim is based on what is alleged to be due from the tenant in terms of S. 8(2)(a) of the Act. The contention of the plaintiff has been that the contractual tenancy expired by efflux of time on 30-6-1975, subject to an additional period of two months as provided under the contract, and accordingly the defendant became liable to pay rent in terms of S. 8(2)(a) instead of the rent agreed to be paid under the contract. This contention was accepted by both the courts. The courts construed the provisions of S. 8 and came to the conclusion that, for the period of occupation by the tenant subsequent to the expiry of the contractual tenancy, the rent which was payable was not what had been stipulated under the contract, but an amount which, the courts held, the plaintiff was entitled to calculate with reference to the municipal assessment. The amounts claimed by the plaintiff, the courts found, were so calculated.

    2. Counsel for the appellant Shri. T.S Venkataswara Iyer contends that the courts wrongly construed S. 8(2), and failed to appreciate correctly the legal nature of the relationship between the parties.

    3. S. 8, in so far as it is material, reads:

    “8. Landlord not to claim or receive onything in excess of fair rent or agreed rent.— (1) Where the Rent Control Court has determined the fair rent of a building:—

    (a) the landlord shall not claim, receive or stipulate for the payment of………anything in excess of such fair rent:………………………………………”

    4. This sub-section has application only where a fair rent has been determined. In a case, such as the present, where no fair rent has been determined for the period in question, it is sub-s. (2) that would apply. That sub-section reads:

    “(2) Where the fair rent of a building has not been determined under S. 5—

    (a) notwithstanding anything contained in any contract, the rent payable for the building in case it is a building falling under clause (i) or clause (ii) of the proviso to sub-s. (2) of S. 5 shall be, where the property tax or house tax has been fixed by the local authority, the maximum rent that may be fixed by the Rent Control Court as provided for in sub-s. (2) of S. 5, or the agreed rent whichever is less, and in cases where no property tax or house tax has been fixed for the buildingor where it has been fixed not on a rental basis, the agreed rent;

    (b) …………………………………”

    5. S. 5 is the provision under which fair rent is determined. It is to sub-s. (2) of that Section that reference is made under S. 8(2). S. 5(2) concerns a building for which property tax or house tax has been fixed, and it is in accordance with that sub-section that fair rent has to be determined in respect of such a building. The maximum fair rent which can be fixed under S. 5(2) is 15 per cent in excess of the monthly rent on the basis of which property tax or house tax has been fixed. For example, if the monthly rent on the basis of which property tax or house tax has been fixed is Rs. 100/-, the fair rent shall cot exceed Rs. 115/- per month. There is no reference to the maximum point at which the fair rent may be fixed. However, for the purpose of determining the rent payable under S. 8(2), with reference to the amount computed in terms of S. 5(2), such rent shall be determined at the maximum rate prescribed under S. 5(2). That rent is, however, only one of the two alternative rents payable under S. 8(2). In case the agreed rent is less than what is computed with reference to S. 5(2) for the purpose of determining the rent under S. 8(2), the tenant is liable to pay only such lower rent. In other words, S. 8(2) which concerns a building in respect of which no fair rent has been fixed, the tenant is given the benefit of paying either the rent computed with reference to S. 5(2) or the agreed rent whichever is less. So far there is no dispute as regards the construction of these provisions. Counsel for the respondent-plaintiff Shri. Vyasan Potti submits that in a case, such as the present, where the period of lease in terms of the contract had expired either by efflux of time or by forfeiture, the concept of agreed rent no longer survives, and, therefore, only such rent as is computed with reference to S. 5(2), as warranted under S. 8(2), is payable, and not any other rent. The rent which had been stipulated under the contract has no application to the period posterior to the termination of the contract. Therefore the rent that the tenant is liable to pay is the rent that is determined with reference to S. 5(2). That is the rent which the plaintiff has demanded and decreed by the courts below. Shri. Venkataswara Iyer, however, points out that the contrast continued to be in force in terms of, and subject to, the statute until the tenant was evicted in due course of law. The contract rent therefore subsisted beyond the period provided under the contract, for the relationship between the landlord and tenant subsisted beyond that period. That, Shri. Iyer submits, is the effect of the statute which is intended to protect the interest of the tenant. I agree.

    6. The fallacy of the plaintiff-respondent's contention is that it fails to take note of the fact that the relationship of landlord and tenant does not cease on the expiry of the contract, for it is kept alive beyond the contractual period until duly terminated in accordance with the provisions of the statute. Even where the lease is determined, by efflux of time or forfeiture the tenant continues to be a tenant and there is no termination of the lease in the eye of law. The Rent Control Act has made a serious inroad into freedom of contract. The landlord is not allowed to snap his relationship with the tenant merely by his act of forfeiture or by reason of efflux of time. His relationship with the tenant continues upon the same terms and conditions as they existed during the period of the contract. S. 11 of the Act is a self-contained provision in terms of which alone can the period of the lease come to an end. Like in the case of a contractual tenancy, so in the case of a statutory tenancy the tenant continues to have an estate in the subject matter of the lease. The estate does not disappear merely because the contractual lease has been determined. The sanctity of contract is thus controlled by legislation so as to obliterate the distinction between contractual tenancy and statutory tenancy. The quality of the estate or interest is the same in either case. The determination of the contractual tenancy does not therefore bring about any change in the status of the tenant or the terms and conditions upon which he is entitled to pay the rent. This means that even beyond the period originally stipulated under the contract, and until evicted in terms of S. 11, the agreed rent alone is payable by the tenant, unless the amount computed in terms of S. 8(2) with reference to S. 5(2) happens to be less than the agreed rent. See D.N Sanghavl v. A.T Das, (1974) 1 SCC 708 : A.I.R 1974 S.C 1026; Damadilal v. Parashram, (1976) 4 SCC 855 : A.I.R 1976 S.C 2229; V. Dhanapal Chettiar v. Yesodai Ammal, (1979) 4 SCC 214 : A.I.R 1979 S.C 1745; Mani Subrat Jain v. Raja Rant Vohra, (1980) 1 SCC 1 : A.I.R 1980 S.C 299; and Gain Devi v. Jeevan Kumar, (1985) 2 SCC 683 : A.I.R 1985 S.C 796. None has a case that in the instant case the agreed rent is not less than the amount payable with reference to S. 5(2). I am, therefore, of the view that there is no substance in the contention that, upon termination of the contractual lease, the agreed rent ceased to operate, and that the tenant is no longer enitled to claim that the only rent payable is the agreed rent.

    7. Shri. Potti, however, contends that in any view the contract-rent did not subsist for the posterior period for the reason that the subject matter of the contract lost its identity on account of alterations and additions made to it. This argument is based on a provision in Ext. A 1 lease deed. Clause (7) of the deed provides that it was open to the lessee to construct at his costs any new building on the demised premises and also make alterations to or demolish the existing building subject to the approval of the lessor. The lease says that the lessee agreed:

    “…………to surrender on the termination of the lease, possession of the demised premises to the lessor, restoring the buildings to their original conditions ordinary wear and tear excepted or paying the lessor the cost of such restoration or otherwise compensating the lessor or as may then be agreed to in respect of the same and to remove at the lessee's cost any buildings, erections or constructions as may have been put up by the lessee in pursuance of this lease deed within two months of the termination of the lease paying for the said two months the proportionate rent namely Rupees Two hundred and fifty or Rupees three hundred per mensem as the case may be failing which the lessee agrees to forfeit all his claims to them or to the value thereof as against the lessor and they shall thence forward vest in and belong to the lessor………………”

    8. On the strength of that prevision the lessee made certain alterations to the existing building and made additions thereto. Those additions were not removed by the lessee, and consequently, upon eviction of the lessee, they became the property of the landlord. There is no provision for payment of any additional rent by reason of the alterations or additions. The contract only provided that the lessee had the freedom to remove the additions at his costs and in case he did not do so, such additions would become the property of the lessor. The landlord has no claim for any additional rent by reason of the alterations or additions. The lessee has no claim for the value of any such additions. This means that, on the rent payable under the contract, the special provision concerning the lessee's freedom to construct by way of alterations or additions did not have any impact. The rent continued to be what was originally agreed upon, despite the alterations, and the terms of contract continued to operate, despite the termination of the lease, until such time as the lease was terminated in terms of S. 11. The additions were made as agreed upon between the parties. The rent was payable also as agreed upon between the parties. There is no case that the agreed rent has not been paid in full until eviction. In the circumstances, the ccurts below went wrong in holding that any further sum was due and payable by the lesssee to the land-lord for the period covered by the suit. The preliminary decree and judgments are accordingly set aside. The appeal is allowed. I make no order as to costs.

    9. Allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P. John Zacharia & Co. v. Ittycheriah
    (Aug 13, 1986)