AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 10 of Order XXXI of the Order of 1875 (which corresponds to Order XI Rule 10 C.P.C), Cotton L.J observed:
  • provision underlying Order XI Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure
  • Procedure Act of 1952, William
  • Order XI Rule 11 C.P.C
  • Order XI Rule 1 C.P.C
  • Order XI Rule 2 C.P.C,
  • Order XI, Rule 11,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 10 of Order XXXI of the Order of 1875 (which corresponds to Order XI Rule 10 C.P.C), Cotton L.J observed:
  • provision underlying Order XI Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure
  • Procedure Act of 1952, William
  • Order XI Rule 11 C.P.C
  • Order XI Rule 1 C.P.C
  • Order XI Rule 2 C.P.C,
  • Order XI, Rule 11,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff is a company manufacturing sophisticated electrical gadgets (including coupling capacitors, capacitative voltage transformers and wave traps) that brought a monetary suit for supplies made to the Kerala and Karnataka Electricity Boards. The defendants denied liability. The parties filed numerous documents and issues were framed.

The plaintiff sought leave under Order XI Rule 1 C.P.C. (I.A. 1958 of 1982) to serve interrogatories; the trial court dismissed that application. The plaintiff challenged that dismissal in C.R.P. No. 108 of 1983 before this Court. This Court (by order dated 27-11-1985) allowed interrogatories related to five issues, set aside the trial court's refusal, and remanded the matter with directions that the lower court should grant leave for interrogatories relating to matters in question, permitting modification where interrogatories were not clearly worded and permitting filing of connected records under Order XI Rule 2 C.P.C. (as quoted in the order).

On remand the trial court directed the defendants to answer interrogatories 1 to 9; the plaintiff agreed to drop questions 10–13. The defendants eventually furnished answers on 10-3-1986. The plaintiff then filed I.A. No. 713 of 1986, complaining that refusal by the defendants to answer interrogatories 4 and 8 was unjustified. The trial court, by order dated 8-8-1986, held that the truthfulness of defendants' answers could not be questioned under Order XI Rule 11 C.P.C and dismissed the application. The present revision petition challenged that order.

On the substantive facts relevant to the interrogatories, the dispute centers on whether the defendants agreed to pass on “export benefits” (valuable incentives) to the plaintiff in respect of certain supplies; the plaintiff claimed Rs. 16 lakhs was due as export benefit, while defendants denied any agreement to pass on benefits, saying there was only a proposal vitiated by mistake and non-compliance with proposal conditions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the answers furnished by the defendants to interrogatories (notably interrogatories 4 and 8) were sufficient within the meaning of Order XI rules and whether the trial court erred in treating those answers as sufficient.
  2. Whether the trial court committed jurisdictional error or inaction by refusing to require the defendants to answer or answer further when answers were, in the view of this Court, insufficient.
  3. Whether an application under Order XI Rule 11 C.P.C. can be used to question the truth or sufficiency of answers to interrogatories, as contended by the defendants and as applied by the trial court.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff filed I.A. No. 713 of 1986 complaining that the defendants' refusal to properly answer interrogatories 4 and 8 was unjustified.
  • Implicit in the complaint is that the information sought (e.g., amounts of export benefits attributable to items supplied by the plaintiff) was available or ascertainable and therefore the defendants should have given a proper answer.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants resisted the initial application for leave to serve interrogatories and succeeded at the trial court (before the High Court remanded that decision).
  • In the specific interlocutory dispute, the defendants argued (by counter-affidavit) that it was not open to the plaintiff to canvass the truth of the answers in an application under Order XI Rule 11, and that “the truth or sufficiency of the answers does not come up for consideration at all.”
  • Defendants also asserted non-availability of certain accounts due to a strike (allegation that some accounts were taken away by striking employees) as a reason for inability to answer fully, a contention the trial court found lacked bonafides.
  • On the substantive merits of the export benefits claim, defendants said there was no agreement to pass on export benefits and, at best, there was a proposal vitiated by mistake and non-compliance with conditions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lyell v. Kennedy, (1884) 27 Ch. D 1 Establishes that on answers to interrogatories the court considers whether an answer is insufficient (not the truth of the answer) — cited together with Rule 10 of Order XXXI of 1875 (corresponding to Order XI Rule 10 C.P.C). The Court cited Cotton L.J.'s statement and used the precedent to explain the established test, but concluded the defendants' answer in the present case was nonetheless insufficient as framed and, therefore, further answer could properly be required.
Hoffmann v. Postill, (1869) 4 Ch. 673 One of three English decisions referred to in the context of authorities about interrogatories. The opinion notes these English decisions were referred to by the court below, but observes that lack of factual background of those decisions misled the court below. No detailed doctrinal application from this case is recorded in the opinion.
(1885) 2 TLR 122 Listed among English authorities in the commentary context. The opinion records that this decision was referred to by the court below but indicates that absence of factual context of that decision contributed to the court below being misguided. No further application is stated in the opinion.
Saunders v. Jones, (1877) 7 Ch. D 435 Authority allowing interrogatories that seek particulars of amounts received where entitlement to a fixed commission or account is in issue; an interrogatory to show amount received would be allowed as a matter of course where account is directly material. The Court relied on this decision as having closer application to the facts (similar factual situation). It supported the proposition that where an account or amount is claimed an interrogatory asking for amount received should be permitted; the Court used it to strengthen the conclusion that an insufficient answer should be supplemented.
Nash v. Layton, (1911) 1911-2 Ch 71 Confirms that where an account is claimed or a question of account arises, interrogatories as to details of account may be allowed. Invoked to support the proposition that interrogatories seeking account details are permissible and to underline that defendants' answers on account-type questions must be adequate.
Jamaitravi v. Motilar Chamaria, AIR 1960 Cal. 536 Mentioned as having been adverted to in an earlier order (referred to in a prior order of John Mathew, J.). The opinion states this decision was adverted to in the earlier order; no detailed principle or separate application from this decision is set out in the present opinion.
Raj Narain v. Indira Gandhi, (1972) 3 SCC 850 (AIR 1972 S.C. 1303) Mentioned as having been adverted to in the earlier order. The opinion notes it was adverted to previously; no detailed doctrinal application in the present opinion is recorded.
Malabar Produce Export Co. v. Nedungadi Bank Ltd., 1982 KLT 462 Mentioned as cited in the earlier order. Referenced as part of the earlier order's discussion; the present opinion does not elaborate separate application beyond noting its prior advertence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by recounting the procedural history: the High Court had already allowed interrogatories relevant to five issues and remanded the matter to the trial court with directions to allow interrogatories relating to “any matters in question,” permitting the trial court to require modification of unclear questions and to permit filing of records under Order XI Rule 2 C.P.C. The trial court directed answers to interrogatories 1–9; the defendants answered; the plaintiff complained that defendants' answers to interrogatories 4 and 8 were unjustified.

The court below dismissed the plaintiff's application, relying on a commentary statement that “sufficiency and not the truth of the answer is the point to be considered at this stage,” and concluded that “the truthfulness of the contentions of the defendants could not be questioned under Order XI Rule 11 C.P.C.” This Court examined the authorities and historical background of interrogatory practice, noting reforms in English Chancery practice and the purpose of interrogatories as tools to ascertain material facts and accounts.

Applying the legal principles from the authorities (notably Lyell v. Kennedy, Saunders v. Jones and Nash v. Layton), the Court emphasized:

  • Although the classical rule (as stated in Lyell) is that the court considers whether an answer is insufficient rather than the truth of the answer, an answer that is plainly insufficient in context permits the court to require a further or proper answer.
  • In account-type disputes (as here, where export benefits/amounts claimed are essentially an account), interrogatories seeking particulars and amounts are allowable and, if answers are inadequate, the court can compel fuller answers (Saunders v. Jones; Nash v. Layton).

The Court then analyzed the specific sequence and substance of the interrogatories in this case: Question 1 asked whether the defendants received any export benefits (answered in the affirmative); Question 2 asked which items attracted cash assistance (answer: assistance received on all items); Question 3 asked the amount received (answer: Rs. 20,24,338). Question 4 then asked whether amounts received included amounts due by way of cash assistance specifically in respect of coupling capacitors, CVTs and wave traps supplied by the plaintiff to the Kerala and Karnataka Boards and, if so, the amount. The defendants answered that those items “were not supplied by the plaintiff … under Tender Specification Nos. …” — an answer the Court found to be inconsistent with the pleadings and the earlier orders and, crucially, to be insufficient and lacking bonafides.

The Court observed that the pleadings and the defendants' own written statement (which explained the administrative process of allocation of export benefits and that the figures are obtainable after submission and processing of forms) demonstrated that the figures were computable and the information was available or ascertainable. Given the earlier orders deeming interrogatories relevant and the trial court's direction to answer, the defendants' evasive answer to Question 4 (and similarly to Question 8, which followed questions establishing receipt of particular forms of export benefits) could not stand.

The Court further criticized the trial court for failing to appreciate the significance of prior orders (both the High Court's remand and the trial court's own earlier direction) and for declining to exercise its power under Order XI Rule 1 C.P.C to require further answers when answers were inadequate. The Court characterized that failure as jurisdictional inaction requiring correction in revision.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is allowed; the order of the trial court (dated 8-8-1986) is set aside. The Court directed that the defendants furnish proper answers to the trial court in relation to the disputed interrogatories (notably interrogatories 4 and 8) within two weeks from the date of the order. The revision was allowed with costs here and in the court below.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The defendants are ordered to provide fuller answers to specified interrogatories (4 and 8) within the stated two-week period; the plaintiff's application complaining of insufficient answers has been upheld in revision and the trial court's contrary order set aside.
  • Procedural/legal consequence: The Court enforced the court's power under Order XI (notably Rule 1) to require proper answers and corrected the trial court's jurisdictional inaction in refusing to require further answers where answers were insufficient and information was ascertainable.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion applies and explains existing principles (drawing on English and other authorities) about sufficiency of answers to interrogatories and the court's power to require further answers; the opinion does not assert that it is creating a new legal doctrine beyond applying those principles to the facts. The decision operates to enforce the earlier orders and existing procedural rules in the particular controversy before the Court.

    W.S Insulators Of India Ltd. v. Power Systems And Projects & Another

    1. Interlocutories in relation to interrogatories have obstructed the trial. That was quite contrary to the intentment of a laudable objective of the salutory provision underlying Order XI Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Code-expediting the disposal of the suit. The suit filed by a company engaged in the manufacture of sophisticated electrital gadgets, made a monetary claim in relation to supplies made by it to the Electricity Boards in the Kerala and Kama aka States on the basis of transaction entered into between it and the defendants. The defendants disclaimed the liability. A replication on behalf of the plaintiff reiterated and expatiated the plaint averments.

    3. The parties filed large number of documents. Issues were framed in the suit. The plaintiff filed an application I.A 1958 of 1982 for leave of the court to deliver certain interrogatories for answers under Order XI Rule 1 C.P.C The defendants resisted this application too. The resistance was upheld by the trial court. The application was accordingly dismissed.

    4. The plaintiff took up the matter before this Court, in C.R.P No. 108 of 1983. This Court disposed it of by order dated 27-11-1985.

    5. The Court noted that five issues did have relation to the interrogatories and consequently they were allowed in the case. The Court however, hastened to clarify;

    “However, it has to be observed that some of the interrogatories are couched in a complicated manner so that the defendants may have a genuine fear Chat they be trapped by the answers that they may give to those interrogatories. This has to be avoided.”

    6. The order of the trial court declining leave to serve the interrogatories was accordingly set aside. The petition was remanded for fresh consideration by the lower court. The further direction reads;

    “The lower court will grant leave to the plaintiff to raise interrogatories relating to “any matters in question” in this suit. In case the defendants satisfy the lower court that any of the interrogatories are not clearly worded or that they should be modified for any other valid reason, the lower court will direct the plaintiff to modify such interrogatories before granting leave. In case the defendant finds it difficult to answer any interrogatory directly, they will be permitted to file all records connected with those interrogatories as provided in Order XI Rule 2 C.P.C, so that the plaintiff and the court may find out the amounts, if any actually received by the defendants.”

    7. There was a fresh hearing of the matter by the trial court. The Court directed the defendants - respondents to answer the interrogatories 1 to 9 in the petition. The plaintiff agreed that questions 10 to 13 need not be answered. The Court stressed that the defendant omitted to specify questions if answered will put them in the trap. Similarly there was no attempt on the part of he defendants to point out to the Court that any of the questions are not properly worded or that they must be modified for any other reason. These omissions are very significant in view of the directions contained in the order of the High Court. A contention about non-availability of certain accounts consequent on a strike situation (the allegation was that some of the accounts were taken away by the striking employees) was found to be bereft of bonafides by the court below, and rightly so. Ultimately the answers were delivered by the defendants on 10-3-1986.

    8. On behalf of the plaintiff I.A No. 713 of 1986 was filed complaining that the refusal of the defendants to answer interrogatories 4 and 8 was unjustified. That was sought to be met by a counter-affidavit by a statement that it was not open to the plaintiff to canvass the truth of the answers in an application under Order XI, Rule 11, and “the truth or sufficiency of the answers does not come up for consideration at all.”. The court below disposed of that application by its order dated 8-8-1986, with a cryptic observation that the truthfulness of the contentions of the defendants could not be questioned under Order XI Rule 11 C.P.C The petition was dismissed. The Court held that the answers furnished by defendants in relation to interrogatories 4 and 8 were sufficient and proper. That order is challenged in this revision petition.

    9. Some facts relating to the core dispute may be relevant to appreciate the justifiability of the stand of the defendants and the sustainability of the order of the court below.

    10. A brief reference to the factual background of the legal issue has to be given at this stage. The Electricity Boards require various sophisticated gadgets in connection with its activities including the transmission of electricity. Wave traps, coupling capacitors and capacity voltage transformers are some of those materials required by the Boards. Global tenders are invited by the Boards for the supply of such articles. Acceptance of tenders from overseas suppliers would not be advantageous to the Nation from the point of foreign exchange. Indigenous entrepreneurship would require encouragement in that context. Manufacturing concerns supplying sophisticated equipments (the procurement of which would have otherwise entailed foreign exchange obligations) are given encouraging incentives. They are termed in the context of these transactions as “export benefits”. Export benefits are indeed very valuable from the business and financial points of view. Such benefits would naturally enter into the reckoning of any sensible and prudent business negotiation. Defendants were awarded contracts from the Electricity Boards of Kerala and Karnataka for the supply of some of the communication and telemetering equipments. According to the plaintiff, the defendants were manufacturing only some of the equipments covered by the contract. The plaintiff claimed to be a manufacturer of coupling capacitors, capacitative voltage transformers and wave traps among others. That the defendants placed orders with the plaintiff for those equipments manufactured in the plaintiff's factory is not disputed. There is, however, controversy that there was an agreement between the parties for passing on to the plaintiff the export benefits in respect of the equipments supplied by the plaintiff. The plaintiff claimed that a sum of rupees sixteen lakhs was due to it as export benefit. According to the defendants, there was no agreement to pass on the export benefits; and there was only a proposal, which was vitiated by mistake. More over, according to the defendants, there was no compliance with the conditions contained in the proposal.

    11. The objection of the defendants about the order of the court below appear to be based on a cryptic sentence occurring in occurring in a commentary to the Civil Procedure Code. No reference is made to any text book or decision for the proposition as given in the order of the court below. It may be probably traced to the following sentence in one commentary:

    “The general rule is that the person answering must answer sufficiently Sufficiency and not the truth of the answer is the point to be considered at this stage.”

    12. Three decisions of the English Courts have been referred to in that context. They are Lyell v. Kennedy, (1884) 27 Ch.D 1 (21), Hoffmann v. Postill, (1869) 4 Ch. 673, and (1885) 2 TLR 122. The non-availability of the factual background of those decisions misguided the court below.

    13. Before discussing in detail those three decisions, it may be helpful just to have a background of the legal history behind interrogatories. William S. Holdsworth in his history of English Laws refers to the course of procedure of Courts as it obtained prior to the Chancery Commission appointed in 1850:

    “The plaintiff began his suit by addressing a bill to the chancellor, praying process against the defendant to compel him to appear and to put in an answer. The bill asked for relief, and required the defendant to make discovery, i.e to give on oath an answer to the matters stated and the interrogatories contained in the bill……. Having obtained this copy, the defendant must decide whether he would demur or plead or answer. He might demur, either on the substantial ground that no case had been made out for the interference of the court or by reason of a technical objection to the form of the bill. A plea was generally a statement of matters not appearing on the face of the bill, which showed a reason why the suit should be either barred or delayed. The answer, which was generally given on oath, both answered the plaintiff's interrogatories contained in the bill and set out other facts essential to the defendant's defence…………”

    (emphasis supplied),

    (See History of English Law by William S. Holdworth. IX, 340-342.)

    14. Further steps in relation to application for time to answer and connected matters are thereafter dealt with:

    “There were frequent applications to a master for more time to answer, and appeals from his decision to the court. Omission to put in an answer in the proper time was punished by attachment; and, if the defendant was attached, all applications for time must be made to the court. After a sufficient answer was filed, a motion was made by the plaintiff for the production of documents in the defendant's possession. This order was also the occasion of considerable expense. It often happened that the answer of the defendant made it necessary for the plaintiff to amend his bill, in order either to traverse the facts stated in the answer, or to introduce new facts. Further answers were then called for; and the case could then either be heard on these answers, or the plaintiff could put in a formal replication denying the answers.”

    (See page Nos. 340-342).

    15. The next stage is described as follows:

    “The pleadings being thus at an end, the next step was to lay them before counsel to advise on the evidence, and to prepare interrogatories for the examination of witnesses. On these interrogatories the witnesses were examined in private, none of the parties or their agents being present. As the interrogatories were framed by counsel without knowing what witnesses would be forthcoming, or what answers they would give, it was necessary to frame question to meet many possible contingencies”.

    (See Pages 340-342)

    16. The practice that obtained in England had been subjected to severe criticism. Gibbon commented that the procedure of the Court of Chancery in 1927 was more or less in the same condition of Roman law in the time of Justinian Dickens described the ill - effects of the practice as it obtained then in his novel ‘Bleak House’. The abuses of the procedure of the Court, atlast came to an end, when on the recommendation of the Chancery Commission, legislative amendments were brought about in the form of Chancery Procedure Act of 1952, William Holdsworth refers to the reforms in that Act:

    “They reformed both the pleading of the court, and its system of procedure. The form of the Bill was changed. It was to consist of a concise narrative of material facts divided into numbered paragraphs, and it was not to contain interrogatories.”

    (See Charles Dickens as a Legal Historian By William S. Holdsworth at page 114)

    17. The provisions of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 has reflected many of the reforms that had come to stay in that country.

    18. The decision in Lyell v. Kennedy, (1884) 27 Ch. D1 was one in which the Court held that the interrogatories had been sufficiently answered. In the background of an interrogatory about steps and persons in the pedigree of hierarchy at law through whom the defendant claimed, there was a professional privilege claim as lawyers and clients. The plaintiff contended that assuming that the plaintiff's claim was property based in law it was not so in fact and therefore could not be relied upon. It was this contention that was discussed with reference to question of discovery and later with reference to answer to interrogatories. After extracting Rule 10 of Order XXXI of the Order of 1875 (which corresponds to Order XI Rule 10 C.P.C), Cotton L.J observed:

    “So that with regard to an answer to interrogatories, what the Court has to consider is this simply, whether the answer is insufficient, not to go into the question of the truthfulness of the answer, but to see whether it is insufficient or not and if it is insufficient, then only can it require a further answer”.

    19. In the present case, the interrogatory relates to a simple question about the export benefits received in relation to some among the many goods supplied by the defendants. An answer of the type as furnished by the defendants, is insufficient in that context. If it is insufficient, the Court has necessarily the power to direct the defendant to answer or answer further.

    20. One case which has closer application, having regard to the similar factual situation, is Saunders v. Jones, (1877) 7 Ch.D 435. The defendants therein employed the plaintiff under a written agreement which stipulated among other things salary and commission on the gross amount of sales. When disputes arose, the defendant dismissed the plaintiff. In a suit filed by the plaintiff, he exhibited interrogatories, the first four of them asking in truth and substance the particulars of misconduct and the fifth asking the gross-proceeding of sale during the period for which the plaintiff claimed remus neration. The defendant refused to answer. As regards the first four interrogatories, the reason was that the interrogatories related to the case of the defendant and not of the plaintiff. In relation to the 5th interrogatory, the ground urged was that the right of action was disputed and that the defendant was not bound to give such account at that stage of the action. It was contended that the defendant having denied that monies were paid, the plaintiff was not entitled to interrogatories. James L.J held;

    “If the plaintiff succeeds in his contention that he is entitled to a fixed commission upon the amount, his having that amount admitted would enable him at the trial, without any further inquiry or litigation, to obtain a decree for the payment of that which is due to him.”

    21. The interrogatories were allowed by Bacon V.C That order was affirmed in appeal. An interrogatory directed to showing what the amount received was, would be allowed as a matter of course at Common law-was the observation of Thesiger L.J

    22. In the course of the Judgment, Bacon V.C observed that the purpose of the interrogatory should not be one “seeking to ransack the depositories of a Defendant of his title deeds or other documents, in order that the Plaintiff may establish more firmly the case he alleges, or make it out entirely”. Such was not the case before him. Such is not the position in the present case too. If the answer of the defendant is allowed to stand, the provision relating to interrogatory would be “an empty word”, to borrow the language of Bacon V.C

    23. Where an account is claimed or question of account arises, the interrogatories as to details of account may be allowed. Vide Nash v. Layton, (1911) 1911-2 Ch 71).

    24. It is unnecessary to deal with these matters over again as they have been already dealt with in the earlier order of my brother John Mathew, J. referred to supra. (The decisions in Jamaitravi v. Motilar Chamaria, AIR 1960 Cal. 536, Raj Narain v. Indira Gandhi, (1972) 3 SCC 850 : AIR 1972 S.C 1303, and Malabar Produce Export Co. v. Nedungadi Bank Ltd., 1982 KLT 462 have been adverted to in that order.)

    25. It is now too late for the defendants to contend that the interrogatories are not relevant. That is now concluded by the order of this Court in C.R.P No. 108 of 1983. Nor can they complain at this stage about the nature of the question or their wording. That too is concluded by the order of the Court passed on 25-2-1986 in I.A 1958/82. The setting in which question No. 4 occurs has also to be noted in this connection. The first question is whether the defendants have received any export benefits. That was answered in the affirmative. The second question related to specific items of articles supplied to the Boards in respect of which export benefits by way of cash assistance had been received. The answer was that such assistance had been received on all items. The third question pertained to the amount received by way of cash assistance. The figure was given as Rs. 20,24,338. Question No. 4 in respect of which there is controversy, comes next and reads:

    “Do those amounts so received include the amount due by way of cash assistance in respect of coupling capacitors, capacity voltage transformers and wave traps supplied by plaintiff to the Kerala State Electricity Board and Karnatake Electricity Board under their respective tender specification and if so, what is the amount received?”

    26. The answer in relation thereto is:

    “Coupling capacitors, capacity voltage transformers and wave traps were not supplied by the plaintiff to the Kerala State Electricity Board and Karnataka State Electricity Board under Tender Specification Nors. IDA/KSEB/8 and IDA/KEB/8.”

    27. Having regard to the pleadings in the case, and the earlier order passed by the trial court, as noted earlier, I have no hesitation to hold that this is not a proper compliance with the direction of the Court to answer interrogatories. The averments in the written statement make it clear that the answer is available or at any rate ascertainable. Illustrative of the situation is the sentence in paragraph 8 of the written statement reading:

    “The allotment of the export benefits are obtained only after the submission of various forms and papers and other formalities are complied with and after passing the said papers through the various authorities. It is a laborious process and involves much time and expenses for getting the said benefits before it is lapsed by time.”

    28. In other words, the figure is computable, though only with some little effort in that behalf. Nothing is made tangible in this world without necessary efforts. The answer to question No. 3 would clearly indicate that the figures are how finally available. When the entirety of the figures is available, as is evident from the answer given in question No. 3, the answer to interrogatory No. 4 comes with little grace. That answer as furnished to question No. 4 is totally unjustified and without bonafides.

    29. The Court at this stage is not concerned with the ultimate entitlement of the plaintiff for the amount. That will necessarily depend upon an evaluation of the contentions between the parties, in the light of the evidence to be adduced in the case. The defendants cannot justifiably take a defiant attitude or indifferent stand, when it is bound by the provisions of law and the orders of Court. No party to a suit can be allowed to adopt such an arrogant attitude. It is some what startling that the defendants indicate a stand that the truth or sufficiency of the answers does not come up for consideration at all. A party to the legal proceedings is bound to state the truth and is not licensed to utter any falsehood. The law frowns upon fouling the court process by false and fabricated evidence or perjury. It may be that an answer bonafide given by a party may not be the correct or proper one, on an elucidation of an issue in the light of the entirely of the evidence. In that way, the Court may not be concerned at an interlocutory stage with the ultimate truthfullness or correctness of the answer. However, the defendant cannot with impunity violate a direction to answer a question when the information is readily available with the defendants and the question is adjudicated by orders of Court as a relevant one to be answered by the defendants. Similar is the situation in relation to the answer to question No. 8. That too is preceded by question Nos. 6 and 7, which respectively deal with the factum of receipt of export benefits by way of import replenishment licence, and the actual receipt of such replenishment licence.

    31. The court below missed the significance of the anterior orders, and the obligations under Order XI Rule 1 C.P.C The jurisdictional inaction involved in not insisting on the defendants giving a proper answer to questions 4 and 8 will have, therefore, to be corrected by this Court in the exercise of its revisional jurisdiction. The Court can, and should, require a person in such a situation to answer, or answer further as the case may be, when such a person omits to answer, or answers insufficiently. The facts of the case clearly make out that the defendants, although obliged to answer in view of the orders passed by this Court and the trial court, had omitted to answer. The Court was statutorily bound to compel such a recalcitrant party to answer. There was jurisdictional deficiency and inaction on the part of the court below when it ordered otherwise. That jurisdictional error has necessarily to be corrected in revision. The order of the court below is accordingly set aside. There will be a direction to the defendants to furnish answers to the court below within a period of two weeks from today. The revision petition is allowed with costs here and in the court below.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    W.S Insulators Of India Ltd. v. Power Systems And Projects & Another
    (Oct 19, 1987)