Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 8 FOREIGN JURISDICTION AND EXTRADITION ACT 1879
  • Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code and Sections 4 and 188 of the Criminal Procedure Code,
  • Sections 8 and 9 of Foreign Jurisdiction and Extradition Act, 1879.26.
  • Sections 4 and 188 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.25.
  • 38) referred to Section 4 of I.P.C and Section 188 of Cr. P.C
  • India.30. Section 388 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • FOREIGN JURISDICTION AND EXTRADITION ACT
  • National Protection Act, the Immigration Act,
  • Section 4 I.P.C and Section 188 Cr. P.C
  • Section 188 Cr. P.C read with Section 4
  • Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code:18.
  • Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code
  • provisions in Section 4 I.P.C
  • Section 188 of the Cr. P.C,
  • supplied)31. Section 2(g)
  • Court.32. Section 2(h)
  • Section 188 Cr. P.C
  • Section 2(h) Cr. P.C
  • Section 2(g) Cr. P.C
  • Section 288 Cr. P.C
  • Section 4 Cr. P.C
  • Section 4 I.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 8 FOREIGN JURISDICTION AND EXTRADITION ACT 1879
  • Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code and Sections 4 and 188 of the Criminal Procedure Code,
  • Sections 8 and 9 of Foreign Jurisdiction and Extradition Act, 1879.26.
  • Sections 4 and 188 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.25.
  • 38) referred to Section 4 of I.P.C and Section 188 of Cr. P.C
  • India.30. Section 388 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • FOREIGN JURISDICTION AND EXTRADITION ACT
  • National Protection Act, the Immigration Act,
  • Section 4 I.P.C and Section 188 Cr. P.C
  • Section 188 Cr. P.C read with Section 4
  • Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code:18.
  • Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code
  • provisions in Section 4 I.P.C
  • Section 188 of the Cr. P.C,
  • supplied)31. Section 2(g)
  • Court.32. Section 2(h)
  • Section 188 Cr. P.C
  • Section 2(h) Cr. P.C
  • Section 2(g) Cr. P.C
  • Section 288 Cr. P.C
  • Section 4 Cr. P.C
  • Section 4 I.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition concerns the jurisdiction of the Kerala Police to investigate offences allegedly committed by the petitioner, an Indian citizen, in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). The respondents (5 and 6) lodged a complaint dated 17-12-1990 alleging that the petitioner, while working as a Manager in the shop of the fifth respondent in the UAE, misappropriated approximately 7,82,737 UAE Dirhams (about Rs. 90 lakhs). The petitioner is accused of criminal misappropriation, breach of trust, and cheating. A prohibitory order was passed by the Ain Civil Court in the UAE to prevent the petitioner from leaving, but the petitioner escaped to India. It is further alleged that the misappropriated money was transferred to India through various banks and some smuggled clandestinely. The petitioner contends that Indian police lack jurisdiction to investigate offences committed abroad unless an extradition treaty exists, and that investigation or evidence gathering by Indian police abroad is impermissible and inadmissible in Indian courts. The Kerala Police proceeded with investigation based on the complaint.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What are the principles applicable regarding extraterritorial jurisdiction of criminal courts over offences committed abroad by an Indian citizen?
  2. What is the scope and effect of Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code read with Sections 4, 188, 2(g), and 2(h) of the Code of Criminal Procedure concerning such offences?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The offences were committed in a foreign country (UAE), so Indian police have no jurisdiction to investigate.
  • Section 4 IPC is substantive law, while Section 188 Cr.P.C relates only to inquiry and trial in India with Central Government sanction; it does not permit investigation by Indian police for offences abroad.
  • Without an extradition treaty, investigation in India is impermissible.
  • Indian police cannot gather evidence abroad, and such evidence would be inadmissible in Indian courts.
  • Indian courts cannot exercise extraterritorial jurisdiction.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Section 188 Cr.P.C empowers police to "deal with" offenders, which includes investigation.
  • Investigation under Section 188 Cr.P.C does not require sanction from the Central Government.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Empress v. Manganlal (1882) ILR 6 Bom. 622 Historical context of foreign jurisdiction and extradition laws Referenced to explain the origins of Section 4 IPC and Section 188 Cr.P.C
Narayan v. Emperor, AIR 1935 Bom 437 Historical context of foreign jurisdiction and extradition laws Supported the understanding of substantive and procedural provisions related to offences abroad
Central Bank Of India v. Ram Narain, AIR 1955 SC 36 Section 4 IPC and Section 188 Cr.P.C jurisdiction over offences committed abroad Held that Indian courts lack jurisdiction if accused was not an Indian citizen at the time of offence
Ajay Aggarwal v. Union of India, 1993 SCC (Cri) 961 Interpretation of Section 4 IPC and Section 188 Cr.P.C; scope of inquiry, trial, and investigation Confirmed that Section 188 Cr.P.C creates a statutory fiction enabling jurisdiction over offences by Indian citizens abroad; sanction of Central Government not always required
Delhi Administration v. Ram Singh, AIR 1962 SC 63 Meaning of "dealt with" in Section 4 Cr.P.C includes investigation, inquiry, trial Supported broad interpretation of procedural powers including investigation
Sahebrao v. Suryabhan Ziblazi, AIR 1948 Nag. 253 Definition of "found" for jurisdictional purposes under Section 188 Cr.P.C Held that jurisdiction applies regardless of how accused came within the territory
Remla v. S.P of Police, 1993 (1) KLT 412 Kerala Police's power to investigate offences committed abroad under Section 188 Cr.P.C Supported the view that Kerala Police can investigate extraterritorial offences without Central Government sanction
CIT v. Ahemadbhai Umarbhai, AIR 1950 SC 134 Use of chapter headings as external aids in statutory interpretation Held that chapter headings cannot override clear statutory language
Frick India Ltd. v. Union of India, (1990) 1 SCC 400 Interpretation of statutory provisions and headings Affirmed approach to statutory interpretation supporting broad reading of procedural sections

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by outlining general principles of extraterritorial jurisdiction: the territorial, protective, nationality (citizenship), and universality principles. It noted that the territorial principle traditionally confines jurisdiction to the place where the offence occurred but that modern complexities require exceptions, especially for offences committed abroad by nationals.

The Court emphasized that Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code embodies the nationality principle, allowing Indian courts to apply substantive criminal law to Indian citizens committing offences abroad. Procedural provisions in Sections 4 and 188 of the Code of Criminal Procedure complement this by governing investigation, inquiry, and trial.

The petitioner’s argument that Section 188 Cr.P.C permits only inquiry and trial but not investigation was rejected. The Court reasoned that the words "dealt with" in Section 188 Cr.P.C must be interpreted broadly to include investigation, inquiry, and trial, consistent with the Supreme Court’s interpretation in Delhi Administration v. Ram Singh. The proviso requiring Central Government sanction applies only to inquiry and trial, not investigation.

The Court held that the procedural provisions of Sections 4 IPC and 188 Cr.P.C are complementary and cannot be read to exclude investigation. Chapter headings cannot restrict the clear language of the statute. The Court also cited precedent that jurisdiction attaches where the accused is "found," regardless of how they came into the jurisdiction.

Further, the Court agreed with the view in Remla v. S.P of Police that Kerala Police can investigate offences committed abroad by Indian citizens without Central Government sanction.

Holding and Implications

The Court dismissed the writ petition.

The Court held that the Kerala Police have jurisdiction to investigate offences allegedly committed abroad by an Indian citizen under Section 4 IPC read with Sections 4 and 188 Cr.P.C. The words "dealt with" in Section 188 Cr.P.C include investigation, inquiry, and trial, and Central Government sanction is not required for investigation. The decision permits Indian police to investigate extraterritorial offences committed by Indian citizens without prior Central Government approval. No broader precedent beyond the direct effect on the parties was established.

    T. Mohammed v. State And Others

    Jagannadha Rao, C.J:— The writ petition raises the question of the jurisdiction of the Kerala Police, in the context of Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code and Sections 4 and 188 of the Criminal Procedure Code, to conduct investigation against the petitioner, who is an Indian citizen, in respect of certain offences said to have been committed by the petitioner in the United Arab Emirates against respondents 5 and 6 in the writ petition, who had lodged Ext. P1 complaint dated 17-12-1990 in the State of Kerala.

    2. If is the case of respondents 5 and 6 in the complaint. Ext. P1 dated 17-12-1990, that the writ petitioner, while working as Manager in the Shop of the fifth respondent in the U.A.E, had diverted to his own accounts a sum of 7,82,737 UAE Dirhams. Total sum is said to be about Rs. 90 lakhs. Petitioner, it is alleged, is guilty of criminal misappropriation of funds. The fifth respondent lodged a complaint with the A1 Ain Civil Court and by the time the Court passed a prohibitory order preventing the petitioner from leaving UAE, petitioner escaped to India, via. Jordan. It is alleged that the money acquired by the above Said misappropriation has been sent to India through various Backs, to his accounts. Some money was allegedly smuggled into India through clandestine methods. These acts, it is alleged, amount to dishonest misappropriation, criminal breach of trust and cheating. Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that inasmuch as the complaint is that the offences took place in a foreign country, the police in India have no power of ‘investigation’. It if argued that while Section 4 is part of the substantive law, Section 188 Cr. P.C read with Section 4 thereof, permits only ‘inquiry and trial’ in India with the sanction of the Central Government and inasmuch as Section 188 Cr. P.C is in Chapter VIII relating to ‘Inquiry and trial’, that Section cannot enable ‘investigation’ by the Indian police, in respect of an offence allegedly committed abroad. Unless there is an extradition treaty between India and the fore go country, no investigation is permissible in India. Further, learned counsel contends that Indian police cannot go to the foreign country for gathering evidence and even if they do, such evidence will not be admissible in India. Indian Courts cannot have extra-territorial jurisdiction.

    3. On the other hand, learned Government Pleader and learned counsel for the fifth and sixth respondents contend that under Section 188 of the Cr. P.C, the police can ‘deal with’ the offender and the said, words include ‘investigation’ also. Such investigation does not require sanction of the Central Government.

    4. The points that arise for consideration are:

    (1) What are the principles applicable in regard to extraterritorial jurisdiction of Criminal Courts in respect of an offence by an Indian citizen which is assumed to have been completed in a foreign country?

    (2) What is the scope and effect of Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code read with Sections 4, 188, 2(g) and 2(h) of the code of Criminal Procedure?

    5. Point No. 1:— In respect of offences allegedly committed by as Indian citizen in a foreign country, particularly where the offence is exclusively completed in such country, the question arises whether the accused can be dealt with by she criminal courts of the country of which he is a citizen. Several important general principles are evolved so cover such a situation and connected problems. Those principles have been extensively considered by several writers of great repute and what we propose to state below is mainly celled out from the views expressed by leading writers(1).

    6. In the early 17th Century, says Lotika Sarkar, when Bodin's Republic was booming the ideological justification of the ??? State, through the concept of sovereighty, criminal jurisdiction began to be based rather on the principle of territoriality. But, in the 19th Century and in the present times, the growth of technology has given rise to crimes which are extensively complex and their capacity to ??? other states has grown greater. Therefore, the need has arisen to dilute the territorial jurisdiction principle and find exceptions for it either through statute or other principles judicially evolved.

    7. Today, the principles evolved fall into font broad categories, namely, the ‘Territorial’ principle; then the ‘Protective’ principle; thereafter the ‘Nationality’ or ‘Citizenship’ principle and finally, the ‘Universality’ principle.

    8. The Territorial principle:—

    9. The Territorial principle, according to Lotika Sarkar, flows from the two accepted principles of international law, namely, territorial sovereignty and the equality of States. (See: Oppenheim, International Law I, 8th Edn. 1955). Territorial sovereignly enables a State to legislate freely, irrespective of the will of other States, provided that such legislation does not violate International law and it is complementary to the principle of equality of all Stages. The State in whose territory the offeacs is committed is more suited to deal with it - the locus delicti. Proponents of this principle say that the advantages of the ‘territoriality’ theory are several. The State where crime is committed can be said to have the strongest interest in punishing she offender; that State can easily apprehend the accused; the local forum of that Sate would be the most coavenient place for trial since the witnesses and Juries are all here and finally the accused cannot be punished unless that country treats the gee as an offence. In fact, the medieval layer was unable to understand how a jury of another country would have knowledge of the crimes committed abroad (R. v. Page, 1954 I.O.B 171).

    10. The territorial principle was applied by the Permanent Court of International Justice 50 years ago is Lotus case when the Turkish Courts took action in regard to a collision off the Turkish coast between a French steamer ‘Lotus’ and a Turkish collier. The Turkish Court applied the territoriality principle and the International Court accepted the same. But the Court observed:

    “territoriality of criminal law, therefore, is not an absolute principle of International law and by no means coincides with territorial sovereignty.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    11. This is because, with the increasing facility of communication and transportation, the opportunities for committing crimes whose constituent elements take place in more than one State, have grown apace. To meet these situations, the jurisdiction of crime to undid upon the territorial principle cannot be an adequate remedy unless exceptions are made(2). In the beginning, England was very conservative in its approach. Jessup attributed this to her insular position having no international land-boundaries sad knowing only boundaries between countries(3). So did America in the early period of history. This was because Anglo-Americas system differed from other countries following the traditions of Roman Law(4). Things have changed for the better now.

    12. England and the U.S.A are now compelled to relax their rigid adherence to the territoriality rule. Glsenville Williams and Michael Hirst enumerate a large number of statutes in England from 3495 upto 1981. These exemptions from the territoriality rule relate to offences at sea, territorial waters, wireless-telegraphy, customs, sexual offences, bigamy, homicide, perjury, terrorism, hijacking etc. The exemptions have become so numerous that the main principle has very little scope for application. A stage has now reached where the following statement of Sir James Stephen(5) looks apposite:

    “The general principle which requires no many exceptions must wrong.”

    13. A survey of there exceptions shows that most of these exceptions became necessary to protect England's security and sovereignty for facts done abroad by British subjects as well es aliens. The Untiled States of America also resorted to exception to the territoriality rule in its National Protection Act, the Immigration Act, the Anti-Trust laws etc. for the reason that the acts abroad had adverse effects in the United States. The British Law Commission has pointed out(6) that England might verily become the ‘haven’ for fraudsters if the territoriality principle remains absolute. The breaking down of the ‘territoriality’ rule is due its becoming subject to the protective or security principle. We shall, therefore, next refer to that principle.

    14. The Protective or Security principle:—

    15. The Protective principle is based upon the nature of interest of the country injured rather then of the country where the offence has taken place.(7) Pro. Brierly said that protective theory received its greatest impetus as a result of aggressive radical nationalism which was launched by the French Revolution and powerfully reinforced by the Italian Risorgimente(8). Whether the offence is committed abroad by citizens or aliens, if it affects or is likely to affect the security or integrity of another State, that State must be able to take punitive action. This is regardless of the locus delict. The principle of extra-territorial jurisdiction can be traced to the right of self-defence stated in the U.N Charter. But, according to Lotika Sarkar, experience showed, that situations arose where the right of self-defence was exercised beyond reasonable limits and there was danger of breaching principles of International law.

    16. The long list of English and U.S statutes referred to by the various authors shows that the exceptions to the territoriality principle are based on the protective principle. This principle has been explained by Glanville Williams as containing two concepts, the ‘initiatory’ and the ‘terminator’. For example, when a person commits a crime across a frontier two views are possible: one that the crime must be taken to have committed where the offender is and secondly, that if is committed where the mischief is completed. These aspects are sometimes described as the ‘subjective’ and ‘objective’ theories. Lord Diplock referred to these theories propounded by Prof Glanville Williams in D.P.P v. Storehouse, (1978 AC 55). Our Supreme Court has also referred to Glanville Williams' articles in Ajay Aggarwal v. Union of India (1993 SCC (Cri) 961) recently. As already stated, the protective principle applies to citizens as well as aliens. We shall next refer to the nationality lot citizenship principle.

    17. The Nationality or Citizenship principle and Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code:—

    18. The nationality principle, according to Lotika Satker, is derived from the sovereignty theory. A State may protect its nationals abroad. This is because a wrong against a citizen is a wrong against his State, which may, therefore, protest and demand compensation on his behalf. Similarly, the State has an interest in punishing is citizens committing offences abroad. Now, if is generally accepted that the profession which a citizen carries wan him wherever he goes also imposes upon him a corresponding duty to conform to the standards of conduct demanded of him by his State. Hence, any act or omission of a citizen abroad which violates these standards will be regarded as a wrong against his Sum, even though it takes place beyond its boundaries and though its impact is felt abroad rather, than at home. ‘It is the relationship between the State and its citizens, rather than the locus delecti or the place of impact, which is the basis of the nationality principle’. The State of which he is a national will be concerned because of its special relationship with him in regulating his conduct. Lotika Sarkar further says (P. 457), referring to Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code, as follows:

    “India has provided that its Penal Code is applicable to its nationals everywhere, no matter how minor the offence.”

    19. This is clear from the very language of Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code. On the other band, in England, citizens committing offences abroad can be brought to book in England only in certain classes of cases covered by specific statutes. Germany assumes jurisdiction not only over those who are nationals at the time of the offence but who later become nationals. Says Lotika Sarkar (P. 460 - 461):

    “It could also be argued that where a national commits a crime abroad, his community will have a strong interest in his rehabilitation and in deterring him from criminal conduct in the future.”

    20. Here again, there are active and passive personality principles. The former deals with punishment of its citizens and the latter with their protection. The personality principle is followed in China, Germany, and Japan also. The passive principle is recognised in the German, Greek, Romanian, Swiss and israeli Codes but is not accepted in Anglo-American Law (see: Shacbor - Landau, p. 283). Michael Hirst suggests (p. 506) that England had better adopt the nationality principle for, in case England has no extradition treaty with the country where the offence is committed, ‘it may sometimes be undesirable for the offender to remain at liberty’, in England. It may be likely that the offence be ‘repeated’. In the country to which he has returned, namely, England. These are indeed grave public policy considerations underlying the Nationality or Citizenship theory. Indeed, Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code which deals which offences committed by ladies citizens abroad, incorporates the Nationality principle. The principle while it is good for the country of origin, it mast, at the same time, be ensured that so for as the scored is concerned, there is no double jeopardy. We shall now refer to the Universality principle.

    21. Universality principle:—

    22. The basis of this principle is that there are certain crimes against international law which, in the absence of an International Court of Criminal Justice, could be punished by the municipal courts, irrespective of locus delecti commissi (see: Shachor-Landau p. 284-5). Under this principle fall offences involving piracy. Cases under the Convention of Obscene Publications 1923 and Suppression of Counterfeiting Currency, 1929 also fall in this category. Soon, offences like genochoe falling under the U.N Convention on the Prevention and Punishment Crime of Genocide 1948 came within the principle. Today more offences against Drug Trafiaking, laws relating to Suppression, of Immoral Traffic in Women and Children, hijacking, terrorism, have joined the list.

    23. The above discussion is a survey of the general principle relating to extra-territorial jurisdiction of ??? offences Point No. 1 is decided accordingly.

    24. Point No. 2:— The Nationality or Citzenship principle discussed under Point No. 1 finds place in Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code, as stated by Lotika Sarkar. That is the substantive part of the law. The procedure provisions are contained in Sections 4 and 188 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

    25. Iisitially, the substantive provisions, now contained in Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code, were there in Section 8 of the Foreign Jurisdiction and Extradition Act, 1879 and the procedure provisions of Section 188 Cr. P.C were there in Section 9 of the said Act of 1879. They were also there with slight, change in the language its the Foreign Jurisdiction and Extradition. Act, 1872 (see: Empress v. Manganlal, (1882) ILR 6 Bom. 622; Narayan v. Emperor, AIR 1935 Bom 437). In the latter case, Sir John ???, C.J (as he then was) observed:

    “In general, the subject of trials in British India for offences committed outside India is dealt with by Section 4 IPC and Section 188 Cr. P.C It is instructive to note the History of those two sections. They are taken substantially from Sections 8 and 9 of Foreign Jurisdiction and Extradition Act, 1879.”

    26. The Supreme Court of Indite, in Central Bank Of India v. Ram Narain, AIR 1955 SC 36 at 38) referred to Section 4 of I.P.C and Section 188 of Cr. P.C and on facts found that the accused was not a citizen of India at the time of the commission of the offence and held that the Indian Courts could not try the offence. In that context, Mahajan, C.J observed, referring to Section 4 I.P.C and Section 188 Cr. P.C that the ‘rule enunciated in the Sections is based on the principle that qua citizens, the jurisdiction of courts is not lost by reason of the venue of the offence. If, however, at the time of the commission of the offence, the accused person is not a citizen of India, than the provisions of these Sections have no application whatsoever’. ‘The circumstances that, after the commission of the offence, a person becomes domiciled in another country or acquires citizenship of that State, cannot confer jurisdiction, on the Courts of that territory retrospectively’.

    27. Recently, in Ajay Aggarwal v. Union of India, 1993 SCC (Cri) 961 the Supreme Court was dealing with a continuing offence of criminal conspiracy and cheating of which part of the acts were done in India. While holding that, in such circumstances, sanction of Central Government under Section 188 Cr. P.C was not necessary, their Lordships considered both Section 4 I.P.C and Section 188 Cr. P.C in the discussion, it is said. Judicial power of a State extends to the punishment of all offences against the municipal laws of the State by whomsoever committed within the territory. It also has the power to punish all such offences wherever committed by a citizen. The provision of Chapter VIII of Cr. P.C are elastic and not peremptory’. It is also stated by K. Ramaswamy, J.:

    “Section 188 by fiction dealt with the offences committed by a citizen of India or a foreigner outside India or on high seas or elsewhere or on any, ship or aircraft registered in India. Such person was directed to be dealt with in respect of such offenses, as if he had committed them at any place within India at which he may be found”.

    (emphasis supplied)

    28. Sahai, J. in a separate judgment, also referred to these provisions.

    29. Now Section 4 of the Indian Penal Code permits, under the Nationality or Citizenship principle, Indian Courts to apply the provisions of the said Code if a citizen does acts abroad which amount to offence under the coda. That the petitioner is a citizen and that the acts attributed to him abroad in the complaint filed by the fifth respondent before police, amount to offences in India, admits of no doubt. That depends on the investigation, inquiry and trial in India.

    30. Section 388 of the Code of Criminal Procedure reads as follows:

    “S. 188 - Offence committed outside India:—

    When an offence is committed outside India-

    (a) by a citizen of India, whether on the high seas or elsewhere;

    (b) by a person, not being such, citizen, on any ship or aircraft registered in India.

    he may be dealt with in respect of such offence as if it had been committed at any place within India at which he may be found:

    Provided that, notwithstanding anything in any of the preceding sections of this Chapter, no such offence shall be inquired into or fried in India except with the previous sanction of the Central Government.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    31. Section 2(g) defines ‘inquiry’ as follows:

    “S. 2(g) - ‘inquiry’ means every Inquiry, other than a trial conducted under this Code by a Magistrate or Court.”

    32. Section 2(h) defines ‘Investigation’ as follows:

    “S. 2(h) - ‘investigation’ includes all the, proceedings under this Code for the collection of evidence conducted by a police officer or by any person (other than a Magistrate) who is authorised by a, Magistrate in this behalf.”

    33. Section 4 of the Cr. P.C on which reliance is placed, reads as follows:

    “S. 4 - Trial of fences' under the Indian Penal Code and other laws:—

    (1) All offences under the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860) shall be investigated, inquired into, tried, and otherwise dealt with according to the provisions hereinafter contained.

    (2) All offences under any other law shall be investigated inquired info, tried, and otherwise dealt with according to the same provisions, but subject to any ??? for the time being in force regulating the manner or place of investigating, inquiring into, trying or otherwise dealing with such offences.”

    34. Counsel for petitioner contends that assuming that the substantive provisions in Section 4 I.P.C could apply if facts are proved, Section its Cr. P.C which permits a criminal court in India to ‘deal with’ the matter, does not apply to enable ‘investigation’ by Indian police. According to him, even if the petitioner can be said to have been ‘found’ is India as required by Section 188 Cr. P.C still, inasmuch as Section 188 is in Chapter XIII dealing wish ‘inquiry’ and ‘trial’ and inasmuch as the proviso to Section 188 also refer to ‘inquiry’ and ‘trial’ of extraterritorial offences, no Section to Chapter XIII, much less Section 188, can permit ‘investigation’ Info such extra-territorial offences. It is argued that ‘investigation’ envisaged in Section 2(h) Cr. P.C is different from ‘inquiry’ as defined in Section 2(g) Cr. P.C and trial. Reliance is also pieced on Section 4 Cr. P.C to say that the words ‘dealt with’ in Section 188 Cr. P.C do not include investigation, iuquiry or trial.

    35. We are unable to agree. As pointed out by the Supreme Court and various High Courts, Section 4 I.P.C and Section 188 Cr. P.C are complementary. The former refer to the substantive law and the latter to the corresponding procedural Jew. We cannot presume that in Section 188 Cr. P.C the legislatures used the words ‘dealt with’ by restricting the meaning to something other than investigation, inquiry or trial. The Supreme Court in Ajay Aggarwal's case, 1993 SCC (Cri) 961, has observed that Section 188 Cr. P.C creates a statutory fiction by using the words ‘as if’. The Section confers jurisdictions on the Court where the alleged offender is found, for the purpose of ‘dealing’ with the offence.

    36. The word-.deal with' in the main part of Section 288 Cr. P.C is, in our view, used in a wide sense. While the proviso to Section 188 Cr. P.C requires sanction of the Central Government for purposes of inquiry' and ‘trial’, the wards ‘deal with’ in the main part must necessarily include atleast ‘inquiry’ and ‘trial’. The words ‘deal with’ in Section 4 of the Cr. P.C referred to above, as amounting to something other than ‘investigation’, ‘inquiry ‘and trial’ therefore, falls to the ground. In face, even while construing Session 4 Cr. P.C, the Supreme Court has stated in Delhi Administration v. Ram Singh, AIR 1962 SC 63, that the words ‘dealt with’ in that Section include not only ‘investigation’, ‘Inquiry’ and ‘trial’ but other aspects also. In view of the said decision of the Supreme Court' the words ‘dealt with’ in Section 188 Cr. P.C must be held to include ‘investigation’ also, apart from ‘inquiry’ and ‘trial’. For purposes of ‘investigation’ into offences committed abroad, sanction of the Central Government is not necessary.

    37. It is true Section 188 Cr. P.C is in Chapter XIII dealing with ‘inquiry’ and ‘trial’. But, that, in our opinion, is not conclusive. On she other hand, Section 188 Cr. P.C is complementary to Section 4 I.P.C and must cover the procedure relating to ‘investigation’ also. Headings of Chapters are external aids and can be resorted to only if there is any ambiguity in the enacting words. (See: CIT v. Ahemadbhai Umarbhai, AIR 1950 SC 134 at 141) (Frick India Ltd. v. Union of India, (1990) 1 SCC 400 : AIR 1990 SC 689 at p. 693). Further, the scope and ambit of the main part of Section 188 Cr. P.C cannot to controlled by the proviso. The words ‘dealt wish’ in the main part cannot be restricted to ‘inquiry’ and. ‘trial’ used in the proviso.

    38. In fact, in Ajay Aggarwal's case, 1993 SCC (Cri) 961 at 980, K. Ramaswamy, J. observed that, even under the proviso to Section 188 Cr. P.C the sanction ‘is not a condition precedent to take cognizance of the offence. If need be, it could be obtained before trial begins’. As to the meaning of the word ‘found’, the accused is found within the particular jurisdiction irrespective of the question as to whether he was brought there against his will or unlawfully. Boss, J. (as be then was) in Sahebrao v. Suryabhan Ziblazi, AIR 1948 Nag. 253, observed that it did not matter whether the person came them voluntarily or in answer to summons or under illegal arrest.

    39. The provision permitting the Court to take action and deal with the accused where he is ‘found’, as are contained in Section 188 Cr. P.C are almost similar to a provisions in a large number of statutes referred to by Prof. Glanville Williams. We are in agreement with the views of K.T Thomas, J. in Remla v. S.P of Police, 1993 (1) KLT 412, that under Section 188 Cr. P.C the Kerala Police can conduct ‘Investigation’ into offences committed abroad and no sanction of the Central Government is necessary for the said purpose.

    40. The Original Petition is dismissed accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T. Mohammed v. State And Others
    (Jan 31, 1994)