AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition was filed by a Trust against orders passed by the State Information Commissioner and the Information Officer. Respondent No. 3, a disciple of Sadguru Pralhad Maharaj, sought information from the Trust under the Right to Information Act. The Trust, represented by the petitioner as Chief Trustee, refused to provide the information citing confidentiality. Respondent No. 3 appealed to the Charity Commissioner (Information Officer), who directed supply of the information upon payment of fees. The Trust then filed a second appeal before the State Information Commissioner, who rejected the appeal. Consequently, the Trust filed the present writ petition challenging these orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Right to Information Act applies to a public trust registered under the Public Trust Act and Societies Act which is not financed or controlled by the Government.
  2. Whether the State Information Commissioner erred in refusing to entertain the plea that the Right to Information Act is not applicable to the Trust on the ground that it was not raised before the first appellate authority.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The Right to Information Act is not applicable to the Trust as it is not a public authority under the Act.
  • The Trust is neither established nor controlled or substantially financed by the Government.
  • The State Information Commissioner erred in rejecting the plea regarding applicability of the Act without considering the legality and jurisdiction of the first appellate authority.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The State Information Commissioner refused to entertain the contention that the Act does not apply to the Trust because it was not raised before the first appellate authority.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed whether a public trust registered under the Public Trust Act and Societies Act falls within the definition of "public authority" under the Right to Information Act. It noted that the Trust is neither established nor constituted by the Constitution, Parliament, State Legislature, or government notification. Further, the Trust is not owned, controlled, or substantially financed by the Government, nor is it a government-funded NGO. The court emphasized that only public authorities as defined in the Act are bound by its provisions. Since the Trust receives no government funding and is not created by government enactment, it does not qualify as a public authority. Consequently, the Right to Information Act does not apply to the Trust. The court also observed that interested persons can seek information from the Charity Commissioner under the Public Trust Act, but there is no obligation for the Trust to appoint an Information Officer or entertain RTI applications. Based on this legal interpretation, the court set aside and quashed the orders of the Information Officer and State Information Commissioner directing disclosure under the RTI Act.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed, and the orders passed by the State Information Commissioner and the Information Officer are set aside and quashed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Trust is not required to comply with the Right to Information Act as it does not constitute a public authority under the Act. No new precedent beyond this case-specific ruling was established. The judgment clarifies that public trusts not created or financed by the Government fall outside the ambit of the RTI Act, and information requests must be pursued under the Public Trust Act instead.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bhaskarrao Shankarrao Kulkarni v. State Information Commissioner, Nagpur And Others

    1. Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith. Heard finally with consent of the parties.

    2. This writ petition is preferred by the Trust against the order passed by the State Information Commissioner as well as the Information Officer.

    3. A few facts may be stated as follows —

    Respondent No. 3 claims to be a disciple of Sadguru Pralhad Maharaj. There is a trust known as Shree Govind Ramnand Samarth Sadguru Pralhad Maharaj (Ramdasi) Sansthan. The petitioner is the Chief Trustee of the said trust. Respondent No. 3 made an application to the said trust to supply certain information to him under the Right to Information Act. The petitioner trustee informed to respondent No. 3 that information being confidential cannot be supplied. Respondent No. 3, therefore, preferred an appeal to the Information Officer i.e the Charity Commissioner. The Charity Commissioner ordered upon payment of fees the information to be supplied. The petitioner, therefore, preferred second appeal to the State Information Commissioner at Nagpur. The State Information Commissioner rejected the appeal. Hence this writ petition.

    4. I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the respondents.

    5. It is not necessary to go into the question as to what information was sought from the trust at all. The only contention of the petitioner is that Right to Information Act itself is not applicable to it and both authorities fell in error in directing the information to be supplied. The State Commissioner has refused to entertain this plea on the ground that it was not raised before the first appellate authority. The question related to the legality of the order passed by the first appellate authority as well as the jurisdiction of the first appellate authority to take cognizance of the appeal. It should have, therefore, dealt with the contention. Be that as it may.

    6. We have therefore now to consider the question if a public trust registered under the Public Trust Act and Societies Act is governed by the Right to Information Act. A public trust to my mind cannot certainly be said to be falling within meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India. It is neither a local authority or other authority of India or an authority under the control of Government. It is not disputed that the present public trust is not provided any sort of grant by the Government. The only exception would, however, be the trust created by the Government and financed by the Government. A Public Trust has been defined in section 2 of sub-section (13) of the Bombay Public Trust Act as follows —

    “Public Trust” means an express or constructive trust for either religious or charitable purpose or both and includes a temple, a math, (church, synagogue, agiary or other place of public religious worship) (a dharmada or any other religious or charitable endowment and a society formed either for a religious or charitable purpose or for both and registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 (XXI of 1860).

    7. A trust is thus established for religious and charitable purpose. It is created upon dedication of certain property by certain persons for certain Page: 804purpose, such as religious or charitable. The question as to whether the public trust is or is not governed by the Right to Information Act has to be decided on the basis of the provisions of the Right to Information Act. It would be necessary to look into certain provisions of the Act. Section 4 of the Right to Information Act casts a duty on every public authority to maintain the record in such a manner to facilitate the supply of information. Section 5 speaks of appointment of Information Officer while section 6 speaks of making an application to the Information Officer. Section 7 deals with the disposal of such request. It is clear from section 4 that Act applies to the public authorities. The definition of public authority as given in the Act reads as follows:

    “Public authority” means any authority or body or institution of self government established or constituted —

    (a) by or under the Constitution;

    (b) by any other law made by Parliament;

    (c) by any other law made by State Legislature;

    (d) by notification issued or order made by the appropriate government, and includes any —

    (i) body owned, controlled or substantially financed;

    (ii) non-Government Organisation substantially financed directly or indirectly by funds provided by the appropriate Government.

    8. A bare reading of definition would make it clear that public trust does not fall in either of the categories. It is not established or constituted under the Constitution of India, bye-law passed by the parliament, by any law of the State Legislature or by Notification issued by any appropriate Government. It is also not a body substantively financed or controlled by the Government nor is it a NGO financed by the Government nor does the trust receive any contribution or grant from the Government. It is not the contention of the State that the State provides any funds to the petitioner trust. It is, therefore, clear from the provisions of this definition that the Act cannot apply to the Public Trust. Any public trust, therefore, is not at all covered by the definition of the public authority. It is only the public authority which is bound by the provisions of the Act. Any person seeking to establish that a particular public trust is covered by the provisions of the Right to Information Act will have to first prove that it is a public trust created by Government or Parliament or is substantively financed by the government. Until that is done, it must be held to be falling outside the scope of the Right to Information Act. If any person interested in the information of the trust, he can definitely apply to the Charity Commissioner under the provisions of the Public Trust Act to have such information, which the Charity Commissioner may deem fit to be provided. But as far as Right to Information Act is concerned, there is no need for any public trust to appoint any Information Officer and to entertain any such application under the Right to Information Act. In the circumstances, the petition has to be allowed. Order passed by both the authorities are set aside and quashed. Petition is allowed. Rule is made absolute.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhaskarrao Shankarrao Kulkarni v. State Information Commissioner, Nagpur And Others
    (Apr 28, 2009)