Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Comprehensive Summary of the Opinion (L.N. Mittal, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit concerns a registered relinquishment/release deed (impugned release deed) relating to suit land measuring 55 kanals 01 marla. The parties are members of the same family. Lakhmir Singh had one son, Harcharan Singh (who predeceased him on 30.08.2001), and two daughters: Gurjit Kaur (respondent No.1 / plaintiff) and Rajinder Kaur (defendant No.8 / proforma respondent No.5). Harcharan Singh left behind defendants No.1 to 3 (minor sons) and defendant No.4 (widow).

The plaintiff pleaded that a release deed, dated in the document as 10.06.2001 but conceded by counsel to have been executed and registered on 10.09.2001, was illegal and void because it was not executed by Lakhmir Singh and because the suit land was self-acquired property which could not be transferred by way of release to persons (defendants No.1 to 3) who had no pre-existing right in the land. The plaintiff sought declaration of illegality of the release deed and mutation entered on its basis, joint possession (as legal heir), and permanent injunction.

Defendants Nos.1 to 6 (and defendant No.8 supporting them) denied the plaintiff’s case and maintained the release deed was executed and registered by Lakhmir Singh, transferring title to defendants No.1 to 3. The trial court (Civil Judge, Junior Division, Yamunanagar at Jagadhari) dismissed the plaintiff’s suit by judgment and decree dated 31.07.2008. On first appeal, the Additional District Judge allowed the plaintiff’s appeal by judgment and decree dated 21.05.2010, holding that the plaintiff and defendant No.8 were entitled to one-third share each and defendants No.1 to 4 had the remaining one-third. Aggrieved, defendants Nos.1 to 4 filed the instant second appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned release deed was actually executed by Lakhmir Singh (i.e., whether execution of the release deed is proved)?
  2. Whether the impugned release deed could validly transfer title in the suit land to defendants No.1 to 3 who had no pre-existing right or title in the suit land?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Defendants No.1 to 4) Arguments

  • Both attesting witnesses of the release deed, Kulwant Singh (defendant No.5) and Surjit Singh (defendant No.6), were examined by the defendants and supported the case that Lakhmir Singh voluntarily executed and registered the release deed.
  • These attesting witnesses' statements were not impeached in cross-examination; such testimony is the best evidence to prove due execution of the deed.
  • The release deed is a registered document and bears Lakhmir Singh's photograph on the registration endorsement, adding to its authenticity and negating any claim of impersonation at the time of execution/registration.
  • Relying on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kuppuswami Chettiar v. Arumugam Chettiar, A.I.R. 1967 S.C. 1395, it was contended that a deed of release, by using words of sufficient amplitude, can transfer title even to a person who had no title before the transfer; consequently, Lakhmir Singh was competent to transfer title to his grandsons (defendants No.1 to 3) by the release deed.

Respondent No.1 / Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The execution of the release deed is surrounded by suspicious circumstances: on 24.08.2001, Lakhmir Singh had affixed thumb impressions (not signatures) on many release deeds and was physically unfit to sign; he also did not attend his son Harcharan Singh’s funeral on 30.08.2001, suggesting physical inability to execute the deed on 10.09.2001.
  • The suit land was self-acquired property of Lakhmir Singh; defendants No.1 to 3 had no pre-existing right therein and, according to the plaintiff’s contention, a release deed can only enlarge a pre-existing right—hence it could not validly transfer title to persons without prior title.
  • Plaintiff adduced a handwriting expert who opined that signatures on the impugned release deed do not match Lakhmir Singh’s standard signatures.
  • Several authorities were relied upon (see Table of Precedents): State v. Alokik Jain; Shri Shailesh Harilal Poonatar v. District Collector of Stamps; J. Kubera Mandadi v. K. Doraswamy Mandadi; Mahip Singh Thakur v. Hema Thakur. It was argued these support the plaintiff’s contention (directly or to some extent).
  • It was contended that defendant No.7, maternal uncle of defendants No.1 to 3, had no right to accept the release deed on their behalf.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kuppuswami Chettiar v. Arumugam Chettiar, A.I.R. 1967 S.C. 1395 Holds that a deed called a "deed of release" can, by using words of sufficient amplitude, transfer title to one having no title before the transfer. The court relied on this Supreme Court decision to conclude that the impugned release deed could validly transfer title in the suit land to defendants No.1 to 3 notwithstanding their lack of pre-existing title; this precedent dispositively answered the plaintiff’s primary contention on the second issue.
State v. Alokik Jain and others, 1998 A.I.R. (Raj.) 348 Relates to stamp duty chargeable on a document (as characterized in the opinion). The court noted this decision pertains to stamp duty issues and did not adopt it to defeat the effect of the release deed under Kuppuswami Chettiar.
Shri Shailesh Harilal Poonatar v. District Collector of Stamps and others, 2005 A.I.R. (Bombay) 29 Relates to stamp duty chargeable on a document (as characterized in the opinion). Treated similarly to State v. Alokik Jain: it concerns stamp duty and was not held to override the Supreme Court principle relied on by the appellants.
J. Kubera Mandadi and others v. K. Doraswamy Mandadi and others, 2005 (4) A.L.T. 728 Was cited by the plaintiff and, according to the opinion, does to some extent support the plaintiff’s contention regarding the effect of a release deed. The court observed this decision offers some support to the plaintiff’s position but held that it could not prevail in face of the Supreme Court decision in Kuppuswami Chettiar.
Mahip Singh Thakur v. Hema Thakur, 2005 (120) D.L.T. 173 Was cited by the plaintiff and, according to the opinion, does to some extent support the plaintiff’s contention regarding the release deed. The court acknowledged this decision lends some support to the plaintiff but concluded it was insufficient to countermand the binding principle in Kuppuswami Chettiar.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the rival contentions on two distinct issues: (1) whether the release deed was actually executed by Lakhmir Singh, and (2) whether such a deed could transfer title to persons who had no pre-existing title.

On the first issue (execution): the defendants produced direct evidence through examination of both attesting witnesses to the release deed, Kulwant Singh (a Lambardar of the village) and Surjit Singh (a relative of defendant No.4). Both attesting witnesses testified that Lakhmir Singh executed and registered the release deed voluntarily; their evidence was not impeached in cross-examination. The court treated such testimony as the best possible evidence to prove due execution. The court further relied on the fact that the release deed was a registered document and bore Lakhmir Singh’s photograph on the endorsement of registration, which added to the document’s authenticity and indicated there was no impersonation at execution/registration. The court evaluated the plaintiff’s handwriting expert’s opinion but held that it could not prevail over the direct testimony of the attesting witnesses—observing that handwriting comparison is a "weak science" and that party-engaged experts often give partisan opinions. The court also rejected inferences urged by the plaintiff from other contemporaneous deeds (where Lakhmir Singh allegedly affixed thumb impressions on 24.08.2001) and from his non-attendance at his son’s funeral, holding these facts did not establish physical inability to execute the impugned deed on 10.09.2001. On this basis the court concluded the execution of the impugned release deed by Lakhmir Singh was fully proved.

On the second issue (legal effect of the release deed): the court found the Supreme Court decision in Kuppuswami Chettiar controlling. That decision authoritatively holds that a deed of release, if drafted with words of sufficient amplitude, can transfer title even to a person who previously had no title. Applying that principle to the clear terms of the impugned release deed, the court concluded that Lakhmir Singh, by executing the release deed, transferred title in the suit land to defendants No.1 to 3. The court noted that other decisions cited by the plaintiff either deal with stamp duty (Alokik Jain; Shri Shailesh Harilal Poonatar) or only partly support the plaintiff’s contention (J. Kubera Mandadi; Mahip Singh Thakur), but they could not outweigh the binding authority of the Supreme Court in Kuppuswami Chettiar. Thus, on legal effect, the court held the release deed validly transferred title to defendants No.1 to 3 despite their lack of pre-existing title.

Holding and Implications

Result: The second appeal is ALLOWED.

Holding (core ruling): The court answered both substantial questions of law in favour of the appellants: (1) the impugned release deed was duly executed by Lakhmir Singh; and (2) by the impugned release deed Lakhmir Singh validly transferred title in the suit land to defendants No.1 to 3 who had no pre-existing title, in view of the Supreme Court decision in Kuppuswami Chettiar.

Immediate consequences: The judgment and decree of the lower appellate court are set aside. The judgment and decree of the trial court dismissing the plaintiff’s suit are restored. The parties were directed to bear their respective costs ("Parties are left to suffer their respective costs throughout").

The opinion does not discuss broader jurisprudential implications beyond the application of the Supreme Court precedent; accordingly, the direct effect is limited to the parties in this litigation (restoration of the trial court's decree and dismissal of the plaintiff's suit).

    Harjot Singh Others v. Gurjit Kaur Others

    JUDGEMENT :-

    L.N.Mittal, J.

    1 Defendants No.l to 4, who were successful in the trial court, but have been unsuccessful in the lower appellate court, have filed the instant second appeal.

    2 Lakhmir Singh had only one son i.e. Harcharan Singh and two daughters i.e. Gurjit Kaur-respondent No.1/plaintiff and Rajinder Kaur-defendant No.8/proforma respondent No.5. Harcharan Singh died on 30.08.2001 during the lifetime of Lakhmir Singh. Harcharan Singh left behind defendants No.l to 3 as minor sons and defendant No.4 as widow.

    3 Case of the plaintiff is that relinquishment deed dated 10.06.2001 registered on 10.09.2001 allegedly executed by Lakhmir Singh in favour of defendants Nos.1 to 3 regarding suit land measuring 55 kanals 01 marla is illegal and null and void along with consequent mutation No.638 entered on its basis because the said release deed was not executed by Lakhmir Singh and also because the suit land being self acquired property of Lakhmir Singh, he could not transfer it by way of release deed to defendants No.l to 3, who had no pre-existing right in the suit land. Consequently, the plaintiff also sought relief of joint possession of the suit land being among the legal heirs of Lakhmir Singh, who died on 25.10.2001. Ancillary relief of permanent injunction was also claimed.

    4 Defendants No.l to 5 broadly controverted the plaint allegations, while admitting the relationship between the parties. It was pleaded that Lakhmir Singh himself executed the registered release deed dated 10.09.2001 in favour of defendants No.l to 3, who have accordingly become owners in possession of the suit land. Defendant No.8 also supported the case of defendants No.l to 5. Defendants No.6 and 7 filed written statement broadly taking the same stand. Release deed was pleaded to be legal and valid by all the defendants.

    5 Learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Yamunanagar at Jagadhari, vide judgment and decree dated 31.07.2008, dismissed the plaintiffs suit. However, first appeal preferred by the plaintiff has been allowed by learned Additional District Judge, Yamunanagar at Jagadhari, vide judgment and decree dated 21.05.2010 and thereby, suit filed by the plaintiff has been decreed. It has been held that plaintiff and defendant No.8 are entitled to one-third share each in the suit land, whereas defendants No.l to 4 have the remaining one-third share in the suit land, as per natural succession of Lakhmir Singh. Feeling aggrieved, defendants No. 1 to 4 have filed the instant second appeal.

    6 I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the case file.

    7 At the outset, it has to be noticed that in the impugned release deed, date of its execution has been inadvertently mentioned as 10.06.2001, but counsel for the parties concede that release deed was executed on 10.09.2001 and was registered on the same date.

    8 Learned counsel for the appellants contended that defendants have examined both the attesting witnesses of the release deed namely Kulwant Singh (defendant No.5) and Surjit Singh (defendant No.6) and both of them have supported the version of the defendants that the aforesaid release deed was executed by Lakhmir Singh voluntarily. It was also contended that by way of release deed, Lakhmir Singh was competent to transfer title in the suit land in favour of his grandsons i.e. defendants No.1 to 3 (sons of pre-de- ceased son of Lakhmir Singh), even though defendants No.l to 3 had no pre-existing right in the suit land. Reliance in support of this proposition has been placed on judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Kuppuswami Chettiar v. Arumugam Chettiar, A.I.R. 1967 S.C. 1395.

    9 On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent No.l-plaintiff vehemently contended that execution of the release deed by Lakhmir Singh is surrounded by suspicious circumstances. It was pointed out that on 24.08.2001, many release deeds were executed by Lakhmir Singh and his brothers etc. regarding mutual partition and Lakhmir Singh affixed his thumb impressions and not signatures on the said release deeds as he was physically unfit to affix his signatures. It was also pointed out that Lakhmir Singh did not attend the funeral of his son Harcharan Singh, who died on 3C.08.2001 being physically unfit and therefore, he could not have affixed his signatures on the impugned release deed dated 10.09.2001.

    10 It was also pointed out that suit land was self-acquired property of Lakhmir Singh, and therefore, defendants No. 1 to 3 had no pre-existing right therein and consequently, there could be no valid release deed for transferring title in the suit land by Lakhmir Singh in favour of defendants No.l to 3 as release deed is executed for enlarging any pre-existing right in the suit property. Reliance in support of this proposition has been placed on four judgments i.e. a judgment of Rajasthan High Court in the case of State v. Alokik Jain and others, 1998 A.I.R. (Raj.) 348, a judgment of Bombay High Court namely Shri Shailesh Harilal Poonatar v. District Collector of Stamps and others, 2005 A.I.R. (Bombay) 29, a judgment from High Court of Andhra Pradesh in the case of J. Kubera Mandadi and others v. K. Doraswamy Mandadi and others, 2005(4) A.L.T. 728 (Equivalent Citation) and lastly a judgment of Delhi High Court namely Mahip Singh Thakur v. Hema Thakur, 2005(120) D.L.T. 173. It was also submitted that plaintiff has examined handwriting expert, who has opined that signatures of Lakhmir Singh on the impugned release deed do not match with his standard signatures. It was also contended that defendant No.7, who is maternal uncle of defendants No.l to 3, had no right to accept the release deed on their behalf.

    11 I have carefully considered the rival contentions.

    12 Twin issues are required to be decided. First is whether release deed was actually executed by Lakhmir Singh or not? Second is whether the release deed could validly transfer the title in the suit land in favour of defendants No.l to 3?

    13 As regards first issue, defendants have led direct evidence by examining both attesting witnesses of the release deed. They have stated that the release deed was executed and got registered by Lakhmir Singh himself voluntarily. Their statements could not be impeached in cross examination. There could be no better evidence to prove due execution of the release deed. It may be added that Kulwant Singh - attesting witness is Lambardar of the village, whereas Surjit Singh - attesting witness is relative of defendant No.4 being husband of her first cousin sister. The defendants have thus led best possible evidence to prove due execution of the release deed.

    14 In addition to it, the release deed is registered one. Registration of the release deed further adds to its authenticity. The release deed also bears photograph of Lakhmir Singh on the endorsement of registration. It further depicts that it was Lakhmir Singh himself, who executed the release deed and got it registered and he was not impersonated at the time of execution and registration of the release deed.

    15 Opinion of handwriting expert examined by the plaintiff cannot prevail over direct evidence of attesting witnesses of the release deed, particularly because release deed is registered one. Science of comparison of handwriting or signatures is weak science. Ordinarily, handwriting expert engaged by a party gives opinion in favour of that party. In the instant case, therefore, mere opinion of handwriting expert is not sufficient to over-ride the reliable testimony of both the attesting witnesses of the release deed so as to discard the registered release deed.

    16 Merely because Lakhmir Singh affixed his thumb impressions on some other release deeds on 24.08.2001, but affixed his signatures on the impugned release deed, the impugned release deed cannot be discarded. There may be many reasons for affixing thumb impressions on release deeds dated 24.08.2001 and not necessarily that he affixed thumb impressions on the said deeds being physically unfit. Similarly, the fact that Lakhmir Singh did not attend the funeral of his only son would not be sufficient to come to the conclusion that he was physically unfit to execute the impugned release deed dated 10.09.2001.

    17 In view of the aforesaid discussion, I have no hesitation in concluding that execution of impugned release deed by Lakhmir.Singh is fully proved.

    18 As regards second issue, the same is concluded in favour of the appellants by judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Kuppuswami Chettiar (supra). The said judgment completely answers the contention raised on behalf of respondent No.1- plaintiff. In this judgment, Hon'ble Supreme Court rejected similar contention that release deed is meant to enlarge a right already existing in the suit property in favour of the releasee. On the contrary, it was held that a deed called a deed of release can, by using words of sufficient amplitude, transfer title to one having no title before the transfer. In the instant case, the impugned release deed is very clear and the releasor Lakhmir Singh, by executing the impugned release deed, transferred title in the suit land to defendants No.1to 3. Consequently, this release deed has the effect of transferring title in the suit land in favour of defendants No.1 to 3, who had no pre-existing right or title in the suit land. Judgments in the cases of Alokik Jain and Shri Shailesh Harilal Poonatar (supra) relate to stamp duty chargeable on a document. Judgments in the cases of J. Kubera Mandadi and Mahip Singh Thakur (supra) do, to some extent, support the contention advanced by learned counsel for respondent No.-1-plaintiff. However, in view of judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Kuppuswami Chettiar (supra), the contention canvassed by counsel for respondent No.1-plaintiff cannot be accepted. Judgment in the case of Kuppuswami Chettiar (supra) is very categorical and lays down in clear words that even title can be transferred by way of release deed in favour of a person, who already had no title in the property.

    19 For the reasons aforesaid, I find that following substantial questions of law arise for determination in the instant second appeal:-

    "1. Whether finding of the lower appellate court that impugned release deed was not executed by Lakhmir Singh is illegal and perverse and not sustainable in the eyes of law in the facts and circumstances of instant case?

    2. Whether finding of the lower appellate court that by impugned release deed, Lakhmir Singh could not validly transfer title in the suit land to defendants No.l to 3, who had no preexisting right or title in the suit land is legally unsustainable?"

    20 As a necessary upshot of the discussion already made, both the aforesaid sub-stantial questions of law are answered in affirmative i.e. In favour of the appellants. Resultantly, the instant second appeal is allowed. Judgment and decree of the lower appellate court are set aside and judgment and decree of the trial court, thereby dismissing the suit of the plaintiff-respondent No.l, are restored.

    Parties are left to suffer their respective costs throughout.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Harjot Singh Others v. Gurjit Kaur Others
    (Mar 7, 2011)