S.S Dewan, C.J:— By this writh petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner Manjit Singh challenges the validity of his detention by the order of the District Magistrate, Jalandhar, under Section 3(2) read with Section 3(3) and Section 14-A of the National Security Act, 1980 (for short, the Act) on his being satisfied that the detention of the petitioner was necessary with a view to preventing him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of the public order
2. The order of detention is based on two grounds; the first of which relates to an incident of October 3, 1986 and the second of February 3, 1989. The grounds of detention are as follows:—
“I. During the year 1986, you were posted as Constable at PAP Headquarter, Jalandhar Cantt. Constable Sardul Singh of PAP was in possession of Quarter. No. 119 in the PAP Complex You and your associates viz. SI Gurbachan Singh, HC Ajit Singh, HC Kulwant Singh, Constable Sardul Singh, Constable Dalwinder Singh, Constable Balwinder Singh and Constable Manjit Singh of PAP and Sukhdev Singh @ Sukha Sepoy used to hold meetings in the aforesaid quarter No. 119 of Constable Sardul Singh and used to make plans to kill J.F Ribeno Director General of Police, for the reasons that Sh. Riberio DGP had insulted the Sikhism and injured the sentiments of the Sikhs by sending the police inside the Golden Temple, Amritsar and killed many Sikh youths in fake police encounters and was committing atrocities on the Sikhs. On 15-9-1986, you alongwith St Gurbachan Singh, C. Sardul Singh, C. Balwinder Singh, C. Dalwinder Singh, C. Balwinder Singh, C. Kewal Singh, HC Ajit Singh and HC Kulwant Singh and Sukhdev Singh @ Sukha offered ‘Aardas’ and look oath in Gurdwara Beant Nagar for the achievement of your goal, i.e to kill Sh. J.F Riberio DGP.
In pursuance of the conspiracy hatched by you and your associates, on 3-10-1986 at about 6.45 a.m, C. Sardul Singh armed with rifle, C. Dalwinder Singh armed with carbine, C. Balwinder Page: 488Singh in uniform of DSP armed with carbine, HC Ajit Singh armed with carbine and one other person wearing the uniform of HC armed with machine-gun came to the GO Mess in the AP complex in Jeep No. 471 PAT which was being driven by Vijaypal Singh and opened fire at Sh. Roberio DPG with intent to kill him, who had a narrow escape. The assailants also fired at C. Joginder Singh who was on Sentry duty and injured him and he succumbed to his injuries later on HC Kulwant Singh also received an injury during the firing. While fleeing, the culprits shot dead C. Kuldip Raj and injured C. Lakshman and Pargode of the CRPF. In this connection case. FIR No. 69 dated 30-10-1986 u/s 302/307/148/149/120B/419/170 IPC, 25 Arms Act and ¾ TDA(P), Act, was registered at P.S Cantt. Jalandhar. During the investigation of the case, statement of HC Sucha Singh was recorded on 3-10-1986, in which be named the four culprits and stated about your involverdent in the murderous assult of Sh. Riberio DGP.C Sardul Singh was arrested on 30-10-1986 while you and C. Kewai Singh were arrested on 8-11-1986 and on interrogation by the police, you and your associates C. Sardul Singh and Kewai Singh admitted your involvement in this case. Copies of FIR No. 69/86 P.S Cantt. Jalandhar, statement of HC Sucha Singh dated 3-10-1986, para No. 1 of CD No. 50 dated 24-11-1986, para No. 2 of CD No. 26 dated 30-10-1986, extract of para No. 2 of CD No. 28 dated 1-11-1986, paras No. 2 and 4 of CD No. 35 dated 8-11-86, and paras Nos. 5 and 7 of CD No. 36 dated 9-11-1986 of this case are attached an Annexures I, II, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, and IX.
On 3-2-1989, ASI Gian Singh of P.S Cantt. Jalandhar was present near Chowk Regal Cinema alongwith other police officials in connection with patrolling where he received secret information that you and Kewal Singh s/o Inder Singh Jat r/o Thande PS Sadar Amritsar, were residing in Kothi No. 28, Haqiqat Road, Jalandhar Cantt. for the last few days. That you and Kewal Singh give shelter to extremists Gurbachan Singh Manochaha Sukhdev Singh Jhamka and Jaspal Singh Sobhana of Khalistan Commando Force, in order to avoid their arrest by the police. That you and Kewal Singh provide them financial aid, meals, clothes and also keep the arms of the extremists with you and supply the same to them when needed. On the basis of above information, case FIR No. 9 dated 3-2-1989 u/s 212/216A IPC and ¾ TDAP Act was registered at P.S Cantt. Jalandhar.
On the same day i.e 3-2-1989, AST Gian Singh raided aforesaid Kothi No. 28, Haqikat Road Jalandhar Cantt. and arrested you and your associate Kewal Singh and that time you both raised slogans ‘Khalistan Zindabad’. On interrogation by the police, you and Kewal Singh admitted that you have been giving shelter to aforesaid extremists and providing them meals. The statement of Kalyan Dass, Member Panchayat, Dakoha, PS Sadar, Jalandhar, was also recorded on 3-2-1989 in which he stated that 3-/4 days back he had seen Sukhdev Singh Jhamka and Gurbachan Singh Manochahal coming out of Kothi No. 28, Haqikat Road, alongwith you and Kewal Singh. Copies of FIR No. 9/89 of PS Cantt. Jalandhar, statement of Kalyan Dass dated 3-2-1989, paras Nos. 5, 7 and 8 of CD No. 1 dated 3-2-1989 of this case Page: 489are attached as Annexures X, XI, XII, XIII and XIV”.
3. The two grounds set out above are nothing but narration of facts bringing out the antecedents history of the petitioner. It is obvious therefrom that the ground for making out The order for his detention is one and the same viz. to prevent him from indulging in such criminal acts affecting public order.
4. Mr. G.S Grewal, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that it is virtually impossible for the petitioner to be released on bail in the aforesaid criminal cases in view of the fact that these cases had been registered for commission of offences punishable under the Terrorist & Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act and that since the detenu would remain in custody there would hardly be any chance for him to inference with the efforts of the Government in coping with the terrorist and disruptive activities. There appears to be substance in his contentions.
5. Apart from the registration of criminal cases against the petitioner referred to above, no other reliable material has been brought on record to show that the petitioner if released on bail, is likely to commit activities prejudicial to the maintenance of public order and security of the State or that there were compelling reasons to justify his preventive detention in view of the fact that the petitioner is already under detention on various charges for committing criminal offences.
6. The matter is not res-integra. K.S Bhalla J., in Yadvinder Singh alias Bira v. The State of Punjab, 1988 (1) Recent CR 419, has observed as under:—
“The power of directing preventive detention given to the appropriate authorities must be exercised in exceptional cases as contemplated by the various provisions of the different statutes dealing with preventive detention and should be used with great deal of circumspection. There must be awareness of the fact necessitating preventive custody of a person for social defence which as shown above is badly lacking in this case. If a man is in custody and there is no imminent possibility of his being released, power of preventive detention cannot be exercised If any authority is needed on the point. Ramesh Yadav v. District Magistrate Etah, (1985) 4 SCC 232 : AIR 1986 SC 315 and Binod Singh v. District Magistrate, Dhanbad, Bihar, (1986) 4 SCC 416 : AIR 1986 SC 2090, can be looked into with advantage, wherein it is provided that it is not proper to pass such order against a person who is in custody in the absence of imminent possibility of his release”.
7. For the foregoing reasons, I am not satisfied that this is a fit case to resort to preventive detention and the petitioner is entitled to succeed on the ground that he was already in custody and so could not have possibly indulged in any prejudicial activity.
8. I accordingly hold that there was clear non-application of mind on the part of the detaining authority. The order of detention dated 14-2-89 and the subsequent confirmatory order are, therefore, quashed. The writ petition is allowed to the extent indicated above.
9. Thus, however, will not affect the detenu's detention under the criminal cases. There is no statement in the petition that the detenu is on bail. Therefore, there will be no order for release of the detenu.