Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Jasmer Singh Bhatti, filed a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking a writ of certiorari to quash orders passed by the Collector Agrarian, Rajpura, and the Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab. These orders declared some of his land to be surplus under the Punjab Land Reforms Act. The petitioner and his wife owned agricultural land in villages Jeoli and Tardak, Tehsil Dera Bassi, District Patiala. The petitioner also claimed ownership of a disputed piece of land originally owned by Shmt. Angoori Devi, based on a Will and adverse possession, though this claim was rejected by the civil court and was under appeal.

The Collector Agrarian initially declared the petitioner a small land-owner in 1976, but later reviewed this order and declared a substantial portion of the petitioner’s land as surplus in 1980/81, wrongly concluding that the petitioner was a tenant of Shmt. Angoori Devi for the disputed land. The petitioner’s son became major during the proceedings, which was not accounted for by the Collector. The petitioner challenged these orders through appeals and writ petitions, contesting the classification of the disputed land and procedural irregularities in the review process.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner was a tenant or a land-owner in respect of the disputed land originally owned by Shmt. Angoori Devi, as defined under the Punjab Land Reforms Act.
  2. Whether the Collector Agrarian had jurisdiction to review and modify his earlier order without prior permission from the Commissioner.
  3. Whether the petitioner was entitled to a separate land unit for his son upon attaining majority during the proceedings.
  4. Whether bona fide sales of land by the petitioner after initial declaration as small land-owner could be excluded in determining surplus land.
  5. Whether the petitioner was given a fair opportunity to select permissible land area after the disputed land was included in the calculation of surplus land.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner claimed ownership of the disputed land through a Will and adverse possession, denying tenant status.
  • The Collector’s review order was illegal and without jurisdiction as it was passed without prior permission from the Commissioner.
  • The petitioner’s son, having become major during the proceedings, was entitled to a separate land unit which was not granted.
  • The petitioner had bona fide sold part of his land after being declared a small land-owner, and such sales should be respected in determining permissible land.
  • The petitioner should have been given a fresh opportunity to select permissible land after the disputed land was included.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The petitioner and his wife were admitted landowners, but the petitioner was a tenant of Shmt. Angoori Devi in respect of the disputed land, as he did not pay rent but held the land under a relationship that amounted to tenancy.
  • The orders passed by the Collector and Commissioner were valid and within jurisdiction, including the review order after the Commissioner’s remand.
  • The son’s majority status did not affect the surplus land calculation as the family was in possession of surplus land on the appointed day.
  • The petitioner intentionally concealed possession of disputed land and did not furnish required declarations under the Punjab Land Reforms Act.
  • The bona fide sales made by the petitioner could not be ignored in determining permissible land area.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jagjit Singh v. The Financial Commissioner Haryana (1981 PLJ 367) Where the revenue record entry regarding payment of rent is blank, it is taken that no rent is being paid; payment of rent is necessary to establish landlord-tenant relationship. The Court applied this principle to hold that the petitioner was not a tenant of Shmt. Angoori Devi because no rent was payable or paid, and no contract existed to that effect.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of the petitioner’s possession of the disputed land and the definitions under the Punjab Land Reforms Act and related statutes. It noted that the revenue record showed no rent payable by the petitioner to Shmt. Angoori Devi, and there was no evidence of any contract for rent. Citing the precedent in Jagjit Singh, the Court held that absence of rent payment negated a landlord-tenant relationship, thus the petitioner could not be treated as a tenant. The Court further examined statutory definitions of “land-owner” under the Punjab Land Reforms Act and the Punjab Land Revenue Act, concluding that the petitioner qualified as a land-owner by virtue of possession and enjoyment of profits, regardless of the outcome of the pending civil suit on ownership.

Regarding the Collector’s review order, the Court found that the Commissioner’s remand and acceptance of appeal effectively amounted to prior sanction required under Section 82 of the Punjab Tenancy Act, validating the Collector’s jurisdiction to review the earlier order. The petitioner’s argument about the son’s majority and entitlement to separate land was rejected, since the family was in possession of surplus land on the appointed day. The Court also dismissed the contention that bona fide sales of land by the petitioner should exclude the sold land from surplus area calculation, holding that concealment of possession of disputed land invalidated such exclusion. The petitioner was given opportunity to select permissible land, and this was found to have been availed of.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition filed by Jasmer Singh Bhatti is dismissed.

The Court upheld the orders declaring certain land in the petitioner’s possession as surplus under the Punjab Land Reforms Act. It clarified that possession without payment of rent did not create a landlord-tenant relationship, and that possession coupled with enjoyment of profits qualified one as a land-owner for the purpose of surplus land determination. The procedural challenge to the Collector’s review order was rejected based on the Commissioner’s prior sanction by way of remand. The petitioner’s claims arising from sales and majority of his son were also denied. This decision directly affects the parties by affirming the surplus land declaration and does not establish any new precedent beyond the statutory and case law principles applied.

    Jasmer Singh Bhatti v. State Of Punjab

    A.L. Bahri, J - Jasmer Singh Bhatti in this petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India prays for issuance of a writ of certiorari quashing orders Annexures P2 and P3 passed by Collector Agrarian, Rajpura, and the Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab whereby some of his land was declared to be surplus. 2. The petitioner owns some agricultural land in village Jeoli and Tardak, Tehsil Dera Bassi, District Pataila. His wife Shmt. Reshmi Devi also owns some land. His son Bandhupal Singh was born on 22nd September, 1962, and was a major when he filed this petition. There was no land in his name. The total holding of the petitioner and his wife was 15.98.06 hectares out of which 0.03.38 was Gair Mumkin leaving a balance of 15.95.28 ordinary hectares. Since the entire land was Barani, in terms of standard hectares it was 5.42.19. In this manner, the petitioner claimed to be a small land-owner under the provisions of the Punjab Land Reforms Act. 3. The petitioner was holding another piece of land measuring 141 Bighas 4 Biswas, entered in the revenue record in the ownership of Shmt. Angoori Devi, respondent No. 5. The petitioner was neither the tenant nor mortgagee of this land. However, he claimed to have become owner of this land by virtue of a Will left by Jai Singh, father of Shmt. Angoori Devi, who was the original owner. The petitioner also claimed adverse possession over this land for more than 12 years. There was dispute regarding this piece of land between the petitioner and Smt. Angoori Devi in the civil court. The suit filed by the petitioner was dismissed and the appeal was stated to be pending in the court of Additional District Judge Patiala. 4. The case of surplus area of the petitioner was decided by Collector Agrarian on June 4, 1976, declaring the petitioner to be a small land-owner. A copy or the order is Annexure P1. This order was not challenged in appeal. The Collector also declared Shmt. Angoori Devi, respondent, to be a small land-owner while including the land in dispute in the possession of the petitioner as owned by Shmt. Angoori Devi. The petitioner made two sale deeds, one on June 22, 1976 and the second on August 31, 1976, in favour of Gurbax Singh and Ujagar Singh in respect of 44 Bighas of land. These vendees were not related to the petitioner in any manner. The vendees are Jat whereas the petitioner is a Rajput. In this manner, the holding of the petitioner was further reduced by about 1.5 standard hectares. Collector Agrarian Rajpura, vide his order dated January 4, 1977, reviewed his earlier order Annexure-P1 whereby the petitioner was declared to be a small land-owner. An appeal was filed against the said order before the Commissioner which was accepted and the case was remanded to the Collector Agrarian for a fresh decision after hearing the petitioner, his wife and Smt. Angoori Devi. The Collector, vide his order Annexure P2 dated October 31, 1980/January 30, 1981, declared 133 Bighas 11 Biswas of land, equal to 3. 77. 24 standard hectares, in the hand of the petitioner as surplus, wrongly coming to the conclusion that the petitioner was a tenant of Shmt. Angoori Devi in respect of land measuring 141 Bighas 4 Biswas. When the case was pending before the Collector, the son of the petitioner became major after completion of 18 years of age. The matter was brought to the notice of the Collector, in writing, on October 1, 1980, and in this manner, the petitioner was entitled to have a separate unit of land for his adult sons. However, the Collector did not allow the same nor did he give credit to the petitioner in respect of sales of 44 Bighas of land. Before reviewing the order P1, the Collector did not obtain prior permission of the Commissioner as required by law. 5. Written Statement was filed by Collector Agrarian Rajpura on behalf of official respondents. It was admitted that the petitioner and his wife Shmt. Reshmii Devi were landowners. However, it was denied that the son of the petitioner was major. As per Jamabandi for the year 1969-70, Jasmer Singh petitioner was shown as owner of 121 Bighas 19 Biswas of land in village Jeoli out of which 8 Bighas of land was Gair Mumkin. In addition, the petitioner also possessed 2 Bighas 4 Biswas of Barani land of Patti Shamlat Didar Singh which included 11 Biswas to Gair Mumkin land and 1 Bigha, 8 Biswas of land of Mandir Shivala Deviwala as Mohtmim. 18 Biswas of land being Gair Mumkin was excluded. In this manner, the petitioner held and possessed 125 Bighas 3 Biswas of Barani land, excluding 1 Bigha of Gair Mumkin land, in village Jeoli. The petitioner and his wife as held land measuring 46 Bighas 6 Biswas and 67 Bighas 14 Biswas respectuicaly in village Tarak out of which 2 Biswas of land was Gair Mumkin and 113 Bighas 18 Biswas of land as Barani. The total land of the petitioner and his wife in the two villages, thus, came to 239 Bighas 1 Biswa of Barani land, equal to 20.15.37 ordinary hectares. By conversion into quality of land, it came to 6-85-24 hectares. 6. It was admitted that the petitioner was in possession of 136 Bighas 15 Biswas of Barani land as tenant of Shmt. Angoori Devi and Mandir Shaivala Deviwala. The petitioner was not paying any rent to Shmt. Angoori Devi or Mandir Shivala Deviwala. The entry with respect to the land of Shmt. Angoori Devi was "Bashara Malkan Bila Malkana". This area comes to 11.52.91 ordinary hectares, and when converted into first quality land it comes to 3.92.00 hectares. The petitioner did not furnish declaration under/Section 5(1) of the Punjab Land Reforms Act intentionally to conceal the land of Shmt. Angoori Devi held by him. It was brought to the notice of the Collector Agrarian Rajpura by Sh. Sahib Singh, Advocate, through an application, that the petitioner cultivated more land that was not considered while passing order dated June 4, 1976. No land with Shmt. Angoori Devi was held to be surplus. The decision in her case will not in way affect the merits of the case of the petitioner. The sales were made by any the petitioner intentionally. The case was remanded by Commissioner Patiala Division to the Collector for a fresh decision. On the appointed day, the petitioner was in possession of surplus land, as discussed above. The fact that the son of the petitioner became major on September 2, 1980, will have no bearing upon the facts of the case, as on the appointed day, the family of the petitioner was in possession of surplus land. Orders passed by the Collector and the Commissioner were valid. 7. The fate of the writ petition depends upon the nature of the possession of the land belonging to Shmt. Angoori Devi held by the petitioner. Admittedly, on the appointed day, the petitioner was holding such land. The question for consideration is as to whether the petitioner holding was such land of Shmt. Angoori Devi as a tenant or as land-owner as defined under the Punjab Land Reforms Act. If it is held that the petitioner was holding the land as land-owner of as tenant, such land belonging to Shmt. Angoori Devi the said land had to be taken into consideration while determining surplus area in the hand of the petitioner. 8. The appointed day as defined under Section 3(1) of the Punjab Land Reformed Act, 1972 is the 24th of January, 1971. Under Section 3 (16) of this Act, the tenant has the meaning assigned to it in the Punjab Tenancy Act, and includes a sub-tenant and self-cultivating lessee but shall not include a present holder as defined in clause (f) of section 2 of the East Punjab Displaced Persons Land Re-settlement Act, 1949. The tenant is defined under the Punjab Tenancy Act as a person who holds the land under another person, and is, or but for special contract would be, liable to pay rent for that land to that other person; but it does not include - (a) an inferior landowner, or (b) a mortgagee of the rights of a landowner, or (c) a person to whom a holding has been transferred or an estate or holding has been let in farm, under the Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887 for the recovery of an arrears of revenue or of a sum recoverable as arrears; or (d) a person who takes from the Government a lease of unoccupied land for the purpose of subletting it. Present-holder as per the aforesaid Act means a person who is in occupation of the land alloted or leased to an allottee or lessee, as the case may be. Since in the revenue record Shmt. Agnoori Devi has been mentioned as the owner, and in the cultivation column, the name of Jasmer Singh, petitioner, is recorded, further entries in the column of lagaan are to be taken into consideration to determine as to whether Jasmer Singh is a tenant of Smt. Angoori Devi or not. It is admitted that the entry under the column of lagaan is as under :- "Bila lagaan Basharah Malkan Bawajah Rishtedari" This entry at the outset indicates that no rent is payable by the petitioner. There is no evidence of any contract between Smt. Angoori Devi and Jasmer Singh, petitioner, regarding payment or non-payment of rent of its adjustment otherwise. In Jagjit Singh v. The Financial Commissioner Haryana 1981 PLJ 367, this Court held that where an entry with respect to payment of rent in the revenue record was blank, it would be taken that no rent was being paid. Payment of rent was necessary to create relationship of landlord and tenant. Learned counsel for the respondent has argued that from the entry of the like nature, it should be persuied that in the absence of any contract the person in occupation of the land would be liable to pay rent to the owner although on account of relationship no rent was being paid and a person in possession of the land on account of relationship would be deemed to be a tenant. I am afraid this contention can not be accepted. As already noticed, the payment of rent is a necessary ingredient to determine the relationship of landlord tenant. The payment of rent can be in kind or in cash, or it can be the subject-matter of a contract to the otherwise. Since in the present case, as already noticed, there is no evidence of contract regarding payment of rent or its adjustment and no rent is mentioned in the revenue records being payable, the petitioner Jasmer Singh could not be held to be a tenant of Smt. Angoori Devi. 9. Section 6 of the Punjab Land Reforms Act defines land-owner' as under :- "land-owner' shall have the meaning assigned to it in Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887 (Punjab Act XVII of 1887); Explanation.- In respect of land mortgaged with possession, the mortgagee shall be deemed to be the landowner". Section 3 (2) of the Punjab Land Revenue Act defines land-owner as under:- "land owner' does not include a tenant or an assignee of land revenue, but does include a person to whom a holding has been transferred, or an estate or holding has been let in farm under this Act for the recovery of an arrear and every other person not herein before in this clause mentioned who is in possession of an estate or any share or portion thereof, or in the enjoyment of any part of the profits of an estate". At the outset it may be stated that owner of the land would be a land-owner. However, a land-owner as defined may not be owner of the land. Further, a tenant or an assignee of a land revenue will not be a land-owner. However, transferee of the holding or an estate or a person who is let in or a person to whom holding has been let in the form of the recovery of arrears would be land-owner. Further more, every other person not hereinbefore mentioned in this clause who is in possession of an estate or in enjoyment of part of the profits of an estate would be land-owner. It is admitted case of the petitioner that he is in possession of the land of Smt. Angoori Devi and that litigation is pending in civil court. The claim of the petitioner on the basis of a will of Jai Singh, original owner, stands negatived by the civil court and now the matter is stated to be pending in the High Court in appeal. If the appeal is decided in favour of the petitioner he would be owner of the land and, thus, a land-owner. That being the position, this piece of land could be included for determination of the surplus area as belonging to the petitioner. Even if he fails in the civil suit, his case is covered in the definition of land-owner as reproduced above. He is in possession of the land and enjoying its profits. The authorities were, thus, justified, though on different grounds, in including this piece of land in the area of the petitioner for determination of the surplus area in his hand. 10. It has been argued on behalf of the petitioner that the impugned order passed by the Collector declaring the petitioner to be a small land-owner without obtaining permission of the Commissioner is illegal and without jurisdiction. This contention again can not be accepted. Section 8 of the Punjab Land Reforms Act provides as under :- "The provision in regard to appeal, review and revision under this Act shall, so far as may be, the same as provided in section 80, 81, 82, 83 and 84 of the Punjab, Tenancy Act, 1887 (Act XVI of 1887)". Section 82 (1) of the Punjab Tenancy Act reads as under :- "A Revenue Officer, as such, may either of his own motion or on the application of any party interested, review, and on so reviewing modify, revise or confirm any order passed by himself or by any of his predecessors in officer : Provided as follows :- (a) When a Commissioner or Collector thinks it necessary to review any order which he has not himself passed, and when a Revenue Officer of a class below that of Collector proposes to review any order whether passed by himself or by any of his predecessors in office he shall first obtain the sanction of the Revenue Officer to whose control he is immediately subject". No doubt, as provided by section 82 of the Punjab Tenancy Act, if the reviewing officer is other than the one who had passed the original order he is to obtain permission of the Commissioner or the Financial Commissioner as the case may be, before reviewing the order. In the case of Collector, prior sanction of the Commissioner is necessary for reviewing the order of the previous Collector. In the present case, as the narration of facts would indicate, the order of review passed by the Collector was challenged in appeal and the Commissioner accepted the appeal and sent the case back to the Collector for fresh decision after hearing the petitioner and others. This order could be treated as prior sanction of the Commissioner to the Collector to review the previous order of the Collector. This order of the Commissioner was not challenged before the Financial Commissioner. It is too late in the writ petition to urge that the order of the Collector is without jurisdiction for want of sanction from the Commissioner. 11. It has been argued on behalf of the petitioner that a fresh opportunity should have been allowed to the petitioner to select his permissible area after the Collector came to the conclusion that the land belonging to Smt. Angoori Devi was to be taken into consideration. This contention can not be accepted for the simple reason that an opportunity was given to the petitioner to select his permissible area and this opportunity was availed of by the petitioner, as is clear from the order of the Collector Agrarian Rajpura, Annexure P 2. 12. It has further been argued on behalf of the petitioner that after declaration of the petitioner being a small land-owner initially by the Collector; he bona fide sold the land measuring 44 Bighas to Gurbax Singh and others and the land covered by the sale deeds which were bona fide made ought not to have been taken into consideration while determining permissible area of the petitioner. This contention again can not be accepted. The land of smt. Angoori Devi was in possession of the petitioner which fact was not disclosed by him when originally he was declared a small land-owner. That being the position, subsequent sales made by him could not be ignored. For the reasons recorded above, finding no merit in the writ petition, the same is dismissed. However, there will be no order as to costs. petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jasmer Singh Bhatti v. State Of Punjab
    (Feb 17, 1989)