Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Section 73 read with Section 76 of U.P Reorganisation Act, 2000.
  • Section 73(2) of the U. P Reorganisation Act, 2000,
  • Section 76 of the U.P Reorganisation Act, 2000.
  • Section 73(2), the Central Government
  • provisions of Section 73 (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Section 73 read with Section 76 of U.P Reorganisation Act, 2000.
  • Section 73(2) of the U. P Reorganisation Act, 2000,
  • Section 76 of the U.P Reorganisation Act, 2000.
  • Section 73(2), the Central Government
  • provisions of Section 73 (2)

    Udai Pratap Singh v. State Of U.P. And Ors.

    S. H. Kapadia, C. J. :-

    The peti­tioner was selected by U.P Public Serv­ice Commission, Allahabad on 16th No­vember 1998 to the post of Bal Vikas Pariyojana Adhikari. He was posted in district Uttarkashi and thereafter in dis­trict Rudra Prayag. He is Class-II officer. He was appointed in the Hill Cadre of the State of U.P This was before 9th November 2000, when the State of U.P was divided and State of Uttaranchal came into existence.

    2. The question whether the services of the petitioner should be allocated to the State of U.P. or to the State of Uttaranchal was not finalised upto 11th September 2001. Petitioner opted for the State of U.P He made several represen­tations. He also made representations to the Advisory Board under Section 76 of the U.P Reorganisation Act, 2000.

    3. We may point out that there are number of petitions pending in this Court of this nature. The State of U.P has a limited capacity to absorb the em­ployees who have opted for that State. However, in any event, the final alloca­tion of the employees between the two States has to be done by the Central, Government under Section 73(2).

    4. By impugned Order dated 11th September 2001, the Government of In­dia has finally allocated the cadre of the petitioner to the State of Uttaranchal. This is the Order under challenge, as vio­lation of Article 14 and 16 of Constitu­tion of India.

    5. The only argument, however, ad­vanced on behalf of the petitioner be­fore us, is that before passing the order dated 11th September 2001, the Cen­tral Government should have invited all concerned teachers, including the peti­tioner, to make representations. It was argued that pending the petitioner's rep­resentations to the Advisory Committee, the impugned guidelines have been is­sued by the Central Government and, therefore, the impugned guidelines have been violated under Section 73 read with Section 76 of U.P Reorganisation Act, 2000. It was argued that Section 73 of the Act does not empower the Central Government to issue guidelines unilaterally without giving opportunity to the concerned teachers, including the pe­titioner.

    6. We do not find any merit in this argument. Under Section 73(1), every person serving in connection with the af­fairs of State of U.P before 09.11.2000 shall provisionally continue to serve the State of U.P unless he is required by Central Government to serve provision­ally the State of Uttaranchal. Under Section 73(2), the Central Government is given the power to allocate the cad­res by general or special order of allot­ment between the two States. Section 76 provides for setting up of an Advi­sory Committee to assist the Central Government. By the impugned order dated 11th September 2001, the Cen­tral Government has issued directions allocating the various cadres between the two States. The Central Government has issued these directions pursuant to the authority given by the Legislature to the Central Government. As stated above, the only point argued before us by the learned Advocate for the peti­tioner is that the Central Government has not given a hearing to the petitioner. That pending his representation to the Advisory Committee, the impugned di­rection has been issued by the Central Government. We do not find any merit in this argument. The Central Govern­ment had constituted an Advisory Com­mittee under Section 76. That Commit­tee submitted its report on 28th April 2001 / 10th May 2001 (See annexure­3). Their report has been accepted by the Central Government as indicated by letter dated 4th September 2001 (annexure-4). We may clarify that the report of the Advisory Committee has not been fully accepted by the Central Government. On one point namely, in­terstate deputation, the report of the Committee has not been accepted. However, on all other points, they have been accepted. The hill cadres have been allotted to the State of Uttaranchal un­der the recommendation of the Advisory Committee. That recommendation has been accepted by the Central Govern­ment. The Advisory Committee has rec­ommended its suggestions after taking into account representations of various organisations as well as individuals. In the circumstances there is no violation of Rules of natural justice, as alleged.

    7. Hence, the writ petition is rejected. 8. Office is directed to list all mat­ters concerning allocation of cadres made by the Central Government under Section 73(2) of the U. P Reorganisa­tion Act, 2000, before Division Bench of this Court including those which are pending before the learned Single Judge of this Court. There are several writ pe­titions pending, on this point, before this Court. These matters pertain to the di­rections given by the Central Govern­ment under Section 73(2); they cannot be classified, as per the post, by the office, Judge-wise. They all pertain to Division Bench, as the provisions of Sec­tion 73 (2) are required to be inter­preted. Accordingly, office is directed to prepare a list of all such matters pend­ing in this Court, both before Division Bench and learned Single Judge and they should be placed for directions on any Monday after list is prepared. That list should be placed on the notice-board one week in advance.

    ……………..

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Udai Pratap Singh v. State Of U.P. And Ors.
    (Sep 9, 2003)