AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 143 of the Rajasthan Co-operative Societies Act. (Section 143 of Rajasthan Co-operative Societies Act
  • Section 13(1)(a) and Section 13(1)(b) of Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947
  • provisions of Section 91 or 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.
  • SECTION 28 BOMBAY RENTS HOTEL AND LODGING HOUSE RATES CONTROL ACT 1947
  • Section 164 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act 1960,
  • Section 91 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.
  • Section 91 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act
  • Section 91(3) of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act.
  • Section 164 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act)
  • Rent Act and the Co-operative Societies Act
  • provisions of Section 28 of the Rent Act.
  • provisions of Section 91 and Section 164
  • ORDER 14 RULE 2 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Section 28 of the Bombay Rent Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 143 of the Rajasthan Co-operative Societies Act. (Section 143 of Rajasthan Co-operative Societies Act
  • Section 13(1)(a) and Section 13(1)(b) of Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947
  • provisions of Section 91 or 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.
  • SECTION 28 BOMBAY RENTS HOTEL AND LODGING HOUSE RATES CONTROL ACT 1947
  • Section 164 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act 1960,
  • Section 91 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.
  • Section 91 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act
  • Section 91(3) of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act.
  • Section 164 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act)
  • Rent Act and the Co-operative Societies Act
  • provisions of Section 28 of the Rent Act.
  • provisions of Section 91 and Section 164
  • ORDER 14 RULE 2 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Section 28 of the Bombay Rent Act,

    Samarth Co-Op.Consumers Central Stores Ltd v. Yeshwant Kashinath Chipkar

    Cases referred :

    AIR 1969 SC 1320 [ 2 , 4 , 5 ]

    AIR 1972 SC 1983 [ 2 ]

    1975 Mah L.J. 39 [ 2 ]

    1986 C.T.J. 210 [ 5 ]

    AIR 1970 SC 245 [ 5 ]

    AIR 1979 Sc 1203 [ 5 ]

    AIR 1981 Raj 41 [ 5 ]

    : Heard both the sides at length.

    The Respondent is owner/landlord of the suit premises who has filed a suit against the Petitioner under Section 13(1)(a) and Section 13(1)(b) of Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 claiming possession and permanent injunction restraining the Petitioner from carrying out further permanent construction in the premises.

    2. 2 points were raised as preliminary under Order 14 Rule 2 of Civil Procedure Code. They were whether in view of Section 164 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act 1960, as no notice was given the suit was maintainable and second whether the Civil Court has jurisdiction to decide the matter in view of Section 91 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. The learned 2nd Joint Civil Judge, J.D., Thane held that notice under Section164 is not a sine qua non for filing the suit. It is not necessary in the present case as the suit falls under S.28 of Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947. Therefore in the absence thereof it cannot be said that suit was not maintainable. The learned Judge also took a view, relying upon the two judgments of the apex Court viz. i) AIR 1969 SC 1320 and ii) AIR 1972 SC 1983 and one judgment of this court reported in 1975 Mah.L.J. 39 Note 81, that the suit does not touch the business of the Society and hence it is not covered by Section 91(3) of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act. The said JUDGMENT and order dated 21-2-1994 is under challenge in this petition.

    3. The learned Advocate for the Petitioner pointed out the objects which are mentioned in its constitution at Sr. No.vi, xi and para v of Powers and Functions of the Board of Directors. They are as follows :-

    vi) To provide for such servicing facilities to customers as may be considered necessary.

    xi) To own lands, buildings, machinery, fixtures and vehicles or take them on lease of rent for the business of the society.

    v) To construct, purchase, take on hire or otherwise acquire godown, trucks, equipment or other structures considered necessary for carrying out the business of the Society and for providing necessary facilities to its members.

    4. It is not possible to accept from this that suit was touching the business of the society. Admittedly, Petitioner Society was constituted as Consumer Co-operative Society and sells various articles in its stores. It is not carrying on business of taking the premises and letting out the same to other persons. Admittedly this premises are not taken by the Petitioner for the purpose of letting out. The apex Court in AIR 1969 SC 1320 Deccan Merchants Co-Op. Bank Ltd. Vs. M/s. Dalichand Jugraj Jain and Ors. has taken the view that :

    18. The question arises whether the dispute touching the assets of a society would be dispute touching the business of a society. This would depend on the nature of the society and the rules and bye-laws governing it. Ordinarily, if a society owns buildings and lets out parts of buildings which it does not require for its own purpose it cannot be said that letting out of those parts is a part of the business of the society. But it may be that it is the business of a society to construct and buy houses and let them out to its members. In that case letting out property may be part of its business. In this case, the society is a co-operative bank and ordinarily a co-operative bank cannot be said to be engaged in business when it lets out properties owned by it. Therefore, it seems to us that the present dispute between a tenant and a member of the bank in a building which has subsequently been acquired by the Bank cannot be said to be a dispute touching the business of the Bank, and the appeal should fail on this short ground.

    23. One other limitation on the word dispute may also be placed and that is that the word dispute covers only those disputes which are capable of being resolved by the Registrar or his nominee. It seems to us very doubtful that the word dispute would include a dispute between a landlord society and a tenant when the landlord society has not been set up for the purpose of constructing or buying and letting out houses. In the presence of various Rent Acts which give special privileges to tenants it would be difficult to say that such disputes were intended to be referred to the Registrar. Of course, this result may also follow from the interpretation of the Rent Act and the Co-operative Societies Act by applying other principles of construction.

    36. If the matter is heard by the Registrar, none of these provisions would apply. We can hardly imagine that it was the intention on the legislature to deprive tenants in buildings owned by co-operative societies of the benefits given by the Rent Act. It seems to us that the Act was passed in the main, to shorten litigation, lessen, its costs and to provide a summary procedure for the determination of the disputes relating to the internal management of the societies. But under the Rent Act a different social objective is intended to be achieved and for achieving that social objective it is necessary that a dispute between the landlord and the tenant should be dealt with by the Courts set up under the Rent Act and in accordance with the Special provisions of the Rent Act. The social objective does not impinge on the objective underlying the Act. It seems to us that the two Acts can be harmonised best by holding that in matters covered by the Rent Act, its provisions, rather than the provisions of the Act, should apply. In view of these considerations we are of the opinion that Section 91 of the Act does not affect the provisions of Section 28 of the Rent Act.

    5. Similar point also arose before this Court in the judgment reported in 1986 C.T.J. 210 Prithiviraj Pannalal Sachadeva Vs. The Dhulia Motor Owners Co-Op. Consumers stores Ltd. and Ors. and this Court held relying on the apex Courts judgment and the judgment of the Rajasthan High Court reported in AIR 1981 Raj. 41 (Shyamlal Vs. Upbhokta Sahakari Samiti) that provisions of Section 91 and Section 164 are not attracted. It was observed that the decisions of the apex Court reported n 1969 SC 1320, AIR 1970 SC 245 and AIR 1979 SC 1203 came to be considered by the Rajasthan High Court in AIR 1981 Rajasthan 41. In the said case a Co-operative Society was a tenant in respect of shop. It was alleged by the landlord that the rent had not been paid and a notice was given to the Society requiring it to vacate and deliver possession of the shop to the landlord on the ground of non-payment of rent for the period specified by the appropriate legislation. A suit for arrears of rent and ejectment was thereafter filed and in Second Appeal a Single Judge of the Rajasthan High Court was required to consider the question whether the suit was liable to be dismissed on the ground of want of notice as required under Section 143 of the Rajasthan Co-operative Societies Act. (Section 143 of Rajasthan Co-operative Societies Act is in pari materia with Section 164 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act) The question arose whether it touches the business of the Society. It was held by the learned Judge that failure to pay rent or failure to comply with ejectment notice and consequential cause of action in the suit cannot be regarded as arising from the acts touching this business of the Society and therefore Section 143 was not attracted. In the present case also it cannot be said that suit is covered by the provisions of Section 91 or 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. First it is not the object of the Petitioner to take the premises and lease out to third parties. The suit premises are taken on lease for its own purpose in this case. The suit therefore squarely falls under Section 28 of the Bombay Rent Act, a special statute for recovery of possession and arrears of rent from a tenant by landlord. Such a suit cannot fall within the ambit of Section 91 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act and cannot attract Section 164 thereof. The view taken by the Court below is therefore right and requires no interference.

    The Petition is summarily rejected.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Samarth Co-Op.Consumers Central Stores Ltd v. Yeshwant Kashinath Chipkar
    (Sep 18, 1995)