Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 17(1) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act.
  • SECTION 17 PROVINCIAL SMALL CAUSE COURTS ACT
  • Section 17(1) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act.
  • Order XXI Rule 26 read with Section 151 C.P.C
  • Section 20(4) of U.P Act, No. 13 of 1972
  • Section 30 of U.P Act No. 13 of 1972
  • provisions of Act No. 13 of 1972
  • Order IX, Rule 13 C.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 17(1) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act.
  • SECTION 17 PROVINCIAL SMALL CAUSE COURTS ACT
  • Section 17(1) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act.
  • Order XXI Rule 26 read with Section 151 C.P.C
  • Section 20(4) of U.P Act, No. 13 of 1972
  • Section 30 of U.P Act No. 13 of 1972
  • provisions of Act No. 13 of 1972
  • Order IX, Rule 13 C.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the tenant of House No. B 1/3, Mahanagar Extension, Kursi Road, Lucknow, who occupied the premises from about 1976. In 1984 the opposite party No. 1 (the plaintiff) filed a suit for ejectment, recovery of arrears of rent and damages. An ex parte decree was passed on 22 April 1985 awarding ejectment, arrears of rent of Rs. 3,570, damages of Rs. 850 and pendente lite and future damages at Rs. 1,700 per month (subject to payment of requisite court-fee). The decree included costs and the petitioner was given one month to vacate.

The petitioner sought two forms of relief: (a) to set aside the ex parte decree under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C., and (b) a stay of execution under Order XXI Rule 26 read with Section 151 C.P.C. The application for setting aside the ex parte decree was rejected by opposite party No. 2 by an order dated 15 March 1986. The present writ petition challenges that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner was required, as a precondition to entertaining his application under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C., to deposit the amount decreed for pendente lite and future damages (mesne profits) in compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act.
  2. Whether the deposit of Rs. 6,900 made pursuant to an execution-court order dated 12.10.1985 and other deposits (including amounts under Section 30 of U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972) sufficed to comply with Section 17 and thus rendered the setting-aside application maintainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The decree for pendente lite and future damages was passed "subject to payment of requisite court-fee" and therefore that part of the decree would not come into being unless additional court-fee was paid; hence the petitioner need not deposit that amount when applying to set aside the ex parte decree.
  • The petitioner had deposited rent under Section 30 of U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972 in Misc. Case No. 33 of 1984, which the petitioner argued was not taken into account by the lower court.
  • The petitioner had deposited Rs. 6,900 pursuant to an order dated 12.10.1985 passed in the execution proceedings (Execution Case No. 4 of 1985), and that deposit should be treated as compliance with the deposit requirement under Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act.
  • The petitioner relied on certain authorities (identified in the opinion) said to support his contention that technicalities or particular circumstances might relieve him of the deposit requirement.

Opposite Party No. 1's Arguments

  • The petitioner was required to comply with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act by depositing the amount of pendente lite and mesne profits before his application under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C. could be entertained, even though the decree-holder had not paid court-fee on that amount.
  • The fact that the decree-holder had not paid court-fee did not eliminate or extinguish the decretal liability; the amount remained due under the decree and therefore the judgment-debtor had to make the deposit.
  • The deposit of Rs. 6,900 ordered in execution proceedings did not constitute compliance with Section 17 because that deposit was insufficient to satisfy the decretal amount required by that section.
  • Deposits said to have been made under Section 30 of U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972 could not be taken into account for periods when that Act was not applicable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhagwan Das Arora v. Ist Additional District Judge, Rampur (1983 9 A.L.R 540 S.C.) Addressed technicality regarding stamp on a security bond; idea that appellant should not suffer for a stamping technicality. The court found this case inapplicable to the present matter because the present dispute was not one of technicality regarding stamping.
Kararri Chand Mohan Singh v. Basheshwar Nath Provisions of Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act should be liberally applied (security furnishing context). The court noted it was not helpful because the present question concerned liability to deposit mesne profits, not a mere technicality of security furnishing.
Ram Saran Das Tarachand v. Ram Richhpal L. Mannu Lal (A.I.R 1963 Punj. 206) Court should examine whether there was substantial compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act. The court held this precedent unhelpful because in the present case the discrepancy in amount was substantial and could not be treated as substantial compliance.
Ram Bharose v. Ganga Singh Relevant to compliance with Section 17 (Full Bench matter). Held not applicable to the present case as the point before the Full Bench was not the same as in the present dispute.
Kallu Mal v. Ch. Bikramajit Singh (A.I.R 1933 Alld. 13) and A.I.R 1925 Allahabad p.412 Considered meaning of "amount due under the decree" as of the date of decree; treatment of ex parte decree set aside. The court observed these authorities were not supportive of the petitioner's position and noted the petitioner could not rely on them to avoid depositing mesne profits.
Nakse Ram v. Second Additional District Judge, Aligarh (1982 1 A.R.C 257) Payment of court-fee does not affect the decree for mesne profits; mesne profits are deemed to be amount under decree whether court-fee paid or not. The court relied on this authority to support the view that decretal liability exists irrespective of payment of court-fee and thus the judgment-debtor must deposit the amount under Section 17.
Smt. Gayatri Devi v. District Judge, Gorakhpur Judgment debtor must deposit pendente lite and mesne profits notwithstanding that court-fee on those amounts was not paid by the decree-holder; decree-holder pays court-fee only if seeking execution. The court cited this case as supporting the proposition that absence of court-fee payment by the decree-holder does not absolve the judgment-debtor's deposit obligation under Section 17.
P.C. Dwada-shahreni & Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. Third Additional District Judge, Aligarh (1982 2 A.R.C 176) Mesne profits decreed constitute an amount due against the judgment-debtor even if court-fee not paid; such amount must be deposited under Section 17. The court relied on this case in support of the rule that mesne profits are payable and depositable despite non-payment of additional court-fee by the decree-holder.
Roop Basant v. Durga Prasad (1983 1 A.R.C 565) Affirmed that judgment-debtor is liable to deposit mesne profits decreed even where no court-fee was paid on that amount. The court cited and followed this view as consistent authority for the depositor's obligation under Section 17.
Ravi Shanker v. V. Additional District Judge, Aligarh (1982 2 A.R.C 109) Supported view that decretal mesne profits are payable even without court-fee; distinguished A.I.R 1925 Allahabad. The court cited this decision as another authority aligning with the position that non-payment of court-fee does not wipe out liability to deposit mesne profits.
Mijan v. Second Additional District Judge, Lucknow (1986 2 A.R.C 316) While applying to set aside a decree under Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, judgment-debtor must deposit mesne profits decreed. The court cited this case as directly analogous and supportive of the requirement to deposit mesne profits when seeking to set aside an ex parte decree.
Khadi Gram Udyog Trust v. Shri Ram Chandraji Virajman Mandir (1978 4 A.L.R 37 S.C.) Interpreted Section 20(4) of U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972 to require deposit of the entire amount which included rent even if time-barred. The court invoked this decision by analogy to reinforce the principle that decretal obligations may encompass broad components and must be deposited where statutory provisions so require.
Badi Vzzaman v. District Judge, Kanpur (1987 1 A.R.C 74) Held that deposits made under Section 30 of U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972 cannot be reckoned for periods during which that Act was not applicable. The court relied on this case to support the conclusion that the petitioner's Section 30 deposits could not be taken into account for compliance with Section 17 where the Act was not applicable for the relevant period.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed the short point of consideration as whether the petitioner was required to deposit the amount decreed for pendente lite and future damages (mesne profits) — which had been awarded subject to payment of court-fee — in compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act before his application under Order IX Rule 13 could be entertained.

The court first accepted as undisputed that the petitioner had not deposited the pendente lite and future damages decreed in favour of the plaintiff. The petitioner contended that because the award of pendente lite and future damages was made "subject to payment of requisite court-fee," that part of the decree would not be enforceable or come into being unless the additional court-fee was paid by the decree-holder, and hence no deposit was required from the petitioner. The petitioner also relied on other deposits he had made (Rs. 6,900 pursuant to an execution-court order and amounts under Section 30 of U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972).

The court examined authorities cited by both sides. It rejected the petitioner's reliance on decisions which were limited to technical or stamp-related issues or which did not address the present factual matrix (e.g., Bhagwan Das Arora; Kararri Chand Mohan Singh; Ram Saran Das Tarachand; Ram Bharose; Kallu Mal). The court then considered a number of consistent decisions relied upon by opposite party No. 1 which establish that mesne profits decreed are nevertheless an amount due against the judgment-debtor and must be deposited in compliance with Section 17 even if the decree-holder has not paid the additional court-fee on that component (cases including Nakse Ram; Smt. Gayatri Devi; P.C. Dwada-shahreni; Roop Basant; Ravi Shanker; Mijan). The court treated these authorities as establishing a clear legal position that the judgment-debtor must deposit mesne profits despite non-payment of court-fee by the decree-holder.

Regarding the deposit of Rs. 6,900 ordered on 12.10.1985 in execution proceedings, the court observed that this deposit was made in a different proceeding (Execution Case No. 4 of 1985) pursuant to a stay order and was not, by itself, compliance with Section 17(1) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act. While that deposit could be adjusted against the amount required under Section 17, if it fell short it could not be treated as satisfying the statutory requirement. The court further considered the petitioner's contention that certain deposits made under Section 30 of U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972 should be taken into account; it accepted the lower court's observation (and authority relied upon by opposite party No. 1) that deposits under Section 30 could not be counted for periods when that Act was not applicable. The court noted the quantitative shortfall: the court below estimated the amount required under Section 17 to be Rs. 28,862.75 and, even accepting all petitioner deposits, the petitioner had deposited only Rs. 18,900 — a shortfall of about Rs. 10,000.

On this basis, applying the statutory requirement of Section 17 and the precedents it had cited, the court concluded that the petitioner had not complied with the mandatory deposit condition and therefore his application under Order IX Rule 13 could properly be rejected.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed with costs. The court held that the petitioner was required to deposit the amount of pendente lite mesne profits in compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act notwithstanding that the decree-holder had not paid court-fee on that amount; the deposits made by the petitioner (including Rs. 6,900 under an execution order and deposits under Section 30 of U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972) did not satisfy Section 17 because they were insufficient and, in part, not applicable for the relevant period.

Implications: The direct consequence is that the petitioner's application to set aside the ex parte decree was correctly rejected for non-compliance with Section 17, and the writ petition seeking to upset that rejection is dismissed with costs. The opinion does not state that it establishes any new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities; it confines itself to applying the relevant statutory requirement and earlier decisions to the facts and quantitative shortfall in deposit.

    Krishna Chandra Seth v. (Dr.) K.P Agarwal And Another

    Brijesh Kumar, J.:— This writ petition has been preferred by the tenant of House No. B 1/3, Mahanagar Extension, Kursi Road, Lucknow, it appears that the petitioner had occupied the premises sometime in 1976. The opposite party no. 1 filed a suit in the year 1984 against the petitioner for ejectment, recovery of arrears rent and damages. The suit was decreed ex parte on 22 April, 1985 awarding a decree against the petitioner for ejectment, recovery of arrears of rent amounting to Rs. 3,570/- and damages for Rs. 850/, along with the pendents lite and future damages at the rate of Rs. 1,700/- per month subject to payment of requisite court-fee. The suit was decreed with costs. The petitioner was given one month's time to vacate the premises. The petitioner on coming to know of the ex parte decree moved two applications one under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C and the other, under Order XXI Rule 26 read with Section 151 C.P.C The application for setting aside ex parte decree was rejected by opposite party No. 2. The petitioner has impugned the said order dated 15 March, 1986 passed by opposite party No. 2.

    2. The point for consideration in this petition is short. The opposite party No. 2 has rejected the application on the ground that the provision of Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act have not been complied with which is a mandatory condition.

    3. There is no dispute about the fact that the petitioner while applying for setting aside ex parte decree did not make deposit of pendente lite and future damages for use and occupation, decreed in favour of plaintiff. On behalf of the petitioner, it has been submitted that the decree for pendente lite and future damages for use and occupation was passed subject to payment of requisite court-fee. Therefore, the petitioner was not required to deposit that amount in compliance with the provisions of Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, as undisputedly no court-fee on the said amount of pendente lite and future damages had been paid by opposite party No. 2. Besides the above contention, it has also been submitted that the petitioner has deposited rent under Section 30 of U.P Act No. 13 of 1972 in Misc. Case No. 33 of 1984 in the court of Munsif South, Lucknow. This amount, according to the petitioner, was not taken into account by opposite party No. 2 while passing the order. Yet another submission made is that the petitioner had deposited the amount which he was directed to deposit by the court on the application moved for stay of execution proceedings under Order XXI Rule 26 read with Section 151 CPC. This, according to him, amounts to sufficient compliance of the orders of the court. A copy of the order passed by the execution court dated 12.10.1985 has been filed as Annexure S-1 along with the supplementary affidavit which the petitioner was permitted to file on 19.11.1987, although the arguments were heard and the judgment was reserved earlier. This permission was granted only in the interest of justice. A reply to the supplementary affidavit was also filed on November 20, 1987 which was ordered to be placed on record. The order dated 12.10.1985 passed by execution court reads as under:—

    “Amin C.C Lucknow—

    The execution of delivery of possession is stayed till 14.10.1985 subject to deposit of Rs. 6,900/- to Amin or D.H in Ex. case No. 4/85 pending in the court of IV ADJ, Lucknow.

    Sd/- Ashok Kumar

    IV ADJ 12-10-85

    1.50 PM”

    4. From a perusal of the above order, it is clear that it was passed in Execution Case No. 4 of 1985.

    5. Let us take up the first point, namely, as to whether the petitioner was required to deposit the amount decreed for pendente lite and future damages for use and occupation subject to payment of court-fee which has, admittedly, not been paid. Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the decree for pendente lite and future damages would not come into being unless the additional court-fee was paid; therefore, that part of the decree was not executable as a consequence whereof he was not required to deposit the amount which could not be realised in execution of the decree. In support of this contention he has, placed reliance upon some cases. He has cited Bhagwan Das Arora v. Ist Additional District, Judge, Rampur . 1983 9 A.L.R 540 S.C.. In that case, the matter related to furnishing of security bond in place of decretal amount. The appellant had furnished the security bond stamped with a court-fee stamp of Rs. 20/- instead of on a general stamp. The view taken was that the appellant should not suffer for this technicality. This case is, therefore, not applicable to the present case. In Kararri Chand Mohan Singh v. Basheshwar Nath,2, it was held that the provisions of Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act should be liberally applied. That was also a case regarding furnishing of security. In the present case, the question of technicality is not involved but the question is whether the petitioner was liable to deposit the amount on account of pendente lite and future damages for use and occupation of the building. Therefore, this case is also of no help to the petitioner. The next case is Ram Saran Das Tarachand v. Ram Richhpal L. Mannu Lal . A.I.R 1963 Punj. 206.. It is also of no help to the petitioner as in that case it has been held that the court should see if the substantial compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts ‘Act has been made or not. In the present case we find that the difference of amount is substantial. Therefore, it cannot be said that the requirement of Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act has been substantially complied with Ram Bharose v. Ganga Singh,4 is not applicable to the facts of the present case as the question involved in the present case was not considered by the Full Bench. Reliance has also been placed upon a case reported in Kallu Mal v. Ch. Bikramajit Singh . A.I.R 1933 Alld. 13.. In this case reliance was also placed upon a case reported in AIR 1925 Allahabad, p. 412 to hold that amount due under the decree would mean the amount which was due under the ‘decree at the date it was given. The ex parte decree was set aside in that case and their lordships observed that it was not a case for interference. Otherwise also in the present case, even the pendente lite damages have not admittedly been paid. Learned counsel for the petitioner has not been able to cite any case holding that mesne profits decreed need not be deposited while applying for setting aside the ex parte decree unless the court fee on the amount of mesne profits has been paid by the plaintiff.

    6. In reply to the above submission, it has been contended on behalf of opposite party No. 1 that it may be different if the decree-holder may like to execute a decree and then he may be required to deposit additional court fee before execution, but where a decree has been passed and the judgment debtor wants the same to be set aside, he has to make all the deposits in compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act before his application under Order IX, Rule 13 C.P.C may be entertained. It has been submitted that in case of non-deposit of additional court-fee, the amount may not be realisable in execution of the decree nonetheless liability of payment of such amount is definitely created. Thus in terms of Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act he must deposit such amount as well. In support of his contention he has placed reliance upon a case reported in Nakse Ram v. Second Additional District Judge, Aligarh . 1982 1 A.R.C 257.. The learned Single Judge while agreeing with an earlier decision of this Court observed that the payment of court-fee did not affect the decree which was for the mesne profits as well. The amount would be deemed under the decree whether court fee was paid or not. The argument advanced in that case that the amount decreed from mesne profits would not be payable in absence of payment of court-fee was repelled. In the other case Smt. Gayatri Devi v. District Judge, Gorakhpur,7 it was held that for compliance of Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, the judgment debtor had to deposit the amount of pendente lite and mesne profits notwithstanding the fact that the court-fee on the said amount was not paid by the decree-holder. It was further observed that it was only necessary for the decree-holder to pay the court-fee if he had applied for execution of the decree. The other case relied upon is reported in P.C Dwada-shahreni and Company Pvt. Ltd. v. Third Additional District Judge, Aligarh . 1982 2 A.R.C 176.. It was held in this case that even though the court-fee may not be paid for the mesne profits-which has been decreed but it is still an amount due against the judgment debtor and the same has to be deposited in compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act. This Court in another case has also taken the same view as mentioned above, namely, in a case reported in Roop Basant v. Durga Prasad . 1983 1 A.R.C 565.. It was held that, the judgment debtor was liable to deposit the mesne profits decreed even though no court-fee was paid on the said amount as non-deposit of court-fee does not wipe out the liability of tenant. A reference has also been made to a case reported in Ravi Shanker v. V. Additional District Judge, Aligarh . 1982 2 A.R.C 109. in which the same view as was taken in the cases mentioned above, was taken. In this case A.I.R 1925 Allahabad Page 412 relied upon on behalf of the petitioner has been distinguished. Yet another case relied upon is reported in Mijan v. Second Additional District Judge, Lucknow . 1986 2 A.R.C 316. In this case also it was held that while applying for setting aside a decree under Section 17 of the Provincial. Small Cause Courts Act, the judgment debtor was liable to deposit the mesne profits which had been decreed. For the purposes of drawing an analogy, the learned counsel for opposite party No. 1 has also placed reliance upon a case reported in Khadi Gram Udyog Trust v. Shri Ram Chandraji Virajman Mandir . 1978 4 A.L.R 37 S.C.. In this case, it was held that as required under. Section 20(4) of U.P Act, No. 13 of 1972 the entire amount-was to be deposited which was held to include rent which had become time-barred.

    7. In view of a number of decisions mentioned above, the legal position is very clear and no doubt can be entertained about the same. “The petitioner was thus required to deposit the amount of pendente lite mesne profits despite the fact that no court-fee was paid by opposite party No. 1.

    8. It was then contended on behalf of the petitioner that he had made a deposit of Rs. 6,900 as ordered by court on 12-10-1985. Therefore, he was not required to deposit any other amount and it should be taken as sufficient compliance with the provisions of Section 17(1) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act. This argument though appears at the first look fascinating but it need not detain us long. The petitioner had moved two separate applications; one under Order IX Rule 13, C.P.C for setting aside ex parte decree and the other for stay of the execution proceedings which appear to have been initiated by opposite party No. 1. The order dated 12-10-1985 was passed in Execution Case No. 4 of 1985 by which the delivery of possession was stayed till a particular date subject to deposit of Rs. 6,900 by the petitioner. This amount which was deposited, was not in compliance with Section 17(1) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act. It could no doubt be very well adjusted against the amount liable to be deposited in compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act but by no means this amount if falls short, can be held to be in compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act. The liability is cast upon the judgment debtor under Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act to make deposit of the amount as provided under the said section and requires no order by the court for making such a deposit. Admittedly the amount deposited by the petitioner in pursuance of the order passed by the court in execution proceedings, did not fully satisfy the entire decretal amount. Therefore, the deposit made by the petitioner cannot be taken to satisfy the condition imposed under Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act.

    9. It has then been submitted that the petitioner had deposited amount of rent under Section 30 of the Act No. 13 of 1972 for a period from July, 1984 to October, 1985. It was deposited in case No. 33 of 1984 pending in the court of Munsif, South, Lucknow. These averments are made in paras 6 and 7 of the application under Order IX, Rule 13 C.P.C a true copy of which has been filed as Annexure-6 to the writ petition-It has been submitted that this deposit has not been taken into account while holding that the amount deposited by the petitioner was short of decretal amount. In this connection I may observe that the learned court below has rightly observed that the Act No. 13 of 1972 did not apply when the deposits were made; therefore, it could not be taken into account. As observed in the order by the court below, there was no dispute about the fact that the house was constructed in April, 1976 and according to own admission of the petitioner, he had deposited the amount under Section 30 of U.P Act No. 13 of 1972 for the period from July, 1984 to October, 1985. In this connection, the learned counsel for opposite party No. 1 has placed reliance upon a case reported in Badi Vzzaman v. District Judge, Kanpur . 1987 1 A.R.C 74. wherein it has been held that the amount deposited under Section 30 of U.P Act No. 13 of 1972 cannot be taken into account for the period during which the provisions of Act No. 13 of 1972 would not be applicable. It may farther be observed that the amount of pendente lite and mesne profits would be much more. The court below has observed that this amount would be Rs. 28,862.75 P. which was required to be deposited in compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act and if for the sake of argument all the deposits of the petitioner are accepted, the total amount deposited by the petitioner comes to Rs. 18,900 which falls short by near about Rs. 10,000. Therefore, the petitioner can claim no benefit from the said deposits for the purpose of compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act.

    10. In view of the discussion held above, I find no merit in the petition and the same is dismissed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Krishna Chandra Seth v. (Dr.) K.P Agarwal And Another
    (Dec 11, 1987)