AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Braund, J. (with Hamilton, J. agreeing)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, Sahu Sarju Prasad, carrying on business as Jagdish Prasad Satish Prasad (and separately in his own name), advanced various sums of money totaling Rs. 49,302-4-0 to a Mirzapur trading firm, Prag Das Gobind Das, pursuant to an agreement dated 9 April 1937. Under that agreement the firm would take foreign zinc by forward purchase, keep the goods in a separate room locked by the plaintiff, and the goods were to remain in the plaintiff's possession until repayment; interest was payable at the stated rate. Between 10 April and 24 July 1937 the plaintiff made a series of advances corresponding to the agreement. Around 1 January 1938 a large quantity of zinc (roughly 3,400 maunds) was transferred to the plaintiff's godown and thereafter the firm was adjudicated insolvent on a petition filed on 26 April 1938. The Official Assignee of the insolvent firm's property was made defendant (and is the appellant in the present appeal).

The plaintiff sued in Suit No. 9 of 1938 seeking recovery of principal and interest and, construed liberally by the Court, a declaration of the plaintiff's security over the zinc and the realisation of that security (sale). The Civil Judge of Mirzapur found for the plaintiff, holding that the monies were advanced under the 9 April 1937 agreement and that the zinc in plaintiff’s possession had been pawned as security for the full sum claimed. An order for sale of the zinc had, prior to the decree, been made and the zinc was sold with proceeds standing in court. The Official Assignee appealed (Appeal No. 90 of 1941). Braund, J. delivered the principal judgment dismissing the appeal; Hamilton, J. agreed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether section 17 of the Presidency-towns Insolvency Act required that the plaintiff obtain leave of the insolvency court before instituting a suit to realise security, and if so whether the plaintiff had (or was protected by) the proviso to section 17.
  2. Whether a pawnee/pledgee (secured creditor) has a right to come to the court to obtain a sale (i.e., whether a court-ordered sale is a mode of "realising" security covered by the proviso to section 17).
  3. Whether, on the facts and evidence, the plaintiff was a secured creditor to the extent claimed (whether the advances were made pursuant to the 9 April 1937 agreement and whether the zinc in the plaintiff's possession was security for the advances).
  4. Whether the transfer of the zinc to the plaintiff's premises at the end of December 1937 was a fraudulent transfer void against the Official Assignee (an issue raised by the appellant in argument but not pleaded in the lower court).

Arguments of the Parties

Official Assignee's Arguments (Appellant)

  • Section 17 of the Presidency-towns Insolvency Act applies equally to secured creditors and requires leave of the insolvency court to institute proceedings to realise security; the plaintiff did not obtain such leave and thus the suit should be dismissed.
  • The proviso to section 17 protects a secured creditor only insofar as he realises his security in the same manner as he would be entitled to do without the Act; it was argued that the plaintiff, as a mere pawnee, had no inherent right to seek a court-ordered sale under Indian law and therefore was not "realising" his security in a manner covered by the proviso.
  • The Official Assignee admitted advances to the extent of Rs. 29,800 (and 1,700 maunds of zinc) but denied the remainder (about Rs. 19,502 and 1,707 maunds of zinc), alleging those sums/quantities were either outside the agreement or the result of fraudulent collusion (including transfer into the plaintiff's godown) and so formed part of the insolvents' estate.
  • The appellant invited the Court to permit argument under section 55 of the Presidency-towns Insolvency Act that the December transfer was fraudulent (a contention not pleaded below).

Plaintiff-Respondent's Arguments

  • The advances totaling Rs. 49,302-4-0 were made in pursuance of the 9 April 1937 agreement for forward purchases of zinc and the corresponding zinc parcels were held as security under that agreement.
  • The plaintiff claimed the right to realise his security by court sale and relied on documentary and oral evidence (including numerous written request "slips" sent by the defendant firm's munib) to show a consistent course of dealing under the agreement.
  • Mr. Banerji for the plaintiff contended the 9 April 1937 agreement, as a matter of construction, secured all zinc purchased by the defendant firm; the Court did not accept that broader construction but found the plaintiff was induced to advance on the representation each time that the money would be used to buy zinc secured for plaintiff’s benefit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Carter v. Wake (Sir George Jessel, M.R.) Illustrates that a pledgee/pawnee under English law had a right to come to the court and ask for a sale of pledged chattels (court-ordered sale recognised as a remedy). The Court relied on this to show that historically courts have entertained suits by pledgees for sale; it supports the view that a pawnee may seek a sale through the court (subject to statutory differences between England and India).
In re L.W. Nasse (Rangoon case) Held (in that decision) that the word "realise" in the proviso to section 17 must be confined to modes of realisation available without court intervention (narrow construction). The Court explicitly rejected this narrow construction and declined to follow the Rangoon decision, preferring the broader construction adopted by Indian High Courts.
Vitla Kamti v. Kalekara Expresses that the power to bring movable property to sale is incident or accessory to the right to recover the debt (implying court sale is an incident of the right). The Court cited this as supporting authority that the right to ask for sale by the court is an incident of a pledgee's security.
Mahalinga Nadar v. Ganapathi Subbien Assumed that the court had power to entertain a suit for sale of movable property at the instance of a pledgee. Used to support the proposition that Indian courts have recognised suits by pledgees for sale as a proper remedy.
Madan Mohan Lal v. Kanhai Lal Taken for granted (in the court's own reporting) that a suit for sale by a pledgee would lie (context: Limitation Act). Relied upon as another instance where Indian courts proceeded on the assumption that a pawnee could sue for sale through the court.
Nim Chand Baboo v. Jagabundhu Ghose Affirms by analogy that a claim of a pawnee for sale is a suit to enforce his charge; no doubt expressed that a pawnee could seek remedies through the court. The Court quoted and relied on this authority to bolster the view that a pawnee's suit to enforce his charge (including sale) is recognised in Indian jurisprudence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in two linked tracks: (1) statutory interpretation of section 17 of the Presidency-towns Insolvency Act (with its proviso) and (2) factual / evidential assessment whether the plaintiff had a valid pledge covering the zinc and advances claimed.

On section 17 the Court concluded:

  • The term "creditor" in section 17 includes a secured creditor; the proviso must be given meaningful work and cannot be read out by treating secured creditors as excluded from the opening words.
  • The Court rejected a narrow construction (as in the Rangoon case In re L.W. Nasse) that would confine "realise" to only those modes of realisation available without court intervention. Such a construction would render "deal with" redundant and be unduly cramped.
  • The Court preferred a construction consistent with a considerable body of Indian High Court authority which treats a secured creditor's invocation of the court to realise security as covered by the proviso to section 17.
  • English statutory developments (Conveyancing Act 1881 and Law of Property Act 1925) show that historically courts recognised pledgee remedies by sale; however, even absent statutory conferral in India, the Court held that it possesses an inherent administrative jurisdiction to order sale of property in suits focused on administering and giving effect to property rights. That inherent jurisdiction supports the view that a pawnee may seek sale through the court and such an invocation falls within the "manner" of realising security contemplated by the proviso.
  • The Court further held that the existence of statutory out-of-court powers (e.g., section 176 Indian Contract Act permitting out-of-court sale on notice) did not imply exclusion of court remedies; the court's inherent jurisdiction remains available.

On the facts the Court reasoned:

  • There was no dispute that the plaintiff made advances totaling Rs. 49,302-4-0. The Official Assignee admitted only Rs. 29,800 were made under the agreement and covered 1,700 maunds; he denied the remainder as being outside the agreement or fraudulently claimed.
  • The Court examined oral evidence (munibs' testimony) and documentary evidence (multiple request slips, exhibits) showing a regular course of dealing in which advances were made upon requests that were consistent with the 9 April 1937 agreement for zinc purchases. The defendant firm's own munib corroborated that advances were for zinc purchases and that written slips were used.
  • The Court found the documentary and oral evidence made it reasonable for the plaintiff to believe each advance was made under the terms of the agreement and in reliance on representations that the money would purchase zinc that would stand as security. The Court rejected the Official Assignee's contention that the general wording of some slips undermined the plaintiff's claim.
  • There was some uncertainty whether the defendant firm's store-room was exclusively used for zinc purchased with plaintiff's money, but the transfer of the store contents to the plaintiff's godown around 1 January 1938 placed exclusive possession in the plaintiff more than three months before any act of bankruptcy: the Court treated this as perfecting a pledge by possession.
  • The Official Assignee's separate contention that the disputed Rs. 19,502 were misapplied and therefore not covered by the agreement was answered twofold: (a) on agency/representation principles the defendant firm could not benefit from its own misapplication of plaintiff's funds to deny the plaintiff the security he was led to expect, and (b) the firm's own acquiescence in transferring the stock to the plaintiff's premises demonstrated acceptance that the stock stood as security.
  • The appellant’s invitation to permit a new case based on section 55 (fraudulent transfer) was declined because that allegation had not been pleaded and belonged to the insolvency forum rather than being reopened on appeal in this suit.
  • Because the zinc had already been sold by order of the Civil Judge (with consent of parties) and proceeds stood in court, the plaintiff's claim was treated as transferred to the proceeds and the Court directed payment out of those proceeds in priority to the plaintiff's secured claim (with provision for costs and balance to the Official Assignee).

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeal (No. 90 of 1941) is dismissed.

Direct consequences and orders made by the Court:

  • Declaration: The Court declared that 3,407 maunds 4 seers 10 chattaks of zinc (as referred to in schedule B of the plaint) were, at the date of vesting of the insolvent firm's assets, in the possession of the plaintiff by virtue of a valid subsisting pledge created by the first two defendants to secure the principal sum of Rs. 49,302-4-0 and interest amounting to Rs. 4,205-10-0, making a total of Rs. 53,507-14-0 due at the date of the plaint.
  • Payment from proceeds: As the zinc had been sold by order of court and proceeds stood in the Civil Judge's court, the sum of Rs. 53,507-14-0 (with interest pendente lite) was declared payable to the plaintiff out of those proceeds; any balance standing in court after payment of the plaintiff's claim and costs would be payable to the Official Assignee as representative of the insolvent estate.
  • Costs: The Official Assignee was ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs of the suit and appeal; to the extent those costs had not been paid out of the proceeds in court, there would be a decree against the Official Assignee for payment.
  • Variation of decree: The Civil Judge's decree dated 10 December 1940 in Suit No. 9 of 1938 was to be varied insofar as necessary to give effect to the foregoing declaration and payment directions.

Broader interpretive implication expressly stated by the Court:

  • The Court construed the proviso to section 17 of the Presidency-towns Insolvency Act as protecting a secured creditor who seeks to realise his security through court proceedings; accordingly, when a secured creditor sues to enforce his charge and asks for a sale by the court, he is exercising a "power ... to realise ... his security in the same manner as he would have been entitled to realise ... it" and does not require leave of the insolvency court for that purpose. The Court preferred the line of Indian High Court authority recognising such suits to the narrower Rangoon decision.

Note on precedent and novelty:

The Court relied on existing Indian authorities and on established principles of the court's inherent jurisdiction to administer property in suits; the decision applies and explains those principles to the facts of this case and resolves the parties' rights and distribution of the proceeds. The judgment does not purport to rest its outcome on a novel statutory amendment but on interpretation of section 17 together with factual findings that the pledge existed and was perfected.

(Hamilton, J. concurred.)

    Official Assignee, High Court Of Judicature At Fort-William v. Sarju Prasad

    Braund, J.:— This is one of four connected appeals from a judgment and decree of the learned Civil Judge of Mirzapur in, suits in which the plaintiff, who carries on business at Mirzapur under the firm name of Jagdish Prasad Satish Prasad, has sued the partners of a firm called Prag Das Gobind Das, which also carried on business at Mirzapur, until it was adjudicated insolvent on a petition in the Calcutta High Court filed on the 26th April, 1938. The Official Assignee of the property of the insolvent defendant firm was made a defendant to the suit, and is the present appellant.

    The plaintiff, Sahu Sarju Prasad, who, as I have said, carried on business in the name of Jagdish Prasad Satish Prasad, also carried on a separate business at Mirzapur in his own individual name. In the course of one or other of these businesses the plaintiff lent; the insolvent defendants various sums of money amounting in all to Rs. 49,302-4-0, which are the subject-matter of this particular suit. It appears that the plaintiff's business was in the nature of a money lending business. The first two defendants, whom for convenience I shall refer to as the defendant firm, on the other hand, dealt in metals, and, among other metals, in zinc. In the course of its business the defendant firm in April, 1937, made a number of forward purchases of zinc from abroad of which they became, or were about to become, liable to take delivery. In these circumstances they approached the plaintiff with a view to obtaining from the plaintiff the finance wherewith to meet their obligations on these contracts of purchase as they fell due, and on the 9th April, 1937, an agreement was reached between the plaintiff and the defendant firm, the terms of which are to be found in Ex. 3, which is printed at page 11 in First Appeal No. 93. This document provided as follows:

    Messrs Sarju Prasad Sao, Mirzapur.

    Prag Das Gobind Das, Mirzapur.

    Our compliments to you. We have purchased foreign zinc in the market by means of forward transaction, for taking delivery of which we are in need of money. Hence we will take from you as much money as we will require in any month and after getting the goods weighed shall keep it in a separate room in our godown, which will be locked by you. The goods will remain in your possession so long as we do not pay the money and on payment of the money due to you we shall take possession of the goods. We shall pay you interest on money which we will take from you at the rate of nine annas six pies per cent, per mensem.

    Dated Chait Badi, 12th Sambat 1993. Equivalent to the 9th April, 1937. Written by the pen of Jagan Nath Prasad Tewari. Please note the contents of the letter.

    Signature of Prag Das Gobind Das by the pen of Gwal Das Binani.”

    In due course the plaintiff from time to time made some nine advances of money to the defendant firm at various dates between the 10th April and the 24th July, 1937, which are set out more particularly in schedule A attached to the plaint. It is not disputed on the pleadings that these sums were advanced by the plaintiff to the defendant firm. The plaintiff alleged by his petition that the nine advances were all made in pursuance of the agreement of the 9th April, 1937, and that with the money so obtained the defendant firm purchased a little over 3,407 maunds, of zinc. This, according to paragraph 6 of the plaint, was all placed under a lock and key of his own by the plaintiff at first in a separate part of the defendant firm's godown or shop premises and later—from about the 1st January, 1938, onwards—in a portion of a godown in the plaintiff's own premises which had theretofore been rented to the defendant firm for the purpose of the storage of carpets. On the 26th April, 1938, certain creditors of the defendant firm filed a petition in insolvency against them founded on an act of insolvency dated the 23rd April, 1938, and in due course the defendant firm was adjudicated insolvent. On the adjudication order all the assets of the defendant firm vested in the defendant, the Official Assignee of its property. The 3,400 odd maunds of zinc in question remained, however, for the time being in the plaintiff's godown and no attempt was made by the Official Assignee to take possession of them for the reason apparently that the plaintiff claimed to be entitled to hold them as a secured creditor in respect of the Rs. 49,000 odd so advanced by him as aforesaid, together with interest thereon. It is possible that in these circumstances the plaintiff might have taken steps out of hand to satisfy his debt by selling the zinc in his possession, but, instead of taking that course, he launched the suit No. 9 of 1938 out of which this appeal arises. It is perhaps worth pausing to observe the manner in which he has framed his prayer for relief, since the real issues have been somewhat obscured by the manner in which he has put forward his claim. After setting out the facts and alleging that “under the circumstances the plaintiff is entitled to realise the security”; the plaintiff proceeded to ask for the recovery of Rs. 53,507-14-0 in respect of principal and interest, together with the costs of the suit, and that a decree for this sum might be “passed in favour of the plaintiff as against the defendants”. In view of the insolvency, this prayer was, of course, from the outset misconceived. He asked, however, in addition that what was due to him might “first be realised by sale of the goods which stand as security for the money claimed….” Allowing some latitude to the draftsman of the plaint, it may, therefore, be said that the plaint did include a prayer for the realisation of the security by sale, meaning, it is to be supposed, by a sale by the court of the zinc in the plaintiff's possession at the date of the insolvency.

    The defendant firm, for obvious reasons, did not appear in the suit. The Official Assignee, after admitting the agreement of the 9th April, 1934, and that the sums in question had in fact been advanced, denied that the whole of the money borrowed from the plaintiff had been borrowed for the purpose of, or applied in the purchase of zinc as provided for by the agreement of the 9th April, 1937. He admitted only that Rs. 29,800 had been so borrowed and applied, and alleged that only 1,700 maunds of the zinc in the possession of the plaintiff were covered by the security constituted by the agreement. As to the remaining 1,707 odd maunds of zinc and the balance of Rs. 19,502, he said, in effect, that these constituted transactions altogether outside the agreement, and that the circumstance that this 1,707 maunds of zinc found its way into the plaintiff's godown was due only to the fraud of the gomashta of the defendant firm, who, being the brother of the munib of the plaintiff, in collusion with the latter, had it transferred about the 1st January, 1938, from the defendant firm's godown to the plaintiff's premises for the fraudulent purpose of establishing a security to which the plaintiff had no title. In these circumstances the Official Assignee, while admitting that the plaintiff was a secured creditor to the extent of Rs. 29,800 and that out of the zinc in the possession of the plaintiff 1,700 maunds were covered by the security, denied that the balance of 1,707 odd maunds was covered by the agreement, and he accordingly claims the latter as part of the assets of the insolvents free from any charge in favour of the plaintiff.

    Such, in brief, were the circumstances which gave rise to this suit. As so often happens, too little thought was given to the pleadings and to the settlement of the issues, which has resulted in a decree which it is not altogether easy to understand, and it is evident that there will in any case have to be a substantial alteration in; its form. The suit, as we have pointed out, could not in any circumstances result in a decree for personal payment by the Insolvents or by the Official Assignee. The suit was in substance a suit for the purpose of obtaining a declaration as against the Official Assignee of the existence of the plaintiff's security over the assets of the insolvents in the plaintiff's possession consisting of the 3,404 maunds of zinc, and, upon a somewhat liberal construction of the plaint, for the purpose of realising that security by ordering a sale by the court. Beyond that it is difficult to see that the plaintiff could properly go, since his remedy for any deficiency, after resort to the security, obviously lay in proving against the estate.

    Before going further, it must be said that the three thousand four hundred odd maunds of zinc have now been sold. The order for sale was made by the Civil Judge of Mirzapur in this suit a few days before passing his decree. The sale was conducted by the Official Assignee and, owing to the rise in the price of zinc, realised more than sufficient to answer the plaintiff's full claim in the suit. Whether these proceedings were regular or not, I do not know. Nor, I think, we are concerned to inquire since they were conducted with the consent of all parties, including the Official Assignee. The result is, as far as this suit is concerned, that the plaintiff's claim has been transferred from the zinc to its proceeds of sale now standing in court.

    The learned Civil Judge came to the conclusion on the evidence that the plaintiff had, upon the facts, established that the monies taken from him by the defendant firm were required and spent for the purpose of, and in, taking up parcels of zinc according to the agreement of the 9th April 1937. He found that the whole of the 3,407 odd maunds of zinc in the plaintiff's possession at the date of the insolvency had been “pawned” for the amount claimed in the suit, and, accordingly, passed the decree we have referred to above, which in form appears to give to the plaintiff a decree against all the defendants, including the Official Assignee, for payment of the amount claimed, with a somewhat obscure proviso that “the property which is pawned in this suit shall be liable to be sold by auction in lieu of the decretal amount and that, if any decretal amount remains unpaid, then that unpaid decretal amount shall be realised in the manner permitted by law.”

    The first, and only troublesome point that has been taken in the appeal is that, under section 17 of the Presidency-towns Insolvency Act, the plaintiff required the leave of the insolvency court to bring this suit, and that, since he did not obtain it (as admittedly he did not) it is now too late to give it to him and his suit should accordingly have been dismissed. This point was, we think, taken before the learned Civil Judge who dealt with it, as issue No. 2, by holding that, as on the facts he had found the plaintiff to he a secured creditor, section 17 of the Act either did not apply at all, or, at least, the plaintiff, in taking steps to realise his security, was immune from its mischief, by virtue of the saving proviso to the section. The argument for the application of section 17 of the Presidency-town's Insolvency Act has, however, been considerably elaborated by the appellant, before us. What I understand to be said by the appellant is, first, that section 17 applies to as secured creditor just as much as to any other creditor, except so far as a secured creditor is exempt from its provisions under the proviso; and, secondly, that, upon that view of the matter, it in impossible to say in this suit that the plaintiff is suing to realise his security, because this is not what he asks for by the relief he claims in the plaint; nor, in fact is there any relief that, as a mere pawnee, he could in law ask the court to give him, recourse to the court for sale not being a “manner” of realising the security of a pawnee known to the Indian law. The Official Assignee accordingly says that the plaintiff is not, in coming to the court in this suit, seeking to “realise” his security in any manner in which he would have been entitled to realise it, if no leave had been required, and, accordingly, the saving proviso to section 17 does not apply. That, as I understand it, is the argument.

    So far as it is said that section 17 of the Presidency towns Insolvency at applies to a secured creditor, subject to any benefit he may be able to derive from the proviso, I am not prepared to dispute. It seems to me to be clear that the word “creditor” in the first part of section 17 must include a secured creditor, since it is difficult otherwise to give any meaning or purpose at all to the proviso. Nor am I prepared to hold, as has been held in the Rangoon case of In re L.W Nasse(1), that the word “realise” in the proviso must be confined to a method of realisation to which the secured creditor is entitled without the intervention of the court, with the result that in all cases in which a secured creditor seeks to realise his security through the court he requires the leave of the court, notwithstanding the proviso. I think that to adopt this construction would be to put on the word “realise” an unnaturally narrow construction and one, moreover, which renders the ensuing words “deal with” redundant. Apart from this there is a considerable volume of authority of the Indian High Courts which has construed the proviso as covering the case of a secured creditor who seeks to realise his security by the institution of a suit and these I respectfully prefer to the Rangoon decision.

    But it is said in the case before us that, even assuming that a secured creditor in realising his security through the court is covered by the proviso, the plaintiff in this case, as a mere pawnee, has no right inherent in his security to come to the court to obtain a sale and that he is not, therefore, in this suit realising or dealing with his security in the same manner as he would have been “entitled” to do, if the section had not been passed. This is an ingenious argument; but in my view it does not bear close examination.

    It is beyond doubt that under English law a pawnee of goods, who has a special property in them, has a right to come to the court and ask for a sale, Carter v. Wake. Sir George Jessel, M.R, was there dealing with a case of a pledge of certain personal chattels, together with a deposit of certain bonds by way of equitable charge. The suit was a suit for sale of the personal chattels and for foreclosure of the equity of redemption in the bonds. The latter remedy was refused, since, unlike a legal mortgage, the pledgee had no absolute ownership of the chattels at law and could not, therefore, foreclose; but no question was raised but that, both in, the case of the chattels and the bonds, the pledgee had a right to come to the court and ask for sale. It was, indeed, taken for granted that a right to ask for a sale was a right incident to the pledgee's security. It may be that the position of a pledgee under English law is somewhat different from that of a pledgee under Indian law, because, since 1881 at least, section 25 of the Conveyancing Act, 1881, coupled with the definition of property contained in section 2(1) of the same Act, expressly confers on every form of charge of property, real or personal, a statutory right of sale. This is reproduced in section 91 of the Law of Property Act, 1925. It appears to be clear, therefore, that under English law a pledgee of goods since 1881 has had an express statutory right of sale, and I have no doubt that these statutory enactments reproduced the law enforced by the courts, as it stood before the Conveyancing Act, 1881. It may be said, therefore, that in England a right of sale by the court is expressly conferred on a pledgee, whereas in India it is not. It is, moreover, pointed out that section 176 of the Indian Contract Act expressly confers upon a pawnee certain specific rights of sale out of court, from which circumstance it is argued that right to have a sale by the court is by implication excluded. Section 176 says that, if the pawnor makes default, “the pawnee may bring a suit against the pawnor upon the debt or promise, and retain the goods pledged as a collateral security; or he may sell the thing pledged on giving the pawnor reasonable notice of the sale….” This undoubtedly defines what I may describe as the personal rights of the pledgee of goods arising out of his special property in them conferred by the pledge, but I should be most reluctant to hold that there is any implication that the Indian Contract Act, by defining his personal rights, cuts down in any way any remedy he may have through the courts. The truth appears to me to be that the court always has an inherent jurisdiction to administer, by sale or otherwise, the property of which it has seizen in any suit which is in effect an administration suit, I do not think that a suit on a mortgage or pledge is in its essential characteristics anything but an administration suit of the same kind as a suit for the execution of a trust, for the administration of the estate of a deceased person, for the administration of partnership assets in a partnership suit or any other suit of the same kind. All such suits are in substance suits to ascertain and declare the rights of some person having an interest in specified property and asking the court, in its administrative jurisdiction, to ascertain and give practical effect to his rights. That is precisely what an encumbrancer asks for when he invokes the assistance of the court, and, in my view, there must necessarily always exist an inherent jurisdiction for the court by its order to direct the property to be dealt with, whether by sale or otherwise, in the proper manner for the purpose of implementing its own orders. It seems to me, therefore, that it is impossible to say that, because a statute confers on a pledgee certain special personal powers outside the court altogether, for that reason the court is divested of its inherent jurisdiction to entertain an administration suit in respect of the same property and in that suit to order a sale. The same question, does not, of course, arise in the case of a simple mortgage in India, as the only remedy of a simple mortgagee is to obtain a sale from the court. This, however, serves as no reason for supposing that, where a man has an additional remedy outside the court, but prefers to come to the court, he should be prevented from doing so. I am, therefore, strongly inclined to think that there is an inherent jurisdiction in the court in a proper case to make an order for sale of property at the expense of any pledgee or chargee. This view is, to my mind, greatly reinforced when one finds that, in case after case, the Indian Courts have in fact exercised this jurisdiction.

    In Vitla Kamti v. Kalekara it is said that: The power to bring the moveable property to sale is an incident in the nature of an accessory to the right to recover the debt….” That must, I think, refer to a power to bring the property to sale in court. In Mahalinga Nadar v. Ganapathi Subbien(2) it was taken for granted that the court had power to entertain a suit for sale of moveable property at the instance of a pledgee. In Madan Mohan Lal v. Kanhai Lal(3), which was a case under the Limitation Act, our own Court took it for granted that such a suit would lie. In Nim Chand Baboo v. Jagabundhu Ghose(4) there was again no doubt expressed but that a pawnee had a right to seek his remedies through the court and was not bound to rely upon his personal remedies. The learned Judges in this case say:

    “It is, we believe, now well settled that when a mortgagee of immovable property brings a suit to recover the money advanced by sale of the property pledged, it is a suit to enforce his charge upon the said property; and we should think, by analogy, the claim of a pawnee for a similar relief in respect of movable property is a suit to enforce his charge upon that property.”

    We find, therefore, numerous cases in the reports in which the Indian Courts have in fact recognised the right of a pawnee to come and ask for a sale. On the other hand, we have been referred to no case in which it has been suggested that such a right does not exist.

    To return to section 17 of the Presidency-towns Insolvency Act, the words we are asked to construe are these:

    “Provided that this section shall not affect the power of any secured creditor to realise or otherwise deal with his security in the same manner as he would have been entitled to realise or deal with it if this section had not been passed.”

    I have, therefore, to ask myself whether the plaintiff in coming to the court in this case and asking for a sale, as I must believe he has done, is the exercise by him of a “power … to realise … his security; in the same manner as he would have been entitled to realise … it” if no leave had been required. In short, the question is whether he would have been entitled to ask for a sale by the court. For the reasons which I have given, I think he would have been so entitled, because such a right is, in the first place, an incident of his security. Even if it were not intrinsically an incident of his security, I should have no hesitation in holding that the fact itself that the courts of India habitually recognise such a right would constitute a “manner” of realising the security on which, in India at any rate, he has become “entitled”. On these grounds I think that the plaintiff is protected by section 17 of the Presidency-towns Insolvency Act and that, for the purpose of bringing a suit on his security and in such suit asking for a sale, no leave of the court was required. I cannot accept the view that the proviso only refers, to a case in which the plaintiff is bound to come to the court where he has no other remedy open to him. I am fortified in this view by the fact that in Sir Frederick Pollock's and Sir Dinshaw Mulla's book on the Contract Act the bringing of a property by a pledgee to sale through he court is a recognised remedy.

    This brings me to the facts of the appeal which are, I think, relatively simple. There is no dispute that the plaintiff did in fact from time to time between the 10th April, and the 24th July, 1937, advance the Rs. 49,302 in question to the defendant firm. What is said is that, out of these advances, only Rs. 29,800 were advanced under the agreement of the 9th April, 1937, for the purchase of 1,700 maunds of zinc and that the balance of Rs. 19,502-4-0 was advanced, or at any rate was applied, for miscellaneous purposes having nothing to do with the agreement. There is oral evidence to the effect that the whole of the Rs. 49,302 was borrowed for the purchase of zinc. The plaintiff's head munib, Bhagwati Prasad, has said that the course of business was that he was from time to time asked by the munib of the defendant firm to make the advances in question for the purchase of zinc and that it was the practice for information to be sent to him a few days later that the particular parcel, of zinc in question had been received, asking him to send to the defendant firm's godown to put it under lock and key. It is significant that this is substantially borne out by the evidence of Jagannath Prasad, the munib of the defendant firm itself, who was called as a court witness. He says that all the advances made by the plaintiff were for the purchase of zinc, although there were other independent transactions altogether. The defendant firm's munib used to send both oral and written requests for the advances as the several parcels had to be taken up. This is strong evidence of a course of business which is quite consistent with the agreement of the 9th April, 1937. To my mind it becomes overwhelming, when we find, as we do find, the several request “slips” (Exs. 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14) which were from time to time sent by the defendant firm to the plaintiff. These documents are in each case requests for advances for the purpose of buying zinc. It is true that none of them specifically refer to the agreement of the 9th April, 1937, but I see no reason why any of them should have done. The point is made by the Official Assignee that whereas some of them—these are the ones which he has admitted—refer to specific amounts of zinc, others are in general terms, mentioning merely that the advance is required “on account of zinc” or “for payment of the price of zinc” without mention of the specific zinc. It is suggested that this is support for the defendants' contention that the Rs. 19,502, which the Official Assignee has not admitted to have been advanced under the agreement of the 9th April, 1937, were advanced merely for the purpose of buying zinc at large, and accordingly became unsecured debts. I regard this view as quite incapable of being supported on the evidence. We have a clear agreement in the document of the 9th April, 1937; we have a course of dealing constituted by the exhibits to which I have referred, which is quite consistent with that agreement; and of this at least I am satisfied, namely that the plaintiff had every right to think, and in fact did think, that what he was being asked for on each occasion was to make an advance upon the terms of the agreement for security contained in the document of the 9th April, 1937. Nor is the matter taken any further by the series of accounts—Exs. 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 26, 27, 28 and 29—which are extracts from the defendant firm's account books. On the facts, therefore, I am satisfied that in the case of each of the advances, it was asked for by the defendant firm in pursuance of the agreement of the 9th April, and upon the footing that it would be applied in the purchase of zinc, which zinc would be available as a security to the plaintiff. I think that the several documents by which the advances were asked for constituted in themselves clear representations to this effect, having regard to the surrounding circumstances; and I am satisfied that the plaintiff lent his money in bona fide reliance on the agreement. It has been somewhat timidly suggested in evidence that the “slips” have been brought into existence for the purpose of this suit. But even the defendants' only witness, their gomashta Jarbundhan, was compelled in cross-examination to admit that he might have written some slips for money from the plaintiff's shop. All the evidence points to the fact that the slips were written and that the plaintiff acted on them. Jagannath Prasad, the defendant firm's own munib, quite clearly says that he used to send written slips as well as make oral requests to the plaintiff for money.

    There is some question as to where the zinc purchased was stocked. As far as the evidence goes, it is not very clear. The facts were that the defendant firm had a premises or godown consisting of several rooms. One of these separate rooms or compartments was used as a store room. There is evidence, which I think can be accepted, as it is supported by Jagannath Prasad, that the key of this room was delivered to the plaintiff or his munib. What, however, is not quite clear on the evidence is whether this store room was used exclusively for the purpose of storing the zinc purchased with the plaintiff's money, or whether it was used as well for storing other goods, and possibly other zinc, of the defendant firm. I am not prepared to find on the evidence that it was exclusively used for the purpose of storing zinc over which the plaintiff had a security. There is at least some doubt in that respect, although it is probable that the key was throughout in the plaintiff's possession. This is, however, immaterial, as at the end of December the goods in the store room, amounting to the 3,400 maunds of zinc in question, were unquestionably transferred to a godown in the plaintiff's own premises, which had formerly been rented by the defendant firm. At this point, I think, they clearly came into the exclusive possession of the plaintiff. That was at a point of time more than three months before any act of bankruptcy and before any title of the Official Assignee accrued. It seems to me, therefore, that, whatever may have been the position prior to the 1st January, a pledge was perfected at that date, whether by the transfer or in pursuance of the subsisting agreement under the document of the 9th April 1937. The position, as the Official Assignee found it, when the assets of the insolvent firm vested in him as at the 23rd April 1938, was that the 3,400 maunds of zinc were in fact in the plaintiff's exclusive possession. In that view of the matter, I think that the plaintiff was entitled to the security he claims.

    There is only one other point to be dealt with, which is the Official Assignee's allegation that the Rs. 19,502 which he disputes were not in fact applied in the purchase of zinc under the agreement at all, but were applied in the purchase of other zinc. Mr. Banerji, who appears for the plaintiff-respondent, meets this in the first place by contending that the agreement of the 9th April, 1937, as a matter of construction, is sufficient to give him a security over all the zinc purchased by the defendant firm, and is not confined to zinc purchased out of the advance made by the plaintiff. With that I am not prepared to agree, as it appears to me that the terms of the document plainly mean that the plaintiff was to have a security over the actual zinc, and no more, purchased with his money. That, however, does not end the matter, since, as I have already indicated, the plaintiff was clearly induced to part with his money on each occasion on a representation that it would be applied according to the agreement of the 9th April, 1937, that is to say in the purchase of zinc for which a security would be created for his benefit. If, in the face of that representation, the defendant firm in fact purchased parcels of zinc with the plaintiff's money which did not strictly answer the description of “foreign zinc” for which they had entered into “forward transactions” according to the terms of the document of the 9th April, 1937, it would not, I think, affect the matter in any way. On ordinary principles, I do not think that the defendant firm could have been heard to say that, by its own misapplication of the plaintiff's money, it was now enabled to deny to the plaintiff the security he had been led to expect. If that were so, it would amount to permitting the defendant firm to take advantage of its own misrepresentation and to elect whether the plaintiff should have a security or not. Nor do I think that the Official Assignee and the general body of creditors can, in this respect, be in any better position than the defendant firm itself would have been. That is sufficient by itself to dispose of this contention, but, even if it had not been, there remains the fact that on or about the 1st January the defendant firm itself acquiesced in the whole of the existing stock being transferred to the plaintiff's godown for no other purpose than to answer his security. That is made plain by the evidence of Jagannath Prasad who says that his master consented to the transfer and that:

    “All the zinc that was lying in Dundhi Katra in December 1937 was sent to the plaintiff's place at Badli Katra. That was all under the lock of the plaintiff. One hundred maunds were lying outside and they were sent afterwards as security for firm Jagdish Prasad Satish Prasad….”

    It is clear that the whole contents of the store room were transferred to the plaintiff's godown upon the footing that it stood as security. It is not, I think, necessary to go so far as to consider whether technically this constituted a new security, or was a continuation of the old one. I should perhaps add that, in agreement with the learned Civil Judge, I can find no sufficient evidence to support the view that the transfer which was effected at the end of December was a fraudulent transaction against the defendant firm.

    I should mention that we have been invited by the appellant, the Official Assignee, to reopen the whole matter and to try a case under section 55 of the Presidency-towns Insolvency Act based on an allegation, which is nowhere raised on the pleadings, that the transfer of the zinc from the defendant firm's godown at the end of December, 1937, and any rights accruing to the plaintiff from that transfer, are void as against the Official Assignee as a fraudulent transfer under section 55 of the Act. It is sufficient to say that, apart from the fact that this is a question which ought to be raised in the insolvency, if it is to be raised at all, and not in this Court, I should not, in any case, be disposed to allow, the Official Assignee to put forward a case here which he has neither pleaded, nor suggested, in the lower court.

    For the foregoing reasons I think this appeal—No. 90 of 1941—must be dismissed. The decree, however, passed by the Civil Judge in form leaves something to be desired. The relief to which the plaintiff is, I think, entitled is, first a declaration that the 3,407 maunds 4 seers 10 chattaks of zinc, referred to in schedule B of the plaint, at the date of the vesting of the assets of the first two defendants in the defendant Official Assignee were in the possession of the plaintiff by virtue of a valid subsisting pledge thereon created by the first two defendants to secure the principal sum of Rs. 49,302-4-0, together with interest thereon at the date of the plaint, amounting to Rs. 4,205-10-0, making in all a sum of Rs. 53,507-14-0 for principal and interest due at the date of the plaint; secondly, that the zinc referred to in schedule B of the plaint: having now been sold by order of the court dated 7th December, 1940, and being now represented by the proceeds of sale thereof standing in the court of the Civil Judge of Mirzapur to the credit of this suit, the said sum of Rs. 53,507-14-0, together with interest pendente lite, is payable to the plaintiff out of the said proceeds of sale so standing in court and that it be declared and decreed accordingly. The balance, if any, of the said sum standing in court, after payment out of such balance to the plaintiff of the plaintiff's costs of this suit and of this appeal, is payable to the Official Assignee, as the Official, Assignee of the estate of the defendant firm. The Official Assignee must pay to the plaintiff his costs of this suit and appeal in both courts and, in so far as such costs shall not have been, or shall not be, paid to the plaintiff out of the said proceeds of sale now standing in court, there will be a decree against the Official Assignee for payment of them. To the extent necessary to give effect to the foregoing decree we shall vary the decree dated the 10th December, 1940, in suit No. 9 of 1938.

    Hamilton, J.:— I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Official Assignee, High Court Of Judicature At Fort-William v. Sarju Prasad
    (Nov 21, 1944)