Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion was delivered by a Division Bench consisting of C.K. Prasad, C.J., and Pankaj Mithal, J. The writ petition sought a direction to respondent no.1 (Judge, Small Causes / Civil Judge (Senior Division), Allahabad) to finally decide Suit No. 484 of 2007 (Sarjeet Kumar Ghoshal v. Km. Shobha Bose) and to respondent no.2 (Additional District Judge, Court No. 10, Allahabad) to decide Civil Revision No. 257 of 2009 (Sarjeet Kumar Ghoshal v. Km. Shobha Bose) within a fixed time. The petitioner, represented by Mr. A.M. Lal, contended that the suit was not being disposed of expeditiously due to delaying tactics by the opposing side and emphasized that the petitioner is an aged lady who may not live long to see the suit’s result. The petition did not assert that later-filed cases had been decided or that the presiding judge was purposely refraining from disposing of the matter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court should exercise its power to direct the trial court and the revisional court to decide the specified suit and revision within a fixed time (i.e., whether to order expeditious or out-of-turn disposal of the lis).
  2. Whether the circumstances in this matter constitute the sort of “extraordinary” situation or would lead to “gross injustice” that would justify such an order for out-of-turn disposal.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The suit and the civil revision have been unreasonably delayed due to delaying tactics adopted by the other side.
  • Because the petitioner is an elderly lady, she may not live long enough to see the outcome unless the matters are disposed of expeditiously.
  • The petition did not allege that later-filed matters had been decided ahead of hers, nor that the presiding Judge was deliberately refusing to dispose of the case.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any specific arguments advanced on behalf of the respondents.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court interpreted the petitioner's prayer as, in substance, a request for out-of-turn or expeditious disposal of the suit and revision. The Court observed that it did not have access to the docket of the Small Causes Court and could not know whether there were earlier-filed cases involving elderly litigants that remained pending. Noting the common knowledge of systemic delay and the thousands of earlier-instituted matters, the Court reasoned that orders directing expeditious disposal can disrupt the ordinary working of courts: judges who receive such judicial directions may focus on those matters to the detriment of older pending cases, and an influx of such directions can lead to practical impossibilities, contempt proceedings, and personal attendance requirements for judges.

On the proper exercise of the High Court’s power, the Court emphasized restraint. Although the High Court possesses the authority to direct early disposal, that power carries a heightened responsibility and should be exercised sparingly and only in extraordinary circumstances. The Court articulated a limiting principle: an order for expeditious or out-of-turn disposal should be made only when delay would cause "gross injustice," and the Court must ensure that granting such relief will not itself cause injustice to other litigants who have waited longer. The Court further held that such an order is appropriate when there is reason to believe the judge in seisin is deliberately avoiding disposal for an improper motive that would defeat justice.

The Court also stated that, ordinarily, petitioners should be relegated to remedies before the court in seisin of the lis, because that court is best placed to consider the totality of circumstances bearing on case prioritization and disposal.

Applying these principles to the present petition, the Court concluded that the petition did not demonstrate the extraordinary circumstances or gross injustice necessary to justify an order for expeditious or out-of-turn disposal, and that the petition therefore was not fit for grant.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was dismissed. Specifically, the petition was dismissed with costs of Rs. 5,000/-. The petitioner was directed to deposit Rs. 5,000/- into the account of the Allahabad High Court Mediation and Conciliation Centre at Allahabad within four weeks. In the event of failure to deposit within the stipulated time, the District Magistrate, Allahabad was directed to recover the said amount from the petitioner as an arrear of land revenue and deposit it in the said account.

Implications: The direct effect of the decision is that no direction was issued for the out-of-turn disposal of Suit No. 484 of 2007 or Civil Revision No. 257 of 2009, and the petitioner must comply with the costs order. The Court emphasized that the decision reflects the application of a restraint-based principle—that orders for expeditious or out-of-turn hearing are exceptional and should not be issued routinely. The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal precedent beyond applying that principle to the facts of this petition.

    Km. Shobha Bose v. Judge Small Causes & Ors.

    C.K Prasad, C.J and Pankaj Mithal, J.:— This writ petition has been filed for issuance of a direction to respondent no. 1 - Judge, Small Causes [(Civil Judge (Senior Division)] Allahabad, to decide finally Suit No. 484 of 2007 (Sarjeet Kumar Ghoshal v. Km. Shobha Bose) as also to respondent no. 2 - Additional District Judge, Court No. 10, Allahabad to decide Civil Revision No. 257 of 2009 (Sarjeet Kumar Ghoshal v. Km. Shobha Bose) within a fixed time.

    2. Mr. A.M Lal, appearing on behalf of the petitioner, submits that because of delaying tactics adopted by the other side, aforesaid suit is not being disposed of expeditiously. It is further pointed out that in case the suit is not decided expeditiously, the petitioner who is an aged lady may not live long to see its result. It is not the case of the petitioner that cases instituted later on have been decided and for one reason or the other, the Judge in seisin of the case is purposely not disposing of her case.

    3. The prayer made in this petition for expeditious disposal of the suit/revision, in sum and substance, is nothing but a prayer for out of turn hearing of the suit. We are unaware of the docket of the Judge, Small Causes Court in seisin of the matter. We also do not know that suits of earlier years in which old ladies figure, are pending or not. However, it is common knowledge that thousands of cases instituted earlier by persons more aged than the petitioner are unfortunately pending in the Court. It is systemic delay. It is further common knowledge that direction of the nature, if granted, affects the working of the Court and the Judges, in seisin of such cases, remain ordinarily occupied with only those cases in which directions have been given for expeditious disposal and cases filed earlier gets ignored as those litigating from earlier years have no resources to approach this Court seeking expeditious disposal of the matter. It is further common knowledge that many of the Judges, because of sheer number of such directions, are unable to carry out these directions and subjected to contempt proceedings and even personally directed to appear in such proceedings.

    4. Such a prayer made in routine manner can not be granted without serious application of mind. It is high time that we must give serious thought to all these considerations before passing any order for expeditious disposal. We are not oblivion of the fact that this Court does possess power to direct early disposal of the case but as often said more the power greater the responsibility. We are of the opinion that power to direct expeditious disposal of suit or for that matter any lis which, in sum and substance, means out of turn disposal is to be exercised sparingly in extraordinary circumstances and not in a routine manner. It is fit to be exercised only when the Court comes to the conclusion that delay would cause gross injustice. However, while deciding this issue, the Court would bear in mind that it does not cause injustice to other litigants, who are waiting for justice from before because the very nature of order delays cases filed earlier. It causes resentment and dissatisfaction to those who are waiting for justice from before. It should be exercised only when it comes to the notice of this Court that Judge in seisin of the case is purposely avoiding to dispose of the suit for any oblique motive, which may defeat the justice. An order for expeditious disposal in a routine manner can not be countenanced.

    5. We hasten to add that even in such kind of cases, ordinarily this Court would relegate the petitioner to the remedy before the Court in seisin of the lis to take appropriate decision, as it is that Court which can consider the matter in totality of the circumstances.

    6. When tested on the aforesaid parameter, we are of the opinion that direction sought for is not fit to be granted.

    7. We are of the opinion that this petition is absolutely misconceived and is liable to be dismissed with cost and, accordingly, it is dismissed with cost of Rs. 5,000/- to be deposited by the petitioner in the account of the Allahabad High Court Mediation and Conciliation Centre at Allahabad within four weeks. In case she fails to deposit the said amount within the time stipulated, the District Magistrate, Allahabad shall recover the said amount from the petitioner as arrears of land revenue and deposit the same in the aforesaid account.

    8. Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Km. Shobha Bose v. Judge Small Causes & Ors.
    (Dec 17, 2009)