Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • U.P Subordinate Services Selection Commission Act, 1998. The U.P Subordinate Services Selection Commission Act, 1998
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979.(ii) The Uttar Pradesh Regulation
  • U.P Subordinate Services Selection Commission (Repeal) Act, 1998.
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 (in short 1979 Rules)
  • Public Service Commission (Second Amendment) Rules, 1989.6.
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979.(iii)
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979.11.
  • Government Service Regularisation Rules
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1998
  • U.P.P.S Commission) Rules, 1998.4.
  • Rule. 10 of the 1979 Rules
  • authority.5. Rule 10,
  • sub-rule (4).(6)
  • sub-rule (1),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • U.P Subordinate Services Selection Commission Act, 1998. The U.P Subordinate Services Selection Commission Act, 1998
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979.(ii) The Uttar Pradesh Regulation
  • U.P Subordinate Services Selection Commission (Repeal) Act, 1998.
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 (in short 1979 Rules)
  • Public Service Commission (Second Amendment) Rules, 1989.6.
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979.(iii)
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979.11.
  • Government Service Regularisation Rules
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1998
  • U.P.P.S Commission) Rules, 1998.4.
  • Rule. 10 of the 1979 Rules
  • authority.5. Rule 10,
  • sub-rule (4).(6)
  • sub-rule (1),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Ten petitioners challenged the process of appointment and sought regularisation of their services in the Irrigation Department of the State of Uttar Pradesh. Petitioners Nos. 1–9 seek regularisation as Junior Engineers (Civil) and Petitioner No. 10 seeks regularisation as Junior Engineer (Mechanical). They also sought quashing of the selection proceedings conducted by the U.P. Public Service Commission, Allahabad, for these posts.

The petitioners alleged that they were working as Junior Engineers on daily wages under the respondents for about ten years. The opinion provides a schedule of the petitioners' dates of commencement of work (examples: Petitioner No.1 Arvind Kumar Rai — 18-3-1989; Petitioner No.4 Vijai Kumar Arora — 01-1-1984; Petitioner No.5 Jagat Singh Visht — 16-8-1986; Petitioner No.9 Prakash Pandey — 1-11-1985; Petitioner No.10 Lalji Pandey — 01-1-1990).

The State Government had framed various rules concerning regularisation of Class III posts, including the Uttar Pradesh Regulation of Ad hoc Appointment (On Posts Within the Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 ("1979 Rules") and related rules for posts outside the purview of the Public Service Commission and a 1998 Rule set for daily wages Group C posts.

The posts of Junior Engineers fell within the purview of the Public Service Commission. The petitioners contended that by a Notification dated 25-11-1989 the post was excluded from the Public Service Commission and was within the purview of the U.P. Subordinate Services Selection Commission Act, 1998 (which was later repealed). The 1979 Rules, and specifically Rule 4 and an added Rule 10 (by notification dated 7-8-1989), were central to the dispute about entitlement to regularisation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether petitioners who are working on daily wages can be treated as having been appointed on an "ad hoc" basis for purposes of Rule 4 of the U.P. Regularisation of Ad hoc Appointment Rules, 1979.
  2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to regularisation under the 1979 Rules given the cut-off dates (notably the relevance of 1-10-1986 as introduced by Rule 10).
  3. Whether the selection proceedings undertaken by the U.P. Public Service Commission (Advertisement No. 3/98-99) should be quashed or affected by the petitioners' claim to regularisation.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The petitioners rely on the contention that their long service on daily wages entitles them to regularisation as Junior Engineers.
  • They contend that the post was excluded from the purview of the Public Service Commission by a notification of 25-11-1989 and fell within the ambit of the U.P. Subordinate Services Selection Commission Act, 1998 (noting that the Act was later repealed).
  • Counsel for the petitioners argued that Rule 10's cut-off date (1-10-1986) is arbitrary and referred to the 1998 Rules for daily wages Group C posts which provide regularisation eligibility to those appointed on or before 29-6-1991 (seeking parity or broader relief).
  • As an alternative, petitioners' counsel invoked general principles of reasonableness and fair play and cited Supreme Court authorities (Arun Kumar Rout and Urmila Devi) which, in counsel's submission, support regularisation on sympathetic grounds where termination resulted from irregular initial appointments.

The opinion does not set out detailed adversarial submissions by the respondents; the respondent positions are reflected through the court's analysis of statutory rules and prior authorities.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in This Opinion
Khagesh Kumar v. Inspector General of Registration, 1995 Supp (4) SCC 182 : AIR 1996 SC 417 Application of the 1979 Regularisation Rules to regularise services of daily wages employees. The court noted this Supreme Court decision applied the 1979 Rules to daily-wage employees in the Registration Department and treated such employees as eligible under the 1979 Rules; it was relied upon in assessing whether similar treatment should apply here.
Ajai Kumar Misra v. Secretary, U.P. Shasan, 1999 (1) UPLBEC 140 Held that registration clerks appointed on or before 1-10-1986 on daily wages would be deemed ad hoc employees under Rule 4. The court treated this decision as a follow-on authority to Khagesh Kumar and applied the same principle to conclude that petitioners who commenced work before 1-10-1986 may be considered for regularisation under the 1979 Rules.
Arun Kumar Rout v. State of Bihar, (1998) 9 SCC 71 : AIR 1998 SC 1477 Supreme Court held that where services were terminated as irregular, absent fraud the employees should be regularised sympathetically. The petitioners' counsel invoked this authority for sympathetic regularisation; the court observed this line of authority but held these decisions had no application to the facts of the present case.
Urmila Devi v. State of Bihar, 1999 SCC (L&S) 642 Persons working on daily wages for a long period may be considered for regularisation in absence of a statutory right. Cited by petitioners as supportive of equitable regularisation; the court found this authority inapplicable on the facts before it.
State of Himachal Pradesh v. Suresh Kumar Verma, (1996) 7 SCC 562 : AIR 1996 SC 1565 Appointments must follow recruitment rules; daily wages appointments cannot be a conduit to regular appointments; protects recruitment process, efficiency and prevention of nepotism/corruption. The court relied on this authority to reinforce that recruitment must follow the rules and that daily-wage employment cannot be used to claim regularisation where rules do not permit it.
Dr. Arundhati Ajit Pargaonkar v. State of Maharashtra, (1994 Supp (3) SCC 380 : AIR 1995 SC 962) Temporary/permanent nature of work does not automatically entitle one to regularisation where recruitment rules require selection through Public Service Commission; Temporary Government Service Regularisation Rules 1975 could not be invoked for posts under PSC. The court cited this case to support the proposition that temporary or long-standing daily-wage service does not override statutory recruitment procedures for posts within PSC purview.
Dr. M.A. Haque v. Union of India, (1993) 2 SCC 213 Recruitment rules made under Article 309 must be strictly followed; ignoring rules and bypassing PSC opens the door to illegal recruitment. The court quoted this authority (via Pargaonkar) to emphasize the necessity of following recruitment rules and to warn against back-door regularisations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by identifying the central legal question: whether daily-wage employees could be treated as ad hoc appointees within the meaning of Rule 4 of the 1979 Rules. It recognized the ordinary meaning of "ad hoc" from dictionary sources cited in the opinion and stressed that Rule 4 must be interpreted in context of the nature of appointment and the work performed.

The court reviewed authoritative decisions where the 1979 Rules had been applied to daily-wage employees (Khagesh Kumar and Ajai Kumar Misra). Those precedents supported the proposition that employees appointed on or before 1-10-1986 could be treated as ad hoc appointees and considered under Rule 4 for regularisation depending on fulfillment of the Rule's conditions.

Applying those principles to the facts of this case, the court identified Petitioners Nos. 4, 5 and 9 as having start dates prior to 1-10-1986 and held they could be considered for regularisation under the 1979 Rules. The court directed Respondent No.1 to consider their cases for regularisation within two months upon production of a certified copy of the order.

For the remaining petitioners who commenced work after 1-10-1986, the court found they are not covered by the 1979 Rules as amended by Rule 10. The court rejected the petitioners' submission that the cut-off date is arbitrary as well as the argument for parity with the 1998 Rules (which provide a later cut-off of 29-6-1991 for certain Group C posts), noting that parity cannot be claimed from rules not applicable to the petitioners' posts or circumstances.

The court considered but declined to apply equitable doctrines relied upon by petitioners (e.g., Arun Kumar Rout, Urmila Devi) to expand regularisation here, stating those authorities had no application to the facts of this case. The court reiterated the binding principle from prior case law that recruitment rules and constitutionally mandated processes (including the role of the Public Service Commission) must be followed, and that temporary/daily-wage employment does not by itself confer a right to regularisation unless a rule provides for it.

Finally, the court left open the possibility that if the State frames a scheme specifically for regularisation of Junior Engineers, the petitioners (other than Nos. 4, 5 and 9) may be considered under such a scheme.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court's ruling can be summarized as follows:

  • Petitioners Nos. 4, 5 and 9 — ENTITLED to consideration for regularisation under the 1979 Rules. The court ordered Respondent No.1 to consider their cases for regularisation within two months upon production of a certified copy of the order.
  • Other petitioners — NOT COVERED by the 1979 Rules because their dates of commencement are after the cut-off date (1-10-1986) introduced by Rule 10; therefore they are not entitled to regularisation under those Rules on the facts before the court.

Implications:

  • The court did not quash the selection proceedings already conducted by the U.P. Public Service Commission; it noted the selection has taken place and appointments have been made. However, if Petitioners Nos. 4, 5 and 9 are regularised they shall be absorbed on the substantive posts that had been notified by Advertisement No. 3/98-99.
  • The decision establishes the direct effect on the parties named (orders for consideration/denial under the 1979 Rules) and emphasizes adherence to recruitment rules; the court indicated that petitioners not covered by the 1979 Rules could only obtain regularisation if the State framed an applicable scheme. The opinion does not purport to create a broader new precedent beyond applying existing authorities and principles to the facts before it.
  • The writ petition was disposed of in accordance with these observations and directions.

Order: The writ petition is disposed of with the directions and observations summarized above.

    Arvind Kumar Rai And Others v. State Of U.P And Others

    1. Petitioner Nos. 1 to 9 are seeking regularisation of their services on the posts of Junior Engineers (Civil) while petitioner No. 10 is seeking regularisation of his services on the post of Junior Engineer (Mechanical). Besides this the petitioners are seeking the quashing of the selection proceedings undertaken by the U.P Public Service Commission, Allahabad for these posts.

    2. The petitioners allege that they are working as Junior Engineers in the Irrigation Department of the State of U.P on daily wages under the respondents at least for the last about ten years. The details as regards the dates since when they started working are given below:

    Names Dates of starting work Departments 1-Arvind Kumar Rai 18-3-1989 Flood Works Division, Allahabad 2-Avdhesh Narain 01-3-1990 -do- 3-Mahanarain Kushwaha 01-1-1991 Bagla Canal Division, Allahabad 4-Vijai Kumar Arora 01-1-1984 Irrigation Division, Rudrapur 5-Jagat Singh Visht 16-8-1986 Kosi Ninnan Khand-2, Ramnagar 6-Anil Kumar Singh 1-11-1987 Musa Khand Bandh Prakhand, Varanasi 7-Hari Shanker Pandey 20-9-1989 —do— 8-Raghvendra Kaushik 1-11-1987 Upari Ganga Nahar, Aligarh 9-Prakash Pandey 1-11-1985 Tarai Sichai Khand, Nainital 10-Lalji Pandey 01-1-1990 Flood Works Division, Allahabad

    3. The State Government has framed various rules in regard to regularisation of Class III posts. They are as under:

    (i) The Uttar Pradesh Regulation of Ad hoc Appointment (On Posts Within the Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979.

    (ii) The Uttar Pradesh Regulation of Ad hoc Appointments (On Posts Outside the Purview of the Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979.

    (iii) The U.P Regularisation of Daily Wages Appointment on Group C Posts (Outside the Purview of U.P.P.S Commission) Rules, 1998.

    4. The posts of Junior Engineers (Civil) and (Mechanical) come within the purview of Public Service Commission. A person who is selected by the Public Service Commission is entitled for appointment to the post of Junior Engineer. The contention of the petitioners is that the post of Junior Engineer in the Irrigation Department was a post which was excluded from the purview of U.P Public Service Commission by Notification dated 25-11-1989 and the same was with in the purview of U.P Subordinate Services Selection Commission Act, 1998. The U.P Subordinate Services Selection Commission Act, 1998 has been repealed by the U.P Subordinate Services Selection Commission (Repeal) Act, 1998. Those petitioners who are covered by the U.P Regularisation of Ad hoc Appointment (On Posts Within the Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 (in short 1979 Rules) can be considered for regularisation of appointments under Rule 4 which reads as under:

    “4. Regulation of ad hoc appointments.

    (1) Any person who—

    (i) was directly appointed on ad hoc basis before January 1, 1977 and is continuing in service, as such, on the date of commencement of these rules;

    (ii) possessed requisite qualifications prescribed for regular appointment at the time of such ad hoc appointment; and

    (iii) has completed or, as the case may be, after he has completed three years continuous in permanent or temporary vacancy as may be available on the basis of his record and suitability before any regular appointment is made in such vacancy in acordance with the relevant service rules or orders.

    (2) In making regular appointment under these rules, reservation for the candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Backward Classes and other categories, shall be made in accordance with the orders of the Government in force at the time of recruitment.

    (3) For the purpose of sub-rule (1), the appointing authority shall constitute a Selection Committee and consultation with the Commission shall not be necessary.

    (4) The appointing authority shall prepare an eligibility list of the candidates, arranged in order of seniority as determined, from the date of order of appointment and if two or more persons are appointed together, from the order in which their names are arranged in the said appointment order. The list shall be placed before the Selection Committee along with their character rolls and such other records, pertaining to them, as may be considered necessary to judge their suitability.

    (5) The Selection Committee shall consider the cases of the candidates on the basis of their records referred to in sub-rule (4).

    (6) The Selection Committee shall prepare a list of selected candidates, the names in the list being arranged in order of seniority, and forward it to the appointing authority.”

    5. Rule 10, however, was added to 1979 Rules by Notification dated 7-8-1989 providing that these rules shall apply mutatis mutandis also to any person directly appointed on ad hoc basis on or beofre Oct. 1, 1986 and continuing in service as such, on the date of commencement of the U.P Regularisation of Ad hoc Appointments (On Posts Outside the Purview of the Public Service Commission (Second Amendment) Rules, 1989.

    6. The question, however, remains as to whether the petitioners who are working on daily wages can be treated to have been appointed on ad hoc basis. A person who is appointed on daily wages cannot normally be treated to have been appointed on ad hoc basis. Rule 4 has, however, is to be interpreted in the context and nature of the appointment and the work on which a person is employed.

    7. According to the Welster's Encyclopedic Unabridged of Dictionary of English Language ‘ad hoc’ means “for this (special purpose); with respect to this (subject or thing).”

    8. According to Words and Phrases (Permanent Edition) Volume 2 ‘ad hoc’ means “The word ‘spread* as used in relation to the appointrnent of special curator, has very much the same meaning as the words ‘ad hoc’, which is the original while special is the translation.

    9. According to the Law Lexicon by P. Ramanath Aiyar ‘ad hoc’ means “for partlcular purpose made, established, acting or concerned with a particular and or purpose.”

    10. The Supreme Court in-the case of Khagesh Kumar v. Inspector General of Registration reported in 1995 Supp (4) SCC 182 : (AIR 1996 SC 417) has applied the 1979 Regularisation Rules for regularising the services of daily wages employees of the Registration Department of the State. This decision was followed in Ajai Kumar Misra v. Secretary, U.P Shasan, 1999 (1) UPLBEC 140, wherein it has been held that the Registration. Clerk appointed on or before 1-10-1986 on daily wages, in the view of the sanction given by the Government for such post, would be deemed to be taken ad hoc employees within the meaning of Rule 4 of the U.P Regularisation of Ad hoc Appointments (On Posts Outside the Purview of the Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979.

    11. Petitioner Nos. 4, 5 and 9 who are claiming to have been working since prior to 1-10-1986, can be considered for regularisation under the 1979 Rules referred to above. The respondent No. 1 shall consider them for regularisation within two months from the date of production of a certified copy of this order.

    12. As regards other petitioners, since they are working on daily wages after 1-10-1986 they are not covered by the 1979 Rules.

    13. Shri Ashok Khare, learned counsel for the petitioners, submitted that the cut off date mentioned under Rule. 10 of the 1979 Rules is arbitrary. He has referred to the U.P Regularisation of Daily Wages Appointment on Group C Posts (Outside the Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1998 whereunder the daily wages employees appointed on or before 29-6-1991 are entitled to be regularised. A person cannot claim parity in respect of regularisation relying upon the provisions of Rules, which are not applicable in the case of the petitioners. It is for the State Government to consider as to whether an employee is to be regularised or not under the Rules framed by it.

    14. The next contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners is that if the petitioners are not entitled to be regularised under 1979 Rules then they will be entitled to be regularised under the general principles of reasonableness and fair play. He has referred to the decision rendered in Arun Kumar Rout. v. State of Bihar, (1998) 9 SCC 71 : AIR 1998 SC 1477, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that if after appointments the service were terminated on the ground that initial appointments were irregular, unless it is shown that the employees concerned had committed fraud, they should be regularised taking sympathetic consideration. In Urmila Devi v. State of Bihar, 1999 SCC (L&S) 642, it has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that the persons working on daily wages basis in the State of Bihar for a long period may be considered for regularisation in absence of statutory right of regularisation. These cases have no application to the facts of the present case.

    15. One view is that the posts are to be filled in accordance with the rules for appointment to the posts and a person cannot be brought in regular service merely because he was given employment on daily wages for one reason or the other. If the person who was given appointment on daily wages or on ad hoc basis, is entitled to participate in the selection for the posts but if he keeps himself out from the selection process, he cannot turn up and say to regularise his servics merely because he had worked on daly wages. The other view is that the persons who are working for a long period should not be thrown out rather they should be regularised in service.

    16. In State of Himachal Pradesh v. Suresh Kumar Verma, 1996 (2) SLR 321 : ((1996) 7 SCC 562 : AIR 1996 SC 1565) (SC) it was held that the appointment is to be made in accordance with the rules and the State is bound to follow the same and to have the selection of the candidates made as per recruitment rules. The Court observed that theappoint-ment of persons on daily wages cannot be a conduit pipe for regular appointments which would be a back door entry, detrimental to the efficiency of service and would breed seeds of nepotism and corruption.

    17. In Dr. Arundhati Ajit Pargaonkar v. State of Maharashtra, (1995) 1 UPLBEC 93 : (1994 Supp (3) SCC 380 : AIR 1995 SC 962) the appellant claimed regularisation on the ground that she had worked on a permanent post for about nine years but her contention was repelled on the ground that the recruitment was to be made in accordance with the rules and a person appointed temporarily was not entitled for regularisation. The claim of the appellant for regularisation was also rejected on the ground that the post was within the purview of the Public Service Commission and the Temporary Government Service Regularisation Rules issued by the Government in 1975 could not be made applicable in the larger interest of such persons who are not covered by the Rules. The Court referred to the observations made in the decision rendered in Dr. M.A Haque v. Union of India, (1993) 2 SCC 213 (219) : (1993 Lab IC 996) as follows at page 964-965; of AIR 1995:

    “……………we cannot lose sight of the fact that the recruitment rules made under Art. 309 of the Constitution have to be followed strictly and not in breach. If a disregard of the rules and the by-passing of the Public Service Commission are permitted, it will open to back-door for illegal recruitment without limit. In fact this Court has, of late, been witnessing a constant violation of the recruitment rules and a scant respect for the constitutional provisions requiring recruitment to the services through the Public Service Commission. It appears that since this Court has in some cases permitted regularisation of the irregularly recruited employees, some Governments and authorities have been increasingly resorting to irregular recruitment. The result has been that the recruitment rules and the Public Service Commissions have been kept in cold storage and candidate dictated by various considerations are being recruited as a matter of course,”

    18. A person who is appointed on daily wages cannot claim a better position from those persons who were appointed on ad hoc or on temporary basis. If a person appointed on temporary basis cannot be regularised in service under the regularisation rules, a person working on daily wages can also not be regularised unless there is any rule for regularisation of his services.

    19. It is, however, made clear that if the Government frames any scheme for regularisation in respect of Junior Engineers, the petitioners other than petitioner. Nos. 4, 5 and 9 may be considered for regularisation under the said scheme.

    20. The petitioners have challenged the selection process undertaken by the U.P Public Service Commission. Allahabad for the post of Junior Engineers in pursuance of the Advertisement No. 3/98-99 on the ground that unless they are regularised, no further appointments be made. The selection has alredy taken place and the appointments have also been made. It is made clear that if petitioner Nos. 4, 5 and 9 are regularised in service they shall be absorbed on the substantive posts, which were notified by advertisement No. 3/98-99. The writ petition is disposed of with the above observations.

    21. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Arvind Kumar Rai And Others v. State Of U.P And Others
    (Mar 30, 2001)