AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 49 INDIAN REGISTRATION ACT
  • Rs.10/-. Article 40 of Schedule 1-A of the Indian stamp Act
  • 8 Section 2 (15) of the Indian Stamp act
  • SECTION 35 INDIAN STAMP ACT
  • Sec.2 (15) of the Indian stamp Act,
  • Sec.35 of the Indian Stamp Act,
  • Sec.35 of Indian stamp Act
  • P. (Amendment) Act 17 of 1986
  • Sec.35 of the stamp Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 49 INDIAN REGISTRATION ACT
  • Rs.10/-. Article 40 of Schedule 1-A of the Indian stamp Act
  • 8 Section 2 (15) of the Indian Stamp act
  • SECTION 35 INDIAN STAMP ACT
  • Sec.2 (15) of the Indian stamp Act,
  • Sec.35 of the Indian Stamp Act,
  • Sec.35 of Indian stamp Act
  • P. (Amendment) Act 17 of 1986
  • Sec.35 of the stamp Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This civil revision petition challenges the order dated 21.10.2009 in O.S. No.162 of 2005 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge, Vizianagaram, which permitted an unmarked document dated 7.11.1990 described as a "partition list" (pampakapu jabitha) to be admitted in evidence.

The petitioners are the plaintiffs in the original suit, which sought a declaration that they are the absolute owners of the plaint-schedule house and a permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with their possession and enjoyment. The defendants contested the suit and, after initial evidence on both sides, obtained permission (by applications IA Nos. 789 of 2008 and 789 of 2008 — one to reopen evidence and one to recall DW1) to reopen defence evidence and recall DW1. During further chief examination of DW1 the defendants sought to mark the disputed unregistered document dated 7.11.1990 as an exhibit. The plaintiffs objected on the grounds that the document was not on proper paper, insufficiently stamped, unregistered and in substance a partition deed (hence inadmissible). The Senior Civil Judge admitted the document on the premise that it was only a partition list and not a partition deed and therefore did not require stamp duty or registration. The plaintiffs challenged that admission by filing the present revision petition.

Factual contentions in the record: the first plaintiff claimed acquisition of the property by a registered sale deed dated 16.3.1970 and a later registered settlement deed dated 12.8.1993 in favour of plaintiffs 2–4; they claim continuous possession. The defendants assert the property belongs to their family for over 90 years and deny the plaintiffs' title. The defendants' written statement did not describe the alleged partition or how their family became owner; the disputed partition document was produced only when DW1's evidence was reopened.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the unregistered document dated 7.11.1990 described as a "pampakapu jabitha" (partition list) is in substance an instrument of partition (a partition deed) or merely a memorandum/list, having regard to its contents rather than its caption.
  2. Whether such a document, if it is an instrument of partition or a memorandum of past partition, must be stamped and/or registered under the Indian Stamp Act (Article 40 of Schedule I-A and Section 2(15)) and whether it is inadmissible if insufficiently stamped (Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act).
  3. Whether an unregistered or insufficiently stamped partition instrument can nonetheless be admitted in evidence for collateral purposes (the scope of the proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act and relevant case law), and whether that exception applies when the document is sought to be used as the source of title.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners / Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The disputed document is in substance a partition deed (not a mere list) and therefore requires proper stamping and registration; it is insufficiently stamped (total stamp value Rs.10/-) and unregistered and thus inadmissible in evidence under Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act.
  • The plaintiffs rely on authorities (including A. Krishna & another v. A. Arjun Rao, 2004 (3) ALD 34 as referenced) to support the contention that the document is inadmissible; they assert that defendants cannot use the document to prove title when it fails statutory formalities.

Respondents / Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants contended that the disputed document was a record/memorandum of a prior family partition and that an unregistered partition deed may be admissible in evidence for collateral purposes (to prove prior partition, division of status, or nature/character of possession), relying on the decision in Pallapothu Naga Prasad & others v. Pallapothu Venkata Krishna Rao & others, 2003 (1) ALD 251 = 2003 (6) ALT 631.
  • The defendants also relied on precedents such as Majeti Basavamma & others v. Majeti Venkateswara Rao & others, 2006 (4) ALD 260 and Amangenti Prameela & another v. P. Venkat Reddy (Died) by LRs & others, 2004 (3) ALD 66 to support the proposition that a family arrangement or memorandum of prior partition may not be compulsorily registrable and, in some circumstances, may not itself create or extinguish rights if it contemplates execution of a later document.
  • Practically, defendants sought to use the disputed document to establish that a family partition had occurred and thereby to found title in their favour.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pallapothu Naga Prasad & others v. Pallapothu Venkata Krishna Rao & others, 2003 (1) ALD 251 = 2003 (6) ALT 631 Holds that an unregistered partition deed is admissible in evidence for the limited purpose of establishing prior partition or to non-suit partition claims, provided it is not used as the source of title to the properties. The court acknowledged the proposition but distinguished the present case: here the defendants intended to rely on the document as evidence of title (the main purpose) and not merely for a collateral purpose; therefore the authority did not permit admission in the present facts.
Rachakonda Ramakoteswara Rao & others v. Manohar Fuel Centre, Nereducherla, Khammam & another, 2003 (2) ALD 638 Holds that Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act is an absolute bar — an instrument not duly stamped cannot be received in evidence for any purpose, and cannot be used even for a limited or collateral purpose; distinct from Section 49 of the Registration Act which permits limited collateral inquiry into unregistered documents. The court relied on this authority to conclude that Section 35 operates as an absolute bar to the admission of an insufficently stamped instrument of partition and that the disputed document is therefore inadmissible for any purpose.
Majeti Basavamma & others v. Majeti Venkateswara Rao & others, 2006 (4) ALD 260 States that a record of family arrangement or settlement already made does not by itself create or extinguish rights in immovable property and is not compulsorily registrable; if a document contemplates execution of a separate registered document later, it cannot be treated as conferring rights or creating interest. The court observed this proposition was not disputed, but distinguished it from the present case because the disputed document, as read, appears to create rights and extinguish rights in favour of specific parties and did not contemplate future execution and registration of a separate document; consequently the precedent was found not applicable to these facts.
Amangenti Prameela & another v. P. Venkat Reddy (Died) by LRs & others, 2004 (3) ALD 66 The specific rule relied upon by the respondents is not set out in detail in the opinion excerpt provided. The respondents relied on this decision, but the court held it was not applicable to the facts of the present case. The opinion does not elaborate the stated rule from this precedent.
A. Krishna & another v. A. Arjun Rao & another, 2004 (3) ALD 34 The opinion indicates the petitioners placed reliance on this authority; the specific principle cited is not described in the provided text. The opinion records that petitioners relied on this case, but does not set out a specific application or detailed treatment of this precedent in the court's reasons as provided in the text.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in the following logical steps, grounded in the statutory provisions and the contents of the disputed document:

  1. Character of the Document — Nomenclature Irrelevant: The court reiterated the established principle that the caption or nomenclature of a document (how it is described) is not decisive; the court must determine the true nature and character of the instrument from its contents. The document dated 7.11.1990 was therefore examined on its face.
  2. Contents of the Document: The disputed document, written on stamped papers totaling Rs.10/-, stated a prior partition of movables occurring 15 years earlier, and described how vacant sites were later partitioned in the presence of elders; it identified 'a' schedule and 'b' schedule vacant sites and records that the partition arrangement is made absolute and forever. The schedule detailed survey numbers, extents and boundaries.
  3. Not a Mere List but a Partition Instrument in Substance: A close reading showed the document did more than recite past division; it sought to put partition of vacant sites into effect and created vested allocations (with no clear recital that a later, registrable document was to be executed). Consequently the court concluded that, despite the caption "partition list," the instrument was in substance a partition deed or instrument of partition rather than a mere inventory or list.
  4. Statutory Consequences under the Stamp Act: Article 40 of Schedule I-A of the Indian Stamp Act imposes stamp duty on instruments of partition (same duty as a bottomry bond for amount/market value of separated shares). Section 2(15) (as amended by A.P. (Amendment) Act 17 of 1986) explicitly includes a "memorandum regarding past partition" within the definition of "instrument of partition". Therefore, even a memorandum of past partition is chargeable with stamp duty according to market value of the share.
  5. Section 35 — Absolute Bar to Admission if Not Duly Stamped: Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act provides that instruments chargeable with duty shall not be admitted in evidence unless duly stamped. The court treated Section 35 as an absolute bar: an insufficently stamped instrument of partition cannot be admitted in evidence for any purpose.
  6. Distinction from Registration Act Collateral Exception: The court addressed the defendants' reliance on case law permitting use of unregistered partition instruments for collateral purposes under the proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act. The court found that the proviso to Section 49 cannot overcome the absolute prohibition under Section 35 of the Stamp Act where the instrument is insufficiently stamped. Also, crucially, in the present case the defendants intended to use the document as the source of title (the main purpose), not merely for a collateral purpose — thus there was no basis to treat the disputed document as admissible on the ground of a collateral exception.
  7. Consideration of Precedents: The court considered and distinguished authorities relied on by both parties:
    • The Pallapothu decision (2003) was acknowledged for the limited rule that an unregistered partition deed may be admissible for collateral purposes but was distinguished because the defendants in the present case were using the document to found title (not collateral use).
    • The Rachakonda decision (2003) was relied upon to emphasize that Section 35 is an absolute bar and that an insufficently stamped instrument cannot be admitted even for limited/collateral purposes.
    • Majeti Basavamma (2006) and Amangenti Prameela (2004) were considered; the court noted these authorities but found them inapplicable where the present document created substantive rights and did not contemplate future execution and registration of a separate document.
  8. Conclusion of Reasoning: Because the disputed document was in substance an instrument of partition (or at least a memorandum of past partition within the statutory definition), and because it was insufficiently stamped and unregistered, Section 35 of the Stamp Act rendered it inadmissible in evidence for any purpose. The Senior Civil Judge's conclusion that it was only a partition list (and therefore not chargeable or registrable) was held to be unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned order dated 21.10.2009 permitting the admission of the disputed document into evidence is set aside. The civil revision petition is allowed. There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The disputed document dated 7.11.1990 (described as "pampakapu jabitha") is held inadmissible in evidence because it is an instrument of partition or a memorandum of past partition that is insufficiently stamped and unregistered; consequently it cannot be used by the defendants in the trial court to prove title or to non-suit the plaintiffs.
  • Scope on broader legal questions: The court reaffirmed the principle that the true character of a document is to be discerned from its contents and emphasized the primacy of Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act as an absolute bar to admission of inadequately stamped instruments chargeable with duty; where a document is chargeable under the Stamp Act, the proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act cannot be used to admit an insufficiently stamped instrument for collateral purposes. The opinion, however, confines its holding to the facts as analyzed and does not purport to create a new broader precedent beyond applying the cited statutory provisions and authorities to the circumstances of this case.

No other orders were made in the text provided beyond allowing the revision and recording "no order as to costs."

    Pariti Suryakanthamma And Another v. Saripalli Srinivasa Rao And Another

    JUDGEMENT :-

    1 This civil revision petition is directed against the order dated 21,10.2009 in OS No.162 of 2005, on the file of the senior Civil Judge, Vizianagaram, wherein an unmarked document dated 7.11.1990 described as partition list (pampakapu jabitha)was permitted to be admitted in evidence.

    2 Heard the learned Counsel appearing for both sides. Perused the record.

    3 The petitioners herein are the plaintiffs. They filed the suit against the respondents/defendants for a declaration that they are the absolute owners of the plaint schedule house and for a permanent injunction restraining the respondents/ defendants from interfering with their possession and enjoyment. The respondents/ defendants filed written statement and contested the suit. During trial, evidence was recorded on both sides and the matter stood posted for arguments. At that stage, the defendants filed IA No.789 of 2008 to reopen the evidence and another IA No.79g of 2008 to recall DW1 for further chief examination. The said applications were allowed on 31.8.2009. During the further chief-examination of DW1, the defendants sought to mark an unregistered document titled as 'pampakapu jabitha' (partition list) dated 7.11.1990 as an exhibit. The plaintiffs opposed the same on the ground that the said document is neither written on proper paper nor registered and the said document being a partition deed is inadmissible in evidence. After hearing both sides regarding the admissibility or otherwise of the said document, the learned Senior Civil Judge, by the impugned order dated 21.10.2009, permitted the defendants to mark the said document as an exhibit on the premise that the said document is only a partition list and not a partition deed and, therefore, does not require any stamp duty or registration. Aggrieved by the same, the plaintiffs preferred the present revision.

    4 According to the plaintiffs, the first plaintiff was the absolute owner of the plaint schedule house having purchased the same under a registered sale deed dated 16.3.1970 from Mula Narasamma, who got the same by inheritance and as the first plaintiff had no issues, she settled 1he western half portion of the plaint schedule site in favour of her brothers' sons i. e. , plaintiffs 2, 3 and 4 under a registered settlement deed dated 12.8.1993 and ever since they have been in continuous possession and enjoyment of the same. They would further contend that the defendants have no right, tide or interest. Hence, they filed the suit for declaration of their title and also for a permanent injunction restraining the respondents/ defendants from interfering with their possession and enjoyment. The defendants, on the other hand, would contend that the said property and other properties belong to the defendants' family since over 90 years and above and they have been in possession and enjoyment of the same and the first plaintiff had no right, title or interest and the alleged settlement deed in favour of plaintiffs 2 to 4 is void and not binding on the defendants.

    5 The written statement is, however, silent about the alleged partition. The written statement, does not, however specify as to how the defendants' family became owner of the plaint schedule property. After the evidence of the DW1 was sought to be reopened, the defendants produced the disputed document, which purports to be a partition list. The plaintiffs objected for marking the said document on the ground that it is a partition deed and is, therefore, inadmissible and is written on insufficiently stamped paper and is not a registered one and is, therefore, inadmissible in evidence. The document is described as pampakapu jabitha (partition list ).

    6 It is well settled that the nomenclature used for describing the document is of no consequence and the nature and character of the document has to be discerned only from its contents. The document is dated 7.11.1990 and is written on stamped papers worth Rs.3/-, 3/-, 2/-, re.1/- and 1/-. The document states that a partition of movable properties had already taken place 15 years back and the movable properties were enjoyed separately by the respective sharers all these years. It further states that the document schedule mentioned vacant sites were, however, kept joint but subsequently they were also partitioned in the presence of elders and in the said partition, 'a' schedule vacant site fell to the first party and 'b' schedule vacant site fell to the share of the second party and both parties have taken possession of their respective shares even prior to the date of the document. It further purports to state that the document is now executed by way of a record of prior partition. The learned Senior Civil Judge observed that the recitals of the documents show that the partition of the property between the sharers had already taken place 15 years back and the same is reduced to writing in the form of a partition list under the disputed document The reference to partition 15 years back in the document is only with regard to movables. Though the document refers to prior partition of the vacant sites, it is not stated as to when and how long prior to the date of the document the said partition of the vacant sites had taken place. The document does not also specify any reason as to why it was felt necessary to reduce the same into writing. The document further stipulates that the partition arrangement is made absolute and put in vogue forever and further stipulates that neither of the parities shall ever complain nor dispute about the said partition. The schedule of the document narrates the details of the properties with reference to the survey numbers, extents and boundaries that fell to the share of each of the parties. A close reading of the entire document would disclose that though the document is captioned as a partition list, it is not a partition list simplicitor, which merely contains list of the items of property that fell to the share of each of the persons, but is a document whereunder partition of the vacant sites is sought to be made. A mere recital to the effect that partition had already taken place without specifying as to when the said partition had taken place and the same is now reduced to writing by way of a list, does not conceal the true nature and character of the document from being a partition deed in view of the other recitals contained in the document. The finding of the learned Senior civil Judge that it is only a partition list and not a partition deed is, therefore, unsustainable.

    7 The objection for the admissibility of the document is twofold - firstly, it is prepared on insufficiently stamped paper and secondly it is an unregistered document drafted on total stamp paper worth Rs.10/-. Article 40 of Schedule 1-A of the Indian stamp Act states that instrument of partition carries the same duty as a Bottomry Bond for the amount or the market value of the separated share or shares of the property.

    8 Section 2 (15) of the Indian Stamp act defines instrument of partition' as follows:

    '"instrument of Partition'" means any instrument whereby co-owners of any property divide or agree to divide such property in severalty, and includes also a final order for effecting a partition passed by any revenue authority or any civil Court and an award by an Arbitrator directing a partition (and a memorandum regarding past partition ). It can, therefore, be seen that a memorandum regarding past partition is also brought within the definition of 'instrument of partition' by A. P. (Amendment) Act 17 of 1986 w. e. f.16.8.1986. By virtue of the said amendment, a memorandum regarding past partition also amounts to instrument of partition requiring same duty as a bottomry bond for the amount or the market value of the separated share or shares. Even assuming that the disputed document is only a memorandum of past partition, still it is required to be drafted on stamp paper as per the market value of the share. The disputed document is, therefore, insufficiently stamped.

    9 Section 35 of the Indian Stamp act contains a bar against admissibility of such document in evidence and the same reads as follows: instruments tut duly stamped inadmissible in evidence etc :-

    No instrument chargeable with duty shall be admitted in evidence for any purpose by any person having by law or consent of parities, authority to receive evidence, or shall be acted upon, registered or authenticated by any such person or by any public officer, unless such instrument is duly stamped. In view of the bar contained in Sec.35 of the Indian stamp Act, the disputed document becomes inadmissible in evidence for any purpose.

    10 The learned Counsel for respondents/defendants would contend that even an unregistered partition deed is admissible in evidence for the purpose of proving a collateral purpose like division of the status and nature and character of possession and in that connection he relied on a decision in Pallapothu Naga Prasad and others V/s. Pallapothu Venkata Krishna rao and others, 2003 (1) ALD 251 = 2003 (6) ALT 631, wherein it was held as follows:

    "an unregistered partition deed is admissible in evidence and can be looked into for non-suiting the claims for partition on the ground of prior partition, as long as the said document is not used as the source of title to any of the properties which erstwhile coparceners hold as a result of that partition."

    The above proposition is not disputed. In the above case also it is observed that the document is admissible in evidence as long as it is not used as source of title. In the present case, which is not a suit for partition but is a suit filed for declaration on the ground that the plaintiffs are the absolute owners of the property, the defendants sought to produce the disputed document to non-suit the plaintiffs and to prove their contention that they are the absolute owners of the property, as they got the same in a family partition. The defendants, therefore, intend to rely on the disputed document to prove their title to the suit property. The disputed document, according to the defendants, is the evidence of their title to the property. The purpose for which the defendants wanted to mark the disputed document in evidence is not for a collateral purpose but for the main purpose of proving their alleged title to the suit property. The question of admitting the disputed document in evidence for any collateral purpose by virtue of proviso to Sec.49 (c) of the registration Act does not, therefore, arise.

    11 In that connection, the learned counsel for the petitioners placed reliance on a. Krishna and another V/s. A. Arjun Rao and another, 2004 (3) ALD 34.

    12 In Rachakonda Ramakoteswara rao and others V/s. Manohar Fuel Centre, nereducherla, Khammam and another, 2003 (2) ALD 638, this Court held as follows;

    "the bar engrafted under Sec.35 of the stamp Act is an absolute bar and, therefore, the document cannot be used for any purpose, unlike the bar contained in section 49 of the Indian Registration Act (for brevity 'the Registration Act' ). Under the proviso incorporated under Sec.49 of the Registration Act, the document can be looked into even if it is not registered for collateral purpose or other purpose specified inter alia in the proviso, The learned counsel appearing for the first respondent endeavours to make a distinction between the expression "as evidence" and the other expression' in evidence' and contends that although a document cannot be received as evidence, the same can be looked into for a collateral matter for the purpose of showing the signature. This contention cannot be acceded, having regard to the fact that it is an absolute bar engrafted under Sec.35 of the stamp Act, Without receiving the document in evidence, it cannot be used even for the limited purpose. For admitting the document in evidence, it is got to be duly stamped although the purpose might be a different one. Therefore, the document in the first instance shall have to be received or admitted in evidence. Even for that the bar contained under Sec.35 of the Stamp operates".

    In the present case also, the document is both insufficiently stamped and unregistered. The bar contained in Sec.35 of the Indian stamp Act being an absolute one, the document even assuming to be a memorandum of past partition, still coming within the definition of 'instrument of partition' under Sec.2 (15) of the Indian stamp Act, is inadmissible in evidence for any purpose including a collateral purpose.

    13 The learned Counsel for the respondents/defendants would rely on another decision in Majeti Basavamma and others v. Majeti Venkateswara Rao and others, 2006 (4) ALD 260 wherein it was held that a record of family arrangement or settlement already made by itself does not create or extinguish any rights in immovable property and is, therefore, not compulsorily registrable and where a document provides for execution of separate document and registration thereof at a later point of time, it cannot be treated as one conferring any rights or creating interest in the property. The above proposition is also not disputed. In the present case, the disputed document though purports to be a record of prior partition is in effect a document whereunder rights are created in favour of one party and extinguished for the other party regarding the respective items and the said document does not also contemplate execution of any regular partition deed in future. For the same reason, the decision in amangenti Prameela and another V/s. P. Venkat Reddy (Died) by LRs and others, 2004 (3) ALD 66, relied on by the learned counsel for the respondents/defendants is not applicable to the facts of the present case.

    14 In fact, the defendants sought to produce and rely on the disputed document not for any collateral purpose but for the main purpose of proving their alleged title to the suit property and thereby non-suit the plaintiffs. The document is, therefore, inadmissible in evidence both in view of the bar contained under Sec.35 of Indian stamp Act as being insufficiently stamped, and also in view of Sec.49 of the registration Act.

    15 In the circumstances, the impugned order permitting the admission of the document into evidence is held unsustainable and the same is accordingly set aside.

    16 In the result, the civil revision petition is allowed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pariti Suryakanthamma And Another v. Saripalli Srinivasa Rao And Another
    (Feb 8, 2010)