Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — C.K. Thakker, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (identified in the record as Shri B.N. Patel in the relevant merit list) seeks quashing of an order dated July 31, 1981 passed by the Manager, Government Central Press, Gandhinagar (respondent No. 3). The petitioner asked the Court to refix his seniority vis-à-vis certain named respondents (the opinion records disputes involving respondent No. 4, K.H. Raval, and other respondents variously described as Nos. 5 and 6 in different parts of the record) and to grant him a deemed date of promotion to the posts of Assistant Compose Foreman and Compose Foreman with consequential benefits.

The petitioner’s factual assertions (as set out in the petition) include: initial appointment as a Compositor on daily wages at Bhavnagar on 14 November 1949, regularized on 1 January 1954; promotion to Assistant Composing Foreman in December 1961; and promotion to Compose Foreman on 3 January 1964. He contended that his seniority was not fixed in accordance with law, resulting in his being erroneously shown junior to employees appointed later (the petition refers to respondents appointed in June 1960 and November 1969 in one place) and thereby being superseded for promotion.

The respondents filed an affidavit (sworn by K.H. Cherian, Under Secretary, Industries, Mines and Power Department) contesting the claim. They explained the recruitment and seniority position at the newly established Ahmedabad (and later Gandhinagar) press: when posts of Assistant Compose Foreman were to be filled in 1961, the feeding cadre at Ahmedabad was not available, and selection was made by inviting applications from other presses and from the open market. A merit list prepared in 1961 placed the petitioner at Sr. No. 4, with respondent Nos. 4 and 5 above him; dates of joining the Assistant Compose Foreman cadre in October–December 1961 are recorded in that list.

The record shows administrative consideration of the petitioner’s claim in 1974 and 1975 (the Government rejected the claim after review), a communication in 1980 that was characterized by the Court as a show-cause/notice, and the final administrative order dated July 31, 1981 which the petitioner challenged in this petition. The High Court dismissed the petition; Rule 15 was discharged and no order as to costs was made.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the administrative order dated July 31, 1981 should be quashed and the petitioner’s seniority refixed so that he is treated as senior to certain other employees (and given deemed dates of promotion and consequential benefits) — in other words, whether the petitioner’s seniority was wrongly fixed and requires correction.
  2. Whether the petition is barred by delay and laches given the passage of a long period (the petitioner’s appointment at the relevant cadre in 1961 and challenge many years later), and whether the Court should exercise its discretion under Article 226 in those circumstances.
  3. On the merits, whether seniority for the cadre of Assistant Compose Foreman should be determined by length of service in the original (lower) cadre or by the date of entry into the Assistant Compose Foreman cadre (i.e., whether prior service in the lower cadre is material for fixing seniority in the promoted cadre).
  4. Whether principles of natural justice were violated by the impugned administrative order (the petitioner alleged the July 31, 1981 order was passed without notice or opportunity of hearing).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented by Miss S.M. Thakkar for Mr. P.N. Thakkar)

  • The petitioner entered Government Press service in November 1949, earlier than respondent Nos. 4 and 6, and that earlier entry should have governed seniority fixation.
  • When promoted/transferred in 1961 to Assistant Compose Foreman, the relevant date of entry in the original cadre (the petitioner’s long prior service) was not considered for fixing seniority; had it been, the petitioner would have been shown senior to respondents.
  • The petitioner relied on an earlier order (dated in 1980) which, she submitted, upheld the petitioner’s claim and placed him at Sr. No. 1; the later order of July 31, 1981 disturbed that position without issuing notice or affording hearing, thereby violating principles of natural justice.
  • The petitioner sought declaration of his seniority as senior to the named respondents and deemed dates of promotion with consequential benefits.

Respondents' Arguments (as presented by affidavit and Miss Doshit for respondents)

  • The respondents conceded that promotion to Assistant Compose Foreman was to be by promotion from senior Compositors with ten years’ service on the basis of seniority and merit, but stressed that after the bifurcation of Bombay State and establishment of a new press at Ahmedabad (and later Gandhinagar), seniority lists were maintained presswise and there was no common seniority across presses.
  • At the time posts at Ahmedabad had to be filled (September/October 1961), no feeding cadre existed there, so the Government invited applications from other presses and the open market; selection produced a merit list in which the petitioner was placed at Sr. No. 4 while respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were placed above him (Sr. Nos. 2 and 3 respectively).
  • Dates recorded in the merit list show respondent Nos. 4 and 5 joined the Assistant Compose Foreman cadre in October and November 1961, while the petitioner joined in December 1961 — therefore they were properly senior in the cadre. The relevant date for fixation of seniority in the Assistant Compose Foreman cadre is entry into that cadre itself, not prior service in the lower cadre.
  • The petitioner had earlier representations rejected by the Government in 1974 and 1975, and the 1980 communication was a prima facie notice calling upon others to show cause; the final decision of July 31, 1981 conformed with law. The petitioner accepted the appointment at Ahmedabad and was aware others were senior. The respondents further relied on delay and laches in the petitioner’s approaching the Court after many years.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P.B. Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamil Nadu, (1975) 1 SCC 152; AIR 1974 SC 2271 The sound exercise of discretion by courts in writ petitions where claimants delay unduly — specifically, a person aggrieved by promotion of a junior over his head should ordinarily approach the Court within six months, or at most within a year, of such promotion; long delay is a ground for refusal to exercise extraordinary writ jurisdiction. The Court relied on this authority to hold that the petitioner’s challenge, brought after about two decades from the date of appointment to Assistant Compose Foreman (1961), was barred by delay and laches; this formed a principal basis for refusing relief.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in two main strands: (A) discretionary bar by delay (laches) and (B) merits of the seniority claim.

A. Delay and discretionary refusal

  • The Court accepted the respondents' submission of gross delay. The petitioner had been appointed to the Assistant Compose Foreman cadre in 1961; the petitioner’s representations were considered and rejected by the Government in 1974 and again in 1975. Respondent No. 4 was promoted on the basis of the then-accepted seniority lists.
  • Relying on P.B. Sadasivaswamy, the Court emphasized that it would be a prudent exercise of discretion to refuse to exercise extraordinary writ jurisdiction where a party sits on rights for a long period and seeks to unsettle long-settled promotions and seniority after many years. The Court found the petitioner’s approach after about two decades to be inexcusable and a sound ground for refusing relief.

B. Merits — how seniority was to be determined and application of facts

  • The Court examined the 1961 merit list and the dates recorded in it. The merit list (produced in the respondents' affidavit) placed the petitioner at Sr. No. 4, while respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were placed above him. The recorded dates of joining the Assistant Compose Foreman cadre show respondents joined the cadre in October and November 1961 whereas the petitioner joined on 7 December 1961.
  • The Court held that for fixation of seniority in the Assistant Compose Foreman cadre the relevant date is the date of entry into that cadre (the date of joining as Assistant Compose Foreman), not the earlier service in the lower cadre (Compositor). Thus prior service in the lower cadre was “not material” for fixing seniority in the promoted cadre.
  • The Court accepted the respondents' account that when the Ahmedabad office was first established there was no feeding cadre and therefore posts had to be filled by selection, including from other presses and by direct recruitment from the open market; the presence of an open-market selectee (I.B. Panmaker/Parmaker in the list) supported that position. The petitioner had been selected and appointed to the Assistant Compose Foreman cadre at Ahmedabad rather than merely being transferred while occupying the lower-cadre post at Bhavnagar.
  • Because the Government had earlier considered the petitioner’s claim and had rejected it after affording personal hearing in 1974–75, the Court found there was no requirement to afford another hearing and no procedural infirmity in the July 31, 1981 order insofar as the petitioner contended that it was passed without notice. The Court concluded that the impugned order was in consonance with law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is DISMISSED.

Consequences and immediate implications:

  • The administrative fixation of seniority and consequent promotions (as reflected in the 1961 merit list and later seniority lists) remain undisturbed; the petitioner is not entitled to have his seniority refixed so as to be treated senior to the named respondents, nor is he entitled to deemed dates of promotion or consequential benefits as claimed in the petition.
  • Rule 15 was discharged. The Court made no order as to costs.
  • The Court emphasized that its decision rested on both discretionary grounds (delay/laches under the principles in P.B. Sadasivaswamy) and on merits (the applicable rule that seniority in the Assistant Compose Foreman cadre is fixed by entry into that cadre and the factual finding that the petitioner joined that cadre after the other employees). The opinion does not purport to establish a new precedent beyond applying the cited authority to the facts of the case.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond what is recorded in the judgment.

    Shri B.M Patel v. State Of Gujarat And Others

    C.K Thakker, J.:— This petition is filed by the petitioner for quashing and setting aside an order passed by the Manager, Government Central Press, Gandhinagar-respondent No. 3 on July 31, 1981 by treating the petitioner as senior to one K.H Raval-respondent No. 4 and to grant deemed date of promotion consequent upon the refixation of seniority of the petitioner vis-a-vis respondent No. 4 to the post of Assistant Compose Foreman and that of Compose Foreman with all consequential benefits.

    2. It is the case of the petitioner that he was appointed as Compositor in the service of the respondent-State and posted at Bhavnagar on November 14, 1949. It was on daily wages basis and he was appointed on regular establishment as Compositor with effect from January 1, 1954. From the post of Compositor, he was promoted to the post of Assistant Composing Foreman in December 1961 and to the post of Compose Foreman on January 3, 1964. The next promotional post was of Junior Assistant Manager. It is his case that since his seniority was not fixed in accordance with law, prejudice was caused to him. According to him he was appointed in November 1949, while respondent No. 4 was appointed in June 1960 and respondent No. 6 was appointed in November 1969 and, therefore, his seniority was required to be fixed on the basis of length of service and continuous officiation in the original cadre and taking into account the date of appointment his case was required to be considered for promotion to the post of compose foreman, compose overseer and higher posts.

    3. Since he was treated junior to the respondent Nos. 4 and 6 by wrong fixation of his seniority, he was superseded and ignoring his legitimate claim, respondent No. 4 was promoted. The said action was illegal, contrary to law and require to be corrected by this Court.

    4. Miss S.M Thakkar for Mr. P.N Thakkar submitted that it is not disputed by the respondents that initial entry of the petitioner in the Government Press was in November 1949 whereas respondent Nos. 4 and 6 entered the service subsequent to him. Miss Thakkar further submitted that in the year 1961, the petitioner was transferred and promoted to the post of Assistant Compose Foreman and even then for the purpose of fixing seniority the relevant date of entry in the original cadre was not considered. Had that date been taken into account the authorities would not have taken the impugned decision at Annexure C by showing the petitioner junior to respondent Nos. 4 and 6. Miss Thakkar further submitted that the order was passed by the third respondent on May 28, 1980 and in that order also upholding the claim of the petitioner he was shown at Sr. No. 1 vis-a-vis all other persons promoted to the post of Assistant Compose Foreman at the Government Central Press, Gandhinagar and respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were shown junior to the petitioner. Without issuing notice and without affording opportunity of hearing, the impugned order came to be passed on July 31, 1981, disturbing the seniority of the petitioner and showing respondent Nos. 4 and 5 as senior to the petitioner which is contrary to law and violative of principles of natural justice. She, therefore, submitted that the petitioner requires to be allowed by granting all consequential benefits prayed for by the petitioner in the petition.

    5. An affidavit is filed by one K.H Cherian, Under Secretary to the Government of Gujarat, Industries, Mines and Power Department, on behalf of the respondents, inter alia disputing the claim of the petitioner on various grounds. It was conceded that the post of Assistant Compose Foreman was required to be filled in by promotion from amongst senior Compositors having 10 years services in the press on the basis of seniority and merit. It was however submitted that after bifurcation of the Bombay State in 1960 new press came to be established at Ahmedabad and then at Gandhinagar. It was further stated that the seniority of Class III Government Press Employees was maintained separately that is, presswise and there was no common seniority of all employees working in various Government Presses. It was then stated that at the initial stage, no government employees to fill in the post of Assistant Compose Foreman were available at Ahmedabad since that office was newly established. Consequently in September 1961 when some posts of Assistant Compose Foreman were required to be filled in at Government Central Press, Ahmedabad, there was no feeding cadre at that Press. Due to that and in view of the fact that posts of Assistant Compose Foreman were required to be filled in applications were invited from other Government Press and also from the open market. Eventually the provisions of the recruitment rules, existing in the erstwhile Bombay State for filling the post of promotion could not be implemented and acted upon. The petitioner also applied for the post of Assistant Compose Foreman alonewith other eligible candidates. None of them was working in the Government Press, Ahmedabad. In all, five candidates came to be selected out of 19 candidates interviewed. The petitioner's name was shown in the merit list at Sr. No. 4, whereas other persons were shown above him including respondent Nos. 4 and 6. Respondent No. 4 was shown at Sr. No. 2 and respondent No. 5 was shown at Sr. No. 3. Even the date of joining is also mentioned in the affidavit-in-reply. The relevant extract reads as under:

    Merit List No. Name Date of joining as Asstt. Compose Foreman Date of promotion as Compose Foreman 1. Shri A.R Vyas 3-10-1961 1-5-1962 2. Shri K.M Raval (Resp. No. 4) 3-10-1961 1-5-1962 3. Shri V.G Survey (Resp. No. 5) 3-11-1961 3-1-1964 4. Shri B.N Patel (Petitioner) 7-12-1961 3-1-1964 5. Shri I.B Panmaker (Open Market) 4-12-1961 3-1-1964

    6. Relying upon the above column, Miss Doshit submitted that according to the merit list respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were above the petitioner. Similarly looking to the date of joining as Assistant Compose Foreman also, both the respondents were senior to the petitioner inasmuch as respondent No. 4 joined as Assistant Compose Foreman in October 1961 and respondent No. 6 joined in November 1961 while the petitioner joined in that cadre in December 1961. Miss Doshit further submitted that after the above appointment, the respondents were further promoted to the higher post of Compose Foreman as well as Compose Oberseer before the petitioner. Every year, seniority lists of the Assistant Compose Foreman and Compose Foreman were published wherein also seniority of the petitioner was fixed on the basis of selection made in 1961. The petitioner made representation to the Government and personal hearing was afforded to him by the Secretary, Industries, Mines and Powers Department and the claim of the petitioner was negatived by the Department. He was informed in 1974 that the Government did not see any reason to uphold the claim of the petitioner. Again in 1975 the Government reiterated its earlier order and held that the Government did not see any reason to review the decision already taken in October 1974. Miss Doshit submitted that the order dated May 20, 1980 on which reliance was placed by Miss Thakkar does not help the petitioner inasmuch as no final decision was taken by the said communication. It was in the nature of a notice issued to respondent Nos. 4, 5 and other persons wherein it was mentioned that prima facie the claim put forward by the petitioner appeared to be well founded and, therefore, before taking any final decision those persons were called upon to show cause as to why the said decision should not be finally taken. Miss Doshit submitted that after considering the claim of contesting employees, again a decision was taken on July 31, 1981 which was in accordance with law and no objection could be taken by the petitioner.

    7. Miss Doshit further submitted that there was a gross delay and laches on the part of the petitioner in approaching the Court. On merits she submitted that for the purpose of fixing seniority to the cadre of Assistant Compose Foreman, relevant date would be entry in service in that cadre and appointment in the lower cadre was altogether immaterial. She therefore submitted that there is no substance in any of the arguments advanced by Miss Thakkar and the petition requires to be dismissed.

    8. Having heard the learned Counsel for the parties I am of the opinion that no case has been made out by the present petitioner to get any relief which is prayed for in the petition.

    9. Miss Doshit is right in contending that there is gross delay and laches on the part of the petitioner in approaching the Court. As is clear, the petitioner came to be appointed to the post of Assistant Compose Foreman in 1961 and was shown junior to respondent Nos. 4 and 6 in various seniority lists, that position reflected in 1974 as well as in 1975, the claim of the petitioner was negatived. Respondent No. 4 was promoted to the higher post on the basis of that seniority. In these circumstances, it is not open to the petitioner to approach this Court after about two decades from the date of his appointment to the posts of Assistant Compose Foreman in the Government Press, Ahmedabad and to unsettle matters. As observed by the Honourable Court in the case of P.B Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamilnadu reported in (1975) 1 SCC 152 : AIR 1974 SC 2271 a person aggrieved by an order promoting a junior over his head should approach the Court at least within six months or at the most within a year of such promotion. It is not that there is any period of limitation for a writ under Article 226 nor is it that there can never be a case where the Courts cannot interfere in matter after the passage of certain length of time. But it would be a sound and wise exercise of discretion for the Courts to refuse to exercise their extraordinary powers under Article 226 in the case of persons who do not approach it extraordinarily for relief and the stand by and allow things to happen and then approach the Court to pul forward stale claims and try to unsettle settled matters.

    (Emphasis supplied.)

    10. On merits also, the contention of the petitioner cannot be upheld. As seen above the petitioner was appointed as Assistant Compose Foreman alongwith respondent Nos. 4 and 5. In the merit list he was at Sr. No. 4, i.e junior to respondent No. 4 and 5. Thus considering the date of joining service also he was junior to the respondent Nos. 4 and 5 since both the respondents joined services in October and November 1961 respectively while the petitioner joined the service as Assistant Compose Foreman on December 7, 1961. In my judgment, the service rendered by the petitioner in the lower cadre is not material for fixing seniority to the cadre of Assistant Foreman as the relevant date would be entry in that cadre by the petitioner as well as by other persons by way of direct recruitment. Therefore it is not necessary for me to decide whether a common seniority list of all the employees working in Government Press had been maintained by the respondents as contended by Miss Thakkar or separate seniority lists were maintained as asserted by Miss Doshit. It, however, clearly appears that the petitioner was not transferred and promoted to Government Press, Ahmedabad from Government Press, Bhavnagar. Miss Doshit is right in contending that when the office came to be established for the first time after 1st May 1960 at Ahmedabad certain posts of Assistant Compose Foreman were required to be filled in at Ahmedabad. Adhering to the rules, those posts were required to be filled in by promotion from the lower cadre of Compositor but when the office came to be established for the first time in 1960 the feeding cadre was not available. In these circumstances, the Government was obliged and complied to fill in posts by inviting applications from eligible candidates from open market and the petitioner was one of them. The petitioner also knew that the posts were to be filled in at Ahmedabad by way of direct recruitment. This is clear from the fact that one Mr. I.B Parmaker who was selected and placed at Sr. No. 5 in the merit list was not serving in any government press and was taken from open market. The petitioner could not have been transferred from the Government Press, Bhavnagar to the Government Central Press, Ahmedabad since at the Government Press, Bhavnagar he was working as Compositor while he was selected and appointed as Assistant Compose Foreman at Ahmedabad. Again Miss Doshit is right in submitting that the petitioner accepted the said order and joined duty. The petitioner was also aware that respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were senior to him. In various seniority lists they were shown senior to the petitioner and were also promoted to the higher post on that basis. The claim of the petitioner was rejected by the Government in 1974 as well as in 1975. Therefore when a notice came to be issued by the Government to other persons it would not be said that a decision was taken by the Government to uphold the claim of the petitioner and to treat the petitioner as senior to respondent Nos. 4 and 5. It may be stated that the claim of the petitioner was rejected after affording personal hearing and, therefore also it was not necessary to give hearing once again. In my opinion therefore, no case has been made out by the petitioner against the impugned section which is clearly in consonance with law.

    11. In the result, I do not find any substance in any of the arguments raised by Miss Thakkar and the petition requires to be dismissed. The petition is dismissed. Rule 15 discharged, however with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri B.M Patel v. State Of Gujarat And Others
    (Jan 20, 1993)