AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from an intra court appeal challenging the order dated 12-9-2008 passed by a learned single judge in writ petition no. 14545/2007. The appellants, as petitioners, invoked the extraordinary jurisdiction of the court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, contesting the legal validity of an earlier order dated 25-8-2007 by the learned second additional district judge, Jabalpur, in civil suit no. 16453/2007. The trial court had held that the appellants, as plaintiffs, were required to pay ad valorem court fee for a suit seeking to declare a sale deed dated 11-5-2004 (registered on 12-5-2004/14-5-2004) null and void. The learned single judge concurred with this conclusion. The appellants contended that only a fixed court fee was payable as they were trying to avoid the sale deed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiffs, being parties to the sale deed, are required to pay ad valorem court fee or only fixed court fee when seeking a declaration that the sale deed is null and void.
  2. Whether a declaratory relief that effectively seeks cancellation of a sale deed attracts ad valorem court fee under Section 7(iv)(c) of the Court Fees Act.
  3. The proper interpretation and application of court fee requirements in suits involving consequential reliefs related to sale deeds.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellants (plaintiffs) argued that they were only required to pay fixed court fee as they were attempting to avoid the sale deed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pratap v. Punia Bai, (1976) 25 JLJ 503 Clarification that relief clauses containing consequential reliefs require appropriate court fee payment. Referred to establish that the relief clause included consequential reliefs, justifying ad valorem court fee.
Kunti Devi v. Roshanlal, 1987 MPLJ 25 Plaintiffs being parties to the sale deed are prima facie bound by it; declaration simpliciter is not available without consequential relief. Applied to hold that since the declaration involved cancellation of sale deed, ad valorem court fee under Section 7(iv)(c) was payable.
Shamsher Singh v. Rajinder Prashad, AIR 1973 SC 2384 General principles regarding court fee and reliefs involving sale deeds. Referred to support the principle that cancellation relief attracts ad valorem court fee.
Ashok v. Narsinghrao, 1974 MPLJ 900 : AIR 1975 MP 39 Similar principle regarding payment of court fee for consequential reliefs. Referred in the context of court fee applicability.
Dattaji Parashramji Patil v. Mst. Bhagirathi, ILR 1939 Nag 373 Established binding nature of sale deeds on parties and implications for court fee. Used to reinforce the obligation to pay ad valorem court fee.
Santosh Chandra v. Cyan Sunder Bail, 1970 MPLJ 363 (FB) : (AIR 1971 MP 1) Principles relating to court fee in cases involving sale deeds and declarations. Referred to support the court's reasoning on fee payment.
Mohammad Jameel Khan v. Miththulal Khushal Singh Gujur, 1999 (1) MPLJ 37 : AIR 1999 MP 70 Allegations in plaint determine court fee; plaintiff cannot mould facts to evade correct fee; declaratory relief aiming to set aside sale deed requires ad valorem fee. Applied to confirm that the plaintiffs' intention to cancel the sale deed necessitated ad valorem court fee payment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the relief clause of the civil suit and noted it included a prayer for declaring the sale deed null and void along with consequential reliefs such as delivery of possession. The court observed that the plaintiffs were parties to the sale deed and thus prima facie bound by it. It relied on established precedents to conclude that a mere declaratory relief is insufficient when it effectively seeks cancellation of a sale deed. Consequently, the suit attracts ad valorem court fee under Section 7(iv)(c) of the Court Fees Act rather than a fixed court fee. The court rejected the appellants' attempt to avoid paying ad valorem fee by characterizing the suit as only declaratory. It emphasized that the court fee must correspond to the true nature and substance of the relief sought, not merely the form in which it is pleaded. After careful analysis of the factual matrix and relevant precedents, the court affirmed the decisions of the lower courts requiring payment of ad valorem court fee.

Holding and Implications

The writ appeal is dismissed.

The court upheld the requirement that plaintiffs who are parties to a sale deed and seek its cancellation through declaratory and consequential relief must pay ad valorem court fee under the applicable provisions of the Court Fees Act. The decision directly affects the parties by confirming the fee liability but does not establish any new precedent beyond the application of existing law. The appeal was dismissed on merits despite potential maintainability issues.

    Shyamacharan Paul, And Another v. Roopali Promoters And Construction And Others

    Dipak Misra, J.:-

    (1) In this intra court appeal, the challenge is to the order dated 12 - 9 - 2008 passed by the learned single judge in writ petition no. 14545/2007.

    (2) The appellants as petitioners invoked the extraordinary jurisdiction of this court under art. 227 of the constitution of india calling in question the legal validity of the order dated 25 - 8 - 2007 passed by the learned second additional district judge, jabalpur in civil suit no. 16453/2007. The learned single judge lias concurred with the conclusion recorded by the trial judge whereby he had held that the appellants as plaintiffs were required to affix the ad valorem court fee for declaring the sale - deed 11 - 5 - 2004 registered on 12 - 5 - 2004/ 14 - 5 - 2004 as null and void.

    (3) We have heard mr. Shripal jain, learned counsel for the appellants, on the question of admission. It is submitted by mr. Jain that the plaintiff were trying to avoid the sale - deed and, therefore, they are only required to pay (he fixed court - fee.

    (4) On a perusal of the order passed by the learned single judge, it is perceivable that he has referred to the relief clause of the civil suit which clearly mentions for declaring the document executed by defendant no. 3 in favour of respondent nos. 10 to 30 as null and void and to deliver the possession and prayed for other ancillary reliefs. On a perusal of the relief clause, it is clear as crystal that it contains consequential reliefs. That apart, the plaintiffs are parties to the document. They intend to declare the sale deed null and void. As is manifest from the order of learned single judge, he has referred to the decision rendered in pratap v. Punia bai (1976) 25 jlj 503.

    (5) In this context, we may profitably refer to the decision rendered in kunti devi w/o of ramdas v. Roshanlal s/o ramdas, 1987 mplj 25 wherein this court, after referring to the decisions rendered in shamshcr singh v. Rajinder prashad, air 1973 sc 2384, ashok v. Narsinghrao, 1974 mplj 900 : air 1975 mp 39; dattaji parashramji patil v. Mst. Bhagirathi, ilr 1939 nag 373 and santosh chandra v. Cyan sunder bail, 1970 mplj 363 (fb) : (air 1971 mp 1) held that the plaintiffs, being parties to the sale - deed, are prima facie bound by it and the relief of declaration simpliciter is not available. The declaration claimed by the plaintiffs necessarily involved a prayer for consequential relief of cancellation of the sale deed, therefore, the court - fee is payable under s. 7 (iv) (c) of the court - fees act.

    (6) In mohammad jameel khan v. Mlththulal khushal singh gujur, 1999 (1) mplj 37 : air 1999 mp 70, it has been that while considering the question of payment of court - fee, the allegations contained in the plaint have to be seen. The plaintiff cannot be permitted to mould the facts and circumstances and the real intention. It transpires that the intention of the plaintiff wassomething different than what had been claimed. The court cannot overlook it. In case where the plaintiff sought a declaratory relief only, but in substance aimed at setting aside the sale - deeds, the court - fee has to be paid in accordance with the law governed by s. 7 (iv) (c) of the court - fees act. The third parties without notice of the alleged fraud can acquire rights and interest in the property and get it enforced against the person defrauded. It cannot, under the circumstances, be taken that he was not a party to the document. Unless the document is got cancelled by a decree of court, it remains a valid document. The relief of declaration cannot be sufficient. The plaintiff has to ask for a consequential relief of cancellation of the sale - deed in order to avoid it. Consequently, a consequential relief of cancellation of sale - deed is necessary and the plaintiff was required to pay ad valorem court - fee on the value of the sale deeds under s. 7 (iv) (c) of the court - fees act.

    (7) In the case at hand, the plaintiffs are parties to the sale - deed. In view of the same, the law enunciated in the aforesaid decision is applicable and, therefore, they are liable to pay ad valorem court - fee and not the fixed court - fee. That apart, there is a consequential prayer in the suit. Thus, considering the factual scenario in entirety, we are of the considered opinion that the concurrence of the learned single judge with the order passed by the learned additional district judge which requires the plaintiff to pay ad valorem court - fee cannot be found fault with.

    (8) We have carefully perused the analysis made by the learned single judge. Regard being had to the analysis made by him, we are of the considered opinion that in view of the obtaining factual matrix, especially with regard to the prayer made, the appellants are required to pay the ad valorem court - fee and not the fixed court - fee.

    (9) Consequently, the writ appeal, being devoid of merit, stands dismissed in limine. We may note with profit that we have dealt with the appeal on merits despite the fact that the writ petition was preferred under art. 227 of the constitution and the learned single judge has dealt with the same under art. 227 of the constitution though the same could have been thrown overboard on the ground of maintainability. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shyamacharan Paul, And Another v. Roopali Promoters And Construction And Others
    (Feb 2, 2009)