AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 6 of the Act
  • Section 4 of the Act
  • The Act under which the land is acquired by the State
  • Section 23 of the Act
  • The Act (no specific section/subsection/year mentioned)
  • Order 41 Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Article 136
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 9 of the Act
  • Section 54 of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 6 of the Act
  • Section 4 of the Act
  • The Act under which the land is acquired by the State
  • Section 23 of the Act
  • The Act (no specific section/subsection/year mentioned)
  • Order 41 Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Article 136
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 9 of the Act
  • Section 54 of the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Karnataka issued a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 on 19-12-1994 to acquire 40 guntas of land near Nehru Medical College, Belgaum, for the establishment of an Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) centre. After a Section 6 declaration on 30-11-1995, the Land Acquisition Officer (LAO) awarded compensation on 06-03-1998 at Rs 1,050 per gunta (Rs 42,000 per acre).

Dissatisfied landowners (respondents) sought reference under Section 18. On 31-03-2005, the Reference Court enhanced compensation to Rs 7,000 per gunta (Rs 2,80,000 per acre). The respondents appealed under Section 54 to the Karnataka High Court, which on 23-03-2007 further enhanced the rate to Rs 99,000 per gunta after deducting 40% towards development.

ICMR, the beneficiary organisation, filed special-leave petitions before the Supreme Court challenging the High Court’s enhancement. The landowners filed cross-objections seeking still higher compensation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in enhancing the compensation from Rs 7,000 per gunta to Rs 99,000 per gunta for the undeveloped acquired land.
  2. Consequent to the above, whether the landowners were entitled to any further enhancement as claimed in their cross-objections.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (ICMR) Arguments

  • Relied on Chandrashekar v. LAO (2012) 1 SCC 390 to contend that a single sale deed of a small, developed plot (Ext. P-10: 4 guntas sold for Rs 6,60,000) cannot determine the value of a large, undeveloped tract; deductions of 40–75% were required.
  • Asserted that the High Court’s 40% deduction was inadequate and without sufficient evidentiary basis, leading to an unjustified jump from Rs 7,000 to Rs 99,000 per gunta.

Respondents (Landowners) Arguments

  • Supported the High Court’s reliance on Ext. P-10, emphasising the land’s high potential value due to surrounding commercial and educational establishments.
  • Via cross-objections, claimed entitlement to even higher compensation than Rs 99,000 per gunta on the strength of existing evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chandrashekar v. Land Acquisition Officer (2012) 1 SCC 390 Summarised permissible deductions (20%–75%) when valuing large undeveloped land using small developed plot sales. Primary authority guiding the Supreme Court’s reassessment; used to justify higher deduction and reduction of compensation.
Brig. Sahib Singh Kalha v. Amritsar Improvement Trust (1982) 1 SCC 419 Deductions of 40%–53% (20% for land left for infrastructure + 20%–33% for development cost). Cited in Chandrashekar extract to frame deduction ranges applicable to present case.
Chimanlal Hargovinddas v. LAO (1988) 3 SCC 751 Need for deductions (20%–50%) when extrapolating from smaller plots; disadvantages of large undeveloped tracts. Illustrated rationale for applying substantial deductions.
Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354 Normal 1/3 deduction for development, variable with location and terrain. Reinforced flexibility in fixing deduction percentage.
Lal Chand v. Union of India (2009) 15 SCC 769 Approved deductions between 20%–75% when using small developed plot prices. Supported possibility of higher deductions than used by High Court.
A.P. Housing Board v. K. Manohar Reddy (2010) 12 SCC 707 Reiterated 20%–75% deduction range; applied 1/3 deduction on facts. Provided comparative benchmark for deciding reasonable deduction.
Land Acquisition Officer v. M.K. Rafiq Saheb (2011) 7 SCC 714 Raised deduction from 50% to 60% where undeveloped land compared with small developed plot. Illustrated courts’ willingness to apply deductions exceeding 50%.
Basavva v. LAO (1996) 9 SCC 640 Highlighted relevance of waiting period and extent of development while deciding deductions. High Court discussed but Supreme Court found facts distinguishable.
Subh Ram v. State of Haryana (2010) 1 SCC 444 Suggested combined deductions up to ~67% (33-1/3% + 33-1/3%). Cited in Chandrashekar extract; supported possibility of substantial deductions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first reviewed the sole exemplar sale deed (Ext. P-10) involving 4 guntas of developed land sold shortly before the notification. Acknowledging its proximity, the Court accepted it as a starting point but emphasised the need for substantial deductions because:

  • The acquired parcel was significantly larger (40 guntas) and remained undeveloped agricultural land at the relevant date;
  • Extensive expenditure would be required for roads, utilities, layout formation, and conversion from agricultural to non-agricultural use.

Drawing on the principles consolidated in Chandrashekar and prior case law, the Court determined that the High Court’s 40% deduction (leading to Rs 99,000 per gunta) was insufficient. Considering location, potentiality, surrounding developments, and development costs, the Court found a rate of Rs 70,000 per gunta to be “just, reasonable and fair.”

All other findings of the High Court (statutory additions, entitlement of parties, etc.) were affirmed. In view of the reduced rate, the landowners’ cross-objections seeking further enhancement were declared infructuous.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeals by ICMR were ALLOWED IN PART; the High Court’s determination of Rs 99,000 per gunta was modified to Rs 70,000 per gunta. Cross-objections by landowners were dismissed as infructuous.

Implications: The LAO must recalculate compensation at the reduced rate, including statutory benefits, and pay verified amounts within three months. No broader legal precedent was set beyond applying existing principles on deductions for development when valuing large undeveloped tracts.

    Indian Council Of Medical Research v. T.N Sanikop And Another

    Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.— Leave granted. These appeals arise out of the judgment dated 23-3-2007 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in T.N Sanikop v. Land Acquisition Officer 2007 SCC OnLine Kar 136, ILR 2007 KAR 2324, 2007 AIHC 2542, (2007) 4 AIR Kar R 371 which arise out of award dated 31-3-2005 passed by the Third Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Belgaum in LACs Nos. 11, 12, 13 and 14 of 1999.

    2. By the impugned judgment 2007 SCC OnLine Kar 136, ILR 2007 KAR 2324, 2007 AIHC 2542, (2007) 4 AIR Kar R 371/decree, the Division Bench of the High Court partly allowed the first appeals filed by the respondents herein (landowners) and while modifying the award of the Additional Civil Judge, Belgaum in the respondents' favour enhanced the quantum of compensation payable to the respondents for their lands which were acquired by the State under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”). Feeling aggrieved by the judgment 2007 SCC OnLine Kar 136, ILR 2007 KAR 2324, 2007 AIHC 2542, (2007) 4 AIR Kar R 371 passed by the High Court, the appellant (Central Government Organisation) for whose benefit the lands in question are acquired has filed these appeals by way of special leave.

    3. The question that arises for consideration in these appeals is whether the High Court was justified in partly allowing the respondents' appeals by enhancing the rate/quantum of compensation payable to the respondents (landowners) for their acquired lands under the Act?

    4. In order to appreciate the controversy involved in these appeals, it is necessary to state the relevant facts infra. The respondents are the owners of the land bearing RS No. 1323, CTS No. 5435-1B; RS No. 1323-1B-2, CTS No. 5435-1B-2; RS No. 1323-B1, CTS No. 5435-B; and RS No. 1323-1B-3, CTS No. 5435-B-3 measuring total 40 guntas situated near Nehru Medical College, Belgaum. In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 4 of the Act, the State Government issued a Notification on 19-12-1994 and acquired a large chunk of land measuring 40 guntas for establishment of Indian Medical Research Centre. This acquisition of land was for the benefit of Indian Council of Medical Research (in short “the ICMR”), an Institute wholly owned and controlled by the Central Government, who were desirous of setting up one Medical Centre in Belgaum town, for the benefit of the public at large. It was followed by the declaration published on 30-11-1995 under Section 6 of the Act. The respondents' lands in question were acquired pursuant to the aforementioned notification under Section 4 of the Act. This led to initiation of proceedings for determination of compensation payable to each landowner including that of the respondents herein by the Land Acquisition Officer (in short “the LAO”).

    5. Notices were accordingly issued to the respondents as per Section 9 of the Act calling upon them to participate in the land acquisition proceedings to enable the LAO to determine the fair market value of the land on the date of acquisition as provided under Section 23 of the Act so that the compensation is paid to the landowners at such determined rate. The LAO held an enquiry and after affording an opportunity to the respondents passed an award on 6-3-1998.

    6. The LAO fixed the compensation @ Rs 1050 per gunta = Rs 42,000 per acre, payable to the respondents for their lands in question as in his opinion, the respondents were entitled to claim compensation for their lands @ Rs 1050 per gunta being the fair market value of the acquired lands in question.

    7. Feeling aggrieved by the said award, the respondents sought reference to the civil court for redetermination of the compensation made by the LAO. The Reference Court, on the basis of the evidence, partly answered the respondents' reference in their favour and by the judgment dated 31-3-2005 enhanced the rate of compensation from Rs 1050 per gunta to Rs 7000 = Rs 2,80,000 per acre. In other words, the Reference Court held that the respondents were entitled to get compensation for their lands @ Rs 7000 per gunta = Rs 2,80,000 per acre being the fair market value of their lands from the date of the preliminary Notification i.e 19-12-1994.

    8. Dissatisfied with the determination made by the Reference Court, the respondents filed appeals under Section 54 of the Act before the High Court challenging the legality and correctness of the award of the Reference Court out of which these appeals arise.

    9. The Division Bench of the High Court by the impugned judgment 2007 SCC OnLine Kar 136, ILR 2007 KAR 2324, 2007 AIHC 2542, (2007) 4 AIR Kar R 371/decree partly allowed the respondents' appeals and enhanced the compensation from Rs 7000 per gunta to Rs 99,000 per gunta. The High Court held that fair market value/rate of the acquired lands on the date of acquisition was Rs 99,000 per gunta and hence, the respondents were entitled to get the compensation @ Rs 99,000 per gunta along with the other statutory benefits payable under the Act. It is against this judgment/decree, ICMR, for whose benefit the lands are acquired, has filed these appeals by way of special leave before this Court.

    10. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.

    11. Shri Raju Ramchandran, learned Senior Counsel, placing reliance on the principles laid down in the decision of this Court in Chandrashekar v. Land Acquisition Officer (2012) 1 SCC 390, contended that the High Court erred in enhancing the rate of land from Rs 7000 per gunta to Rs 99,000 per gunta. According to him, there was neither any evidence nor any basis for enhancing the rate from Rs 7000 per gunta to Rs 99,000 per gunta. The learned Senior Counsel urged that when admittedly the acquired land was a large area of undeveloped land, which needed a lot of expenditure for its development requiring deductions between the range of 40% to 75%, the High Court should not have relied upon the solitary sale deed (Ext. P-10) because admittedly Ext. P-10 pertained to sale of very small piece of developed land i.e 4 guntas which in no case could be compared with the real market value of the acquired lands in question. In other words, the submission was that the lands in question being large and undeveloped could not have been placed on a par with the land (4 guntas) sold by Ext. P-10 for Rs 6,60,000 as the latter was small in size and developed one.

    12. The learned Senior Counsel further urged that it is not appropriate to compare such lands for determining their rates as has been held by this Court in the case relied upon by him. The learned Senior Counsel further contended that there being no other evidence except Ext. P-10 to decide the comparative sales effected in the adjacent area of the acquired lands, the entire basis of the High Court while determining the rate by giving phenomenal rise does not appear to be legally justified and hence, the respondents' appeals should have been dismissed by the High Court by upholding the award of the Reference Court or in any event, the rate could have been enhanced by giving reasonable rise after keeping in view the law laid down.

    13. Ms Kiran Suri, learned Senior Counsel for the respondents supported the impugned judgment 2007 SCC OnLine Kar 136, ILR 2007 KAR 2324, 2007 AIHC 2542, (2007) 4 AIR Kar R 371 and contended on the basis of cross-objections filed in these appeals that the respondents are entitled for more compensation than what has been awarded by the High Court. According to her, the High Court should have awarded more compensation to the respondents because the market value of the lands on the date of acquisition was more than what is determined by the High Court and this, according to the respondents, can be proved on the basis of the evidence on record.

    14. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record of the case, we find force in the submissions urged by the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant and hence we are inclined to allow these appeals in part and accordingly modify the impugned award to the extent indicated below by reducing the rate of acquired lands and in consequence, the compensation determined by the High Court.

    15. Law on the question as to how the Court is required to determine the fair market value of the acquired land is fairly well settled and remains no more res integra by several decisions of this Court. It is apposite to take note of some decisions summarised in Chandrashekar (2012) 1 SCC 390 which are as follows:

    “(i) In Brig. Sahib Singh Kalha v. Amritsar Improvement Trust (1982) 1 SCC 419, this Court opined, that where a large area of undeveloped land is acquired, provision has to be made for providing minimum amenities of town life. Accordingly, it was held that a deduction of 20% of the total acquired land should be made for land over which infrastructure has to be raised (space for roads, etc.). Apart from the aforesaid, it was also held that the cost of raising infrastructure itself (like roads, electricity, water, underground drainage, etc.) needs also to be taken into consideration. To cover the cost component, for raising infrastructure, the Court held that the deduction to be applied would range between 20% to 33%. Commutatively viewed, it was held, that deductions would range between 40% and 53%.
    ***
    (iii) In Chimanlal Hargovinddas v. Land Acquisition Officer (1988) 3 SCC 751, while referring to the factors which ought to be taken into consideration while determining the market value of the acquired land, it was observed that a smaller plot was within the reach of many, whereas for a larger block of land there were implicit disadvantages. As a matter of illustration it was mentioned that a large block of land would first have to be developed by preparing its layout plan. Thereafter, it would require carving out roads, leaving open spaces, plotting out smaller plots, waiting for purchasers (during which the invested money would remain blocked). Likewise, it was pointed out that there would be other known hazards of an entrepreneur. Based on the aforesaid likely disadvantages it was held that these factors could be discounted by making deductions by way of allowance at an appropriate rate, ranging from 20% to 50%. These deductions, according to the Court, would account for land required to be set apart for developmental activities. It was also sought to be clarified that the applied deduction would depend on whether the acquired land was rural or urban, whether building activity was picking up or was stagnant, whether the waiting period during which the capital would remain locked would be short or long; and other like entrepreneurial hazards.
    ***
    (v) In Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354 this Court opined that in respect of agricultural land or undeveloped land which has potential value for housing or commercial purposes, normally 1/3rd amount of compensation should be deducted, depending upon the location, extent of expenditure involved for development, the area required for roads and other civic amenities, etc. It was also opined that appropriate deductions could be made for making plots for residential and commercial purposes. It was sought to be explained that the acquired land may be plain or uneven, the soil of the acquired land may be soft or hard, the acquired land may have a hillock or may be low-lying or may have deep ditches. Accordingly, it was pointed out that expenses involved for development would vary keeping in mind the facts and circumstances of each case. In Kasturi case (2003) 1 SCC 354 it was held that normal deductions on account of development would be 1/3rd of the amount of compensation. It was however clarified that in some cases the deduction could be more than 1/3rd and in other cases even less than 1/3rd.
    ***
    (x) In Lal Chand v. Union of India (2009) 15 SCC 769 it was held that to determine the market value of a large tract of undeveloped agricultural land (with potential for development), with reference to sale price of small developed plot(s), deductions varying between 20% to 75% of the price of such developed plot(s) could be made.
    ***
    (xii) In A.P Housing Board v. K. Manohar Reddy (2010) 12 SCC 707, having examined the existing case law on the point it was concluded, that deductions on account of development could vary between 20% to 75%. In the peculiar facts of the case a deduction of 1/3rd towards development charges was made from the awarded amount to determine the compensation payable.
    (xiii) In Land Acquisition Officer v. M.K Rafiq Saheb (2011) 7 SCC 714 this Court after having concluded that the land which was the subject-matter of acquisition was not agricultural land for all practical purposes and no agricultural activities could be carried out on it, concluded that in order to determine fair compensation, based on a sale transaction of a small piece of developed land (though the acquired land was a large chunk), the deduction made by the High Court at 50%, ought to be increased to 60%.”

    After taking note of the aforesaid cases and placing reliance upon the principles laid down therein, this Court in Chandrashekar (2012) 1 SCC 390 observed as under:

    “20. It is essential to earmark appropriate deductions out of the market value of an exemplar land, for each of the two components referred to above. This would be the first step towards balancing the differential factors. This would pave the way for determining the market value of the undeveloped acquired land on the basis of market value of the developed exemplar land.
    21. As far back as in 1982, this Court in Brig. Sahib Singh Kalha case (1982) 1 SCC 419 held that the permissible deduction could be up to 53%. This deduction was divided by the Court into two components. For the ‘first component’ referred to in the foregoing paragraph, it was held that a deduction of 20% should be made. For the ‘second component’, it was held that the deduction could range between 20% to 33%. It is therefore apparent that a deduction of up to 53% was the norm laid down by the Court as far back as in 1982. The aforesaid norm remained unchanged for a long duration of time, even though, keeping in mind the peculiar facts and circumstances emerging from case to case, different deductions were applied by this Court to balance the differential factors between the exemplar land and the acquired land. Recently, however, this Court has approved a higher component of deduction.
    22. In 2009, in Lal Chand case (2009) 15 SCC 769 and in 2010, in A.P Housing Board case (2010) 12 SCC 707 it has been held that while applying the sale consideration of a small piece of developed land, to determine the market value of a large tract of undeveloped acquired land, deductions between 20% to 75% could be made. But in 2009 in Subh Ram case (2010) 1 SCC 444, this Court restricted deductions on account of the ‘first component’ of development, as also, on account of the ‘second component’ of development to 33-1/3% each. The aforesaid deductions would roughly amount to 67% of the component of the sale consideration of the exemplar sale transaction(s).”

    16. Keeping the aforesaid principles in mind, we have perused the evidence. It is not in dispute that total acquired land is around 40 guntas. It is also not in dispute that the respondents (landowners) filed only one sale deed (Ext. P-10) in support of their case to prove the market rate of lands in question for claiming more compensation. It is also not in dispute that evidence other than Ext. P-10 is of no relevance. It was also not relied upon by the Reference Court or/and the High Court while determining the fair market value of the acquired lands.

    17. We have seen the evidence and are of the view that Ext. P-10 alone can be looked into to some extent. Though, it pertains to 4 guntas and sold for Rs 6,60,000 on 23-3-1994, it is situated near the acquired land.

    18. The finding of the High Court on the issue in question is contained in paras 8 to 11. It is reproduced infra in verbatim: (T.N Sanikop case 2007 SCC OnLine Kar 136, ILR 2007 KAR 2324, 2007 AIHC 2542, (2007) 4 AIR Kar R 371, SCC OnLine Kar paras 8-11)

    “8. We are now left with the question of determining the market value of the lands in question. The sale deed at Ext. P-10 is dated 23-7-1994. It shows that the total sale consideration of Rs 6,60,000 (Rupees six lakhs sixty thousand only) is paid for an extent measuring four guntas. That it is a genuine sale transaction; that the property covered under Ext. P-10 and the lands in question fall within the limits of Belgaum Urban Agglomeration are not in dispute at all. Further, the purchaser of the property at Ext. P-10 is also examined as PW 2. He has deposed that the area in question is the commercial area and that the plots therein are not readily available on sale. His further evidence is that the value of the acquired lands is higher than that of the properties situated on Club Road.
    9. PW 1 (Appellant 1) has given the evidence that in the vicinity of the acquired lands, a Kptcl office, Dental College, Polytechnic School, High Schools and Colleges are situated. He erected a building and started his business venture of vehicle showroom and an auto garage. It is his further evidence that the water supply and electrical connections were given to the building erected on the lands of PW 1. Plant and machinery was installed in the building. On account of the compulsory acquisition of the land, the appellant had to close down his business and pay a compensation of Rs 1,00,000 (Rupees one lakh only) to his workmen. Totally he claims to have incurred loss of Rs 2,00,000 on account of dislocation of his business activities.
    10. In our considered view, the sale deed, Ext. P-10 forms the reliable basis for the determination of the market value of the lands in question. However, the price of Rs 1,65,000 given for one gunta of land cannot be straightaway made applicable for the acquired lands. Because, as revealed by the respondent Land Acquisition Officer's award at Ext. D-1, the lands in question were agricultural lands as on the date of the issue of the preliminary notification. They were not converted into non-agricultural lands. As held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a catena of cases, there is difference between a developed area and an area having potential value which is yet to be developed. That the lands if adjacent to developed area will not ipso facto make every land situated in the area also developed so as to be valued as a building site or plot. The acquired land is just abutting National Highway 4. In the vicinity of the acquired lands a number of commercial establishments, government offices and educational institutions were already in existence at the time of the issuance of the preliminary notification in 1994. Under these circumstances, we have no doubt that the lands in question had acquired high potential value; but that by itself does not enable the lands in question to be treated as developed lands. Lot of developmental activities are to be undertaken, like laying of roads and creating facilities and amenities viz. electricity and water supply, culverts, sewerage, parks, etc. We have also given our anxious consideration to the submissions made on behalf of the Government that there was not even the preliminary earthwork and that the lands continue to retain their agrarian character for all practical purposes. Thus, the appellants are required to incur enormous amount of expenditure towards conversion earthwork, formation of layout, etc.
    11. Now, we have to provide for deduction of certain percentage towards the cost of development, taking the value of the developed plot at Rs 1,65,000 per gunta. There has been a serious contest at the Bar regarding the percentage of deduction towards the cost of development of land; it can vary from 20% to 53%. The facts of the instant case are entirely different from the facts of Basavva (1996) 9 SCC 640. None can have any dispute over the well-considered position laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that the time lay for real development and the waiting period for development are also relevant considerations for determination of just and adequate compensation. In the instant case, one of the acquired lands was already being used for non-agricultural i.e commercial purpose. Therefore, we are afraid the said reported decision does not come to the rescue of the Government in any way. There is no hard and rigid formula or yardstick for providing the percentage towards the cost of development. It depends on the facts of each case. In our considered view, as the acquired lands have attained high potentiality value and they were acquired for the purpose of setting up a Medical Research Centre, not too many internal roads are required to be formed; hence, there is also the likelihood of utilising more space. We, therefore, feel it safe, reasonable and just to hold that 40% of Rs 1,65,000 per gunta has to be earmarked for developmental activities. 40% of Rs 1,65,000 comes to Rs 99,000 (Rupees ninety-nine thousand only). We, therefore, enhance the market value of the lands in question from Rs 7000 per gunta to Rs 99,000 per gunta. Needless to observe that the appellants are entitled to proportionate increase in the solatium and additional market value besides the interest thereon.”

    19. We have given our anxious consideration to the whole issue keeping in view the peculiar facts, evidence adduced and the law quoted above. In our considered view, having regard to the total scenario emerging from the record of the case, such as the location of land, its potentiality, surroundings, the rate at which the developed small piece of land (4 guntas) in the adjoining area to the acquired lands was sold few months prior to the date of acquisition (Ext. P-10), the condition of the acquired undeveloped lands, the expenditure required to develop the acquired land to start the construction for the project for which it was acquired, percentage of deduction to be made, its proximity to various places in the town, the fair market value of the respondents' land can reasonably be worked out at Rs 70,000 per gunta in place of Rs 99,000 per gunta which was determined by the High Court. In other words, in our considered opinion, the High Court was not right in determining the fair market rate of acquired land at Rs 99,000 per gunta but instead it should have determined @ Rs 70,000 per gunta.

    20. We have arrived at the figure of Rs 70,000 per gunta after applying all the relevant factors laid down by this case, which we have mentioned above. In our view, the rate determined by this Court is just, reasonable and represents fair market value of the land in question on the date of acquisition. Indeed in such cases, one can never come to any exact figure of price of lands because in the very nature of things, the prices are bound to vary from land to land and further depending upon the individual buyer to buyer, seller to seller, reasons behind the sale and purchase, etc. However, the courts in such cases always exercise their discretion within the permissible parameters after appreciating the evidence on record and applying relevant legal principles. We have kept these factors in mind.

    21. We have also taken note of other arguments of the learned Senior Counsel for the parties on various issues relating to grant of compensation. However, we do not think that in the light of our findings determining the rate at Rs 70,000 per gunta, any more discussion or/and separate finding is necessary. Even otherwise, we do not find any merit in any of the submissions urged by the learned counsel in support of their stand and hence, we concur with all the other findings of fact recorded by the High Court on the issues, which, in our view, are based on proper appreciation of evidence calling no interference in our jurisdiction under Article 136.

    22. In the light of the foregoing discussion, once we reduce the rate of compensation determined by the High Court partly in the appellant's favour then in such circumstances, the question of considering grant of further enhancement in compensation to the respondents does not arise. It is for this reason, the cross-objections filed by the respondents become insignificant and deserve to be dismissed as having been rendered infructuous. It is accordingly dismissed.

    23. We, therefore, decline to examine the legal issue raised by the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant by way of his preliminary objection that cross-objections filed by the respondents under Order 41 Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure are not maintainable and leave this legal question open for its decision in any other appropriate case provided it is not yet decided by this Court.

    24. In view of the foregoing discussion, the appeals filed by ICMR succeed and are accordingly allowed in part. The impugned judgment 2007 SCC OnLine Kar 136, ILR 2007 KAR 2324, 2007 AIHC 2542, (2007) 4 AIR Kar R 371 and decree is modified to the extent indicated above.

    25. The LAO concerned is directed to calculate the compensation payable to the respondents (landowners) for their lands @ Rs 70,000 per gunta and accordingly calculate all statutory compensation such as solatium, interest, etc. payable under the Act to every landowner whose land is acquired by the State under the Act. Let this calculation be made, as directed above, by the LAO concerned and the amount so calculated be paid to the respondents (landowners) after making proper verification within three (3) months from the date of receipt of this judgment. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Indian Council Of Medical Research v. T.N Sanikop And Another
    (Nov 12, 2014)