AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule-9 and Rule-17 of THE JAMMU AND KASHMIR CIVIL SERVICES (CLASSIFICATION, CONTROAL AND APPEAL) RULES, 1956 (for short Rules of 1956) and Article 37(1)(3) and Note-7
  • JUDGMENT:Muzaffar Hussain Attar.Different clauses of Article 37 of J&K Civil Service Regulations, 1956, (for short Regulations)
  • Rule-9 of Rules of 1956.Rule-17 of the Rules of 1956,
  • Article 37 of J&K Civil Service Regulations
  • Note-7 of Article 37 of the Regulations
  • Article 37 of the Regulations
  • Article 37(1) of Regulations
  • Article 37 of Regulations
  • Rule-9(b) and Rule-17(b)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule-9 and Rule-17 of THE JAMMU AND KASHMIR CIVIL SERVICES (CLASSIFICATION, CONTROAL AND APPEAL) RULES, 1956 (for short Rules of 1956) and Article 37(1)(3) and Note-7
  • JUDGMENT:Muzaffar Hussain Attar.Different clauses of Article 37 of J&K Civil Service Regulations, 1956, (for short Regulations)
  • Rule-9 of Rules of 1956.Rule-17 of the Rules of 1956,
  • Article 37 of J&K Civil Service Regulations
  • Note-7 of Article 37 of the Regulations
  • Article 37 of the Regulations
  • Article 37(1) of Regulations
  • Article 37 of Regulations
  • Rule-9(b) and Rule-17(b)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

In August 2009 respondent No.4 issued an advertisement inviting applications for engagement as ReT for a vacancy. That advertisement was withdrawn and respondent No.4 issued a fresh advertisement dated 30 December 2009, published on 31 December 2009, inviting applications from eligible candidates of the concerned revenue village (10+2 with Math & Science). The re-advertisement stated that "the last date will be cutoff date for determining age/qualification/merit" and the last date for submission of applications was 10 January 2010.

Both the appellant and respondent No.4 applied. A provisional merit panel dated 27 January 2010 placed the appellant at Sr. No.1 and respondent No.4 at Sr. No.2. A selection list dated 4 February 2010 provisionally recommended the appellant. Respondent No.4 filed objections alleging that the appellant was below 18 years of age on 1 January 2009 and thus ineligible under Article 37 of the J&K Civil Service Regulations, 1956. The official respondents accepted the objection and ultimately engaged respondent No.4 as ReT on 28 October 2010.

The appellant challenged the appointment by filing a writ petition. The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition by judgment dated 25 May 2012. The appellant filed this Letters Patent Appeal (LPA) against that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the minimum age of 18 years prescribed by Article 37(1) of the J&K Civil Service Regulations is to be reckoned with reference to "the first day of January of the year in which the competitive examination is held or nomination is made" (as contended by the appellant) or with reference to "the first day of January in which the advertisement notice for the post(s) is issued" as clarified by Note‑7 (as contended by the respondents).
  2. Whether Note‑7 appended to Article 37 is a marginal note (and therefore non‑operative for purposes of construction) or a statutory/clarificatory note that must be read as part of Article 37.
  3. Whether a cutoff date for determining age fixed by an advertising/appointing authority in the advertisement can override the prescription contained in Article 37 and Note‑7 of the Regulations.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Counsel for the appellant argued that the re-advertisement provided that the "last date will be the cutoff date for determining age/qualification/merit" (last date 10 January 2010) and that the age should be reckoned with reference to the year in which the competitive examination is held or nomination is made (i.e., 2010), not with reference to the year of the advertisement.
  • The appellant asserted he had attained the minimum prescribed age of 18 years on 31 March 2009 (a fact the appellant's counsel said was admitted by respondent No.3 in a communication dated 17 May 2010) and that on 1 January 2010 he was above 18, so he could not be deprived of engagement on that basis.
  • Counsel contended that Article 37(1) mandates reckoning age from the first day of January of the year in which the competitive examination is held or nomination is made, and that Note‑7 and Article 37(1) should not be read to require reckoning by reference to the year of the advertisement.
  • He argued that Note‑7 is a marginal note and therefore cannot control Article 37(1); he relied on decisions including Board of Muslim Wakfs, Maharashtra Tubes Ltd. and Datar Switchgears Ltd. to support this position.
  • Relief sought: quash the engagement of respondent No.4 and direct engagement of the appellant as ReT in his place.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Counsel for official respondents asserted that Note‑7 to Article 37(1) requires that, for initial appointments made on recommendations of Recruitment Boards/PSC/Selection Committees, the minimum and maximum age limits be observed with reference to the first day of January in the year in which the advertisement notice is issued; on that basis the appellant was below 18 on 1 January 2009 and was ineligible.
  • Counsel for respondent No.4 submitted the appellant admittedly was not 18 on 1 January 2009, respondent No.4 was within the prescribed age on that date and had been validly engaged on the basis of merit; he also referred to this Court's Division Bench decision in Ms. Shaheena Masarat v. State (2010) and relied on paragraphs 34–35.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Board of Muslim Wakfs, Rajasthan v. Radha Kishan, (1979) 2 SCC 468 Cited by appellant to support the proposition that a marginal note cannot be used to control or alter substantive provisions. The court recorded that the appellant initially relied on this line of authority but then conceded that Note‑7 is not a marginal note. The court therefore did not apply the marginal‑note principle to exclude Note‑7 from consideration.
Maharashtra Tubes Ltd. v. State Industrial & Investment Corporation of Maharashtra Ltd., (1993) 2 SCC 144 Cited by appellant for the proposition concerning the non‑operative status of marginal notes in statutory construction. The court noted the reliance but observed that Note‑7 was not a marginal note and thus the precedent did not support excluding Note‑7 from the interpretive exercise.
Datar Switchgears Ltd. v. Tata Finance Ltd., (2000) 8 SCC 151 Cited by appellant in support of arguments on statutory interpretation (relative to marginal notes/interpretative aids). The court recorded the citation but proceeded on the basis that Note‑7 is a statutory note; thus Datar Switchgears did not displace the statutory force of Note‑7 in the present context.
Rekha Chaturvedi (SMT) v. University of Rajasthan, 1993 (Supp.) 3 SCC 168 Principle that qualifications must be judged with reference to a certain, ascertainable date (the last date for applications) and that relying on an uncertain date (such as the date of selection) produces unfairness and potential for manipulation. The court relied on paragraph 10 of this decision to emphasize that Article 37(1) cannot be read in isolation and that the recruitment process requires a fixed, certain date for assessing eligibility; this supported reading Article 37(1) with Note‑7 and other clauses to avoid uncertainty.
A.P. Public Service Commission, Hyderabad v. B. Sarat Chandra; and District Collector & Chairman, Vizianagaram Social Welfare Residential School Society v. M. Tripura Sundari Devi (referenced together) Referenced in Rekha Chaturvedi and relied upon for the proposition that the only certain date for scrutiny of qualifications in the absence of an express date is the last date for making application; to avoid uncertainty, the advertisement should fix a date. The court relied on the reasoning cited in Rekha Chaturvedi (which referred to these cases) to support the need to harmonize Article 37(1) with Note‑7 and to reject interpretations that would permit uncertain or manipulable eligibility dates.
Ms. Shaheena Masarat v. State, 2010 (1) S.L.J. 477 Held (by a Division Bench of this court) that Article 37 of J&K Civil Service Regulations is applicable to Re‑T posts. The court accepted this precedent as confirming the applicability of Article 37 to Re‑T appointments and specifically noted counsel's reliance on paragraphs 34–35 of that judgment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by observing that different clauses of Article 37 are worded in ways that, if read in isolation, can appear inconsistent and give rise to anomalous outcomes. The court emphasized its constitutional duty to interpret subordinate legislation purposively so that provisions are harmonized and meaningful, while avoiding judicial overreach into legislative functions.

The court examined the statutory framework: Rule‑9 and Rule‑17 of the Jammu & Kashmir Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1956, and Article 37(1), Article 37(3) and Note‑7 of the J&K Civil Service Regulations. It noted that Rule‑17 prescribes minimum and maximum ages for direct recruitment but does not specify at which stage of the recruitment process the age requirement must be applied.

The court analyzed Article 37(1) and observed that, read in isolation (to mean age to be reckoned in the year of the competitive examination or nomination), the provision could create an anomalous situation where persons who were ineligible on the advertisement cutoff date might later claim eligibility in a different year and disrupt the selection process. To illustrate this danger the court posed a hypothetical: an advertisement issued in year X but the competitive examination or nomination occurring in year X+1, allowing persons who were underage at the time of application to claim eligibility later and thereby vitiating the process and impinging Article 14 (equality) by creating unfairness among competing candidates.

The court turned to Note‑7 which had been inserted by statutory notification in 1982. It expressly found that Note‑7 is a statutory, clarificatory note and not a marginal note. The plain language of Note‑7 states that for initial appointments made on recommendations of Recruitment Boards/PSC/Selection Committees, the limitations of minimum and maximum age are to be observed with reference to the first day of January in which the advertisement notice for the post(s) is issued.

On this basis the court held that Article 37(1) must be read in conjunction with Article 37(3) and Note‑7. The minimum age of 18 years prescribed by Article 37(1) therefore has reference to the first day of January of the year in which the advertisement notice is issued (i.e., the year in which the recruitment process is initiated). The court concluded that the statutory scheme requires a certain, ascertainable date for determining eligibility (consistent with Rekha Chaturvedi) and that Note‑7 serves that clarificatory function.

The court further held that the advertisement‑level cutoff date set by an officer (in the present case fixing the cutoff such that age would be determined by last date for application) cannot override the statutory prescription in Article 37 and Note‑7; Article 37 prevails.

Applying these conclusions to the facts, the court found that the advertisement was published on 31 December 2009 and therefore the relevant date for reckoning the minimum age was 1 January 2009 (the first day of January of the year in which the advertisement was issued). The appellant admittedly was not 18 on 1 January 2009 and therefore was not entitled to consideration for initial appointment; consequently he lacked locus to challenge the selection of respondent No.4.

The court also noted the hard result produced by the timing (publication on 31 December 2009 rather than 1 January 2010) and advised selection authorities to avoid such timing which may unfairly affect candidates, but nonetheless held that the legal position mandated dismissal of the appeal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The LPA is dismissed and the impugned judgment of the Single Judge dated 25 May 2012 is upheld.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The engagement of respondent No.4 as ReT stands; the appellant was not within the minimum prescribed age on the statutorily relevant date (1 January 2009) and therefore had no right to be considered or to challenge respondent No.4's selection.
  • Interpretive consequence: Article 37(1) must be read in conjunction with Article 37(3) and Note‑7; for initial appointments recommended by Recruitment Boards/PSC/Selection Committees, the minimum and maximum age limits are to be observed with reference to the first day of January of the year in which the advertisement notice is issued. An advertising authority cannot, by fixing a cutoff date in an advertisement, override the statutory prescription contained in Article 37 and Note‑7.
  • Practical guidance: Selection authorities are advised to avoid issuing or publishing advertisement notices at times (for example on 31 December) that produce harsh, arbitrary or uncertain results for competing candidates; the selection authority should prescribe clear cutoff dates in conformity with statutory rules to ensure certainty and fairness in the recruitment process.
  • No broader declaratory precedent beyond this construction is expressly set out beyond the interpretation of Article 37(1)/(3) and Note‑7 in the factual matrix of the case; the court applied existing principles of statutory construction to harmonize the provisions and to avoid anomalous results.

    Farooq Ahmad Nengroo Petitioner v. State Of J&K And Ors. S

    JUDGMENT:

    Muzaffar Hussain Attar.

    Different clauses of Article 37 of J&K Civil Service Regulations, 1956, (for short Regulations) have been worded and phrased differently by the rule making authority, which phraseology, not only appear to be creating anomalous situation, but also seem to be at logger heads with each other. When such type of provisions of law come up for consideration of the court, its first effort has to place purposeful construction on them. The court by applying judicial methodlogy has to harmonize and place such construction on them which would make them meaningful and effective. The Article 37 as it exists in the “Regulations” would require to be chisled in a manner which would make it purposeful and result oriented. Article 37 would require to be read down so as to being it within the frame work of Article 14 of Constitution.

    In our constitutional scheme not only jurisdiction but functions of three organs of the State viz executive, legislature and judiciary are delineated. Every organ of the State has to maintain diehard discipline in its functioning to ensure that it does not transgress its limits and usurp the powers and functions of one or other organ of the State. These organs of the State are like the creature of nature viz stars/planets, and have to strictly tread the path which has been delineated for them. Any deviation from natural course would result in collision of these organs of the nature and the consequences would be catastrophic. Likewise in democratic state like ours in which functioning of different organs of the State is regulated by the Constitution, any effort to breach the frontiers of other organs of the State would definitely have catastrophic effect on the body politic.

    The duty of the courts of law is to ensure that the other organs of the State function in accordance with the mandate contained in the Constitution and other laws. Further duty of the courts is to interpret the laws made by legislature as also the subordinate legislations. Under the guise of the interpreting laws, the courts cannot, however, assume unto themselves the functions of the legislature and start writing Statutes/laws, which certainly, is the function of the legislature. The function of Constitutional Courts is to interpret laws and in the first place construe them in a manner which would save them from rigour of provision of constitution.

    In the aforementioned backdrop a brief narration of facts of this case becomes imperative.

    On 13th August 2009 respondent No. 4 issued advertisement notice whereunder applications were invited from eligible candidates for seeking consideration for being selected/appointed as ReT which had become vacant because of resignation of person who was earlier appointed on the said post. One of the terms and conditions of the advertisement notice was that the last date for filing the applications would be cutoff date for determining age/eligibility/qualification. This advertisement notice was withdrawn by notification dated 14 Dec. 2009. The respondent No. 4, thereafter issued another notification dated 30 Dec. 2009 which was published in daily newspaper on 31st of Dec. 2009, whereunder the applications were invited from eligible candidates of the concerned revenue village having 10+2 and above qualification with Math and Science back ground, for engagement as ReT, besides in other schools in M.S Shumnag. One post was notified for being filled up in the said School. One of the condition contained in the re-advertisement notice was “the last date will be cutoff date for determining age/qualification/merit”.

    The appellant as also respondent no. 4 responded to the said notice and sought consideration for being selected/engaged as ReT in M.S Shumnag. Provisional merit panel was prepared on 27 Jan. 2010, in which the appellant on the basis of his merit figured at Sr. No. 1 and respondent No. 4 at Sr. No. 2. Selection list was issued on 4 Feb. 2010 by respondent No. 3 whereunder the appellant was provisionally recommended for being engaged as ReT in M.S Shumnag zone chadura. It was provided that any person having objection regarding the eligibility of the appellant shall file same with documentary proof within week's time from the date of publication of notice. The respondent No. 4 filed objections in which he stated that on the first day of Jan. 2009 appellant was below 18 years of age and in terms of Article 37 of the “Regulations” was ineligible for being engaged as ReT. The objection raised by respondent No. 4 found favour with the official respondents and respondent No. 4 was selected and ultimately engaged as ReT on 28 Oct. 2010. It is this order, which was called in question in the writ petition by the appellant.

    The respondents in their reply affidavit/objections filed before the writ court have taken a definite stand that the advertisement notice dated 30 Dec. 2009, was published on 31 of Dec. 2009 and appellant admittedly on 1 of Jan. 2009, had not attained the age of 18 years, thus, was not eligible and his selection for being engaged as ReT has rightly been cancelled/withdrawn and respondent No. 4 on the basis of his merit has been selected and engaged as ReT, thus, no fault can be found with the appointment of private respondent.

    The ld single judge vide his judgment dated 25 May 2012, dismissed the writ petition. The appellant being aggrieved of the order/judgment has challenged the same in this LPA.

    Mr. B.A Bashir, ld Sr. counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that it was provided in the re-advertisement notice dated 30 Dec. 2009, and published on 31 of Dec. 2009, that “the last date will be the cutoff date for determining age/qualification/merit”, and since the last date for submitting the application was 10 Jan. 2010, and not only on that date but even on the date of issuance of advertisement notice, appellant was within prescribed age limit, in as-much-as, he had attained the minimum prescribed age of 18 years on 31 of March, 2009, which fact is admitted by respondent No. 3 in his communication dated 17 May 2010, addressed to respondent No. 2 (annexure-L of writ petition). Ld counsel submitted that the advertisement notice constitutes representation to the eligible candidates and in view of terms and conditions contained therein the appellant as already stated was within prescribed age limit at the time advertisement notice was issued and in view of his superior merit he was rightly recommended for being engaged as ReT, but has been illegally deprived of the same. Ld counsel further submitted that Article 37(1) and Note-7 appended to said Article do not provide that the minimum prescribed age has to be reckoned as 1 of Jan. of the year in which the advertisement notice was issued. Ld counsel while referring to the Article 37(1) submitted that it mandates that the minimum and maximum age limit in respect of Direct Recruit to government service in the sub-ordinate and gazetted service has to be reckoned from first day of January of the year in which the “competitive examination is held or nomination is made in respect of the vacancy”. Ld counsel submitted that the language of the said “Regulation” would show that the age of 18 years has reference to the first day of January of the year in which the “competitive examination is held or nomination is made in respect of the vacancy” and not to the issuance of advertisement notice. Ld counsel further submitted that since the nomination in respect of the vacancy in the present case has been made in the year 2010, and admittedly on 1 day of January 2010, the appellant was above 18 years of age, he could not have been, thus, stripped off of his right of being engaged as ReT. Ld counsel further submitted that note-7 of Article 37 cannot control Article 37(1) and that it being marginal note cannot be referred to for purpose of construing the statute. Ld counsel further submitted that purpose of introducing Note 7 in Article 37 is to protect initial appointment to Government Service and will not be applicable to the facts of this case. Ld counsel in support of his contention referred to and relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case titled Board of Muslim Wakfs, Rajasthan, Appellant v. Radha Kishan, Respondents reported in (1979) 2 Supreme Court Cases 468; case titled Maharashtra Tubes Ltd., appellant v. State Industrial and Investment Corporation of Maharashtra Ltd., Respondents, reported in (1993) 2 SCC 144 and in case titled Datar Switchgears Ltd., Appellant v. Tata Finance Ltd., Respondents, reported in (2000) 8 Supreme Court Cases 151. Ld counsel, accordingly, prayed that LPA be allowed and the engagement order of respondent No. 4 be quashed, with further direction to official respondents to engage the appellant as ReT in place of respondent No. 4.

    Mr. S.A Naik ld counsel for official respondents submitted that in view of the mandate contained in note-7 of Article 37(1) the appellant was below prescribed minimum age limit on first Jan. 2009 and was ineligible, thus, could not be engaged as ReT.

    Mr. A. Haqani ld counsel for respondent No. 4 submitted that the, appellant, on 1 day of January 2009, admittedly was not within the minimum prescribed age limit of 18 years accordingly being not eligible could not have any grievance in law against the engagement of respondent No. 4 who admittedly was within the prescribed age limit on first day of January 2009 and on the basis of his merit was engaged and is continuously discharging his duties. Ld counsel submitted that Article 37(1) and Note-7 are to be construed in a manner which would ensure that the regulations/note is not manipulated to obtain the desired results by authorities. Ld counsel in support of his contention referred to the Division Bench judgment of this court in case titled Ms. Shaheena Masarat v. State, reported in 2010 (1) SLJ 477. Ld counsel made specific reference to paragraphs 34 and 35 of the said judgment.

    In order to appreciate the contentions raised at bar, it is apposite to take note of Rule-9 and Rule-17 of THE JAMMU AND KASHMIR CIVIL SERVICES (CLASSIFICATION, CONTROAL AND APPEAL) RULES, 1956 (for short Rules of 1956) and Article 37(1)(3) and Note-7 of the “Regulations.”

    “9. First appointments to a service or class may be made:-

    (a) by promotion from the same or by transfer from an other service or class, or

    (b) by direct recruitment, or

    (c) partly by (a) and partly by (b).

    “17. Qualification:- No person shall be eligible for appointment to any service by direct recruitment, unless:-

    (a) he is hereditary State Subject to be known hereafter as a permanent resident;

    (b) The age of the candidate for appointment to Government service shall be subject to the following maximum and minimum limits as on first day of January of the year in which the competitive examination is held or application are invited for a vacancy for which direct recruitment is made.

    Category Minimum age Maximum age

    1. General Candidates 18 years 35 years

    2. Members of Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes 18 years 38 years

    3. Physically handicapped 18 years 37 years

    4. Candidates already in Govt. Services. 38 years

    Provided that the age limit as shown above against each category may be relaxed by the competent Authority in respect of any individual case on the merits of each case.

    Provided further that Government may in respect of any particular service prescribe a different age limit”.

    (c) he satisfies the appointing authority that he is of sound health, active habits and free from any bodily defect or infirmity un-fitting him for such service; and

    (d) he satisfies the appointing authority that his character and antecedents are such as to qualify him for such service.

    [37. (1) Except in the case of direct recruits to (i) Kashmir Administrative Service (ii) Kashmir Police Service (iii) Kashmir Forest Service (iv) Kashmir.

    Accounts Service, in which case the minimum and maximum age limits for recruitment, will be governed by the recruitment rules of the respective services, the age of direct recruits to Government Service in the rest of subordinate and Gazette Services shall on the first date of January of the year in which competitive examination is held or the nomination is made in respect of the vacancy to which the direct recruitment is made, shall not be less than 18 years sand shall not exceed 30 years.

    Provided that the maximum age for such recruitment to the posts shown below does not exceed the limit indicated against each, Gezetted Service.

    Gezetted Service:

    1. Kashmir Medical Service ……. 32 years

    Non-Gezetted:

    1. Police Sub-Inspectors)

    2. Constables and Head Constables ..28 years

    3. Subordinate posts in Fire Services)

    4. Shepherds of the Sheep Breeding and … 35 years

    Provided that the upper age limits for entry into Government service in respect of handicapped persons shall be relaxed by 5 years.

    The age limit may be relaxed by the competent authority]

    37.(3) Notwithstanding anything otherwise contained in Articles 37(i) and 37(2) the following maximum age limits shall apply (and shall always be deemed to have applied from 16-12-1988) in respect of direct recruits to Government service in all the subordinate and Gezetted services on the first day of the January of the year in which the competitive examination is held or nomination is made in respect of the vacancy to which direct recruitment is made:—

    Category Maximum age

    (i) General candidates 35 years

    (ii) Physically handicapped 37 years

    (iii) Members of Scheduled Castes Scheduled Tribes 38 years

    (iv) Candidates already in Government Service 38 years

    Note 7— In the case of initial appointment to Government Service made on the recommendations of the Recruitment Boards, Public Service Commission, or any Selection Committee, the limitations of minimum and maximum age as contained in Article 37, shall be observed with reference to first day of January in which the advertisement notice for the post(s) is issued. This shall also apply to pending cases if-any.”

    One of the prescribed mode of first appointment to a service or class of service is by direct recruitment in terms of Rule-9 of Rules of 1956.

    Rule-17 of the Rules of 1956, deals with the qualification and provides that no person shall be eligible for appointment to any service by direct recruitment, if, as provided in clause (b) of the said Rule, he is below the minimum or above the maximum age limit as may be prescribed by the Government for direct recruitment to the service or class or post under rules applicable, either general, or with reference to any particular service, class or post. It is further provided that age limit may be relaxed by the competent authority in any individual case.

    The conjoint reading of Rule-9(b) and Rule-17(b) provide that when a person is appointed as a direct recruit, he has not to be below the minimum and above maximum age limit as prescribed by the Government. These rules, however, do not provide as to which shall be the stage of recruitment process at which the minimum and maximum age limit prescribed by the Government has to be applied. It may not be out of place to mention here that temporary provisions have been made in terms of Rule-17 of the Rules of 1956, whereunder, the upper age limit for appointment to government service in clause (b) was relaxed by 1/2 years from time to time.

    Article 37(1) of the “Regulations” deals with two types of direct recruitments, viz., Kashmir Administrative Service/Kashmir Police Service/Kashmir Forest Service and Kashmir Accounts Service, in which case it has been provided that the minimum and maximum age limits for recruitment will be governed by recruitment rules of the respective services, and the another part of the said Article provide that the age of direct recruitment in the government service in the rest of the subordinate and gazetted services shall on the first day of Jan of the year “in which the competitive examination is held or nomination is made in respect of the vacancy to which the direct recruitment is made”, be not less than 18 years and shall not exceed 30 years. In terms of Article 37(3), the upper age limit has been prescribed as 35 years for general category candidates, 37 years physically handicapped and 38 years for Schedule caste, Schedule tribe and in service government candidates. The minimum age of 18 years as prescribed in Article 37(1) has reference to the year of competitive examination or the nomination made in respect of the vacancy.

    In common parlance it would mean that in the year the competitive examination is held or nomination is made in respect of vacancy in direct recruitment process, the candidate shall not be less than 18 years of age and shall not exceed the age as prescribed under “Regulations” 37(3). The phraseology of the Article 37(1) of the “Regulations”, if read in isolation of other clauses and is given effect, would trigger off an anomalous situation and will give rise to complete chaos in recruitment process.

    Assume a situation that advertisement notice is issued in year 2012 and a candidate “A” is unable to respond to the said notice being below the minimum prescribed age limit of 18 years on the last date fixed in the advertisement notice. For any reason the competitive examination is not held in the same year but is held in 2013, or nomination is made in respect of the vacancy in the year 2013 and before completing of aforementioned eventualities, the candidate who was not eligible being below the prescribed age limit on the last cutoff date for filing application forms, comes up of age and becomes eligible for seeking consideration for being selected/appointed on the post advertised in the year 2012 in view of the expressions used in Article 37(1) would it stand to reason to say that a candidate who was ineligible when the recruitment process was initiated by issuance of advertisement notice can be considered for being selected/appointed on the post in the year when competitive examination is held or nomination is made, moreso, when he has not been part of the recruitment process. If such an argument is accepted then analmous situation would be created. Not only that the selection process cannot be brought to its logical conclusion as there would be apparent conflict of interest between those candidates who were eligible on the last date fixed in the advertisement notice and those, who were ineligible on the said date and were not part of selection process, but still would claim to be considered for being selected/appointed in view of the language used in Article 37(1) of the “Regulations”, and will also vitiate the entire selection process for violating Article 14 of Constitution. The interpretation sought to be placed by Mr. B.A Bashir ld sr. counsel appearing for the appellant on Article 37(1) in these circumstances cannot be accepted. The expression “age of direct recruitment to Government service…….on the first day of January of the year in which the competitive examination is held or the nomination is made in respect of the vacancy….. shall not be less than 18 years and shall not exceed 30 years” has to be considered in conjunction with other clauses and Notes of Art. 37.

    The clause (1) of the Article 37 has been re-numbered vide F.D Notification SRO-23rd dated 14 January, 1991. The clause (III) of Article 37 has been re-numbered/inserted vide the same F.D Notification SRO 23 dated 14 Jan. 1991. The Note-7 has been inserted in Article 37 of the “Regulations” by F.D Notification SRO-19 dated 25.1.1982 The Note-7 is a statutory note inserted in Article 37 and is not a marginal note.

    It may not be out of place to mention here, that when this position was indicated to ld counsel for the appellant, he also fairly conceded that the Note-7 is not marginal note, though at the time of commencement of the submissions ld counsel had argued that note-7 is a marginal note and same cannot be referred to for the purpose of construing the Article 37(1) of “Regulations” and for this reliance was placed by him on decision of Hon'ble S.C in cases of Board of Muslim Wakfs' and Maharashtra Tubes Ltd.

    The Note-7 which is the statutory note and inserted way back in the year 1982, in fact is clarificatory in nature and the intention of the rule making authority as manifested in Article 37 is made clear by it. The plain language of note-7 would show that at the time of initial appointment to government service made on the recommendations of the recruitment board/PSC or any selection committee, the limitations of minimum and maximum age as contained in Article 37 have to be mandatorily observed with reference to first day of January in which year the advertisement notice for the post(s) was issued. The plain construction of the Note-7 would, thus, get manifested in one fact that at the time of initial appointment of a person to government service, the minimum age limit prescribed by the Article 37 would have reference to first day of January in which the advertisement notice for the post(s) was issued. Article 37 has prescribed the minimum age limit of 18 years for seeking consideration for being appointed as a direct recruit to government service. Since the recruitment process is initiated by issuance of advertisement notice, thus, on the first day of January in which year the advertisement notice is issued for filling up of post(s), the candidate must have minimum age of 18 years. The note-7 of Article 37 of the “Regulations” has the potential of accomplishing two purposes viz one that a candidate at the time of issuance of advertisement notice may be within the prescribed upper age limit and for any reason the recruitment process may get delayed and by the time he is recommended for initial appointment he may have crossed the maximum age limit prescribed, it would cause great injustice to such person and in order to remedy the mischief and wrong, maximum age limit at the time of his initial appointment, has to date back to first day of January of the year in which the advertisement notice is issued. Secondly, on the same analogy a candidate has to be possessed of minimum age limit prescribed on the first day of January of the year in which the advertisement notice for the post(s) was issued. The aforementioned construction and interpretation placed on note-7 of Article 37 would end the confusion and the uncertainty that may otherwise arise. The selection authority is duty bound to avoid creating of a situation which would give rise to uncertainty in the selection process, and providing scope for creating uncertainty in the selection process is neither in the interest of competing candidates and nor that of the selection authority/government. There are two ways of providing certainty and avoiding confusion in the selection process; one is that, date for settling the eligibility qualification would be determined by the statutory rules, and other, would be to determine it by providing such clauses in the advertisement notice. The Article 37(1)(3) and note-7 when read in conjunction prescribe minimum and maximum age limit and this prescription has reference to first day of January of the year in which the advertisement notice for the post(s) is issued. The selection authority is duty bound to prescribe cutoff date in the advertisement notice for determining age and other education/technical qualification so as to ensure that the selection process is initiated and concluded in smooth manner and without creating confusion in the minds of the candidate(s) about the same.

    One of the admitted modes of construing the statute or provisions of statute is to read it in conjunction with the other clauses of the same provision or with preceding and succeeding clause of the same statute/statutory rules.

    In its setting the Article 37(1) cannot be read in isolation to other clauses and the statutory notes of the said Article. Different clauses and Notes of Article 37 have to be harmonized and blended with each other and it is only by construing the Article 37 in its entirety, the appropriate results can be derived. Reading Article 37(1) in isolation would otherwise be not in accordance with the Scheme of Article 37 and has to be read with other clauses/statutory notes thereof. Reading Article 37(1) in isolation and not in unison with other clauses and statutory notes of Article 37 would attract the observation made by Hon'ble S.C in case titled Rekha Chaturvedi (SMT) … Petitioner v. University of Rajasthan … Respondents, reported in 1993 (Suppl) (3) SCC 168 and paragraph-10 thereof is taken note of:-

    “The contention that the required qualifications of the candidates should be examined with reference to the date of selection and not with reference to the last date for making applications has only to be stated to be rejected. The date of selection is invariably uncertain. In the absence of knowledge of such date the candidates who apply for the posts would be unable to state whether they are qualified for the posts in question or not it they are yet to acquire the qualifications. Unless the advertisement mentions a fixed date with reference to which the qualifications are to be judged, whether the said date is of selection or otherwise, it would not be possible for the candidates who do not possess the requisite qualifications in praesenti even to make applications for the posts. The uncertainly of the date may also lead to a contrary consequence, viz, even those candidates who do not have the qualifications in praesenti and are likely to acquire them at an uncertain future date, may apply for the posts thus swelling the number of applications. But a still worse consequence may follow, in that it may leave open a scope for malpractices. The date of selection may be so fixed or manipulated as to entertain some applicants and reject others, arbitrarily. Hence, in the absence of a fixed date indicated in the advertisement/notification inviting applications with reference to which the requisite qualifications should be judged, the only certain date for the scrutiny of the qualifications will be the last date for making the selection/committee in the present case, as argued by Shri Manoj Swarup, took into consideration the requisite qualifications as on the date of selection Committee in the present case, as argued by Shri Manoj Swarup, took into consideration the requisite qualifications as on the date of selection rather than on the last date of preferring applications, it acted with patent illegality and on this ground itself the selections in question are liable to be quashed. Reference in this connection may also be made to two recent decisions of this Court in A.P Public Service Commission, Hyderabad v. B. Sarat Chandra and District Collector and Chairman, Vizianagaram Social Welfare Residential School Society Vizianagaram v. M. Tripura Sundari Devi.”

    The Division Bench of this court in case titled Ms. Shaheena Masarat v. State, reported in 2010 (I) S.L.J, ruled that Article 37 of J&K Civil Service Regulations is applicable to the posts under Re-T.

    In order to give proper meaning, interpretation and construction to Art. 37(1) of the “Regulations” and in order to make it in tune with service jurisprudence and the purpose of making the direct recruitment which has to be made in accordance with the mandate contained in Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India, for our above stated reasons, it is held that the expression “the age of direct recruitment to government service in respect of subordinate and gazetted services shall on the first day of January of the year in which the competitive examination is held or the nomination is made in respect of the vacancy to which the direct recruitment is made, shall not be less than 18 years and shall not exceed 30/35/37 and 38 years,” to mean that this minimum age limit has reference to first day of January in which year by issuance of advertisement notice the recruitment process is started.

    The stipulations contained in the advertisement notice dated 30 Dec. 2009 provide besides other things about the age to be determinable with reference to the last cutoff date, which in view of the mandate contained in Article 37(1)(3) and note-7 cannot be fixed by an officer of the government as he has no authority to fix the same and it is to be fixed in accordance with the mandate contained in Article 37(1)(3) and note-7.

    In any event Article 37 of “Regulations” has to prevail and the cutoff date fixed for determining the age by respondent No. 4 in the factual and legal background of this case will be inconsequential, same being not in accord with statutory rule.

    In view of our above stated discussions, the appellant admittedly was not within the minimum prescribed age limit on first day January 2009 in which year the advertisement notice was issued and consequently was not clothed with any right to seek consideration for being selected/engaged as ReT. The appellant being not an aggrieved person in law could not challenge the selection/engagement of respondent No. 4 in the writ petition.

    However, one thing which stares us is the date on which the advertisement notice was published viz 31 of Dec. 2009. Had the advertisement notice been issued on first of Jan. 2010, the appellant would be eligible and on the basis of his merit would have been engaged as ReT. The issuance and publication of advertisement notice has worked harshly to the rights and interests of the appellant. The selection authorities are advised to avoid issuance and publication of advertisement notice in the manner in which it has been done in this case, as by gap of twelve hours the fate of meritorious candidate(s) got sealed. It, otherwise, does not appear to be reasonable and just to publish an advertisement notice on 31 of December of the year when the minimum age of the competing candidate(s) has to be determined with reference to the first day of January of the said year.

    For our reasons recorded in this order, the impugned judgment does not call for any interference and LPA is accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Farooq Ahmad Nengroo Petitioner v. State Of J&K And Ors. S
    (Aug 23, 2012)