Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • suit.4. Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C
  • Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C6.
  • Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • suit.4. Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C
  • Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C6.
  • Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent-plaintiff filed a suit against the petitioner-defendant seeking an injunction claiming title over certain immovable property described as a tin-shed premises. The petitioner-defendant also claimed title to the property based on a registered sale deed. The respondent-plaintiff challenged the validity of the sale deed, asserting it was invalid in law. During the trial, the respondent-plaintiff filed an application under Order 16 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Code (C.P.C.) to summon the admission register and Transfer Certificate (T.C.) from E.V. Reddy College, Kodad, which indicated that the petitioner was a minor at the time of executing the sale deed. The petitioner contested the Trial Court's authority to summon documents from a third-party public office without the respondent-plaintiff demonstrating the relevancy of those documents to the suit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court had the authority under Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C. to summon documents from a third party without prior consideration of their relevancy or legality.
  2. Whether the petitioner can challenge the summons for production of documents on the ground that the respondent-plaintiff did not establish the relevancy of the documents before the Court issued the summons.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The Trial Court lacked authority to summon documents from the custody of a third party, particularly a public office, without the respondent-plaintiff first showing the relevancy of those documents for adjudication.
  • The validity of the sale deed should not be challenged by summoning documents without proper legal basis or scrutiny by the Court at the summons stage.

Respondent-Plaintiff’s Arguments

  • The respondent-plaintiff sought to summon the admission register and T.C. to establish that the petitioner was a minor at the time of executing the sale deed, which is relevant to the challenge against the validity of the sale deed.
  • Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C. empowers the Court to summon any person to produce documents without requiring the person to appear personally to give evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C. Authority of the Court to summon any person to produce documents without requiring personal attendance for evidence. The Court held that the provision does not require prior scrutiny of the relevancy or legality of the document before summoning it from a third party; compliance with the summons by producing the document satisfies the rule.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the scope of Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C., emphasizing that it authorizes summoning a person to produce a document without necessitating personal attendance for giving evidence. The Court clarified that it is not the Court’s duty at the stage of issuing summons to scrutinize the relevancy or legality of the documents sought. Instead, the parties are free to adduce any oral or documentary evidence to substantiate their claims, and the Court will consider the relevancy or validity of such evidence only after it is tendered. Consequently, the Court found no illegality or jurisdictional error in the Trial Court’s order summoning the admission register and T.C. from the college, even though the petitioner challenged the summons on the ground of lack of demonstrated relevancy at the summons stage.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the Criminal Revision Petition (C.R.P.) at the admission stage, upholding the Trial Court’s authority to summon documents under Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C. The direct effect is that the petitioner’s challenge to the summons was rejected, allowing the respondent-plaintiff to obtain the documents for use in the suit. No broader precedent beyond the interpretation and application of Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C. was established.

    Chekka Krishna Prasad v. Kotha Appa Rao .

    1. Heard.

    2. Mr. Y. Venkateswarulu, the learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the respondent-plaintiff has filed a suit against the petitioner who is the defendant therein for a mere injunction claiming title over certain immovable property which is said to be a tin-shed premises, for which, the petitioner-defendant is also claiming title on the basis of a registered sale deed; but, the respondent-plaintiff challenges the validity of the said sale deed in favour of the petitioner-defendant on the ground that it is invalid in law.

    3. The Trial Court, on an application filed by the respondent-plaintiff under Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C has allowed the petition to summon admission register and T.C from E.V Reddy College, Kodad, which reflects the age of the petitioner as a minor on the date of execution of the sale deed. In this regard, the learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Court has no authority to summon a document from the custody of third party, especially public office, without the respondent-plaintiff showing the relevancy of the particular document for adjudication of the rights of the parties in the suit.

    4. Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C is to the following effect:

    “Summons to Produce Document: Any person may be summoned to produce a document without being summoned to give evidence and any person summoned merely to produce a document shall be deemed to have complied with the summons if he causes such document to be produced instead of attending personally to produce the same.”

    5. It must be remembered that the parties to the suit are at liberty to adduce oral and documentary evidence, whatsoever according to their choice in order to substantiate their case. The question of relevancy or validity of documents, after they are tendered in evidence, shall be considered by the Court in accordance with law. Before a document is summoned from the custody of any office, the Court cannot embark upon a duty to scrutinise or consider the legality or relevancy of the same before it is actually tendered in evidence and Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C does not mandate this to the Court. Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C is in simple language wherein it is stated that any person may be summoned to produce a document without being summoned to give evidence and any person summoned merely to produce a document shall be deemed to have complied with the summons, if he causes such document to be produced instead of attending personally to produce the same. The affect of this Rule is that the Court has the authority to summon any person to be summoned to produce a document and if a document is produced or it is caused to be produced before the Court in compliance with such summons, it is due compliance of Order 16 Rule 6 C.P.C

    6. The rights of the parties or adjudication on the issues between the parties to the suit will be decided on consideration of all the material which is placed before the Court and a party cannot be restrained to call for the documents, which it feels that the said documents are relevant and necessary to substantiate its case.

    7. In the above view of the matter, I do not see any illegality or jurisdictional error in the order passed by the Trial Court. As such, this C.R.P lacks merits.

    8. Accordingly, this C.R.P is dismissed at the admission stage.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chekka Krishna Prasad v. Kotha Appa Rao .
    (Dec 3, 1997)