Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The matter arises from a dispute within the Posts and Telegraphs Department concerning promotions from Junior Engineer to Assistant Engineer. Promotions occur through two channels: (i) a Departmental Qualifying Examination (filling two-thirds of posts) and (ii) a Departmental Competitive Examination (filling one-third). This appeal concerns the first category and, specifically, the manner of preparing the eligibility list of candidates who have passed the Departmental Qualifying Examination for consideration by the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC).

Clause 6 of Appendix I in the Schedule to the Telegraph Engineering Service (Class II) Recruitment Rules, 1966 provides that eligibility lists shall be prepared in accordance with Government instructions issued from time to time. It was stated that Government of India instructions were issued via a Memorandum dated 28-6-1966, including that separate lists be prepared for each year of recruitment/appointment (subject to specified clauses).

Before the Tribunal, the respondents contended that lists should be prepared with reference to the year of confirmation. The Tribunal did not accept that position, nor did it uphold the Department’s position, and instead directed preparation of lists based on the year of passing the Departmental Qualifying Examination. The Union of India appealed. Although the respondents were served, no one appeared for them; the court heard counsel for the appellant (Union of India).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. How should the eligibility list of candidates who have passed the Departmental Qualifying Examination be prepared for consideration by the Departmental Promotion Committee under Clause 6 of Appendix I to the Telegraph Engineering Service (Class II) Recruitment Rules, 1966 and the relevant Government instructions—by year of recruitment/appointment, by year of confirmation, or by year of passing the qualifying examination?
  2. Whether the Tribunal acted impermissibly by directing preparation of eligibility lists on a basis not provided in the rule/instructions (i.e., by year of passing the examination), thereby effectively rewriting the rule.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court focused on the governing text: Clause 6 of Appendix I to the 1966 Recruitment Rules, which mandates that eligibility lists be prepared in accordance with Government instructions issued from time to time. The court then considered the Government of India Memorandum dated 28-6-1966 issued pursuant to Clause 6, which (to the extent reproduced) provides that separate eligibility lists shall be prepared for each year of recruitment/appointment.

Reading Clause 6 together with the quoted instructions, the court concluded that the eligibility lists must be prepared according to the year of recruitment/appointment. The Tribunal’s direction to prepare lists on the basis of the year of passing the Departmental Qualifying Examination was held to be inconsistent with the rule and instructions.

The court further reasoned that the Tribunal’s approach effectively amounted to “rewriting the rule,” which it should not have done. On this basis, the court interfered with and set aside the Tribunal’s orders.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED: The appeal was allowed; the Tribunal’s order directing preparation of eligibility lists by the year of passing the Departmental Qualifying Examination was set aside. The Tribunal’s order dismissing the Union of India’s review was also set aside. No costs were awarded.

The direct effect is that eligibility lists for DPC consideration in the relevant promotional channel must be prepared according to the year of recruitment/appointment as indicated by the rule read with the Government instructions referenced in the opinion. The opinion does not discuss broader implications beyond setting aside the Tribunal’s contrary directions, and it does not set out any new precedent.

    Union Of India v. Madras Telephones Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes Social Welfare Association .

    Order

    1. Though the respondents are served, no one appears for them. We have heard Shri R. Venugopal Reddy, learned counsel for the appellant — Union of India.

    2. In the Posts and Telegraphs Department, there are two methods of promotion from the post of Junior Engineer to the post of Assistant Engineer. Two-thirds of the posts are filled on the basis of Departmental Qualifying Examination while the remaining one-third are filled on the basis of a Departmental Competitive Examination. We are concerned in this appeal with the first mentioned category and the question is how should the eligibility list of candidates, who have passed the Departmental Qualifying Examination for consideration of the Departmental Promotion Committee be prepared. Clause 6 of Appendix I in the Schedule to the Rules to Telegraph Engineering Service (Class II) Recruitment Rules, 1966 provides:

    “6. The eligibility lists of the candidates who have passed the Departmental Qualifying Examination for consideration of the Departmental Promotion Committee, shall be prepared in accordance with the instructions, as may be issued by the Government from time to time.”

    3. It is stated that pursuant to the said clause 6, instructions have been issued by the Government of India in its Memorandum dated 28-6-1966. Insofar as is relevant, it reads as follows:

    “In pursuance of para 6 of Appendix I of the Government of India, Department of Communication, P&T Board Notification No. 108/11/49-STA dated the 15th June, 1966 it has been decided that, the eligibility list for consideration by the Departmental Promotion Committee for promotion to Telegraph Engineering Service, Class II, from amongst the Engineering Supervisors, Wireless Supervisors and ex-company officials, who qualify in the prescribed Telegraph Engineering Service, Class II Promotional Examination, shall be prepared in the following manner:
    (i) Separate lists shall be prepared for each year of recruitment/appointment, subject to the provisions in clauses (vi) and (vii) below.”

    4. From the aforesaid clause read with instructions, it is clear that the eligibility lists have to be prepared according to the year of recruitment/appointment. The respondent's case, before the Tribunal, however, was that the said lists should be prepared not with reference to the year of recruitment/appointment but with reference to the year of confirmation. The Tribunal neither accepted their statement nor did it uphold the Department's case but directed that these lists should be prepared on the basis of the year of the passing of the Departmental Qualifying Examination and not on the basis of the year of recruitment/appointment. In our opinion what the Tribunal has done really amounts to rewriting the rule which should not have been done by it. The appeal is accordingly allowed. The order of the Tribunal is set aside. For the same reasons, the order dismissing the review filed by the Union of India, by the Tribunal, is also set aside. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India v. Madras Telephones Sc...
    (Feb 13, 1997)