AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 142 of the Constitution
  • Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)
  • Criminal Procedure Code, 1973
  • Section 164-A CrPC inserted by Act 25 of 2005 in CrPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 142 of the Constitution
  • Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)
  • Criminal Procedure Code, 1973
  • Section 164-A CrPC inserted by Act 25 of 2005 in CrPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The court had earlier passed an order on 30-8-2013 (reported at 2014 8 SCC 916) expressing concern about the absence of a genuinely “fast-track” procedure for rape and gang-rape trials despite the existence of Fast Track Courts. Notices were issued to the Union of India, the Law Commission of India, State Law Commissions, and State Law Secretaries to elicit suggestions for procedural reform, particularly concerning the recording of victim and witness statements. Responses were received, including one from the Law Commission of India, which agreed in principle with the need for reform but cautioned that proposed changes might affect police investigations. Senior members of the Bar were then invited to assist the court. Following submissions by learned Senior Counsel and the Additional Solicitor General, the court proceeded to pronounce the present interim order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a streamlined, fast-track procedure should be introduced—by judicial direction pending legislative action—for recording statements of victims and witnesses in rape and gang-rape cases under Section 164 CrPC, bypassing multiple recordings under Section 161 CrPC.
  2. Whether such statements, once recorded by a Metropolitan or preferably Lady Judicial Magistrate, can be treated as evidence at trial subject only to cross-examination, thereby expediting proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Submissions by Court-appointed Amicus (Mr Shekhar Naphade, Senior Advocate)

  • Supported the court’s proposal that the victim’s statement be recorded under Section 164 CrPC before a Lady Judicial Magistrate.
  • Suggested that the recorded statement be placed on record, treated as evidence, and later tested only through cross-examination to avoid duplication and delay.

Submissions by the Union of India (Mr Siddharth Luthra, Additional Solicitor General)

  • Drew the court’s attention to possible implications for the trial if the victim’s Section 164 statement were made directly admissible as substantive evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court emphasised that the repetitive recording of evidence under the existing framework is a principal cause of delay in rape trials. Observing an alarming rise in cases of rape and gang-rape nationwide, it deemed immediate procedural reform imperative. The court reasoned that:

  • Recording the victim’s and key witnesses’ testimony once, at the earliest stage, before a Judicial Magistrate under Section 164 CrPC would eliminate redundant evidence-taking.
  • Such testimony, sealed and produced at trial, could be subjected to cross-examination by the defence, preserving fair-trial rights while substantially shortening trial duration.
  • Given the urgency and constitutional obligation to ensure speedy justice, the court invoked its powers under Article 142 to issue interim directions pending legislative amendment.

Holding and Implications

INTERIM MANDAMUS ISSUED: Exercising powers under Article 142, the court directed every Police Station-in-Charge across the country to comply with a five-point protocol, including:

  • Immediate presentation of the victim before a (preferably lady) Metropolitan or Judicial Magistrate for recording a Section 164 CrPC statement, with confidentiality safeguards.
  • Prompt medical examination under Section 164-A CrPC and transmission of the report to the Magistrate.
  • Documentation of the exact time the investigating officer learned of the offence and any delay beyond 24 hours in taking the victim to the Magistrate, with reasons recorded in the case diary.

Copies of the order are to be circulated by all Directors General and Commissioners of Police for state-wide implementation. The matter is to be listed after four weeks for compliance review.

Implications: The ruling imposes an immediately operative, uniform procedure intended to expedite rape investigations and trials. It affects investigative practice nationwide but does not create binding precedent on substantive evidentiary law; longer-term legislative amendment remains anticipated.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Karnataka By Nonavinakere Police v. Shivanna Alias Tarkari Shivanna .

    Order

    1. Vide order dated 30-8-2013 (2014) 8 SCC 916, we had proposed to consider this matter on merit after service of notice to the respondent-accused as we felt acutely concerned as to why the Union of India should not take initiative and steps to evolve a procedure for fast track justice to be adopted by the investigating agencies and the Fast Track Courts by proposing amendments into the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) for speedy justice to the victim.

    2. We had noted that the Fast Track Courts no doubt are being constituted for expeditious disposal of cases involving the charge of rape at the trial stage, but we are perturbed and anguished to notice that although there are Fast Track Courts for disposal of such cases, we do not yet have a fast track procedure for dealing with cases of rape and gang rape lodged under Section 376 IPC with the result that such heinous offences are repeated incessantly.

    3. We had further observed that there is a pressing need to introduce drastic amendments into CrPC in the nature of fast track procedure for Fast Track Courts when we considered just and appropriate to issue notice and called upon the Union of India to file its response as to why it should not take initiative and sincere steps for introducing necessary amendment into the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 involving trial for the charge of “rape” by directing that all the witnesses who are examined in relation to the offence and incident of rape cases should be straightaway produced preferably before the Lady Judicial Magistrate for recording their statement to be kept in sealed cover and thereafter the same be treated as evidence at the stage of trial by producing the same in record in accordance with law which may be put to test by subjecting it to cross-examination. We were and are further of the view that the statement of victim should as far as possible be recorded preferably before the Lady Judicial Magistrate under Section 164 CrPC skipping over the recording of statement by the police under Section 161 CrPC to be kept in sealed cover and thereafter the same be treated as evidence at the stage of trial which may be put to test by subjecting it to cross-examination.

    4. We are further of the view that the statement of victim should as far as possible be recorded preferably before the Lady Judicial Magistrate under Section 164 CrPC skipping over the recording of statement by the police under Section 161 CrPC which in any case is inadmissible except for contradiction so that the statement of the accused thereafter be recorded under Section 313 CrPC. The accused then can be committed to the appropriate court for trial whereby the trial court can straightaway allow cross-examination of the witnesses whose evidence were recorded earlier before the Judicial Magistrate.

    5. What we wished to emphasise is that the recording of evidence of the victim and other witnesses multiple times ought to be put to an end which is the primary reason for delay of the trial. We are of the view that if the evidence is recorded for the first time itself before the Judicial Magistrate under Section 164 CrPC and the same be kept in sealed cover to be produced and treated as deposition of the witnesses and hence admissible at the stage of trial with liberty to the defence to cross-examine them with further liberty to the accused to lead his defence witness and other evidence with a right to cross-examination by the prosecution, it can surely cut short and curtail the protracted trial if it is introduced at least for trial of rape cases which is bound to reduce the duration of trial and thus offer a speedy remedy by way of a fast track procedure to the Fast Track Court to resort to.

    6. Considering the consistent recurrence of the heinous crime of rape and gang rape all over the country including the metropolitan cities, we are of the view that it is high time such measures of reform in CrPC be introduced after deliberation and debate by the legal fraternity as also all concerned.

    7. We had therefore issued notice to the Union of India as also the Law Commission of India and all the State Law Commissions and the Law Secretaries of the States for eliciting their views on the subject. The Law Commission of India filed its response to the same, and although in principle agree that the proposed changes in CrPC are justified, it is of the opinion that the same might prejudice the investigation of the case by the police. Thereafter, we thought appropriate to invite the views of the legal fraternity and hence a general notice was issued to the members of the Bar to assist the Court considering the importance of the issue raised.

    8. We, thereafter, appointed the learned Senior Counsel Mr Shekhar Naphade and Mr U.U Lalit, who appeared and addressed this Court. The learned Senior Advocate Mr Shekhar Naphade agreed with the suggestions given by this Court that the statement of the victim of rape and gang rape may be and should be recorded under Section 164 CrPC which should be placed on record, treated as evidence of the victim and may later be relied upon as evidence and then the accused may be given a chance to cross-examine the prosecution version and the evidence recorded at the instance of the victim. The learned Senior Counsel Mr Shekhar Naphade was good enough to give us a brief note in this regard.

    9. The learned Additional Solicitor General Mr Siddharth Luthra also ably assisted us and drew the attention of this Court regarding the implications on the trial in case the statement of victim is recorded under Section 164 CrPC and is made admissible for the purpose of trial.

    10. On considering the same, we have accepted the suggestion offered by the learned counsel who appeared before us and hence exercising powers under Article 142 of the Constitution, we are pleased to issue interim directions in the form of mandamus to all the Police Stations-in-Charge in the entire country to follow the directions of this Court which are as follows:

    10.1 Upon receipt of information relating to the commission of offence of rape, the investigating officer shall make immediate steps to take the victim to any Metropolitan/preferably Judicial Magistrate for the purpose of recording her statement under Section 164 CrPC. A copy of the statement under Section 164 CrPC should be handed over to the investigating officer immediately with a specific direction that the contents of such statement under Section 164 CrPC should not be disclosed to any person till charge-sheet/report under Section 173 CrPC is filed.

    10.2 The investigating officer shall as far as possible take the victim to the nearest Lady Metropolitan/preferably Lady Judicial Magistrate.

    10.3 The investigating officer shall record specifically the date and the time at which he learnt about the commission of the offence of rape and the date and time at which he took the victim to the Metropolitan/preferably Lady Judicial Magistrate as aforesaid.

    10.4 If there is any delay exceeding 24 hours in taking the victim to the Magistrate, the investigating officer should record the reasons for the same in the case diary and hand over a copy of the same to the Magistrate.

    10.5 Medical examination of the victim: Section 164-A CrPC inserted by Act 25 of 2005 in CrPC imposes an obligation on the part of investigating officer to get the victim of the rape immediately medically examined. A copy of the report of such medical examination should be immediately handed over to the Magistrate who records the statement of the victim under Section 164 CrPC.

    11. A copy of this order thus be circulated to all the Directors General of Police of all the States/Commissioners of Police in Metropolitan cities/Commissioners of Police of Union Territories who are then directed to send a copy of this order to all the Police Stations-in-Charge in their States/Union Territories for its compliance in cases which are registered on or after the receipt of a copy of these directions. Necessary instructions by the DGPs/Commissioners of Police be also issued to all the Police Stations-in-Charge by the DGPs/Commissioners of Police incorporating the directions issued by us and recorded hereinbefore.

    12. The matter be posted again after four weeks to ensure compliance with this order by the DGPs and Commissioners of Police in the country before the appropriate Bench and also for such other further order or orders which may be considered necessary.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Karnataka By Nonavinakere Police v. Shivanna Alias Tarkari Shivanna .
    (Apr 25, 2014)