AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 143, 147, 323, 324, 427, 435 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution
  • Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1959
  • Section 3(1) of the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984
  • the said articles
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 143, 147, 323, 324, 427, 435 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution
  • Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1959
  • Section 3(1) of the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984
  • the said articles
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 2 March 2012, during the scheduled production of former Karnataka Minister Shri Janardhana Reddy before the 46th Additional City Civil and Special Judge (CBI) at the Bangalore City Civil Court Complex, a large crowd gathered. A scuffle erupted among advocates, police, and media persons, leading to injuries, property damage, and the registration of 191 criminal cases against various groups.

The Advocates Association, Bangalore, lodged complaints against alleged police excesses and sought a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe. The State Government instead ordered an internal inquiry by the Director General of Police, CID, who reported supervisory lapses but could not identify individual policemen.

Multiple writ petitions, including W.P. No. 7623 of 2012, were filed in the Karnataka High Court. On 16 May 2012, the High Court constituted a Special Investigation Team (SIT) headed by Dr R.K. Raghavan. Subsequent Supreme Court proceedings on 19 October 2012 reconstituted the SIT and fixed a three-month deadline for completion of investigation.

Despite several State Government notifications, the SIT was never fully constituted and the investigation did not commence. The Advocates Association appealed to the Supreme Court and filed a contempt petition and I.A. No. 8 seeking transfer of the probe to the CBI.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the continued failure to constitute an effective SIT justified transferring the investigation of the 2 March 2012 courtroom violence to the Central Bureau of Investigation.
  2. Whether the High Court’s order constituting an SIT should be set aside in light of subsequent non-compliance and delay.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant Association

  • Emphasised that, despite High Court and Supreme Court directions, no investigation had begun even after more than a year.
  • Argued that, because the incident involved advocates, police, and media, only an independent agency like the CBI could ensure an impartial probe.

Respondent State of Karnataka

  • Attributed delay to the need for clarifications regarding SIT composition.
  • Maintained that entrusting the matter to the CBI was unnecessary.

Union of India

  • Stated that the CBI would comply with any Supreme Court order but preferred that the SIT continue due to the CBI’s heavy workload.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of W.B. v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights (2010) 3 SCC 571 High Courts, under Article 226, may direct the CBI to investigate offences within a State without State consent, but such power must be used sparingly and in exceptional circumstances. The Court applied the criteria outlined in paras 69–70 to conclude that the present case was exceptional and warranted transfer of investigation to the CBI.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that, despite explicit directions from both the High Court (16 May 2012) and itself (19 October 2012), the investigation had not even begun because the SIT was never fully formed. This “unfortunate” inertia demonstrated that the existing mechanism was ineffective.

Invoking the principles articulated in Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights, the Court examined whether circumstances were “exceptional” enough to warrant a CBI probe. It observed:

  • The incident involved multiple stakeholder groups—advocates, police, and media—raising concerns about impartiality.
  • More than fifteen months had elapsed without any investigative progress, undermining public confidence.
  • The SIT’s composition remained unresolved, proving institutional incapacity.

Given these factors, the Court found that transferring the investigation to the CBI was necessary to “provide credibility and instil confidence,” squarely fitting the constitutional benchmarks for such a transfer.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Supreme Court set aside the Karnataka High Court’s order constituting an SIT, modified its own earlier order, and entrusted the entire investigation to the Central Bureau of Investigation. The Court directed the CBI to file its report before the competent court in Bangalore within six months and ordered the State/SIT to hand over all records immediately.

Implications: The decision terminates the stalled SIT process and places responsibility on the CBI, ensuring an independent probe. The ruling does not create new legal doctrine but reinforces the circumstances under which superior courts may mandate a CBI investigation when State-level mechanisms fail.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Advocates Association, Bangalore v. Union Of India And Others

    P. Sathasivam, C.J— Leave granted. This appeal is filed against the final judgment and order dated 16-5-2012 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in Advocates Assn. v. Union of India (2012) 3 KCCR 2246, (2012) 3 AIR Kant R 611 whereby the Division Bench of the High Court constituted a Special Investigation Team (SIT) to investigate into the broadcasting of certain news items by certain television channels on 2-3-2012 regarding scuffle between advocates, police and media persons in the premises of the City Civil Court Complex, Bangalore.

    Brief facts

    2. On 2-3-2012 Shri Janardhana Reddy, former Minister in the Government of Karnataka was sought to be produced by CBI, Bangalore Branch, in the Court of 46th Additional City Civil and Special Judge, CBI at Bangalore City Civil Court Complex in a case which invited considerable public attention. The electronic as well as the print media were in the precincts of the court so as to film and make video coverage and publish the news regarding the production of the former Minister.

    3. A large crowd gathered in the court premises caused a great deal of inconvenience, as a result of which, scuffle ensued between advocates, police and media persons and simultaneously violence broke out and the police resorted to lathi-charge in which several persons got injured. A number of vehicles were also damaged and destroyed due to stone pelting and arson. Over 191 cases were registered in regard to the abovesaid incident against the police, advocates, media persons, public, etc. under various categories in various police stations of the city.

    4. On 6-3-2012 Advocates Association, Bangalore, the appellant herein, registered under the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1959, submitted a representation to the Chief Minister of Karnataka to take suitable action against the police atrocities committed on the advocates on 2-3-2012. Subsequently, on 7-3-2012, the General Secretary of the appellant Association filed a detailed complaint in the jurisdictional police station wherein the names of the police officers who were involved in the said incident were given.

    5. On the very same day i.e on 7-3-2012, the Government of Karnataka issued a government order (G.O) and appointed the Director General of Police, CID, Special Units and Economic Offences as the inquiry officer to conduct an in-house inquiry into the matter. On 10-3-2012 the Registrar, City Civil Court, Bangalore, lodged a complaint with Ulsoor Gate Police Station for causing damage to the property of City Civil Court, Bangalore which came to be registered as FIR No. 206 of 2012 under Sections 143, 147, 323, 324, 427, 435 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”) and Section 3(1) of the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984 against unknown persons. On 19-3-2012 the Director General of Police submitted his report stating that the officers on bandobust failed to exercise adequate and proper supervisory control on the policemen while controlling the situation, which resulted in excesses committed by some of the policemen, and the police personnel responsible for excesses could not be easily identified.

    6. Several writ petitions came to be filed before the High Court seeking various reliefs inter alia including direction to the State Government to entrust the investigation to CBI. On 26-3-2012 the President of the appellant Association filed an affidavit in the writ petitions viz. Nos. 7623 and 8328 of 2012 apprising the Court about the dismal progress in the investigation carried out by the police. In view of the same, on 29-3-2012 and 2-4-2012, the Assistant Commissioner of Police filed an affidavit and counter-affidavit respectively stating the status of the investigation. It was further stated that the State Government has accepted the report of the Director General of Police and he has been directed to conduct further inquiry. Several documents, records and other details were produced before the High Court during the course of the proceedings.

    7. The High Court, by order dated 16-5-2012 (2012) 3 KCCR 2246, (2012) 3 AIR Kant R 611, constituted a Special Investigation Team (SIT) headed by Dr R.K Raghavan, a retired Director of CBI as Chairman and Mr R.K Dutta, Director General of Police, CID, Bangalore as Convenor along with other police officials to investigate into the incident with reference to the complaints lodged by the police, advocates as well as media against each other and to conclude the same within 3 months from the date of the government notification. In pursuance of the same, the State Government issued a series of notifications constituting and reconstituting SIT for reasons of non-availability of officers to be its members.

    8. Being aggrieved of the impugned order (2012) 3 KCCR 2246, (2012) 3 AIR Kant R 611, this appeal has been filed by way of special leave before this Court. On 19-10-2012 SLP (C) No. 22604 of 2012 this Court rejected the prayer of alteration of the investigating agency and directed the SIT to commence the investigation forthwith and submit a report within 3 months from the date of the order. Pursuant to the same, the State Government issued Notifications dated 3-11-2012, 13-11-2012 and 17-11-2012 for appointing and substituting various officers in the SIT. On 12-12-2012 the State Government filed an application seeking extension of 6 months' time to investigate the case. In January 2013, the State Government filed a similar application for an extension of 6 months to submit a report.

    9. Being aggrieved of the fact that in spite of a lapse of over 1 year from the date of incident, the investigation has not even commenced even after the orders of the High Court dated 16-5-2012 (2012) 3 KCCR 2246, (2012) 3 AIR Kant R 611 and this Court dated 19-10-2012 SLP (C) No. 22604 of 2012, the appellant Association filed a contempt petition.

    10. The interlocutory application being No. 8 also came to be filed in the abovesaid special leave petition to direct the SIT to hand over the investigation to CBI in view of this Court's order dated 19-10-2012 SLP (C) No. 22604 of 2012.

    11. Heard Mr K.K Venugopal, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant Association, Mr K.V Viswanathan, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent State and Mr Amarjit Singh Chandhiok, learned Additional Solicitor General for the Union of India.

    Contentions

    12. Mr K.K Venugopal, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant Association submitted that in spite of the fact that the incident occurred on 2-3-2012 and in view of the subsequent order of the High Court dated 16-5-2012 (2012) 3 KCCR 2246, (2012) 3 AIR Kant R 611 constituting a Special Investigation Team (SIT) and subsequent direction of this Court dated 19-10-2012 SLP (C) No. 22604 of 2012 modifying the composition of SIT, the fact remains that till this moment, nothing has turned down, in fact, the investigation is yet to commence. The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant Association further contended that in view of the fact that persons concerned in the issue are members of the Bar, police personnel, persons from both print and electronic media, it is a fit case which the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) should investigate fixing an outer limit for the same.

    13. On the other hand, Mr K.V Viswanathan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent State, by drawing our attention to various orders of the High Court and this Court, submitted that owing to the clarifications sought for in respect of the composition of SIT, the matter got delayed in commencing the investigation and according to him, there is no need to entrust the investigation to an agency like CBI.

    14. Mr A.S Chandhiok, learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the Union of India submitted that though CBI is to abide by the orders of this Court but due to various activities being handled by CBI, let the SIT be allowed to continue and complete the investigation.

    Discussion

    15. It is seen that on account of serious and unfortunate incident involving advocates, police personnel, journalists, media persons in the City Civil Court Complex at Bangalore on 2-3-2012, large number of persons were assaulted and injured. It is alleged by the appellant Association that the same was caused due to the action of the police and the media. The appellant Association also raised serious allegations against the print and electronic media in broadcasting false and provocative news thereby maligning and demeaning the advocate community.

    16. Initially, the appellant Association filed Writ Petition No. 7623 of 2012 praying for a direction to the State Government to entrust the investigation to CBI. Several other writ petitions were also filed. By the impugned order dated 16-5-2012 (2012) 3 KCCR 2246, (2012) 3 AIR Kant R 611, the High Court disposed of the writ petition by constituting a SIT headed by Shri R.K Raghavan, a retired Director of CBI and other officers. It is further seen that on 19-10-2012 SLP (C) No. 22604 of 2012, this Court reconstituted the SIT to investigate into the incident and also directed to submit a report within three months from the date of the order.

    17. It is the grievance of the appellant Association that in spite of the directions of this Court and a series of notifications issued by the State Government constituting and reconstituting SIT for one reason or the other, the fact remains that even after a lapse of one year and five months from the date of the incident, the investigation has not yet been commenced. It is unfortunate that even after the order of this Court dated 19-10-2012 SLP (C) No. 22604 of 2012 nothing has happened. It is relevant to mention that the constitution of the so-called SIT has not been completed till date. Though Mr K.V Viswanathan, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent State raised an objection as to the averments in Para 9 in IA No. 8 filed by the appellant Association, it is clear that in spite of the modified order of this Court, the investigation is yet to commence due to non-formation of SIT.

    18. As regards entrusting the investigation to CBI, a Constitution Bench of this Court in State of W.B v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights (2010) 3 SCC 571 has laid down certain principles. Though the Supreme Court has issued various principles/suggestions for endorsing the matter to CBI in para 68, it is worthwhile to refer the conclusion in paras 69 & 70:

    “69. In the final analysis, our answer to the question referred is that a direction by the High Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, to CBI to investigate a cognizable offence alleged to have been committed within the territory of a State without the consent of that State will neither impinge upon the federal structure of the Constitution nor violate the doctrine of separation of power and shall be valid in law. Being the protectors of civil liberties of the citizens, this Court and the High Courts have not only the power and jurisdiction but also an obligation to protect the fundamental rights, guaranteed by Part III in general and under Article 21 of the Constitution in particular, zealously and vigilantly.
    70. Before parting with the case, we deem it necessary to emphasise that despite wide powers conferred by Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution, while passing any order, the courts must bear in mind certain self-imposed limitations on the exercise of these constitutional powers. The very plenitude of the power under the said articles requires great caution in its exercise. Insofar as the question of issuing a direction to CBI to conduct investigation in a case is concerned, although no inflexible guidelines can be laid down to decide whether or not such power should be exercised but time and again it has been reiterated that such an order is not to be passed as a matter of routine or merely because a party has levelled some allegations against the local police. This extraordinary power must be exercised sparingly, cautiously and in exceptional situations where it becomes necessary to provide credibility and instil confidence in investigations or where the incident may have national and international ramifications or where such an order may be necessary for doing complete justice and enforcing the fundamental rights. Otherwise CBI would be flooded with a large number of cases and with limited resources, may find it difficult to properly investigate even serious cases and in the process lose its credibility and purpose with unsatisfactory investigations.”

    19. Keeping the above principles in mind, considering the series of unfortunate incidents which occurred within the City Civil Court Complex, Bangalore on 2-3-2012 involving members of the Bar, police personnel, journalists and media persons and in spite of the specific direction by the High Court as early as on 16-5-2012 (2012) 3 KCCR 2246, (2012) 3 AIR Kant R 611, subsequent order of this Court dated 19-10-2012 SLP (C) No. 22604 of 2012, and also of the fact that the composition of SIT itself has not been finalised, we feel that the present case falls within the principles enunciated by the Constitution Bench in Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights (2010) 3 SCC 571 and we are satisfied that CBI inquiry is necessitated in the matter in issue.

    20. In the light of what is stated above, while setting aside the impugned order of the High Court dated 16-5-2012 (2012) 3 KCCR 2246, (2012) 3 AIR Kant R 611 and in modification of earlier order of this Court dated 19-10-2012 SLP (C) No. 22604 of 2012, we entrust the entire investigation of the incident to CBI. Accordingly, we direct CBI to carry out the investigation and submit a report before the appropriate court having jurisdiction at Bangalore within a period of six months from the date of receipt of copy of this judgment. We further direct the State/SIT to immediately hand over all the records pertaining to the said investigation to CBI.

    21. The appeal is allowed in the above terms. In view of the above direction, no separate order is required in IA No. 8 of 2013, accordingly, the same is also disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Advocates Association, Bangalore v. Union Of India And Others
    (Aug 27, 2013)