P. Sathasivam, J.— This appeal by the State of Maharashtra is directed against the judgment and order dated 8-12-2006 passed by the High Court of Judicature of Bombay in Raj Marketing v. State of Maharashtra whereby the High Court allowed the writ petition of the first respondent herein.
2. The issue involved in this appeal is: whether Candyman, Minto Fresh, Kitchens of India, Badam Halwa and Ashirvaad Atta, etc. can be considered as a “wholesale package” within the definition of the expression “wholesale package” under Rule 2(x) of the Standards of Weights and Measures (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 1977 (hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”).
Brief facts
3. The respondent is a firm carrying on the business of buying and selling various products and they used to store these products in their godown at Gali No. 8, Senior Tyre Compound, NSS Road, Narayan Nagar, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai. On 31-10-2006, the second appellant, Inspector of Legal Metrology, Mumbai visited the first respondent's godown and seized various packages of packed commodities such as Candyman, Minto Fresh, Kitchens of India, Badam Halwa and Ashirvaad Atta, etc. vide seizure memo bearing Nos. 0114769 and 0114770 dated 31-10-2006. The reason for seizure, according to him, is that on the wholesale packets, the details regarding the name and addresses of the manufacturer, cost, month, year, etc. has not been declared and also the retail sale price was not mentioned which is in violation of the Rules.
4. A show-cause notice dated 6-11-2006 has been issued by the appellant to the respondent for the violation of Section/Rules 33 and 39 read with Rules 23(1) and (6) of the Rules. It was mentioned in the said notice that the offence is compoundable as per Section 73 of the Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976 and Section 65 of the Standards of Weights and Measures (Enforcement) Act, 1985. On 18-11-2006, the respondents, vide their letter, replied to the notice dated 6-11-2006.
5. On 28-11-2006, the respondents filed a writ petition being WP No. 2982 of 2006, inter alia, for quashing the seizure memo dated 31-10-2006 and notice dated 6-11-2006.
6. The High Court, by the impugned order dated 8-12-2006 allowed the writ petition by holding that the packages containing Candyman, Minto Fresh, Kitchens of India, Badam Halwa and Ashirvaad Atta are not wholesale packages within the definition of the expression “wholesale package” under Rule 2(x) of the Rules.
7. Questioning the said order of the High Court, the State filed the above appeal by way of special leave.
8. Heard Mr Chinmoy Khaladkar, learned counsel for the appellant State and Mr Ravinder Narain for Respondent 1.
9. Rule 2(x) of the Rules defines “wholesale package” to mean:
“2. (x) ‘wholesale package’ means a package containing—
(i) a number of retail packages, where such first mentioned package is intended for sale, distribution or delivery to an intermediary and is not intended for sale direct to a single consumer; or
(ii) a commodity sold to an intermediary in bulk to enable such intermediary to sell, distribute or deliver such commodity to the consumer in smaller quantities; or
(iii) packages containing ten or more than ten retail packages provided that the retail packages are labelled as required under the rules.”
10. Rule 29 of the Rules reads as under:
“29. Declaration to be made on every wholesale package.—Every wholesale package shall bear thereon a legible, definite, plain and conspicuous declaration as to—
(a) the name and address of the manufacturer or where the manufacturer is not the packer, of the packer;
(b) the identity of the commodity contained in the package; and
(c) the total number of retail packages contained in such wholesale package or the net quantity in terms of standard units of weights, measures or number of the commodity contained in wholesale package:
Provided that nothing in this Rule shall apply in relation to a wholesale package if a declaration similar to the declaration specified in this Rule, is required to be made on such wholesale packages by or under any other law for the time being in force.”
11. In order to attract violation of the Rules referred above, the package seized must fall within the expression “wholesale package”. A package used merely for protection during conveyance or safety would not be pre-packed commodity for the purpose of the Act and the Rules. As rightly observed by the High Court that for the package to be treated as a wholesale package, the package must not be a secondary package. In that event, we have to find out whether the secondary package is only for safety, convenience or the like.
12. As demonstrated before the High Court, the counsel appearing for the first respondent placed all the abovementioned products before us i.e both the wholesale package as well as the retail package. The Department's only contention was that the secondary package in which the wholesale package was packed does not contain the said information. In the light of the provisions which we have referred above and on verification of the products which were shown to us, we are of the view that the secondary outer packing for transportation or for safety of the goods being transported or delivered cannot be described as a wholesale package.
13. On going through the statutory provisions which we have adverted to in the earlier paragraphs and on verification of the products which were shown to us during the course of argument, we fully agree with the conclusion arrived at by the High Court. Consequently, the appeal fails and the same is dismissed with no order as to costs.