AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2004 INSC 124
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2004 INSC 124
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Supreme Court of India – State Bank of Patiala Voluntary Retirement Scheme Case

Factual and Procedural Background

State Bank of Patiala (“the Bank”), a subsidiary of State Bank of India, issued Circular No. PER/VRS/48 dated 20-1-2001 introducing its Voluntary Retirement Scheme (“SBPVRS”). The Scheme was open from 15-2-2001 to 1-3-2001.

Respondents 1-3 applied within that window but attempted to withdraw their applications on 2-3-2001, 3-3-2001/5-3-2001 and 5-3-2001 respectively. On 3-4-2001 the Bank rejected the withdrawals, stating they were sought after the Scheme had closed.

The respondents, along with others, filed writ petitions before the High Court, which on 3-4-2002 quashed the Scheme and held that employees could withdraw their options before acceptance by the Bank. The Bank appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether employees who applied under SBPVRS could withdraw their applications after 1-3-2001 but before formal acceptance by the Bank.
  2. Whether SBPVRS should be equated with the State Bank of India VRS considered in Bank of India v. O.P. Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721, thereby attracting the same legal consequences.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents’ Arguments

  • Clause 9(i) of SBPVRS (“application once made cannot be withdrawn”) is analogous to clause 10.5 of the nationalised banks’ VRS discussed in Swarnakar, hence employees should be free to withdraw until acceptance.
  • The earlier decision in State Bank of Patiala v. Jagga Singh overlooked clause 9(i) and therefore requires reconsideration.

Bank’s Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the Bank’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bank of India v. O.P. Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 Classified VRS schemes as invitations to offer; distinguished schemes permitting withdrawal during a specific period from those that forbid withdrawal. Treated as controlling authority; SBPVRS held analogous to SBIVRS, restricting withdrawals to the scheme’s open period.
State Bank of Patiala v. Jagga Singh, Civil Appeal No. 2341 of 2003 Applied Swarnakar to SBPVRS, allowing withdrawal only within the stipulated 15-2-2001 to 1-3-2001 period. Cited to demonstrate that a co-ordinate Bench has already equated SBPVRS with SBIVRS; present Bench reaffirmed that conclusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court characterised SBPVRS as an “invitation to offer,” adopting the approach in Swarnakar. It construed clauses 5, 8, and 9(i) together:

  • Clause 5 kept the Scheme open until 1-3-2001, providing employees locus poenitentiae only within that period.
  • Clause 8 allowed the Bank up to two months after closure to vet applications and compute the financial burden of the funded Scheme.
  • Clause 9(i) prohibits withdrawal, but only after the closure date when the Bank begins the acceptance process.

Permitting withdrawals after 1-3-2001 would undermine the Bank’s actuarial and funding calculations. Citing principles from Chitty on Contracts and Halsbury’s Laws of England, the Court reiterated that an offer can be withdrawn before acceptance, but acceptance here starts only after the closure date.

Because the Bank is a subsidiary of State Bank of India and SBPVRS mirrors SBIVRS, the Swarnakar ratio “squarely applies.” Thus employees cannot withdraw after 1-3-2001, and the High Court erred in quashing the Scheme.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Appeals allowed; the High Court’s judgment is set aside; no order as to costs.

Implications: The decision reinstates SBPVRS and confirms that employees who opted for the Scheme cannot withdraw their applications after its closure date. The ruling reinforces Swarnakar’s principles and clarifies that each VRS must be construed as a whole, but it sets no new precedent beyond this clarification.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Bank Of Patiala v. Romesh Chander Kanoji And Others

    S.H Kapadia, J.— Leave granted.

    2. The question in these appeals concerns determination of the scope of the judgment of this Court in the case of Bank of India v. O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 as also the judgment of this Court in the case of State Bank of Patiala v. Jagga Singh.

    3. The dispute lies within a narrow compass. State Bank of Patiala, a subsidiary of State Bank of India, issued Circular No. PER/VRS/48 dated 20-1-2001 publishing their Voluntary Retirement Scheme (hereinafter referred to as “SBPVRS”) drawn up in the light of the guidelines issued by the Indian Banks Association. The object of SBPVRS inter alia was to downsize the existing strength of the employees and to increase profitability. The Scheme was to open on 15-2-2001 and it was to close on 1-3-2001 (inclusive of both days). The applications under SBPVRS were to be accepted during the period when the Scheme was to remain open between 15-2-2001 to 1-3-2001. Clauses (5), (8) and (9)(i) of the Scheme are relevant for the purpose of deciding this matter and accordingly, they are quoted hereinbelow:

    “(5) Period.—The Scheme will remain open during the period 15-2-2001 to 1-3-2001 (inclusive both days) with an option to the Bank to close early/extend the Scheme without assigning any reasons. The applications for voluntary retirement under SBPVRS will be accepted during this period only.
    (8) Other features.—The Bank intends to control the outflow of personnel according to its requirements. Towards this end, the Bank retains the discretion to limit the number of employees to be allowed to retire in each category of staff viz. officer/clerical-cash/subordinate, to be covered under SBPVRS. As such, the Bank will have the sole discretion as to the acceptance or the rejection of the request for retirement under SBPVRS depending upon the requirements of the Bank. For the purpose of exercising discretion in this regard, categorywise lists of eligible applicants would be prepared in descending order of their age and applications of employees coming in higher age groups above cut-off age would be accepted; the cut-off age in each category will of course depend upon the acceptable number of employees who can be permitted to retire.
    No voluntary retirement shall be deemed to have come into effect unless the decision of the competent authority has been communicated in writing, which will be convened within a maximum period of two months after the date of closure of receipt of applications i.e 1-3-2001.
    (9) General conditions.—(i) Staff members desirous of availing benefits under the Scheme will have to submit a written application to the competent authority, through proper channel, in the specified format, within the period for which the Scheme is kept open (i.e 15-2-2001 to 1-3-2001). The application once made cannot be withdrawn and the same will be treated as irrevocable. While making application, the employee will be required to declare the name of nominee, to whom the payment may be made in the event of death of a VRS optee after the competent authority has accepted his VRS application but before payment has been effected.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    4. To complete the chronology of events, the respondents herein applied under SBPVRS between 15-2-2001 and 1-3-2001. Respondent 1 withdrew his application for voluntary retirement on 3-3-2001/5-3-2001. Similarly, Respondent 2 withdrew his application for voluntary retirement on 2-3-2001. Respondent 3 withdrew his application for voluntary retirement on 5-3-2001. However, on 3-4-2001, the Bank refused permission to the said respondents to withdraw from the Scheme since their withdrawal was made after the date of the closure of the Scheme on 1-3-2001. The decision of the Bank not to allow the respondents to withdraw from the Scheme came to be challenged by way of a writ petition before the High Court along with several other writ petitions involving the same question. By common judgment dated 3-4-2002, the High Court allowed the writ petitions by quashing SBPVRS itself. The High Court held that even if it is assumed for the sake of argument that the Scheme was validly framed, it would still be open to an employee to withdraw his option before the same came to be accepted and effectively enforced. Being aggrieved, the Bank has come by way of appeal to this Court.

    5. In the case of Bank of India v. O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 a similar question arose for determination, namely, whether an employee having once opted for voluntary retirement pursuant to a Voluntary Retirement Scheme is precluded from withdrawing his offer/opting out from the Scheme? This Court in the above judgment found that there was difference between the Voluntary Retirement Scheme framed by State Bank of India (hereinafter referred to as “SBIVRS”) on one hand and the Voluntary Retirement Scheme framed by nationalized banks on the other. The difference in the two Schemes was that in the case of SBIVRS, an opportunity of fifteen days was given to the employee-applicant to withdraw from the Scheme whereas under the Voluntary Retirement Scheme of nationalized banks no such opportunity was given. In the case of Voluntary Retirement Scheme framed by nationalized banks, clause 10.5 stipulated that it will not be open for an employee to withdraw his request for voluntary retirement after having exercised such option. In the circumstances, this Court took the view that the case of State Bank of India stood on different footing vis-à-vis schemes framed by other nationalized banks. The reasons for the difference are contained in para 92 of the said decision, which reads as under:

    “92. However, the case of the State Bank of India stands slightly on a different footing. Firstly, the State Bank of India had not amended the Scheme. It, as noticed hereinbefore, even permitted withdrawal of the applications after (sic by) 15th February. The scheme floated by the State Bank of India contained a clause (clause 7) laying down the mode and manner in which the application for voluntary retirement shall be considered. The relevant clause as referred to hereinbefore creates an enforceable right. In the event the State Bank failed to adhere to its preferred policy, the same could have been specifically enforced by a court of law. The same would, therefore, amount to some consideration.”

    6. It is evident from above that in the case of SBIVRS, where there is a specific provision for withdrawal, the employee must exercise his option within the time specified; and in case of nationalized banks where there was no provision to withdraw (and in fact the Scheme forbade withdrawal), the withdrawal must be effected prior to acceptance by the Bank. Therefore, in terms of the ratio laid down by this Court, the employee is ensured under SBIVRS the right of withdrawal within the specified period.

    7. The decision of this Court in Bank of India v. O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 is dated 17-12-2002. The decision was given by a three-Judge Bench of this Court. A similar question came before the Division Bench of this Court once again in the case of State Bank of Patiala v. Jagga Singh by way of Civil Appeal No. 2341 of 2003. It was held by the Division Bench that State Bank of Patiala was a subsidiary of State Bank of India; that clause (8) of SBPVRS was similar to clause (7) of SBIVRS; that clause (8) of SBPVRS also gave opportunity to the employee to withdraw and consequently the appeal filed by State Bank of Patiala was allowed in terms of the decision in the case of Bank of India v. O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721. The decision in the case of Bank of India v. O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 has since been followed in several cases.

    8. In the present matter, the question is once again sought to be reagitated. Mr Ahmadi, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents herein contended that clause (9)(i) of SBPVRS, quoted above, was similar to clause 10.5 of the Scheme of other nationalized banks inasmuch as it provided that application once made cannot be withdrawn. It was submitted that clause (9)(i) of the said SBPVRS has not been noticed by the Division Bench of this Court in its judgment in the case of State Bank of Patiala v. Jagga Singh. It was contended that clause (9)(i) of SBPVRS was dissimilar to SBIVRS, which gave opportunity to the employee to withdraw and consequently the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in State Bank of Patiala v. Jagga Singh needs reconsideration.

    9. We do not find any merit in the above argument. It is important to bear in mind that the Schemes in question are basically funded schemes. Under such Schemes, time is given to every employee to opt for voluntary retirement and similarly time is given to the management to work out the Scheme. Clause (5) of SBPVRS gave fifteen days' time to the employees to opt for the Scheme and under clause (8) a period of two months is given to the management to work out the Scheme. Since the said Schemes are funded schemes, the management is required to create a fund. The creation of the fund would depend upon the number of applications; the cost of the Scheme; liability which the Scheme would impose on the Bank and such other variable factors. If the employees are allowed to withdraw from the Scheme at any time after its closure, it would not be possible to work out the Scheme as all calculations of the management would fail. In the case of Bank of India v. O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 SBIVRS is held to be an invitation to offer. Following the said judgment, we hold that SBPVRS is an invitation to offer and not an offer. Clause (5) of the said SBPVRS inter alia states that the Scheme will remain open during the period 15-2-2001 to 1-3-2001 whereas Rule 8 thereof provides for mode of acceptance by the management. It is in the light of Rules 5 and 8 that one has to read clause (9)(i) which provides for general conditions and under which it is provided that application once made cannot be withdrawn. In Chitty on Contracts (28th Edn., p. 125), the learned author states that

    “an offer may be withdrawn at any time before it is accepted. That this rule applies even though the offeror has promised to keep the offer open for a specified time, for such a promise is unsupported by consideration.”

    Therefore, clause (5) of SBPVRS gives locus poenitentiae to the employee to withdraw by 1-3-2001 after which the mode of acceptance contemplated by clause (8) of SBPVRS would apply and the Bank will proceed to vet the applications. As stated above, the Bank needs time to ascertain its liability; it is required to find out the cost of creation of a separate fund which in turn depends on the number of applications and if the employees are permitted to withdraw after the date of closure it would be impossible for the Bank to implement the Scheme. Therefore, clause (5) gives time to the employee to withdraw by 1-3-2001 and the Bank is given time of two months thereafter to complete the designated mode of acceptance (see Halsbury's Laws of England, 4th Edn., p. 133). Reading clauses (5), (8) and (9)(i), it is clear that employees are precluded from withdrawing from SBPVRS after the closure of the Scheme on 1-3-2001.

    10. Subject to above, we hold that State Bank of Patiala is a subsidiary of State Bank of India; that SBPVRS is similar to SBIVRS and consequently, the judgment of this Court in the case of Bank of India v. O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 squarely applies to the facts of this case. We may clarify that each Scheme for the purposes of enforceability is required to be read as a whole.

    11. Accordingly, the appeals are allowed in terms of the decision of this Court in Bank of India v. O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 and the impugned judgment of the High Court is set aside with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Bank Of Patiala v. Romesh Chander Kanoji And Others
    (Feb 24, 2004)