Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2002 INSC 401
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2002 INSC 401
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The deceased, Om Pal, had purchased land that Appellant 1 (Dila) claimed to possess. After a daytime altercation on 27-09-1979 over the standing crop, Dila allegedly threatened Om Pal. Around 12:30 a.m. on the night of 28-09-1979/29-09-1979, Dila, his son Telu Ram (Appellant 2) and others went to the house of Kishan Singh looking for Om Pal. When Kishan Singh stayed silent, Dila struck him with a lathi. Onlookers arrived, and, on Dila’s exhortation, Telu Ram shot Om Pal with a country-made pistol. Om Pal died en route to the Saharanpur hospital; several witnesses sustained blunt-weapon injuries.

The Sessions Judge tried all five accused for offences under Sections 147, 148, 302/149 and 323/149 IPC and acquitted everyone. The State appealed. The High Court affirmed the acquittal of three co-accused but reversed the acquittal of Dila and Telu Ram, convicting them under Section 302/149 IPC (life imprisonment) and imposing lesser sentences for the remaining counts. Dila and Telu Ram appealed to the Supreme Court, resulting in the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in reversing the acquittal of Appellants 1 and 2 and convicting them on re-appreciation of the same evidence that had led the Sessions Court to acquit all accused.
  2. Whether the evidence regarding motive, eyewitness testimony, lighting conditions, and ballistic findings reasonably established the participation of the appellants in the offences under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The High Court erred by substituting its own view merely because an alternative interpretation of the evidence was possible, contrary to principles limiting interference with an acquittal.
  • The same prosecution story was insufficient to convict the appellants when three co-accused were acquitted and four unidentified persons were allegedly involved.
  • Dila, being over 80 years old, deserved sympathetic consideration in sentencing.

State's Arguments

  • The High Court correctly applied its power to overturn an unreasonable acquittal that was against the weight of evidence.
  • The evidence of injured eyewitnesses, corroborated by medical and investigative material, conclusively proved the appellants’ guilt.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court re-examined the entire record, noting that the High Court had accurately stated the law governing appellate interference with acquittals. Key points of analysis included:

  • Credibility of Injured Eyewitnesses: PWs 1–3 (Geeta Ram, Hari Singh, Kishan Singh) were present at the scene, sustained injuries, and consistently identified the appellants as participants. Their presence was natural given the proximity of their houses to the place of occurrence.
  • Lighting Conditions: A lantern was burning in Hari Singh’s verandah, and two witnesses carried torches. These sources of light were referenced in the FIR, verified by the Investigating Officer, and mapped in the site plan, rebutting the Sessions Judge’s doubts.
  • Motive: Ongoing civil, revenue and criminal litigations over the disputed land, coupled with Dila’s threat on 27-09-1979, established motive. The High Court correctly rejected the Sessions Judge’s view that motive was unproven.
  • Ballistic and Medical Evidence: The post-mortem revealed thirteen pellets in the pleural cavity, consistent with a country-made pistol, not a rifle. The investigating officer recovered a used .12-bore cartridge corroborating the eyewitness version that Telu Ram fired the fatal shot. The Sessions Judge’s contrary inference of rifle use was deemed a misreading of evidence.
  • Overall Assessment: The High Court demonstrated that the trial court’s reasons were unreasonable and contrary to the weight of evidence; therefore, interference was warranted. The Supreme Court found this re-appreciation proper and refused to disturb the conviction.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED. The conviction and life-imprisonment sentences of Dila and Telu Ram under Section 302/149 IPC, and lesser sentences under other sections, are affirmed. The appellants, currently on bail, are to be taken into custody to serve the remaining sentence.

Implications are confined to the parties: the convictions stand affirmed, and the Court expressed an expectation that the State may consider Appellant 1’s age (over 80 years) sympathetically if he applies for commutation, but no new legal precedent was created.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Dila And Another v. State Of U.P .

    Shivaraj V. Patil, J.— These two appellants along with three other accused were tried for the offences under Sections 147, 148, 302 read with Sections 149 and 323 read with Section 149 IPC. The learned Sessions Judge, after trial and on the basis of the material placed before him, acquitted all the accused. On appeal filed by the State, the High Court by the impugned judgment and order affirmed the order of acquittal as regards the three other co-accused and reversed the order of acquittal relating to these appellants and convicted and sentenced them to imprisonment for life for offence under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC and sentenced them to a shorter period for the offences under other sections. The appellants have assailed the said judgment and order of the High Court in this appeal.

    2. In short, the prosecution case was that the deceased Om Pal had purchased some land from one Smt Mukandi, widow of Chhota of Village Krishni. Appellant 1 Dila disputed the possession of Om Pal over the land. On 27-9-1979, there was an altercation between Om Pal and Dila over harvesting of crop standing on the said land. At that time, Dila had threatened Om Pal. On the night of 28-9-1979/29-9-1979, at about 12.30 a.m, the appellants and the other acquitted three co-accused accompanied by four others went to the house of Kishan Singh. Dila enquired about the whereabouts of Om Pal and when Kishan Singh kept mum, he was hit with a lathi by Dila. On the shouting of Kishan Singh, Om Pal, Randhir Singh, Geeta Ram, Hari Singh, Balbir and Ved Prakash reached the place. Dila exhorted his son Telu Ram to kill Om Pal on which Telu Ram shot at Om Pal with a country-made pistol as a result of which Om Pal was injured, fell down and became unconscious. It was alleged that Dila was armed with lathi, Sitam Singh with knife, Gaje Singh and Ram Pal were armed with guns and four unknown persons were armed with lathis and kulhari. The accused assaulted Kishan Singh, Hari Singh and Randhir Singh. After the accused left the place, Om Pal and the injured persons were taken to hospital at Saharanpur. Om Pal died near the hospital. The injured persons were examined at hospital. As already noticed above, the trial court acquitted all the accused and the High Court, on appeal, reversed the order of acquittal as regards these two appellants.

    3. The learned counsel for the appellants strongly contended that the High Court committed an error in reversing the order of acquittal on mere possibility of taking a contrary view. According to him, the conclusions drawn by the Sessions Judge based on proper appreciation of evidence and supported by reasons could not be disturbed by the High Court; the appellants could not be convicted on the basis of the same prosecution story which could not be proved against the three other co-accused particularly so when four unknown persons were also involved in the incident. The learned counsel also submitted that Appellant 1 Dila is more than 80 years old and at this length of time his case needs to be considered sympathetically having regard to his age, health and other circumstances. In opposition, the learned counsel for the State argued in supporting the impugned judgment and order.

    4. We have carefully considered the evidence placed on record in the light of the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties. In support of its case, the prosecution examined Geeta Ram (PW 1), Hari Singh (PW 2) and Kishan Singh (PW 3) who are the injured eyewitnesses. Saktu (PW 5) was examined to prove the motive of the crime. Dr M.N Ansari (PW 6) who conducted the post-mortem examination was examined. Another doctor, Dr S.K Bansal (PW 7) who examined three other injured witnesses (PWs 1 to 3) also gave evidence. In addition, SI Sanpat Singh (PW 8), the investigating officer, was also examined besides other witnesses. As is evident from the impugned judgment, the High Court was fully alive to the legal position as to when and under what circumstances, there could be interference in the order of acquittal. In the judgment, it is stated that in an appeal against the order of acquittal, the High Court has same powers which the trial court has in examining the evidence and if it comes to the conclusion that the view taken by the trial court was unreasonable or against the weight of evidence, it could reject the finding recorded by the trial court.

    5. The incident in question had taken place at 12.30 a.m on the night of 28-9-1979/29-9-1979. Geeta Ram (PW 1) lodged the first information report at 8.15 a.m on 29-9-1979 at Police Station Rampur. It is not in dispute that Om Pal died due to the injuries caused during the occurrence. It is clear from the evidence of Dr M.N Ansari (PW 6) that the deceased had received one gunshot injury on the chest and two minor incised wounds on his head. PWs 1 to 3 received a number of injuries which could have been caused by some blunt weapon such as lathi as testified by Dr S.K Bansal (PW 7). PWs 1 to 3 have supported the case of the prosecution as to the mode and manner of occurrence and the persons who had participated in the commission of these offences. It is evident from the site plan (Ext. Ka-13) that in the abadi of Village Krishni, there was a bagar in which there were the houses of PWs 1 to 3, deceased Om Pal and others. Having regard to the topography of the place of occurrence described in detail by the High Court in the impugned judgment, the presence of PWs 1 to 3 at the place of occurrence could not be ruled out. On the other hand, it was but natural for them to be there, as spoken to by them. PW 1 has stated in his evidence that a lantern was burning in the verandah of Hari Singh and that witnesses Ved Prakash and Sukhbir had torches. He also stated about the medical examination of the injured and death of Om Pal and that he got FIR written at Saharanpur Hospital and thereafter he lodged the same at Police Station Rampur. Hari Singh (PW 2) has also stated about the occurrence. He has mentioned the names of the appellants and the weapons possessed by them. He also stated that his father Kishan was beaten by the accused when he did not disclose the whereabouts of Om Pal. He has further stated that Appellant 2 Telu on being instigated by Dila, Appellant 1, fired a shot from a country-made pistol causing injury to Om Pal who fell down and became unconscious. He also deposed that the accused persons had caused injuries to him as well as PWs 1 to 3. The prosecution witnesses have stated about the availability of light of burning of lantern as well as the torches possessed by the two witnesses. The instigating officer actually examined the lantern and found that a lantern was hanging at Place ‘C’ shown in the site plan. He also examined the torches of the witnesses and prepared memos in respect of the same. The prosecution witnesses have also deposed about the motive for the crime. It has come on record that there was litigation between accused Dila on the one hand and deceased Om Pal on the other relating to the land which Om Pal had purchased. The dispute also related to the crop and on the day before the occurrence, Appellant 1 Dila had actually threatened the deceased Om Pal. PW 1 has also stated that one year before the occurrence, there was an incident in which accused Telu and his mother were injured for which the deceased Om Pal and he himself were prosecuted. The High Court did not agree with the observation of the learned Sessions Judge that it was difficult to accept that Dila, Appellant 1, was not aggrieved and that persons related or interested in Om Pal could have named the accused persons on suspicion. For the reason that the motive was clearly established as there were several litigations between the parties, the dispute relating to the land was still pending before the Revenue Court and there were civil and criminal litigations. In such circumstances, the High Court found that the trial court was wrong in recording a finding that the motive aspect was not proved and that the appellant Dila was not aggrieved with the deceased or that the accused persons had been named merely on the ground of suspicion. The learned Sessions Judge had doubted the presence of light at the scene of occurrence but the High Court did not agree with the same having regard to the evidence placed on record in this regard. A lantern was burning in the verandah outside the kothari of Hari Singh (PW 2). The investigating officer examined the lantern and marked the place where it was hanging, in the site plan. The fact of burning of lantern was mentioned in the FIR as well as in the statements of witnesses. Further, it is in the evidence that the witnesses Sukhbir and Ved Prakash who had reached the scene of occurrence, had torches which they flashed. This source of light was also mentioned in the FIR. The investigating officer did examine the torches of these witnesses and prepared the memos in respect of the same. The eyewitnesses have also stated about the source of torchlight at the scene of occurrence. In view of this evidence, as rightly observed by the High Court, the trial court ought not to have disbelieved this evidence merely on the ground that the two witnesses Sukhbir and Ved Prakash were not injured. It was not necessary that every one of the witnesses should have been injured.

    6. With regard to the contradiction found by the trial court as regards the place where the deceased Om Pal was sleeping, the High Court has in the impugned judgment considered in sufficient detail and recorded that the so-called contradiction was not material.

    7. The High Court in the impugned judgment as regards participation of the appellants in the crime, has observed thus:

    “However, as regards accused Dila and Telu, we do not find anything to throw any doubt regarding their participation in the crime. It appears that these two accused persons along with four others had committed the murder of Om Pal and caused injuries to three others. It appears that the learned Sessions Judge has been much influenced by the so-called absence of any injury which could have been caused by a country-made pistol and the alleged presence of an injury which could have been caused by a rifle, on the body of the deceased. The learned Sessions Judge has referred to the recovery of one used .12 bore cartridge and one live rifle cartridge at the scene of occurrence and thereafter, due to some unexplained reason, has come to the conclusion that there was every likelihood of use of a rifle on the spot. He has thereafter negatived the contention of the witnesses that Om Pal was hit by a country-made pistol used by Telu. We are of the view that these observations by the Sessions Judge are the result of misreading of the evidence. The investigating officer found a .12 bore used cartridge as well as a live rifle cartridge on the spot. It will thus appear that a .12 bore cartridge was fired. There is nothing to show that any of the assailants was armed with a rifle or had used the same. The post-mortem of Om Pal clearly and beyond doubt shows that Om Pal was not hit by a rifle cartridge but was shot by a cartridge which could have been fired from a country-made pistol. The post-mortem report shows that thirteen small pellets were recovered from the pleural cavity. Obviously these pellets could not have been fired from a rifle but could have been fired from a country-made pistol. It appears that learned Sessions Judge did not consider the clinching evidence available on this point and so coming to a wrong conclusion, rejected the assertions made by the prosecution witnesses about the firing of the shot from a country-made pistol by accused Telu.”

    8. Thus, in our view, the High Court on proper analysis and objective reappreciation of evidence, keeping in view the probabilities of the case, was right and justified in reversing the order of acquittal passed by the trial court so far as it related to these appellants. It is not a case where the High Court has interfered with the order of acquittal merely because it could take a different view. On the other hand, the High Court has shown how the reasons recorded by the trial court for acquittal were wrong and that the view taken by the trial court was not a reasonable view and it was opposed to the weight of evidence. We see no reason or ground to interfere with the impugned order. Consequently, the appeal is dismissed. The appellants are at large on bail. They shall be taken into custody for serving the remaining part of the sentence.

    9. Responding to the last submission of the learned counsel for the appellants in regard to Appellant 1 Dila, being an old person, we expect that the respondent State will consider his case sympathetically as and when an application is made by him for commutation of sentence having regard to the relevant rules, keeping in view that he is more than 80 years old; the incident relates to the year 1979 and the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dila And Another v. State Of U.P .
    (Sep 20, 2002)