AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Bombay Public Trusts Act and the Societies Registration Act
  • Section 5, Subsection (2) of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 5 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Bombay Public Trusts Act and the Societies Registration Act
  • Section 5, Subsection (2) of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 5 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a public trust running Sant Bahinabai Educational Institutions at Shioor (District Aurangabad), advertised for, and on 22-6-1996 appointed, the first respondent as a Lab Attendant for a fixed term of two academic years (24-6-1996 to 23-6-1998). The Deputy Director of Education approved the appointment for 1996-97 only. Because approval for 1997-98 was not forthcoming and the management claimed inability to pay the salary, the appellant terminated the respondent’s services on 17-9-1997.

The respondent appealed to the Schools Tribunal, which on 6-1-2001 ordered his reinstatement with 75% back wages and consequential benefits. The High Court (Aurangabad Bench) dismissed the appellant’s writ petition on 11-4-2001, affirming the Tribunal. The appellant then approached the Supreme Court, which issued notice limited to whether the appointment should be confined to the contractual period.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent’s reinstatement should be confined to the contractual period ending 23-6-1998, given that his appointment letter explicitly limited his tenure to two academic years.
  2. Whether the post was in fact reserved for a Scheduled Tribe (ST) candidate—rendering the respondent (an SC candidate) ineligible—and, if so, whether his appointment could be continued.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The roster showed the Lab Attendant post was reserved for a Scheduled Tribe candidate; mistaken advertisement indicating Scheduled Caste reservation could not validate respondent’s appointment, especially after an ST candidate had since been appointed.
  • The respondent’s appointment was expressly temporary for two years; approvals granted by the education authority were also time-bound. Therefore, any reinstatement should be limited to that period.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • Under Section 5(2) of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977, completion of two years’ service in a permanent vacancy results in deemed confirmation; thus he was entitled to reinstatement beyond the contractual term.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Reservation Issue: The Court examined the advertisement and appointment order, noting both described the vacancy as reserved for a Scheduled Caste candidate. Although a copy of the roster indicated ST reservation, the original roster was never produced. Consequently, the Court found no basis to disturb the Tribunal’s finding that the vacancy could be treated as carried forward and that the respondent’s appointment was not invalid on this ground.

Contractual Tenure & Section 5(2): The Court analyzed Section 5 of the 1977 Act. Sub-section (2) applies only to probationers appointed to permanent vacancies; it grants deemed confirmation upon successful completion of a two-year probation. The respondent, however:

  • Was expressly appointed for a fixed term without being placed on probation,
  • Was terminated before completing two years, and
  • Had executed an undertaking waiving any claim after expiry of the academic year 1997-98.

Hence, Section 5(2) did not aid the respondent. The Court concluded that his entitlement extended only until 23-6-1998, the end of the contractual period.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is allowed in part. The respondent is entitled to salary from 18-9-1997 (the day after termination) to 23-6-1998 only. Reinstatement is confined to that period. Out of Rs 50,000 deposited by the appellant pursuant to an earlier order, the respondent shall receive the aforesaid salary and Rs 5,000 as costs; any surplus is to be refunded to the appellant, and any shortfall must be paid within four weeks.

Implications: The decision limits relief for employees appointed on fixed-term contracts who were neither on probation nor confirmed. It clarifies that Section 5(2) of the Maharashtra Act does not create deemed confirmation for purely time-bound appointments. The ruling is case-specific and sets no broad precedent beyond interpreting the statutory deeming provision in the context of fixed-term employment.

    Bharatiya Gramin Punarrachana Sanstha v. Vijay Kumar And Others

    Syed Shah Mohammed Quadri, J.— Leave is granted.

    2. This appeal is from the judgment and order of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Bench at Aurangabad, in Writ Petition No. 697 of 2001 dated 11-4-2001. By the impugned order the High Court upheld the order of the Presiding Officer, Schools Tribunal, Aurangabad Division, Aurangabad (for short “the Tribunal”) in Appeal No. 222 of 1997 dated 6-1-2001 directing reinstatement of the first respondent in service with 75% back wages and consequential benefits.

    3. On 6-8-2001, this Court issued notice limited to the question as to why the appointment of the respondent (Respondent 1) should not be confined to the period mentioned in the order of appointment dated 22-6-1996.

    4. To appreciate the contention of the learned counsel for the parties the following facts may be noticed:

    The appellant is a public trust and a society under the Bombay Public Trusts Act and the Societies Registration Act, which runs Sant Bahinabai Educational Institutions at Shioor, Taluka Vaijapur, District Aurangabad, which are fully aided. The first respondent applied for the post of Lab Attendant in response to an advertisement. He was selected and appointed by the appellant on 22-6-1996 for a period of two years from 24-6-1996 to 23-6-1998. The appointment of the first respondent was approved by the Deputy Director of Education, Aurangabad initially for the academic year 1996-97. As no approval was forthcoming for the next academic year 1997-98 and the management was not in a position to pay the salary to the first respondent, his services were terminated by the appellant on 17-9-1997. The first respondent challenged the order of his termination before the Tribunal. However, on 2-2-1998, the Deputy Director of Education approved the appointment of the first respondent for the academic year 1997-98. The Tribunal by its order dated 6-1-2001 directed reinstatement of the first respondent with 75% back wages and consequential benefits. That order was unsuccessfully challenged by the appellant before the High Court in Writ Petition No. 697 of 2001 which was dismissed on 11-4-2001. That order of the High Court is assailed in this appeal.

    5. The submission of Mr Ashok Godhamgonkar, learned counsel appearing for the appellant is that though the post was meant for a Scheduled Tribe candidate according to the roster, by mistake it was shown as reserved for a Scheduled Caste candidate, therefore, the first respondent could not be continued in the said post particularly when a Scheduled Tribe candidate has been appointed in the said post. The High Court did not accept that contention on the ground that the vacancy could be carried forward. On 4-6-1996, the appellant issued an advertisement calling for applications for appointment to fill up various posts including the post of Lab Attendant. Though, according to the roster the said post is said to be earmarked for a Scheduled Tribe candidate, the advertisement, however, shows that it is reserved for a Scheduled Caste candidate. A perusal of the advertisement as well as the order of appointment does not support the contention that the vacancy was reserved for a Scheduled Tribe candidate. The Tribunal noticed that a copy of the roster filed before it, did indicate that the vacancy was meant for a Scheduled Tribe candidate but it did not act upon it as the original roster was not produced before it. We have, therefore, no reason to hold that the High Court erred in not quashing the order of the Tribunal for that reason.

    6. It is next contended that the appointment was purely temporary for a period of two years and that an undertaking was also taken from the first respondent in regard to the nature of appointment and the approval of the appointment of the appellant given from time to time was also for the said period, therefore, the reinstatement of the first respondent could have been ordered only for the said period. Mr B.N Deshmukh, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the first respondent, invited our attention to sub-section (2) of Section 5 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977 (for short “the Act”) and submitted that after the period of two years the first respondent would be deemed to have been confirmed, therefore, the order under challenge does not warrant any interference.

    7. We may notice here, Section 5 of the Act deals with certain obligations of management of private schools. Sub-section (2) of Section 5 on which reliance is placed by Mr Deshmukh reads as under:

    “5. Certain obligations of management of private schools.—(1) ***
    (2) Every person appointed to fill a permanent vacancy shall be on probation for a period of two years. Subject to the provisions of sub-sections (4) and (5), he shall, on completion of this probation period of two years, be deemed to have been confirmed.”

    A plain reading of the said provision which is subject to the provisions of sub-sections (4) and (5), would show that it applies to a person who is put on probation consequent upon his appointment in a permanent vacancy. In such a case the period of probation will be for a period of two years. Sub-section (4) refers to computation of the period of probation of a probationer who is terminated by the management during the period of probation but who has been reappointed within a period of one year. Sub-section (5) empowers the management to fill up temporary vacancy by appointing a qualified person in such a vacancy. It is thus clear that only when an employee has completed successfully the probation period of two years, sub-section (2) directs that he shall be deemed to have been confirmed. In our view, this provision does not help the first respondent. First, because his services were terminated before completion of two years and his case does not fall within sub-section (4); secondly, admittedly the first respondent was appointed only for the period of two academic years 1996-97 and 1997-98 and was not put on probation. The order of appointment specifically mentions that after the expiry of the said period of two years the services of the first respondent would come to an end without any notice. Even the undertaking given by the first respondent recites that on relieving him on the expiry of the period of academic year 1997-98 he shall not claim any right on the said post. It may be noticed that, admittedly, the approval of appointment of the first respondent, given from time to time, is also up to 1997-98. The order of termination, referred to above, dated 17-9-1997, was passed before the expiry of the said period of two years. Under the said order of appointment the first respondent is entitled to remain in service till the end of academic year 1997-98.

    8. For the aforementioned reasons, the order of the Tribunal directing reinstatement in service of the first respondent has to be confined to the period till 23-6-1998. The first respondent is, therefore, entitled to his salary from the date of his termination till 23-6-1998. The order of the Tribunal as confirmed by the High Court is modified in the above terms.

    9. Pursuant to the order of this Court dated 10-8-2001, the appellant has deposited a sum of Rs 50,000. The first respondent shall be paid his salary for the period from 18-9-1997 to 23-6-1998 and the costs of this appeal which we quantify at Rs 5000, out of the said amount of Rs 50,000. The balance amount, if any, shall be refunded to the appellant. If, however, the liability of the appellant exceeds Rs 50,000, then any amount due to the first respondent shall be paid by the appellant to the first respondent within four weeks from today. The appeal is accordingly allowed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bharatiya Gramin Punarrachana Sanstha v. Vijay Kumar And Others
    (Aug 23, 2002)