Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 159
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Central Public Works Department (Director General of Works) Recruitment (Amendment) Rules, 1992
  • Article 226 of the Constitution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 159
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Central Public Works Department (Director General of Works) Recruitment (Amendment) Rules, 1992
  • Article 226 of the Constitution
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Appellant 4, Shri Krishnamoorti, received a notional promotion to the post of Additional Director General (Works) in the Central Public Works Department (CPWD) with effect from 22-2-1995, though the formal order was issued on 10-6-1998. On 1-7-1997 the post of Director General (Works) became vacant. Under the Central Public Works Department (Director General of Works) Recruitment Rules, 1986 as amended in 1992, promotion to Director General requires two years of “regular service” as Additional Director General (Works).

When the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) met in January 1999 it considered Krishnamoorti for the vacant Director General post. Shri K.B. Rajoria (Respondent 1) filed an application before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) asserting that, had a DPC been convened in 1995-96, he too would have been promoted to Additional Director General and therefore should now be considered for Director General. The CAT dismissed his claim on 12-5-1999.

Rajoria challenged the CAT’s order in a writ petition before the High Court. The High Court concluded that neither Krishnamoorti nor Rajoria satisfied the eligibility criterion of two years’ “regular service”, treating “regular” as actual, physical service. It therefore set aside consideration of Krishnamoorti’s candidature. Krishnamoorti appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether “two years’ regular service in the grade” under the Recruitment Rules can be satisfied by a notional promotion, or whether it requires actual physical service.
  2. Whether Respondent 1, who never received notional promotion, had locus standi to challenge the consideration of Krishnamoorti’s candidature.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Madhavan v. Union of India
(1987) 4 SCC 566; (1987) 5 ATC 91
Meaning of the phrase “on a regular basis” in eligibility clauses. Relied upon to show that “regular” distinguishes appointments made in accordance with the Rules from ad hoc or stop-gap appointments, not to insist on actual tenure in the post.
Union of India v. M. Bhaskar
(1996) 4 SCC 416
Interpretation of an eligibility clause requiring “two years’ experience”. Distinguished: the earlier case spoke of “experience”, whereas the present Rules require “regular service”; hence Bhaskar does not govern the present situation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice Ruma Pal, writing for the Supreme Court, analysed the High Court judgment as follows:

  • Concession overlooked: Rajoria had expressly conceded before the CAT that he was not challenging Krishnamoorti’s eligibility; the High Court ignored this.
  • Locus standi: Rajoria lacked standing because his claim rested on hypothetical promotion scenarios; unlike Krishnamoorti, he had never been granted notional promotion.
  • Construction of “regular service”: The High Court erroneously equated “regular” with “actual” service. Relying on K. Madhavan, the Court held that “regular” refers to the nature of appointment—one made in conformity with the Recruitment Rules—as opposed to ad hoc or stop-gap appointments.
  • Office Memorandum 18.4.3: This directive mandates that when a senior is superseded he receives notional promotion, carries seniority from the date the junior was promoted, and can count that period towards eligibility for further promotion. Thus Krishnamoorti’s qualifying service ran from 22-2-1995.
  • Schedule Notes 1 & 2: These notes tie “eligibility” to completion of the prescribed qualifying service and provide that when a junior is considered, the senior must also be considered even if lacking actual service. They confirm that “service” means “qualifying service”, which may be notional.
  • Distinction between “service” and “qualifying service”: The Court rejected the High Court’s attempt to read a difference between the terms, calling the distinction “specious”.
  • Purpose of notional promotion: Denying Krishnamoorti consideration would perpetuate the injustice his notional promotion was meant to remedy.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; the High Court’s order is set aside insofar as it held Krishnamoorti ineligible for consideration.

Immediate effect: Krishnamoorti’s notional service from 22-2-1995 counts toward the two-year eligibility requirement, restoring his candidature for promotion to Director General (Works). Broader implication: the Supreme Court affirms that “regular service” in promotion rules encompasses notional service where the promotion is made in accordance with the Rules; it need not be actual physical tenure, thereby clarifying promotion jurisprudence within the Central Government services.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India And Others v. K.B Rajoria .

    Ruma Pal, J.— Leave granted.

    2. The undisputed facts of this case are that Appellant 4 was notionally promoted to the post of Additional Director General (Works) of the Public Works Department with effect from 22-2-1995. The notional promotion was given by an order dated 10-6-1998 in terms of instructions contained in DPT's OM No. 22011/05/86 Estt.D, dated 10-4-1989 as amended from time to time. In the meanwhile on 1-7-1997, the post of Director General (Works), CPWD fell vacant. The mode of selection to the post has been laid down in the Central Public Works Department (Director General of Works) Recruitment Rules, 1986, which were amended on 23-3-1992 by the Central Public Works Department (Director General of Works) Recruitment (Amendment) Rules, 1992. The amendment came into force on 4-4-1992. The Schedule to the Rules (referred to hereinafter as the said Schedule) provides that the post of Director General (Works) is a selection post to be filled up by promotion from amongst, inter alia, “Additional Director General (Works) with two years' regular service in the grade.”

    3. Since Krishnamoorti had been granted notional promotion to the post of Additional Director General on 10-6-1998 w.e.f 22-2-1995, his name was considered for the post of Director General when the Departmental Promotion Committee met in January 1999.

    4. Shri K.B Rajoria (Respondent 1 before us) filed an application before the Central Administrative Tribunal claiming that he was also eligible to be considered for the post of Director General. According to Rajoria, if the Departmental Promotion Committee had been held in 1995-96, he could have been appointed to the post of Additional Director General which had fallen vacant on 1-5-1995. His case was that he too should have been given notional promotion with effect from 1-5-1995 in which case he would have also been eligible for promotion to the post of Director General. Rajoria claimed that he had been unfairly discriminated against because only Krishnamoorti was being considered for the post of Director General. It was however made clear before the Tribunal that Rajoria was not challenging the eligibility of Krishnamoorti to be considered but was only seeking consideration of his own case along with Krishnamoorti for the post of Director General.

    5. The Tribunal dismissed Respondent 1's application on 12-5-1999. Respondent 1 challenged the decision of the Tribunal before the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution.

    6. The High Court held that neither Respondent 1 nor Krishnamoorti were eligible on the cut-off date i.e 1-7-1997 for promotion to the post of Director General. According to the High Court the words “regular service” in the Rules means actual service and that the fiction of notional promotion could not amount to the two years' experience necessary under the Rules. The High Court was of the view that the notional seniority granted to Krishnamoorti by the order dated 10-6-1998 was no substitute for the requirement of two years' regular service as Additional Director General (Works) which had been laid down in the relevant Rules as the eligibility criterion for promotion to the post of Director General (Works).

    7. In our view, the High Court's decision cannot be sustained. First, the concession of Rajoria before the Tribunal that he was not challenging the eligibility of Krishnamoorti to be considered for promotion was overlooked.

    8. Second, the High Court erred in not dismissing the writ petition on the ground of the obvious lack of locus standi in Rajoria who had never been granted notional promotion because DPC was not in fact held for reasons which the High Court felt were unavoidable. Rajoria case was built on hypothetical situations, and his position could not reasonably be equated with that of Krishnamoorti.

    9. Third, the High Court erred in construing the words “regular service in the grade” as actual physical service. If that were so, then an ad hoc appointee who actually serves in the post could also claim to be qualified to be considered for the post of Director General. The High Court itself held that “ad hoc service rendered by any of the parties would not count towards eligibility”.

    10. Finally, while considering the definition of the word “regular” in the Concise Oxford Dictionary, 9th Edn., the High Court noted that it meant:

    “(1) conforming to a rule or principle; systematic. (2) harmonious, symmetrical. (3) acting or done or recurring uniformly or calculably in time or manner; habitual, constant, orderly. (4) conforming to a standard of etiquette or procedure; correct; according to convention. (5) properly constituted or qualified; not defective or amateur; pursuing an occupation as one's main pursuit.”

    11. The word “regular” therefore does not mean “actual” and the first question the High Court should have considered was whether the appointment of Krishnamoorti was regular and in accordance with the Rules or it was irregular in the sense that it was contrary to any principle of law.

    12. The decision which is somewhat apposite is the case of K. Madhavan v. Union of India (1987) 4 SCC 566, (1987) 5 ATC 91 where the eligibility requirement was eight years in the grade “on a regular basis”. In that case it was held:

    “In our view, therefore, the expression ‘on a regular basis’ would mean the appointment to the post on a regular basis in contradistinction to appointment on ad hoc or stopgap or purely temporary basis.”

    13. It is nobody's case that the notional promotion granted to Krishnamoorti was “irregular”. By giving him notional promotion as Additional Director General with effect from 22-2-1995, Krishnamoorti was in fact regularly appointed to the post on that date.

    14. The next question which should have been considered was the meaning of the word “service” in the light of the relevant Rules.

    15. The office memorandum referred to in the order dated 10-6-1998 and in terms of which notional promotion was granted to Krishnamoorti contains several provisions of which one is relevant for our purposes:

    “18.4.3 If the officers placed junior to the officer concerned have been promoted, he should be promoted immediately and if there is no vacancy the juniormost person officiating in the higher grade should be reverted to accommodate him. On promotion, his pay should be fixed under FR at the stage it would have reached, had he been promoted from the date the officer immediately below him was promoted but no arrears would be admissible. The seniority of the officer would be determined in the order in which his name, on review, has been placed in the select list by DPC. If in any such case a minimum period of qualifying service is prescribed for promotion to higher grade, the period from which an officer placed below the officer concerned in the select list was promoted to the higher grade, should be reckoned towards the qualifying period of service for the purpose of determining his eligibility for promotion to the next higher grade.”

    16. Analysed, these instructions provide:

    (i) For the immediate promotion of a person who has been superseded.
    (ii) Upon such promotion his pay should be fixed at the stage at which it would have reached had he been promoted from the date that the junior officer was promoted.
    (iii) The seniority of such notionally promoted officer would be determined according to the select list prepared by DPC if a minimum period is prescribed.
    (iv) For the further promotion of such notionally promoted officer, his eligibility would be calculated as including the period from which the junior officer was promoted.

    17. Krishnamoorti was admittedly superseded by Shri S.R Goyal, a junior officer on 22-2-1995, when S.R Goyal was promoted to the post of Additional Director General (Works). In terms of the provisions of para 18.4.3, Krishnamoorti was entitled to count the period from 22-2-1995 as the period of qualifying service for the purpose of further promotion to the post of Director General.

    18. The distinction drawn by the High Court between the word “service” used in the eligibility criterion in this case and the words “qualifying service” in para 18.4.3 is specious. The notes to the eligibility criteria as set out in the said Schedule fortify this view. Notes 1 and 2 to the said Schedule clarify the position with regard to the calculation of “two years' regular service in the grade”:

    “(1) The eligibility list for promotion shall be prepared with reference to the date of completion by the officers of the prescribed qualifying service in the respective grades/posts.
    (2) If a junior with the requisite years of service is considered, the senior will also be considered notwithstanding the fact that he does not possess the requisite years of service.”
    (emphasis added)

    19. Note 1 leaves no room for doubt that the word “service” means “qualifying service” and Note 2 makes it clear that in case of supersession actual service for the prescribed period is not required. This is in keeping with para 18.4.3 of the OM quoted earlier. As the notional date of promotion of Krishnamoorti was 22-2-1995 he was eligible to be considered for the post of Director General in 1999.

    20. In the context of this case, the High Court erred in equating the words “regular service” with “actual experience” relying on the decision in Union of India v. M. Bhaskar (1996) 4 SCC 416. In that case the eligibility criterion expressly was of “completion of 2 years' experience in Grade II”. The case is therefore entirely distinguishable.

    21. The notional promotion was given to Krishnamoorti to right the wrong that had been done to him by his supersession on 22-2-1995. If Krishnamoorti is denied the right to be considered for promotion to the post of Director General on the basis of such notional promotion, particularly when the relevant provisions so provide, it would result in perpetuating the wrong done to him. That is exactly what the High Court has done.

    22. We, therefore, allow the appeal and set aside the impugned order of the High Court, insofar as the finding regarding Krishnamoorti was concerned. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others v. K.B Rajoria .
    (Mar 28, 2000)