AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 451
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 451
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 1, recently promoted from Messenger to Cashier at the appellant Bank, was served a charge-sheet alleging that on 23-6-1973 he received Rs 3002.40 and two draft applications from customer Smt. Parul Rani Chowdhury, but retained an excess Rs 1000 with intent to misappropriate it. When pressed by the customer later that day, he allegedly denied receipt of the excess and, during a search of employees, threw the notes on the floor. A domestic enquiry was held: three bank officers testified; the respondent led no evidence. The Enquiry Officer found him guilty and he was dismissed on 27-1-1976.

An industrial dispute was referred to the Central Industrial Tribunal. The Tribunal accepted that the enquiry was fair but nonetheless set aside the finding of guilt, criticising the absence of the customer’s testimony, non-production of the money and other materials. A Single Judge of the High Court quashed the Tribunal’s award, but a Division Bench reversed that decision and reinstated the Tribunal’s award. The Bank obtained special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after accepting that a domestic enquiry was fair and valid, the Tribunal could re-appraise the evidence and set aside the finding of misconduct.
  2. Whether the Tribunal’s reliance on factors such as non-examination of the customer and non-production of the money was justified in overturning the dismissal.
  3. Whether the High Court’s Division Bench erred in restoring the Tribunal’s award despite the Single Judge’s contrary view.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant Bank's Arguments

  • The Tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction once it held the enquiry fair; under settled law its power of interference was then very limited.
  • The testimony of three bank officers conclusively proved misconduct; the Tribunal ignored this relevant evidence and relied on irrelevant considerations (absence of customer’s evidence, non-production of money or alleged confession).
  • The Division Bench repeated the Tribunal’s errors and therefore its judgment should be set aside.

Respondent 1's Arguments

  • He was a victim of conspiracy by members of a rival union; crucial evidence was withheld during the enquiry.
  • The dismissal order itself acknowledged that not all evidence was produced, reflecting a perverse approach by the Enquiry Officer.
  • The Tribunal correctly evaluated shortcomings such as failure to call the customer or produce the alleged excess cash.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Workmen v. Firestone Tyre & Rubber Co. of India (P) Ltd., (1973) 1 SCC 813 Enumerates limits on a Tribunal’s power to interfere with findings of a valid domestic enquiry; interference justified only if findings are perverse or enquiry vitiated. The Court relied on these principles to hold that, once the enquiry was found fair, the Tribunal had only narrow grounds to disturb the finding of guilt—none of which existed.
Indian Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. Workmen, AIR 1958 SC 130 Pre-Section 11-A position: Tribunals cannot interfere with managerial decisions unless findings are perverse or punishment indicates victimisation. Cited to contrast past limits with the current statutory regime, yet emphasising that, even under Section 11-A, interference must be based on proper re-appraisal of evidence, not irrelevant factors.
Management of Panitole Tea Estate v. Workmen, (1971) 1 SCC 742 After setting aside dismissal, whether to order reinstatement or compensation lies within Tribunal’s discretion. Referenced in the extracted passage from Firestone to outline general principles; not directly determinative of the present dispute.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that the Tribunal had expressly upheld the fairness of the domestic enquiry, thereby limiting its scope of review to checking for perversity or victimisation. Analysing the evidence of three bank officers—particularly Branch Manager A.R. Dutt, who witnessed the respondent discarding the money—the Court held the misconduct “stood proved to the hilt.” It found no contradictions elicited in cross-examination and noted that the respondent neither testified nor produced contrary evidence.

The Tribunal’s reliance on the absence of the customer’s testimony, non-production of the money, and an un-produced confession was deemed irrelevant. The Court reasoned that involving a customer in a domestic enquiry could harm banker-customer relations; moreover, once the bank had credited the customer’s account, physical production of the cash was unnecessary. Consequently, the Tribunal’s conclusion that the charge was unproved was labelled “fallacious.”

Addressing the respondent’s contention that the Enquiry Officer admitted withholding evidence, the Court read the statement as merely indicating that additional, redundant evidence need not be produced when the evidence on record sufficed. Therefore, no adverse inference could be drawn.

Because the Tribunal and Division Bench misapplied the governing principles, the Supreme Court restored the Single Judge’s decision upholding the dismissal.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; the judgment of the Division Bench is set aside and the Single Judge’s order (which had quashed the Tribunal’s award and upheld the Bank’s dismissal of Respondent 1) is restored.

Implications: The decision re-affirms that once a domestic enquiry is found to be fair, the Tribunal’s power is confined to correcting perversity, victimisation, or similar infirmities; it cannot reassess credibility based on irrelevant omissions. The ruling fortifies employers’ disciplinary autonomy when procedures comply with natural justice, without establishing new precedent beyond applying existing principles.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Bank Of India v. Tarun Kumar Banerjee And Others

    S. Rajendra Babu, J.— A charge-sheet issued to Respondent 1 reads that at about 11 a.m on 23-6-1973 Smt Parul Rani Chowdhury, a customer of the appellant Bank, handed over to Respondent 1 a sum of Rs 3002.40p along with two draft applications each for Rs 1001.20p; that even though Respondent 1 received excess amount of Rs 1000 over Rs 2002.40p, he neither refunded the same nor asked the customer as to the manner in which the said amount was to be deposited either by depositing the same in the savings bank account or deposit the same in the Sunday deposits account; that instead he retained the said money with him with the intention of misappropriating the same; that thereafter Smt Parul Rani Chowdhury returned at about 1.30 p.m on the same day and demanded the said amount of Rs 1000 handed over to Respondent 1 in excess, which he flatly denied; that on a report being made to the Branch Manager by Smt Parul Rani Chowdhury he inquired about the matter; that when a preliminary search failed to trace the amount and a physical search of all the employees was being conducted, Respondent 1 threw away the said amount of Rs 1000 on the floor that thereby he retained the amount with him with a criminal intent to misappropriate the same and thus lowered the image of the appellant Bank and thus acted in a manner highly prejudicial to the interest of the appellant Bank. Respondent 1 replied to the said charge-sheet by stating that on a memorandum being issued to him directly involving him in an alleged misappropriation of the said sum on 23-6-1973 he was compelled to sign a statement which he was not allowed to go through even. Thereafter, he was placed under suspension. He alleged that he is a victim of serious conspiracy specially while after his recent promotion from Messenger to Cashier he was looking forward to a bright future and he denied all the charges levelled against him and he claimed to be innocent.

    2. A domestic enquiry was held against him and three witnesses were examined. Respondent 1 did not adduce any evidence nor he examined himself. On the basis of the evidence recorded in the domestic enquiry by a report made finding him guilty of charges against him, on 27-1-1976 Respondent 1 was asked to show cause as to why an appropriate punishment should not be imposed upon him and he was heard in the matter. The Regional Manager thereafter communicated to Respondent 1 the decision to dismiss him. On dismissal being made an industrial dispute was raised which was referred to the Central Industrial Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”). The presiding officer held that the domestic enquiry conducted was just, fair and proper. However, on examination of the material on record the presiding officer came to the conclusion that the finding of guilt against the first respondent was not just on the evidence on record and, therefore, he set aside the same. This award was challenged by a writ petition which was allowed by a learned Single Judge of the High Court and the award given by the presiding officer was quashed. On a further appeal the Division Bench of the High Court held that the learned Single Judge could not have interfered with the award made by the Tribunal and set aside the same and restored the award made by the Tribunal. Hence this appeal by special leave.

    3. The Tribunal having held that the domestic enquiry was fair and valid, the scope of interference was very limited. This Court in Workmen v. Firestone Tyre & Rubber Co. of India (P) Ltd. (1973) 1 SCC 813, (1973) 3 SCR 587 stated the law as follows:(-A)

    “32. (1) The right to take disciplinary action and to decide upon the quantum of punishment are mainly managerial functions, but if a dispute is referred to a Tribunal, the latter has power to see if action of the employer is justified.
    (2) Before imposing the punishment, an employer is expected to conduct a proper enquiry in accordance with the provisions of the Standing Orders, if applicable, and principles of natural justice. The enquiry should not be an empty formality.
    (3) When a proper enquiry has been held by an employer, and the finding of misconduct is a plausible conclusion flowing from the evidence adduced at the said enquiry, the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to sit in judgment over the decision of the employer as an appellate body. The interference with the decision of the employer will be justified only when the findings arrived at in the enquiry are perverse or the management is guilty of victimisation, unfair labour practice or mala fide.
    (4) Even if no enquiry has been held by an employer or if the enquiry held by him is found to be defective, the Tribunal in order to satisfy itself about the legality and validity of the order, had to give an opportunity to the employer and the employee to adduce evidence before it. It is open to the employer to adduce evidence for the first time justifying his action, and it is open to the employee to adduce evidence contra.
    (5) The effect of an employer not holding an enquiry is that the Tribunal would not have to consider only whether there was a prima facie case. On the other hand, the issue about the merits of the impugned order of dismissal or discharge is at large before the Tribunal and the latter, on the evidence adduced before it, has to decide for itself whether the misconduct alleged is proved. In such cases, the point about the exercise of managerial functions does not arise at all. A case of defective enquiry stands on the same footing as no enquiry.
    (6) The Tribunal gets jurisdiction to consider the evidence placed before it for the first time in justification of the action taken only, if no enquiry has been held or after the enquiry conducted by an employer is found to be defective.
    (7) It has never been recognised that the Tribunal should straight away, without anything more, direct reinstatement of a dismissed or discharged employee, once it is found that no domestic enquiry has been held or the said enquiry is found to be defective.
    (8) An employer, who wants to avail himself of the opportunity of adducing evidence for the first time before the Tribunal to justify his action, should ask for it at the appropriate stage. If such an opportunity is asked for, the Tribunal has no power to refuse. The giving of an opportunity to an employer to adduce evidence for the first time before the Tribunal is in the interest of both the management and the employee and to enable the Tribunal itself to be satisfied about the alleged misconduct.
    (9) Once the misconduct is proved either in the enquiry conducted by an employer or by the evidence placed before a Tribunal for the first time, punishment imposed cannot be interfered with by the Tribunal except in cases where the punishment is so harsh as to suggest victimisation.
    (10) In a particular case, after setting aside the order of dismissal, whether a workman should be reinstated or paid compensation is, as held by this Court in Panitole Tea Estate v. Workmen (1971) 1 SCC 742, within the judicial discretion of a Labour Court or Tribunal.
    32-A. The above was the law as laid down by this Court as on 15-12-1971, applicable to all industrial adjudications arising out of orders of dismissal or discharge.”

    4. Prior to the insertion of Section 11-A where a proper domestic enquiry had been held before the passing of the order of punishment, the Tribunal had no power to interfere with its findings on the misconduct recorded in the domestic enquiry unless it was vitiated by one or the other infirmities pointed out in Indian Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. Workmen AIR 1958 SC 130, 1958 SCR 667. The conduct of the disciplinary proceedings and imposition of the punishment were all considered to be managerial functions with which the Tribunal had no power to interfere unless the findings were perverse or the punishment was so harsh as to lead to an inference of victimisation or unfair labour practice. Now, the position is different. In the course of adjudication proceedings if the Tribunal is satisfied that the order of discharge or dismissal was not justified, it can reappraise the evidence adduced in the domestic enquiry and satisfy itself whether the evidence relied upon by the employer establishes the misconduct alleged against the workman. The criticism advanced against the award of the Tribunal is that evidence of three witnesses recorded at enquiry being sufficient to record the guilt of Respondent 1, that evidence has been ignored and irrelevant considerations such as non-examination of complainant Smt Parul Rani Chowdhury, non-production of money and non-availability of other evidence not on record is taken note of and, therefore, its award is vitiated. The Division Bench too fell in the same error, it is contended.

    5. If we look at the evidence adduced in the present case, it is given by three witnesses who are the officers of the appellant Bank (i) Shri A.R Dutt, the Branch Manager, (ii) Shri S.K Mitra, Head Clerk, and (iii) the present Bank Manager. The evidence of Shri A.R Dutt is that on the date of occurrence a lady depositor produced two pay-in-slips consisting of draft application forms and a saving bank deposit form, each for Rs 1000 only plus Bank's commission for draft application form which were passed by the Accounts Clerk for deposit in cash department. The amount was received by the first respondent who was acting as Head Cashier. The lady customer did not produce the savings bank pay-in-slip at the cash counter but delivered Rs 3000 as told by her to him with two draft application forms. At about 1 p.m the lady with her husband came to him and complained that she had deposited Rs 3000 and odd with the cashier but did not receive the savings Bank pay-in-slip nor the excess amount refunded to her by the Cashier. On the receipt of the information he personally went to the cash department and checked the cash but did not find any excess amount therein. On asking the first respondent about the amount received by him he completely denied the same. He asked the Accountant to check the cash in the strong room and searched the Cashier concerned whether he has any cash of Rs 1000 with him. There was no excess cash found in the strong room. When at about 4.30 p.m he asked the Accountant to search the Cashier, Respondent 1, the Accountant then started checking him, he personally went out of room and saw the first respondent throwing the bundles of notes by the side of the wall in the accounts department, the possession of which was taken by him and he questioned Respondent 1 about the same. Respondent 1 told him that he had put the money in his socks. On next Monday he took a statement in writing duly signed by the first respondent and reported the matter to the head office and thereafter Respondent 1 was put under suspension under instructions from head office. In the cross-examination nothing worthwhile was elicited to tilt the evidence tendered in the examination-in-chief. This statement of Shri A.R Dutt is corroborated by Shri S.K Mitra who was Head Clerk at the relevant time. Again nothing worthwhile is elicited in his cross-examination except to state that he belonged to SBSSA. The Tribunal, however, went on to say that even though the first respondent had not examined himself nor was any cross-examination directed at the witnesses to the question of his being a victim of conspiracy by the employees of the appellant Bank who are members of another rival union to which he belonged and placed heavy reliance on non-examination of the complainant, non-production of money, non-production of the so-called confessional statements and non-production of any evidence which may have been available. But as far as the evidence tendered by the two witnesses is concerned who actually saw the incident having taken place in the manner referred to earlier, the charge of misconduct against the first respondent stood proved to the hilt and we fail to appreciate as to how the Tribunal could have taken any other view.

    6. A customer of the Bank need not be involved in a domestic enquiry conducted as such a course would not be conducive to proper banker-customer relationship and, therefore, would not be in the interest of the Bank. Further, when money was secured a prudent banker would deposit the same in the account of the customer complaining of loss of money and, therefore, non-production of money also would not be of much materiality. When in the course of the domestic enquiry no reliance was placed on the so-called confessional statement made by the first respondent, then non-production of the same is also of no significance. Thus, in our opinion, these circumstances are irrelevant and the Tribunal could not have placed reliance on the same to reach the conclusion it did and, therefore, the learned Single Judge was justified in interfering with the same. In the writ appeal the learned Judges on the Division Bench reiterated the view expressed by the Tribunal which we have found to be fallacious.

    7. At this stage, it is necessary to notice one argument that was urged on behalf of the first respondent, namely, that in the course of the order dismissing the first respondent from service it is noticed as follows:

    “In summing up after going through the issue raised by Shri Banerjee in detail, I am of the opinion that a domestic enquiry like ours does not give any scope for producing all evidences whether having direct bearing in the case or not as is being done in a court.”

    8. It is submitted that even if evidence is withheld, the conclusion of the enquiry officer would be correct is a perverse approach. We do not think so. What is stated therein is that when sufficient evidence was produced to conclude one way or the other, the evidence not produced will not be of any significance unless there was such evidence which was withheld would have tilted the evidence adduced in the course of domestic enquiry. No such evidence is forthcoming in this case. Therefore, this argument deserves to be rejected.

    9. For the foregoing reasons, we have no hesitation in setting aside the order made by the Division Bench of the High Court and restore that of the learned Single Judge.

    10. For the aforesaid reasons, this appeal is allowed as stated above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Bank Of India v. Tarun Kumar Banerjee And Others
    (Sep 19, 2000)