Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 16 of the Arbitration Act, 1940
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 16 of the Arbitration Act, 1940
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Orissa granted the respondent company an exclusive right and licence (agreement dated January 1974) to fell, cut and remove bamboos. Disputes arose regarding the quantity of bamboo that constitutes a tonne and the consequent royalty payable. Pursuant to an arbitration clause, the parties referred two specific disputes to an arbitrator, who delivered an award on 30 November 1978. The award:

  • Accepted, without further analysis, the Chief Conservator of Forests’ (CCF) determination that 2,300 metres (7,475 running feet) of salia bamboos and 600 metres (1,950 running feet) of daba bamboos make one tonne; and
  • Granted the respondent a refund of Rs 2,03,325 for excess royalty paid.

The Sub-Judge, Bhubaneswar made the award a rule of the court on 7 August 1980. On the respondent’s appeal, the Orissa High Court set aside the award on 19 November 1986, holding that the arbitrator had failed to decide the disputes actually referred and remitted the matter for reconsideration under Section 16 of the Arbitration Act, 1940. The State of Orissa then filed the present civil appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution, which has now been decided after more than twelve years of pendency.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the arbitrator had adequately decided all three components of the first dispute—specifically, the scientific validity of the CCF’s methodology and its universal applicability from 1-10-1973—or had merely adopted the CCF’s view without independent determination.
  2. Consequently, whether the Orissa High Court was justified in setting aside the award and remitting the matter to the arbitrator for fresh consideration.

Arguments of the Parties

State of Orissa (Appellant)

  • The award shows that the arbitrator concurred with the CCF’s methodology; therefore, no further reasons were required in what was, in effect, a non-speaking award.
  • Because the arbitrator had accepted a technically competent authority’s determination, interference by the High Court was unwarranted.

Respondent Company

  • The arbitrator failed to address critical points within the first dispute: whether the CCF’s calculation was scientific and whether it should apply to all cases from 1-10-1973.
  • This non-application of mind meant the disputes remained unresolved, justifying the High Court’s decision to set aside the award and remit the matter for fresh determination.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the specific questions framed in the reference to the arbitrator:

  1. Validation of the CCF’s conversion figures;
  2. Scientific soundness of that calculation; and
  3. Its applicability in all cases from 1-10-1973.

The award merely reiterated the CCF’s figures and declared them final and binding, without discussing the latter two components. The Court agreed with the High Court that this omission constituted a failure to decide the entire dispute. Merely concurring with the CCF did not amount to an adjudication of whether the methodology was scientific or universally applicable. Because essential questions remained unanswered, the award was legally unsustainable. Justice D.P. Wadhwa, in concurrence, noted additionally that the State should have accepted the High Court’s order instead of prolonging litigation, thereby saving public resources and judicial time.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed with costs.

The High Court’s order setting aside the arbitrator’s award and remitting the matter stands affirmed. The practical consequence is that the disputes return to the arbitrator for fresh determination. The judgment contains a cautionary observation that governmental litigants should exercise restraint and avoid unnecessary appeals; however, it does not establish a new legal precedent beyond reaffirming the need for arbitrators to address all issues referred to them.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Orissa v. Orient Paper & Industries Ltd. .

    D.P Wadhwa, J. (concurring)— I agree.

    2. I may, however, add that in this case the agreement was entered into in January 1974. After disputes and differences arose and the parties went for arbitration, the arbitrator gave his award on 30-11-1978. The award was challenged by the respondent before the Sub-Judge, Bhubaneswar who upheld the award by judgment and order dated 7-8-1980. The matter was taken in appeal before the Orissa High Court by the respondent. The High Court by its judgment dated 19-11-1986 allowed the appeal holding that the arbitrator had failed to decide the actual disputes specifically referred to him and remitted the matter to the arbitrator for reconsideration under Section 16 of the Arbitration Act, 1940. This appeal was filed by the State of Orissa against the judgment of the High Court and it has taken more than 12 years for the decision of the appeal. However, it was not necessary that the State Government should have challenged the order of the High Court in the circumstances of the case causing unnecessary expense to the parties and the time this Court had to spend in hearing the appeal. Had the State Government abided by the order of the High Court the matter before the arbitrator would have been completed years ago. The State cannot act like a private litigant that it must challenge every order made against it. The State has to be advised properly if a case required determination of this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution.

    N. Santosh Hegde, J.— Disputes having arisen between the State of Orissa and the respondent in this civil appeal, in respect of exclusive right and licence to fell, cut and remove bamboos, parties opted to go for arbitration as provided in the agreement. The disputes referred to the arbitrator for determination are:

    “1. As provided in Note (i) under clause 10 of the agreement, the CCF, Orissa has determined that 2300 mtrs or 7475 running ft of salia bamboos and 600 mtrs or 1950 running ft of daba bamboos respectively make a tonne vide his Letter No. 24755 dated 17-12-1974 (copy of which is placed in the State's written argument and the same is held to be final and binding on both parties).

    2. The respondent-Company was entitled to a refund of Rs 2,03,325 for excess royalty paid.”

    4. The arbitrator by his award held as follows:

    “As provided in Note (i) under clause 10 of the agreement, the Chief Conservator of Forests has determined that 2300 metres of 7475 running feet of salia bamboos and 600 metres of 1950 running feet of daba bamboos respectively make a tonne vide his Letter No. 24755 dated 17-12-1974 copy of which is placed in the State's written argument and the same is held to be final and binding on both parties.”

    5. Based on the finding in Dispute 1, he made a consequential award on the second issue. The said award of the arbitrator was made a rule of the court by the judgment of the learned Sub-Judge, Bhubaneswar dated 7-8-1980 in Miscellaneous Case No. 442 of 1978.

    6. Being aggrieved by the said order of the learned Sub-Judge, the respondent-Company preferred Miscellaneous Appeal No. 260 of 1980 before the Hon'ble High Court of Orissa at Cuttack. The High Court by its judgment dated 19-11-1986 allowed the miscellaneous appeal setting aside the order of the Subordinate Judge as well as the award of the arbitrator and remitted the matter back to the arbitrator for redetermination.

    7. Being aggrieved by the order of the High Court referred to above, this appeal is preferred. The High Court came to the conclusion that the learned arbitrator had not decided the disputes referred to him for arbitration. Therefore, the award was unsustainable in law. Consequently, the High Court held that such an award could not have been made a rule of the court by the learned Subordinate Judge.

    8. Before us, Shri P.N Misra, the learned Senior Advocate appearing for the State of Orissa contended that a perusal of the award shows that the arbitrator had in fact concurred with the decision taken by the Chief Conservator of Forests, Orissa in regard to the methodology to be adopted for determining the quantity of bamboos cut and removed. Since the arbitrator was agreeing with the methodology adopted by the Chief Conservator of Forests, the question of giving reasons in a non-speaking award does not arise. Therefore, the High Court ought not to have interfered with the award and the consequential order passed by the Subordinate Judge. On behalf of the respondent, Shri S.B Sanyal, Senior Advocate contended that the High Court was right in setting aside the award in question since the learned arbitrator had not at all decided the various points that arose in the first dispute referred to him, therefore, there was non-application of mind by the arbitrator and consequently the dispute referred to the arbitrator remained unanswered, hence the High Court was justified in remitting the matter back to the arbitrator.

    9. A perusal of the first dispute referred to the arbitrator shows that he had to determine three specific points, namely:

    (1) Whether the decision of the Chief Conservator of Forests that 2300 metres or 7475 running feet of salia bamboos and 600 metres or 1950 running feet of daba bamboos would make a tonne in weight;

    (2) Whether this calculation is scientific;

    (3) Whether this calculation will apply in all cases, to take effect from 1-10-1973.

    10. The award of the learned arbitrator in regard to the first dispute referred to him merely says that the Chief Conservator had determined under clause 10 of the agreement that 2300 metres or 7475 running feet of salia bamboos and 600 metres or 1950 running feet of daba bamboos respectively make a tonne and the same is held to be final and binding on both the parties. He did not even advert to the other points. In my opinion, the High Court was right in coming to the conclusion that the learned arbitrator did not decide the question whether the method adopted by the Chief Conservator of Forests was scientific or not. He also did not determine whether this methodology could be made applicable to all cases w.e.f 1-10-1973. In my opinion by merely agreeing with the decision of the Chief Conservator of Forests, the arbitrator has not addressed himself to other points arising in the first dispute and has not answered those points. Therefore, in my opinion the High Court is justified in setting aside the award and remitting it back to the arbitrator.

    11. This appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Orissa v. Orient Paper & Industries Ltd. .
    (Apr 9, 1999)