AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 226 of the Constitution of India
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 226 of the Constitution of India
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Government of India introduced a centrally-assisted scheme in 1974-75 to impart non-formal education to children aged 9–11 years who were school drop-outs or had never attended school. The State of West Bengal implemented the scheme from 8-12-1978 and, with effect from 4-10-1989, framed a revised policy. Non-formal education centres were part-time institutions run by Panchayat Samitis in rural areas and by Municipal bodies in urban areas. Instructors taught for two hours a day and were paid a fixed honorarium of Rs 105 (primary level) or Rs 125 (upper-primary level).

Monirujjaman Mullick and similarly situated instructors filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution before the Calcutta High Court claiming parity of pay and allowances with regular primary school teachers on the principle of “equal pay for equal work.” A learned Single Judge allowed the petition. On appeal, the Division Bench affirmed pay parity (with increments) but rejected absorption into regular service and clarified that services would terminate if the scheme was discontinued; it also directed extension of the benefit to all similarly placed persons.

The State of West Bengal appealed to the Supreme Court. The present judgment disposes of Civil Appeal No. 4195 of 1994 and connected appeals/orders dated 19-7-1996.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether instructors engaged in non-formal education centres are entitled to the same pay scale and allowances as regular primary school teachers under the doctrine of “equal pay for equal work.”
  2. Whether the High Court exceeded its jurisdiction under Article 226 by enlarging the scope of the non-formal education scheme to grant such parity.

Arguments of the Parties

State of West Bengal (Appellant)

  • Non-formal education centres are not part of the State’s regular educational system; they are temporary, part-time arrangements funded under a Central Government scheme.
  • Instructors work only two hours daily, receive an honorarium, and were never appointed to a regular pay scale; therefore, parity with full-time primary teachers is unwarranted.
  • The High Court, in judicial review, cannot expand the scheme’s scope to confer benefits it never contemplated.
  • Relied on Delhi Development Horticulture Employees’ Union v. Delhi Administration, (1992) 4 SCC 99, where the Supreme Court held that employees engaged under welfare schemes cannot claim regularisation or equal pay with regular staff.

Respondents (Instructors)

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents’ legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Delhi Development Horticulture Employees’ Union v. Delhi Administration, (1992) 4 SCC 99 Employees engaged under special welfare schemes cannot demand regularisation or equal pay with regular employees; such claims would frustrate the scheme. The Court invoked this authority to hold that extending regular pay scales to part-time instructors would undermine the object and financial viability of the non-formal education scheme.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court drew a clear distinction between non-formal education centres and regular primary schools:

  • Nature of Institutions: Non-formal centres are temporary, part-time entities created exclusively to implement a welfare scheme; primary schools are permanent establishments of the Education Department.
  • Conditions of Service: Instructors receive only a nominal honorarium, teach for two hours daily, and are appointed through an informal process, whereas primary teachers serve full-time, follow formal recruitment procedures, and draw salary scales.
  • Functional Differences: Although the syllabus and ultimate educational goal may be similar, qualitative differences exist in teaching methods, responsibilities, working hours, and institutional infrastructure.

On these grounds, the Court concluded that the instructors’ work is not identical or comparable to that of primary teachers, rendering the doctrine of “equal pay for equal work” inapplicable. Applying its earlier ruling in Delhi Development Horticulture Employees’ Union, the Court held that judicial intervention cannot enlarge welfare schemes to impose additional financial obligations on the State.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court judgments set aside. Writ petitions dismissed. No costs.

Immediate Effect: Non-formal education instructors are not entitled to pay parity or allowances equal to primary school teachers, and the benefits granted by the High Court stand withdrawn.

Broader Implications: The decision reaffirms limits on the “equal pay for equal work” doctrine in the context of part-time or scheme-based employment and cautions courts against extending welfare schemes beyond their intended scope. No new legal precedent was created, but the judgment reinforces existing Supreme Court jurisprudence on scheme-based employment.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of W.B And Others v. Monirujjaman Mullick And Others

    Kuldip Singh, J.— Monirujjaman Mullick and other private respondents, in the appeal herein, were working as Instructors in various non-formal education centres in different districts in the State of West Bengal. They approached the High Court by way of a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking a direction — based on the principle of “equal pay for equal work” — that they were entitled to the same scales of pay and allowances as were admissible and being paid to the primary school teachers. A learned Single Judge of the High Court allowed the writ petition. Appeal filed by the State of West Bengal was disposed of with the following directions:

    “The writ petitioners who are not in regular employment elsewhere and who have the minimum qualification prescribed for the primary school teachers are entitled to the same scale of pay and allowances as admissible to the primary school teachers from the date of their initial appointment and further that they are also entitled to annual increments in the pay scale in accordance with law; but their claim for absorption in the department as regular primary school teachers cannot be sustained and therefore stands rejected.
    It is made clear that the services of such non-formal teachers will be liable to stand automatically terminated as and when the non-formal education scheme is discontinued in this State.
    Persons similarly placed should also be given the same benefit to avoid further litigation in regard to the selfsame issue.”

    This appeal by the State of West Bengal is against the judgment of the learned Single Judge and of the Division Bench of the High Court dated 28-6-1993.

    2. We may briefly state the facts of the case. Government of India introduced a scheme in the year 1974-75 for imparting non-formal education to the children in the age group of 9/11 years who were either school dropouts or did not go to school. The scheme provided for the opening of non-formal education centres (part-time) by the State Government with the help of Central Government grant. West Bengal Government took a policy decision on 8-12-1978 to implement the scheme. Subsequently the State Government formulated a new scheme regarding non-formal education, which became operative with effect from 4-10-1989. The non-formal centres were part-time institutions. The instructors were given a fixed honorarium of Rs 105 per month at the primary level and Rs 125 per month at the upper primary level. Persons with a motivation to serve the community — particularly the weaker sections — were appointed instructors. They were required to teach the children for two hours a day. The centres were run by the Panchayat Samitis in rural areas and by the Municipal Committees/Corporations in urban areas. There were no specific buildings or sites for the centres. The instructors could use any site or building belonging to a social organisation or a local authority.

    3. The Division Bench of the High Court applied the doctrine of “equal pay for equal work” on the following reasoning:

    “From the booklet published and distributed by the Primary Education Directorate regarding formal (Prathamik Shiksha) and non-formal (Bidhijukta Shiksha), it appears that the purposes of both the streams being to help attain human values through practical literacy in language, elementary arithmetic, awareness for maintaining personal and public health and good environment, social awareness, scientific outlook to get rid of prejudices, etc., the syllabus and the books prescribed for formal and non-formal education are almost same with the ultimate goal of equipping the boys and girls for entry into class V in regular High or Junior High School.
    It is thus clear and we are also of considered opinion that neither stream is inferior to the other and that the duties, functions and responsibilities of the teachers of the formal and non-formal education are alike, if not heavier on the side of the non-formal stream.”

    4. Mr Dipankar Gupta, learned Solicitor General, appearing for the State of West Bengal has contended that the non-formal education centres were not a part of the regular educational system of the State of West Bengal. These centres were started under a policy decision of the Central Government which was implemented by the State of West Bengal to help educate the children belonging to weaker sections of the society. These centres were part-time by nature and the instructors were paid an honorarium. They were not appointed to a regular pay scale and were not paid any salary. Even the teaching in the centres was not for a full educational day, it was only for two hours. According to Mr Gupta when the scheme provided for two hours of non-formal teaching at the part-time centres by the part-time instructors, who were paid a mere honorarium the High Court was not justified in enlarging the scope of the scheme in the exercise of its power of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Mr Gupta relied upon the judgment of this Court in Delhi Development Horticulture Employees' Union v. Delhi Admn. (1992) 4 SCC 99, (1992) 21 ATC 386 P.B Sawant, J. speaking for the Court observed as under:

    “Those employed under the scheme, therefore, could not ask for more than what the scheme intended to give them. To get an employment under such scheme and to claim on the basis of the said employment, a right to regularisation, is to frustrate the scheme itself. No court can be a party to such exercise. It is wrong to approach the problems of those employed under such schemes with a view to providing them with full employment and guaranteeing equal pay for equal work. These concepts, in the context of such schemes are both unwarranted and misplaced. They will do more harm than good by depriving the many of the little income that they may get to keep them from starvation. They would benefit a few at the cost of the many starving poor for whom the schemes are meant. That would also force the State to wind up the existing schemes and forbid them from introducing the new ones, for want of resources.”

    We are of the view that the non-formal educational centres cannot be equated with the primary schools which are regularly run by the Education Department of the State Government. Apart from the basic qualitative differences between the two institutions even the nature of work of the non-formal instructors and the primary school teachers is not identical. The method of appointment, the source of recruitment, method of teaching, hours of teaching and the mode of payment are entirely different. In the facts and circumstances of this case the High Court fell into patent error in applying the principle of “equal pay for equal work”.

    5. The appeal is allowed and the judgment of the learned Single Judge of the High Court and the impugned judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court are set aside. The writ petitions filed by the respondents before the High Court shall stand dismissed. No costs.

    6. All the IAs are disposed of.

    Connected Orders
    (Before Kuldip Singh and S. Saghir Ahmad, JJ.)
    STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANOTHER . . Appellants;
    Versus
    WEST BENGAL NON-FORMAL EDUCATION CENTRES TEACHERS' ASSOCIATION AND OTHERS . . Respondents.
    Civil Appeal No. 9395 of 1994, decided on July 19, 1996
    Order

    1. Special leave granted.

    2. We have, by a separate judgment pronounced today, allowed Civil Appeal No. 4195 of 1994 (State of W.B v. Monirujjaman Mullick) and have set aside the Division Bench judgment of the Calcutta High Court (State of W.B v. Monirujjaman Mullick 97 CWN 1075).

    3. We therefore, allow the appeal and set aside the impugned judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court which is based on Monirujjaman case. No costs.

    (Before Kuldip Singh and S. Saghir Ahmad, JJ.)
    WEST BENGAL NON-FORMAL EDUCATION CENTRES TEACHERS' ASSOCIATION . . Appellant;
    Versus
    STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND OTHERS . . Respondents.
    Civil Appeal No. 4194 of 1994, decided on July 19, 1996
    Order

    We have by a separate judgment pronounced today in CA No. 4195 of 1994, set aside the Division Bench judgment of the Calcutta High Court in State of W.B v. Monirujjaman Mullick 97 CWN 1075. This appeal has been filed by the Non-formal Education Teachers' Association against the Monirujjaman case. This appeal has become infructuous and as such is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of W.B And Others v. Monirujjaman Mullick And Others
    (Jul 19, 1996)