Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Union of India appealed against orders of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Allahabad, which directed the Northern Railway authorities to absorb the respondents on a regular basis as “mates” (a Class III post). The respondents had originally been engaged as casual mates, worked for more than 120 days, passed the requisite trade test, and were accorded temporary status in line with the Supreme Court’s directions in Ram Kumar v. Union of India. In 1993, the Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction), Northern Railway, issued two orders regularising them instead as “gangmen” (a lower Class IV post). The respondents challenged those orders before the CAT, which held that—given their long service as mates—it was inappropriate to place them in a lower post and accordingly directed their regularisation as mates. The Union of India brought the present civil appeals against that CAT decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Railway Rules permit direct appointment to the post of mate in Class III and, if not, whether prolonged factual continuance as a mate confers a right to be regularised in that post.
  2. Whether the conferment of temporary status as a mate, by itself, entitles an employee to regular absorption as a mate rather than as a gangman.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (Union of India / Railway Authorities)

  • Temporary status does not automatically convey a right to regularisation in the same post; it only affords limited service benefits.
  • Under Railway Rules the normal career progression is gangman → keyman → senior keyman (all Class IV) → mate (Class III) after passing a trade test; direct or regular appointment as mate is impermissible.
  • Although respondents had been working as mates, those appointments were ad hoc and contrary to the rules; hence regularisation must start at the lowest rung (gangman).
  • The respondents’ existing pay as mates had been protected, so no illegality or prejudice flowed from placing them as gangmen.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • Railway rules do not expressly bar direct appointment as a mate; in practice they were so appointed and have served for over two decades.
  • Having held the post of mate continuously and having been accorded temporary status, it would be inequitable and unlawful to regularise them at the lower rank of gangman.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Kumar v. Union of India, (1988) 1 SCC 306; (1987) 5 ATC 404 Defines the rights that accrue when a Railway casual/daily-wage employee acquires temporary status; such status does not itself confer a right to regularisation. The Court relied on this case to hold that obtaining temporary status as a mate does not create an automatic entitlement to permanent absorption in that post.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Examining the Railway Rules and administrative instructions, the Court held that the post of mate is promotional in nature and cannot be filled by direct recruitment. Promotion is available only from among gangmen/keymen who have qualified through a trade test.

2. Therefore, the respondents’ initial direct appointment as casual mates—though acquiesced in for operational reasons—was contrary to the statutory scheme and did not confer an enforceable right to regularisation in that post.

3. Citing Ram Kumar, the Court reiterated that temporary status merely provides specified service benefits; it does not ipso facto guarantee regular absorption in the same grade.

4. Notwithstanding the above legal position, the Court invoked equitable considerations: the respondents had served as mates for 22–25 years and had already been accorded temporary status and placed in the seniority list for that post.

5. Balancing strict legality against long-standing service realities, the Court declined to interfere with the CAT’s direction to regularise the respondents as mates, expressly stating that this result rested on the peculiar facts and should not be treated as a precedent.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED – The civil appeals filed by the Union of India were rejected.

Implications: The respondents will continue to be regularised as mates in Class III, preserving their existing pay and status. The Court explicitly declared that its decision rests on equitable considerations unique to this case and is not to be cited as precedent for future matters.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India And Another v. Moti Lal And Others

    Order

    1. Delay condoned.

    2. Leave granted.

    3. These appeals by the Union of India are directed against the orders passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Allahabad directing the Railway authorities to absorb the respondents on regular basis as mates.

    4. The respondents approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, Allahabad challenging the orders dated 18-2-1993 and 11-6-1993 passed by the Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction), Northern Railway, regularising the respondents in the post of gangman in the grade of Rs 775 to Rs 1025 in Class IV. It was alleged by the respondents that they had been directly appointed as casual mates in Class III post in Northern Railway and after continuously working for more than 120 days they acquired temporary status as mates. It was also averred that before conferring temporary status on them they were required to pass the trade test and in pursuance of the directions of the Supreme Court in Ram Kumar case (1988) 1 SCC 306, (1987) 5 ATC 404 they were conferred the temporary status as mates and a seniority list was drawn up. While they were so continuing, the two impugned orders emanated regularising them against the post of gangman in Class IV. Accordingly they prayed before the Tribunal that the Railway authorities should be directed to regularise them against the post of mates. The appellants Railway authorities took the stand before the Tribunal that the post of mate is a promotional post and can be filled on regular basis only by considering the employees from lower grade of gangman/keyman/senior keyman. They did not dispute the fact that the respondents were granted temporary status against the post of mates but contended that since the gangman can only be promoted on regular basis to the post of mate subject to his fitness and qualification the authorities have regularised the respondents by the impugned order in the lowest post of gangman. The Tribunal on consideration of the respective stand of the parties came to the conclusion that since the respondents have worked all these years as mates right from the inception it would not be appropriate to regularise them against the lower post as gangman and accordingly directed that they be regularised against the post of mate. It is this order of the Tribunal which is being assailed in these appeals.

    5. Mr Goswami, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Union of India and other Railway authorities, contended that the conferment of the temporary status on a casual employee does not ipso facto entitle him to be regularised to the said post and, therefore, merely because the respondents were given temporary status against the post of mates, the Tribunal erred in law in directing their regularisation as mates. He further contended that under the rules in Railways a person has to be appointed in the lowest post of gangman and from the said post the next promotional post is keyman and then senior keyman which are the posts in Class IV and thereafter those of the senior keyman who are found suitable for promotion to the post of mate after holding a trade test, are promoted to the post of ‘Mate’ in Class III. This being the normal procedure of promotion it would be wholly inequitable and contrary to the rules to regularise the respondents as mates. It was not disputed, however, that the respondents on account of dearth of people had been appointed as mates and continued as such for all these years and also had been conferred with the temporary status against the post of mate and a seniority list had also been drawn up. But according to him such appointment of the respondents as mates is contrary to the rules and, therefore, such continuance does not confer a right of regularisation against the said post.

    6. Mr Goswami further contended that the respondents' pay, what they were drawing as mates has been fully protected and, as such, there has been no illegality with the orders issued by the Railway authorities regularising the respondents as gangman.

    7. The learned counsel appearing for the respondents, on the other hand, contended that there is no bar for direct appointment as mate and in fact the respondents having been appointed as mates and their services having been utilised by the Railway authorities for more than 20 years and they having been given temporary status it is not permissible for the Railway authorities to regularise them as gangman. Consequently, the Tribunal was justified in issuing the impugned directions.

    8. In view of the rival stand of the parties two questions really arise for our consideration:

    1. Is it permissible under rules to appoint a person directly as mate in Class III and if not, then whether the factual continuance of the person as a mate for a considerable period entitles him to be regularised as a mate?
    2. Conferment of a temporary status as a mate whether ipso facto entitles a person to be regularised as a mate and not as a gangman?

    9. So far as the first question is concerned, on examining the relevant provisions of the rules as well as the administrative instructions issued by the Railway authorities we are of the considered opinion that it is not permissible to appoint a person directly as a mate and it is only a promotional post from Class IV post of gangman and keyman. These gangmen and keymen can be promoted to the post of mate in Class III subject to their suitability and efficiency being tested through trade test. It is no doubt true that these respondents under certain circumstances had been appointed directly as casual mates and they continued as such and further by virtue of their continuance they acquired temporary status but that by itself does not entitle them to be regularised as mates since that would be contrary to the rules in force. In our considered opinion the respondents did not acquire a right for regularisation as mates from mere fact of their continuance as casual mates for a considerable period.

    10. So far as the second question is concerned, we are also of the considered opinion that conferment of the temporary status as mate ipso facto does not entitle the person concerned to regular absorption as mate. In the case of Ram Kumar v. Union of India (1988) 1 SCC 306, (1987) 5 ATC 404 this Court has held that an employee on daily-wage basis under the Railway acquires temporary status on completion of a specified number of days in service and with the acquisition of the said status such employees are entitled to:

    (1) Termination of service and period of notice (subject to the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947).

    (2) Scales of pay.

    (3) Compensatory and local allowances.

    (4) Medical attendance.

    (5) Leave rules.

    (6) Provident fund and terminal gratuity.

    (7) Allotment of railway accommodation and recovery of rent.

    (8) Railway passes.

    (9) Advances.

    (10) Any other benefit specifically authorised by the Ministry of Railways.

    11. Thus it is apparent that a daily-wage or casual worker against a particular post when acquires a temporary status having worked against the said post for specified number of days does not acquire a right to be regularised against the said post. He can be considered for regularisation in accordance with the rules and, therefore, so far as the post of mate under Railways is concerned, the same has to be filled up by a promotion from the post of gangman and keyman in Class IV subject to employees passing the trade test.

    12. In this view of the matter the Tribunal was not justified in directing regularisation of the respondents as mates.

    13. Even though on principle we are in agreement with the submissions of Mr Goswami, learned Senior Counsel appearing for railway administration but having taken into account the fact that the respondents were directly appointed as mates though on casual basis and having continued as such mates for more than 22 to 25 years it will be wholly inequitable to require them to be regularised against the post of gangman in Class IV. In the premises, as aforesaid, we decline to interfere with the ultimate conclusion of the Tribunal on equitable ground, in the facts and circumstances of the present case. The direction will not be treated as a precedent.

    14. The appeals are accordingly dismissed. But there will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Another v. Moti Lal And Others
    (Feb 15, 1996)