AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1995 INSC 730
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 12 of the Passport Act
  • Section 419, Section 420, Section 468, Section 471, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 302, Sections 307, Sections 326, Sections 323, Sections 436, Section 120-B, Indian Penal Code
  • Sections 3, Sections 4, and Sections 5 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987
  • Sections 4 and Sections 5 of the Explosive Substances Act
  • Section 20(4), TADA (Terrorist and Disruptive Activities Act)
  • the statute
  • Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 20(4)(bb) TADA as inserted by Amendment Act of 1993
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1995 INSC 730
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 12 of the Passport Act
  • Section 419, Section 420, Section 468, Section 471, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 302, Sections 307, Sections 326, Sections 323, Sections 436, Section 120-B, Indian Penal Code
  • Sections 3, Sections 4, and Sections 5 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987
  • Sections 4 and Sections 5 of the Explosive Substances Act
  • Section 20(4), TADA (Terrorist and Disruptive Activities Act)
  • the statute
  • Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 20(4)(bb) TADA as inserted by Amendment Act of 1993
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Devinderpal Singh (“the appellant”) was deported from Germany and arrested upon arrival in New Delhi for allegedly travelling on a false passport (FIR No. 22 of 1993 under Sections 419/420/468/471 IPC and Section 12 of the Passport Act). Although released on bail in that matter, he was arrested the same day (19-1-1993) in a separate and far more serious case (FIR No. 316 of 1993) involving offences under Sections 302/307/326/323/436/120-B IPC, Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (“TADA”) and Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act.

The appellant remained in judicial custody. The statutory 180-day period for completing investigation under Section 20(4)(b) TADA expired on 17-7-1995. Five days earlier (12-7-1995) the Investigating Officer applied to the Designated Court for an extension of 60 days to complete the investigation and, correspondingly, to extend the appellant’s detention. Without producing the appellant and without any report from the Public Prosecutor, the Designated Court granted the extension.

On 17-7-1995 the remand was formally extended to 15-9-1995. The appellant immediately applied for bail, asserting that (i) the investigation was not completed within 180 days, (ii) no independent report of the Public Prosecutor had been filed, and (iii) he had not been heard before the extension order was made. While the bail application was pending, a charge-sheet (challan) under Section 173 CrPC was filed on 30-9-1995.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Designated Court’s extension of time for investigation and detention under Section 20(4)(bb) TADA is valid when granted solely on the Investigating Officer’s application, without a report by the Public Prosecutor and without the accused being produced or heard.
  2. Assuming the extension order is invalid, whether the appellant retains an “indefeasible” right to be released on default bail after a charge-sheet has subsequently been filed.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Section 20(4)(bb) TADA mandates a report from the Public Prosecutor describing investigation progress and stating specific reasons for further detention; no such report was filed.
  • Under Hitendra Vishnu Thakur v. State of Maharashtra (1994 4 SCC 602), strict compliance with clause (bb) is essential and no extension can be granted for any reason outside the statute.
  • The extension order was passed without notice to, or production of, the appellant, violating the requirement that the accused be enabled to oppose the request.
  • Because of these defects the appellant acquired an indefeasible right to default bail when the 180-day period expired.
  • The reliance on Sanjay Dutt v. State (1994 5 SCC 410) by the State is misplaced; that decision arose on a concession and does not cure the illegal extension order.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • There was ample material justifying the 60-day extension; the Designated Court examined case diaries and other records before granting it.
  • Under Sanjay Dutt v. State (1994 5 SCC 410), any indefeasible right to default bail exists only until the charge-sheet is filed; once the challan (filed on 30-9-1995) is before the court, the right is extinguished.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hitendra Vishnu Thakur v. State of Maharashtra, (1994) 4 SCC 602 Strict requirements for extension under Section 20(4)(bb) TADA: mandatory Public Prosecutor’s report and opportunity for the accused to be heard. Relied upon to hold that the Designated Court’s extension order, made without a Public Prosecutor’s report and without producing the appellant, was erroneous and unsustainable.
Sanjay Dutt v. State through C.B.I., Bombay (II), (1994) 5 SCC 410 The accused’s “indefeasible” right to default bail must be exercised before the filing of the charge-sheet; it lapses thereafter. Also clarified that presence of the accused in court suffices as notice for extension hearings. Accepted as binding; the Court noted it need not re-examine this aspect but directed the Designated Court to consider the pending bail application in light of this precedent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court scrutinised the validity of the 12-7-1995 extension order. It observed that:

  • The application for extension emanated solely from the Investigating Officer; no independent report from the Public Prosecutor, as demanded by Section 20(4)(bb) TADA and emphasised in Hitendra Vishnu Thakur, was placed before the Designated Court.
  • The appellant was neither produced nor informed that extension of time and detention were under consideration, denying him an opportunity to oppose the request—another departure from the principles in Hitendra Vishnu Thakur.
  • Sanjay Dutt did not dilute the statutory requirement of a Public Prosecutor’s report; it only clarified that formal written notice is unnecessary if the accused is produced and informed. In the present case even that minimal requirement was absent.
  • Accordingly, assessed on the facts existing on 12-7-1995, the extension order was irregular and legally untenable.

On the separate question of bail, the Court recognised that a charge-sheet had meanwhile been filed. Given the divergence between the parties on the effect of that development, and mindful of the Constitution Bench ruling in Sanjay Dutt, the Court refrained from deciding the bail request itself, leaving it to the Designated Court to apply the governing principles.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF.

The Supreme Court set aside the Designated Court’s extension order as erroneous but did not itself grant bail. Instead, it directed the Designated Court to dispose of the pending bail application “expeditiously” in accordance with the legal framework laid down in Hitendra Vishnu Thakur and Sanjay Dutt. The ruling has immediate consequences for the parties but does not announce any new legal principle; it reiterates strict compliance with Section 20(4)(bb) TADA and confirms continued authority of the Sanjay Dutt precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Devinderpal Singh v. Govt. Of National Capital Territory Of Delhi .

    Suhas C. Sen, J.— Special leave granted.

    2. Devinderpal Singh, the appellant herein, was deported from Germany and was arrested on his arrival at New Delhi on the charge of having travelled to Germany on a false passport. A case being FIR No. 22 of 1993 under Sections 419/420/468/471, Indian Penal Code, and Section 12 of the Passport Act, was registered against him. He was subsequently ordered to be released on bail.

    3. On the very same day i.e 19-1-1993, the appellant was also arrested in another case being FIR No. 316 of 1993 registered under Sections 302/307/326/323/436/120-B, Indian Penal Code, Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 and Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act.

    4. The appellant was remanded to judicial custody which was extended from time to time and the statutory period of 180 days expired on 17-7-1995.

    5. Before the expiry of the aforesaid statutory period of 180 days, an application was moved on 12-7-1995 for extension of time for completion of the investigation and for that purpose a prayer was also made for extending the period of detention of the appellant beyond the period of 180 days. The Designated Court No. II, Tis Hazari, Delhi, ordered:

    “I have seen the entire file and progress of investigation. I have heard today the learned Public Prosecutor. The evidence has to be collected from Jaipur, Baroda, Ahmedabad against the accused persons and that some of the offenders are yet to be arrested against whom some clues are received very recently. Keeping this in view, I am of the opinion that this is a fit case where extension of time as per provisions of Section 20(4)(bb) TADA as inserted by Amendment Act of 1993, should be given. I accordingly allow extension of period for another sixty days at the expiry of first statutory period of 180 days with direction to positively complete the investigation by then.”

    6. The appellant was produced before the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, New Delhi, on 17-7-1995 and the period of judicial remand was extended on the ground that the Designated Court had already extended the time for completion of the investigation for another 60 days. Consequently, the judicial remand of the appellant was extended for a further period of 60 days till 15-9-1995.

    7. The appellant, thereafter, on 17-7-1995, moved an application for bail on the ground that the prosecution had failed to complete the investigation within the statutory period of 180 days and that no independent report had been submitted by the designated Public Prosecutor regarding the progress of the investigation and specific reasons for detaining the appellant beyond the statutory period of 180 days were not stated by the Public Prosecutor. The further contention of the appellant was that he was not produced before the Designated Court at the time of hearing of the application for extension on 12-7-1995 and the order of extension was passed behind his back and without giving him any opportunity to show cause why the prayer for extension should not be allowed.

    8. Mr Sodhi appearing on behalf of the appellant, has contended that by virtue of the proviso to sub-section (4)(bb) of Section 20, it is possible for the Designated Court to extend the statutory period of detention beyond the prescribed period of 180 days only if the conditions laid down in that sub-section are fulfilled. An essential requirement of sub-section (4)(bb) of Section 20 is that there will have to be a report of the Public Prosecutor indicating the progress of the investigation and also the specific reasons for the detention of the accused beyond the aforesaid statutory period. In the instant case, the Public Prosecutor has not given any such report. The Designated Court, therefore, was in error in extending the period of detention without any report of the Public Prosecutor, as required by the statute. Mr Sodhi further argued that in the judgment in the case of Hitendra Vishnu Thakur v. State of Maharashtra (1994) 4 SCC 602 (in which one of us, Dr Anand, J. was a party), it was clearly laid down that no extension under clause (bb) can be granted for reasons other than those specifically contained therein and the requirements of clause (bb) must be strictly complied with before any extension was granted. The accused had acquired an indefeasible right to be released on bail in this case on account of the default of the prosecution. The Designated Court was clearly in error in extending the time, even though the Public Prosecutor had failed to make a report as required by the statute. It was also emphasised by Mr Sodhi that the order of extension was passed without any notice to the accused and without producing him before the court.

    9. On behalf of the respondent, Mr R.P Srivastava has argued that there is sufficient material on record and good grounds for extending the period of detention beyond the statutory period. It was contended that the application for extension of time of the period of detention was fully considered and heard by the Designated Court. The order to extend the period of detention was passed only after carefully perusing the case diaries and other relevant materials on record of the case. He drew our attention to the statement made on behalf of the respondent in the affidavit filed in this Court by S.N Srivastava, Deputy Commissioner of Police, Head Quarters-II, PHQ, Delhi, that a challan has been filed under Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure against the appellant before the Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi, on 13-9-1995.

    10. Mr Srivastava contended that in the case of Sanjay Dutt v. State (1994) 5 SCC 410, it has been laid down that the indefeasible right accrued to the accused for non-compliance with the requirements of Section 20(4)(bb) was enforceable only prior to the filing of the challan. This indefeasible right did not survive or could not be enforced after the challan was filed. The appellant had failed to enforce his right before the challan was filed and, therefore, he could not enforce this right any more now that the challan has been filed.

    11. Mr Sodhi countered this argument by saying that the order passed by the Designated Court was clearly erroneous. When the court heard the case, the challan had not been filed at all. He further contended that the decision in Sanjay Dutt case (1994) 5 SCC 410 was given on a concession made by the counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant and the court had no occasion to examine this issue in detail.

    12. We need not express any opinion on this aspect of the matter. The decision in Sanjay Dutt case (1994) 5 SCC 410 was rendered by a Bench of five Judges and is binding upon this Court.

    13. The Designated Court granted extension of time to the investigating agency for completion of the investigation under clause (bb) of Section 20(4) of TADA. This extension was granted on an application made by the investigating officer only and without any report of the Public Prosecutor. It is submitted by Mr Sodhi that extension was granted behind the back of the appellant and without permitting the appellant to have his say against the grant of extension. This position has not been controverted by learned counsel for the respondents. In Hitendra Vishnu Thakur case (1994) 4 SCC 602, it was observed:

    “Thus, for seeking extension of time under clause (bb), the public prosecutor after an independent application of his mind to the request of the investigating agency is required to make a report to the Designated Court indicating therein the progress of the investigation and disclosing justification for keeping the accused in further custody to enable the investigating agency to complete the investigation. The Public Prosecutor may attach the request of the investigating officer along with his request or application and report, but his report, as envisaged under clause (bb), must disclose on the face of it that he has applied his mind and was satisfied with the progress of the investigation and considered grant of further time to complete the investigation necessary. The use of the expression ‘on the report of the Public Prosecutor indicating the progress of the investigation and the specific reasons for the detention of the accused beyond the said period’ as occurring in clause (bb) in sub-section (2) of Section 167 as amended by Section 20(4) are important and indicative of the legislative intent not to keep an accused in custody unreasonably and to grant extension only on the report of the Public Prosecutor. The report of the Public Prosecutor, therefore, is not merely a formality but a very vital report because the consequence of its acceptance affects the liberty of an accused and it must, therefore, strictly comply with the requirements as contained in clause (bb). The request of an investigating officer for extension of time is no substitute for the report of the Public Prosecutor.”

    14. In Hitendra Vishnu Thakur case (1994) 4 SCC 602 it was also opined that no extension can be granted by the Designated Court under clause (bb) unless the accused is put on notice and permitted to have his say so as to be able to object to the grant of extension.

    15. The Constitution Bench in Sanjay Dutt case (1994) 5 SCC 410 did not express any contrary opinion insofar as the requirement of the report of the Public Prosecutor for grant of extension is concerned or on the effect of the absence of such a report under clause (bb) of Section 20(4), but observed that the ‘notice’ contemplated in the decision in Hitendra Vishnu Thakur case (1994) 4 SCC 602 before granting extension for completion of investigation is not to be construed as a “written notice” to the accused and that only the production of the accused at the time of consideration of the report of the Public Prosecutor for grant of extension and informing him that the question of extension of the period for completing the investigation was being considered would be sufficient notice to the accused.

    16. The validity of an order granting extension under clause (bb) of Section 20(4) of TADA is to be considered with reference to the facts as existing on the date of the order. Mr Sodhi is right in his contention that the order passed by the Designated Court on 12-7-1995 without any report of the Public Prosecutor and without even the appellant being produced and informed by the Designated Court that question of grant of extension of the period for completing investigation was under consideration, renders the order granting extension by the Designated Court erroneous and it cannot be sustained.

    17. This now takes us to the question of grant of bail to the appellant. Learned counsel for the parties state that challan has since been filed on 30-9-1995. Learned counsel are at variance about the effect of filing the challan on the right of the appellant to be released on bail. This question was examined in Sanjay Dutt case (1994) 5 SCC 410 where it has been laid down that the right to be released on bail for failure to complete the investigation within the prescribed time is not automatic and even if ‘indefeasible’ it has to be “availed of” by the accused at the appropriate stage and that:

    “The indefeasible right accruing to the accused in such a situation is enforceable only prior to the filing of the challan and it does not survive or remain enforceable on the challan being filed, if already not availed of. Once the challan has been filed, the question of grant of bail has to be considered and decided only with reference to the merits of the case under the provisions relating to grant of bail to an accused after the filing of the challan. The custody of the accused after the challan has been filed is not governed by Section 167 but different provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure. If that right had accrued to the accused but it remained unenforced till the filing of the challan, then there is no question of its enforcement thereafter since it is extinguished the moment challan is filed because Section 167 CrPC ceases to apply.”

    18. Since, as submitted by Mr Sodhi, an application for grant of bail on the ground that the prosecution had failed to complete investigation within the statutory period of 180 days was filed and is pending before the Designated Court, we refrain from dealing with the bail application filed in this Court or express any opinion on the merits of the bail application pending before the Designated Court. The Designated Court shall dispose of the pending bail application in accordance with law expeditiously, keeping in view the principles laid down by this Court in the above-referred cases.

    19. The appeal and the bail application are, therefore, disposed of in the terms noticed above. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Devinderpal Singh v. Govt. Of National Capital Territory Of Delhi .
    (Nov 14, 1995)