Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the text)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the text)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, serving as Senior Godown Keeper for the Food Corporation of India, was prosecuted after police raided the Central Godown at Ranchi on the night of 2 March 1968. A truck (Registration No. BRN 4281) with 22 bags of wheat allegedly loaded on the appellant’s instructions was seized. Police also took possession of Release Order 115, purportedly authorising delivery of 1200 bags of wheat to Hatia Consumers’ Co-operative Society, but the document was never produced in court.

The Munsif Magistrate, First Class, Ranchi, convicted the appellant of criminal breach of trust. On appeal, the Judicial Commissioner, Ranchi, modified the conviction to one under Section 409 read with Section 511 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) but retained a sentence of two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹200. The Patna High Court affirmed the conviction while reducing the sentence to six months’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹50. The present appeal was filed in the Supreme Court of India by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a conviction under Section 409 read with Section 511 IPC can be sustained when a crucial defence document (Release Order 115), seized by the prosecution, is withheld from evidence.
  2. Whether the trial court and High Court erred in placing the burden on the accused to produce the seized release order in support of his defence.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Arguments

  • The appellant directed the unauthorised loading of 22 bags of wheat onto the truck, constituting an attempt to commit criminal breach of trust.
  • No valid documentation was produced to justify the despatch of the wheat.

Appellant's Arguments

  • The wheat was being despatched pursuant to Release Order 115 in favour of Hatia Consumers’ Co-operative Society.
  • The release order, seized by police and not produced at trial, prevented the appellant from substantiating his defence.
  • The prosecution’s failure to exhibit this vital document created reasonable doubt, rendering the conviction unsustainable.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that the defence centred on Release Order 115, a “relevant and vital document” seized from the appellant’s custody. Because the prosecution deliberately withheld this document, the Court held that:

  • The statement of PW 2 regarding entries in unspecified release orders constituted “no evidence at all” absent production of Release Order 115.
  • The Magistrate’s rejection of the defence on the ground that the accused did not produce the document overlooked the fact that the document was in the prosecution’s possession.
  • The High Court’s dismissal of the defence for lack of supporting material was likewise unjustified because the absence of material was attributable to the prosecution’s non-production.

Given these circumstances, the Court concluded that sustaining the conviction would be unsafe and contrary to principles of fair trial and evidentiary burden resting on the prosecution.

Holding and Implications

Conviction and sentence set aside; the appellant is acquitted of the charge under Section 409 read with Section 511 IPC, and his bail bond is discharged.

Immediate Implications: The appellant is released from criminal liability and any custodial sentence or fine imposed by the lower courts. The judgment underscores the prosecution’s duty to place before the court any material evidence in its possession, especially when such evidence is exculpatory. No broader precedent was articulated beyond the case-specific reinforcement of this evidentiary obligation.

    Chittaranjan Choudhury v. State Of Bihar .

    M.M Dutt, J.— In this appeal by special leave the appellant has challenged the judgment of the Patna High Court affirming the order of the learned Judicial Commissioner, Ranchi, whereby the learned Judicial Commissioner altered the order of conviction of the appellant as passed by the learned Munsif Magistrate, First Class, Ranchi, to one under Section 409 read with Section 511 IPC, but maintained the sentence of two years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 200. The High Court has, however, reduced the order of sentence to six months' rigorous imprisonment and to a fine of Rs 50.

    2. The appellant was the Senior Godown Keeper of the Food Corporation of India. The prosecution case, in short, was that on 2-3-1968 at 8.00 p.m in the night on a confidential information, the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Ranchi, raided the Central Godown of the Food Corporation of India along with the Town Inspector and found that a truck bearing Registration No. BRN 4281 standing in front of the godown, and that 22 bags of wheat had already been loaded in the truck. It was learnt by him that the said bags were being loaded under the instruction of the appellant. The truck along with the said 22 bags of wheat was seized. The police also seized certain documents including the release Order 115 in favour of Hatia Consumers, Co-operative Society in respect of 1200 bags of wheat. The appellant was, accordingly, prosecuted for criminal breach of trust.

    3. Out of 14 witnesses mentioned in the charge-sheet, only 6 were examined at the trial. The Investigating Officer was, however, not examined by the prosecution.

    4. The defence plea of the appellant was that the loading of the truck in question was being done for despatching wheat to Hatia Consumers' Cooperative Society in accordance with the said release Order 115 which was seized by the police. The said release order, however, was not produced by the police at the trial. The learned Munsif Magistrate while convicting the appellant by his order dated 7-9-1973 recorded therein as follows:

    “Accused Chittaranjan Choudhury in his statement under section 342 CrPC has of course, stated that he was sending the wheat to HEC as per release order. This fact was hence within his knowledge and therefore it was his duty to produce the release order but unfortunately neither any release order has been produced by him nor any attempt was made by him to bring it on record.”

    5. As the release order was seized by the police and not produced at the trial, the appellant could not place any reliance thereon in proof of his plea that the loading was being made in the truck in question for despatching wheat as per the release order. Before the High Court also it was contended on behalf of the appellant that the said bags of wheat were being despatched to Hatia Consumers' Cooperative Society. As there was no material in support of the said contention, the High Court rejected the same.

    6. It is curious that although the defence plea was based on the said release Order 115, the same was not filed before the trial court or at any stage of the proceeding. Our attention has been drawn to the evidence of PW 2, Rajendra Narain Singh, the City Deputy Superintendent of Police, Ranchi. In the course of his evidence. PW 2 stated that he perused the Gate Pass-Book and also the printed release orders dated 7-3-1968 in which delivery was marked in respect of the goods which were despatched outside. This evidence is noticed only to be rejected. In our opinion where, as in the instant case, the defence is founded on a relevant and vital document seized from the custody of the accused and not deliberately produced, it is difficult to sustain the conviction of the accused. It was the duty of the prosecution to produce the release Order 115 in order to remove all doubts by showing that the goods which were being despatched by the appellant, were not covered by the release order. The said statement of PW 2 that in the release orders dated 7-3-1968 delivery was marked in respect of the goods which were despatched outside without producing the release order in question, is no evidence at all and is also no answer to the defence plea that the said 22 bags of wheat were loaded in the truck as per the release Order 115. The learned Munsif Magistrate completely overlooked that the said release order was seized from the custody of the appellant.

    7. The learned Magistrate was, therefore, not justified in rejecting the defence plea on the ground of non-production of the release order by him. The High Court also was not justified in rejecting the defence plea as there was no material on record in support of the same. As the release order, which is a very relevant and vital document, had been deliberately withheld by the prosecution, the conviction of the appellant cannot be sustained.

    8. For the reasons aforesaid, the conviction and sentence of the appellant are set aside and he is acquitted of the charge under Section 409 read with Section 511 IPC. The bail bond is discharged.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chittaranjan Choudhury v. State Of Bihar .
    (Jan 28, 1987)