AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2 of the Partition Act
  • Section 3(1) of the Partition Act, 1893
  • Order 20 Rule 18 of the Code of Civil Procedure
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2 of the Partition Act
  • Section 3(1) of the Partition Act, 1893
  • Order 20 Rule 18 of the Code of Civil Procedure
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns a two-storeyed building with 200 square yards (167.22 sq. metres) of land at R/845, New Rajendra Nagar, New Delhi. In 1973 a suit for partition was filed. A preliminary decree, passed on compromise, declared that each of the six parties held a one-sixth share. Because the property was found indivisible by metes and bounds, three parties (the two plaintiffs and Defendant 2) asked for a public auction under Section 2 of the Partition Act, 1893, while Defendant 1 and Defendant 3 applied under Section 3(1) to buy out the others at a valuation.

A Single Judge ordered a public auction; the Division Bench reversed that order and directed that the shares of the applicants opposing auction be sold to either of the Section 3(1) applicants. The present appeal was filed by the two plaintiffs and Defendants 3 and 4 before the Supreme Court.

Pending appeal, the Court twice appointed valuers, ultimately accepting a September 1986 valuation by Col. R.K. Kohli (Retd.), who assessed the market value of the property at Rs 4,92,000.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Sections 2 and 3 of the Partition Act, the property should be sold by public auction or allotted to a single shareholder willing to purchase the others’ shares.
  2. What is the correct method for determining the market value of land with a building standing on it for purposes of a Section 3(1) purchase—separate land-and-building valuation or capitalization of rental value as a single unit?
  3. What final directions should be issued for completion of partition given the protracted history of the suit?

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent 1 (Shri Dharam Pal Kapoor)

  • Challenged the Kohli valuation for separately valuing land and building; contended the unit should be valued on a rental-capitalization basis, relying on State of Kerala v. P.P. Hassan Koya.
  • Asserted that the total market value could not exceed Rs 1,20,000.
  • Urged that the property be put to auction so the highest bid could determine market value, and argued that the plaintiffs, having earlier sought an auction, could not now oppose it.

Appellants (Plaintiffs and Defendants 3 & 4)

  • Accepted the Kohli valuation as a minimum but maintained the market value was at least Rs 6,00,000.
  • Offered to purchase Respondents 1 and 2’s shares for Rs 1,00,000 each (total Rs 2,00,000) if Respondent 1 failed to deposit the valuation amount.
  • Opposed a fresh public auction, asserting that Respondent 1 sought only to delay proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Kerala v. P.P. Hassan Koya, AIR 1968 SC 1201; (1968) 3 SCR 459 In valuing land with buildings for compensation, land and building should be treated as a single unit; rental-capitalization may be an appropriate method. The Court noted that the decision does not mandate rental-capitalization in every case and accepted the valuer’s “building and land method” as suitable for the present facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first addressed valuation. It observed that Col. Kohli considered size, location, renovation in 1967, and prevailing market rates, fixing land at Rs 2250 per sq. metre and depreciated building value at Rs 1,16,000, totalling Rs 4,92,000. Respondent 1 had not objected during valuation proceedings, and his suggested figure of Rs 1,20,000 was found unrealistic.

On the legal method of valuation, the Court distinguished Hassan Koya, holding that capitalization of rental income is not the exclusive method; the chosen “building and land” approach was appropriate in the circumstances.

The Court rejected Respondent 1’s renewed request for an auction, emphasizing that a party who invoked Section 3(1) to purchase others’ shares cannot “blow hot and cold” by simultaneously demanding a public auction.

Balancing delay (the suit dated from 1973) against the need for finality, the Court crafted conditional directions: Respondent 1 is given two months to deposit Rs 4,10,000 (Rs 82,000 to each of the five other one-sixth shareholders). Failing that, the appellants may, within a further two months, deposit Rs 2,00,000 (Rs 1,00,000 each to Respondents 1 and 2) and obtain the entire property. These directions reconcile Sections 2 and 3 of the Partition Act while expediting partition.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed; the Delhi High Court’s order is set aside. The Court affirms the Kohli valuation (Rs 4,92,000) and lays down a two-stage mechanism:

  • Respondent 1 may acquire the entire property by depositing Rs 4,10,000 within two months, after which a final decree will allot the property exclusively to him.
  • If he fails, the appellants may acquire it by depositing Rs 2,00,000 within the next two months, whereupon a final decree will allot the property to them jointly.

Direct implications are confined to the parties: they receive fixed monetary compensation or exclusive title based on compliance with the deposit schedule. No broader legal precedent is announced beyond reaffirming that valuation methods may vary with facts and that a Section 3(1) applicant cannot simultaneously demand a public auction. Each side bears its own costs.

    Kishore Chand Kapoor (Dr) And Others v. Dharam Pal Kapoor And Others

    M.M Dutt, J.— The special leave has already been granted. As elaborate arguments were made at the hearing of the special leave petition, we proceed to dispose of the appeal on merits.

    2. The appeal has been preferred by the two plaintiffs and Defendants 3 and 4 and is directed against the order of the Delhi High Court under Section 3(1) of the Partition Act, 1893.

    3. The preliminary decree was passed by a learned Single Judge of the High Court in terms of a compromise entered into between the parties. By the compromise decree the share of each party was declared as one-sixth in the suit property comprising 200 sq yds of land and a two-storeyed building standing thereon. Appellants 1 and 4, who were the plaintiffs, applied for passing a final decree under Order 20 Rule 18 of the Code of Civil Procedure. A Commissioner for Partition was appointed by the High Court. According to the report of the Commissioner, the building was incapable of being divided by metes and bounds. The finding of the Commissioner was accepted by all the parties in the suit. The plaintiff-appellants filed an application for sale of the property by public auction under Section 2 of the Partition Act. Respondent 2, Smt Savitri Devi Behl, who was Defendant 2 in the suit, also made a similar application. Thus three of the parties in the suit, having in aggregate a half share in the property, applied for the sale of the property in question by public auction under Section 2 of the Partition Act. On the other hand, Respondent 1 and Appellant 2, who were respectively Defendants 1 and 3, made two separate applications praying for the purchase of the shares of the other parties at a valuation. On the said applications, the learned Single Judge of the High Court directed that the property should be sold by public auction and the highest bid in that auction would determine the true market value of the property. On an appeal by defendant-Respondent 1, the Division Bench of the High Court rightly set aside the said order and directed that the shares of the plaintiff-appellants and Respondent 2 would be sold to either of the applicants, namely, Appellant 3 and Respondent 1. Being aggrieved by the said order of the Division Bench of the High Court, the appellants have preferred the instant appeal.

    4. The position now is that Appellant 3, Smt Ram Dulari Dhawan, who made an application under Section 3(1) of the Partition Act, is no longer willing to purchase the property herself. Now it is only Respondent 1, Shri Dharam Pal Kapoor, who is only willing to purchase the shares of the other parties so that the entire property may be allotted to him.

    5. The suit has been pending since 1973 and, with a view to expediting the partition of the property, this Court without deciding the correctness or otherwise of the order of the Division Bench of the High Court, by its order dated April 13, 1986 appointed Shri O.P Goel, a Government Valuer, to value the property in dispute and to submit his report on or before August 8, 1986. This Court, however, by its order dated August 4, 1986, rejected the report of the valuer since it related to the year 1978. By agreement of the parties, Col.R.K Kohli (Retd.) was appointed a valuer of the property. Column Kohli was directed to value the property as on the date of the order after giving notice to the parties and to submit the report to this Court within four weeks from that date. Column Kohli has since submitted his report of valuation. It is stated in the report that the present market value (September 1986) of the property is worked on “building and land method”, that is, the depreciated value of the building plus the market value of the land as available to the owners in September 1986. In the opinion of the valuer, this is the most appropriate method of valuation in this case.

    6. The property is situate at R/845, New Rajendra Nagar, New Delhi, and, admittedly, defendant-Respondent 1, Shri Dharam Pal Kapoor, is in possession of the same. It appears that after taking into consideration the size, situation, location, emplacement and the utility, he came to the conclusion that the market value of the land should be at the rate of Rs 2250 per sq. meter. Accordingly, the total market value of the land at the above rate, as per the valuer, is Rs 3,76,250, and the depreciated value of the building is Rs 1,16,000. The total market value of the property, therefore, as found by the valuer, is Rs 4,92,250, say Rs 4,92,000.

    7. The learned counsel for Respondent 1 has challenged the mode of valuation of the property. It is submitted by him that the valuer was wrong in valuing the land and building separately. According to the learned counsel, the land and building should have been valued as one unit on the rental basis. Further, it is submitted by him that the value of the entire property in dispute could not have been more than Rs 1,20,000. In support of the said contention, the learned counsel has placed much reliance upon a decision of this Court in the State of Kerala v.P.P Hassan Koya AIR 1968 SC 1201, (1968) 3 SCR 459 relating to determination of compensation under the Land Acquisition Act. In that case, it has been held by this Court that in determining compensation payable in respect of land with buildings, compensation cannot be determined by assessing the value of the land and the “break-up value” of the buildings separately; the land and the building constitute one unit and the value of the entire unit must be determined with all its advantages and its potentialities. The trial court in that case proceeded to capitalize the net annual rental having regard to the rate of return of 3½ per cent from gilt-edged securities by multiplying it by 35 times inasmuch as there was clear evidence about the rental of the building. This Court while approving the method adopted by the trial court in valuing the building observed that it cannot be laid down as a general rule applicable to all situations and circumstances that a multiple approximately equal to the return from gilt-edged securities prevailing at the relevant time forms an adequate basis for finding out the market value of the land. It cannot, therefore, be said that the method of capitalization of the rent actually received or which might reasonably be received from the land or the building is the only method that should be adopted in valuing land and building. In the instant case, the valuer has taken into consideration all relevant factors and has valued the property in question at Rs 4,92,000. No objection seems to have been taken by Respondent 1 before the valuer. It is difficult for us to accept the contention of Respondent 1 that the market value of the property in suit comprising a two-storeyed building and land measuring 167.22 sq mtrs cannot be more than Rs 1,20,000. In this connection, it may be pointed out that the building had been renovated and new additions were made in 1967. This fact has also been noticed by the valuer.

    8. It is next contended on behalf of Respondent 1, that, as prayed by the plaintiff-appellant and Respondent 2, the property should be put up for auction-sale so that the highest bid in the auction may determine the market value of the property. This was exactly the order that was passed by the learned Single Judge of the High Court, but Respondent 1 felt aggrieved by the said order and preferred an appeal to the Division Bench of the High Court. Such a contention is not only devoid of any merit, but also is not maintainable at the instance of Respondent 1, who has expressed his willingness by an application under Section 3(1) of the Partition Act to buy up the shares of the other parties at a valuation. Respondent 1, therefore, cannot be allowed to blow hot and cold. The contention is, therefore, rejected.

    9. There is also no merit in the contention of Respondent 1 that the plaintiff-appellants having prayed for the sale of the property by public auction under Section 2 of the Partition Act, cannot oppose the prayer of Respondent 1 for such sale. It appears to us that Respondent 1 being in possession of the property wants to prolong the proceedings as much as possible.

    10. It is submitted on behalf of the appellants that the valuation of the property, as made by the valuer, is low, but they will accept such valuation if Respondent 1 wants to purchase the shares of the other parties including the appellants on the basis of such valuation. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants that the market value of the property in dispute cannot be less than Rs 6 lakhs and in case Respondent 1 does not purchase the shares of the other parties on the basis of valuation made by the valuer, the appellants undertake to this Court to purchase the shares of Respondent 1 and of Respondent 2 on the basis of the valuation of the property at Rs 6 lakhs. In other words, the appellants offer to pay Rs 1 lakh to each of the Respondents 1 and 2.

    11. After considering the facts and circumstances of the case and the submissions made on behalf of the parties, we accept the valuation as made by Column Kohli (Retd.) at Rs 4,92,000. Respondent 1 will be entitled to purchase the shares of the appellants and Respondent 2 by paying to each of them a sum of Rs 82,000, that is, in all a sum of Rs 4,10,000. If the said sum of Rs 4,10,000 is deposited by Respondent 1 in the Delhi High Court within two months from the date, a final decree will be passed in the suit allotting the entire property to Respondent 1. The appellants and Respondent 2 will be entitled to withdraw their respective shares in the said sum of Rs 4,10,000 without furnishing any security. If, however, no such deposit is made within the period mentioned above, Respondent 1 will be debarred from purchasing the shares of the other parties and, in that case, the appellants will be entitled to purchase the shares of Respondents 1 and 2 by paying to each of them a sum of Rs 1 lakh, that is, in all a sum of Rs 2 lakhs as agreed to and undertaken by them. The said sum of Rs 2 lakhs shall be deposited by the appellants in the High Court within two months from the date of expiry of the period allowed to Respondent 1. If such deposit is made, the final decree will be passed allotting the entire property jointly to the appellants. Respondents 1 and 2 will be entitled to withdraw their respective shares in the said sum of Rs 2 lakhs, that is to say Rs 1 lakh each, without furnishing any security.

    12. The impugned order of the Delhi High Court is set aside. The appeal is disposed of accordingly. There will, however, be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kishore Chand Kapoor (Dr) And Others v. Dharam Pal Kapoor And Others
    (Oct 24, 1986)