Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The court heard Mr. A.P. Mohanty for the appellant and Mr. S. Markandeya for the respondents. The appellant’s services with the U.P. State Electricity Board, Lucknow were terminated with effect from December 31, 1967. The appellant held the post of Town Incharge. He was subsequently re-employed afresh as Substation Assistant on December 4, 1968 and was confirmed in that post, receiving a monthly salary during that period. This order addresses the legality of the 1967 termination in light of a cited precedent and determines consequential reliefs, including reinstatement and computation of back wages and other benefits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant’s termination of service with effect from December 31, 1967 constituted “retrenchment,” and if so, whether it was invalid for want of the prerequisite(s) for a valid retrenchment.
  2. What consequential reliefs flow from the finding of invalid retrenchment, including continuity of service, reinstatement, and entitlement to back wages and other benefits.
  3. How the monetary and non-monetary benefits should be computed, particularly in light of the appellant’s subsequent re-employment as Substation Assistant and the need to give credit for salary and allowances received during that period.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Submissions

  • On the respondents’ computation, an amount of “Rs 13,000 and odd” would be payable to the appellant. Respondents undertook to pay this amount within one month.

Appellant's Position

  • The appellant does not accept the respondents’ computation. He will, however, accept the payment of approximately Rs 13,000 without prejudice to all his contentions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mohan Lal v. Management of M/s Bharat Electronics Ltd., (1981) 3 SCR 518; (1981) 3 SCC 225; (1981) 58 FJR 467 Termination constituting retrenchment; absence of prerequisite(s) for valid retrenchment renders the termination invalid and inoperative. The appellant’s termination effective December 31, 1967 was held to constitute retrenchment and, due to absence of prerequisite(s), was treated as invalid and inoperative; the appellant is deemed to be in continuous service as Town Incharge without interruption.
Order in CMP 15708 of 1981 in CA 364 of 1981 In similar circumstances, the Labour Court was directed to compute benefits due pursuant to the Court’s decision. Following this precedent, the Court directed the Labour Court to compute the appellant’s back wages and other monetary and non-monetary benefits.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court anchored its decision on the ruling in Mohan Lal v. Management of M/s Bharat Electronics Ltd. Applying that decision, it concluded that the appellant’s termination from December 31, 1967 constituted retrenchment. Because the prerequisite(s) for a valid retrenchment were absent, the termination was invalid and inoperative.

From this conclusion, the Court held that the appellant is deemed to have continued in service as Town Incharge without interruption. Consequentially, he is entitled to arrears of salary and other benefits that can be quantified. However, given the “peculiar feature” that the appellant was re-employed as Substation Assistant from December 4, 1968 and confirmed in that post, the Court specified that any computation of arrears and benefits must give credit for the salary and allowances already received during that re-employment.

Addressing the respondents’ stated computation (approximately Rs 13,000) and the appellant’s non-acceptance of that figure, the Court determined that a formal computation was necessary. Consistent with its approach in CMP 15708 of 1981 in CA 364 of 1981, the Court directed the Labour Court to compute the appellant’s monetary and non-monetary entitlements pursuant to the present decision, while ensuring that the interim payment of about Rs 13,000—payable within one month—is credited against the final determination.

The Court set timelines: the appellant’s reposting as Town Incharge must occur forthwith and not later than a fortnight; the Labour Court must complete the computation within six months and submit a report to the Court; the balance of the computed amount shall be paid within such reasonable time as the Labour Court determines.

Holding and Implications

Termination held to be invalid retrenchment; continuity of service affirmed. The appellant’s termination with effect from December 31, 1967 is treated as invalid and inoperative. The appellant is deemed to be in continuous service as Town Incharge without break.

Reinstatement and computation ordered. The appellant shall be reposted as Town Incharge forthwith and not later than a fortnight from the date of the order. The Labour Court is directed to compute back wages and other monetary and non-monetary benefits within six months, giving credit for the interim payment of approximately Rs 13,000 (to be paid within one month) and for salary and allowances received during the appellant’s re-employment as Substation Assistant. The balance shall be paid within a reasonable time as determined by the Labour Court. The respondents shall pay Rs 1,000 as costs to the appellant.

Implications: The immediate effect is reinstatement and a structured mechanism for quantifying and paying back wages and benefits, including an interim payment and a credit for sums already received. The order applies the cited precedent to the parties’ dispute and sets no broader rule beyond its reliance on the existing authority.

    Hari Mohan Rastogi v. Labour Court And Another

    Order

    1. We heard Mr A.P Mohanty, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr S. Markandeya, learned counsel for respondents.

    2. In view of the decision of this Court in Mohan Lal v. Bharat Electronics Ltd. (1981) 3 SCR 518, (1981) 3 SCC 225, (1981) 58 FJR 467, the termination of service of the appellant by respondent U.P State Electricity Board, Lucknow on and from December 31, 1967 will constitute retrenchment and prerequisite for a valid order of retrenchment being absent has to be treated as invalid and inoperative. The appellant will continue to be in service as town Incharge continuously without interruption and any break from the date of ineffective termination of service.

    3. Now that the appellant continues to be in service as town Incharge, he will be entitled to arrears of salary and other benefits which can be computed in terms of money. One peculiar feature of this case is that the appellant was reemployed afresh as Substation Assistant on December 4, 1968 and was confirmed in that post. While rendering his service as Substation Assistant he was in receipt of monthly salary. Therefore, while working out the monetary benefit with regard to the arrears of back wages and other monetary benefits, credit will have to be given for what the appellant has received as and by way of salary and all other allowances.

    4. Mr Markandeya for the employer stated that on the computation made by the respondent Management, it will have to pay Rs 13,000 and odd to the appellant. This amount will be paid by respondent-Management to the appellant within one month from today, and the appellant will accept the same without prejudice to all his contentions.

    5. As the appellant does not accept the computation made by the respondent-Management, it would be necessary to determine the. monetary benefit to which appellant would be entitled. In this connection, we would like to follow a precedent in CMP 15708 of 1981 in CA 364 of 1981 wherein in similar circumstance, we directed the Labour Court to compute the benefits which the appellant was entitled to, pursuant to the decision of this Court.

    6. We, therefore, direct that the appellant shall be reposted as town Incharge forthwith and not later than a fortnight from today. We direct the Labour Court to compute the back wages payable by respondent to the appellant pursuant to this decision and this computation may be both of monetary benefits and non-monetary benefits to which the appellant is entitled after giving credit for the amount of Rs 13,000 which would be paid to the appellant within one month from today. The balance shall be paid within such reasonable time as may be determined by the Labour Court. The Labour Court do compute monetary and non-monetary benefits within a period of six months from today. The report will also be submitted to this Court. Respondent shall pay Rs 1000 as and by way of costs to the appellant.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hari Mohan Rastogi v. Labour Court And Another
    (Sep 14, 1983)