The rule of “last come, first go” envisaged in Section 25-G is not an inflexible rule and variations from it may be justified in extraordinary situations. The Management has a discretion to depart from the rule provided it acts bona fide and there are valid and justifiable reasons for such departure. Absence of mala fides by itself is no absolution from the rule and the burden is on the Management to substantiate the special grounds. But once valid and justifiable reasons are made out Section 25-G will be vindicated and not violated. (Paras 5 and 6)
Om Oil and Oilseeds Exchange Ltd., Delhi v. Workmen, AIR 1966 SC 1657 : 1966 Supp SCR 74 : (1967) 2 SCJ 132, relied on
Further, Section 25-G insists on the rule being applied categorywise i.e only those who fall in the same category shall suffer retrenchment in accordance with the rule. Same seniority list maintained for all the workers is a telling circumstance to show that they fall in the same category. Within the same category if grades for scales of pay, based on length of service etc. are evolved, that process cannot amount to creation of separate categories.
(Para 7)
Labour and Services — Reinstatement — Relief in lieu of — Workshop in which the workmen were employed prior to their retrenchment since closed — In lieu of their reinstatement one year's wages calculated on the Wage Board scale directed to be paid for each such workman
(Para 10)
Labour and Services — Reinstatement — Back wages — Court does not sympathise with the Management which drags workmen up to Supreme Court to justify retrenchment and when the court orders reinstatement with back wages, pleads for relief in payment of arrears — Even then, because of inordinate delay due to long pendency of the case, the court granted some reliefs to the Management — Practice and Procedure
(Para 9)
Labour and Services — Practice and procedure — New plea based on fact not to be allowed — Plea not raised before tribunal and High Court not permitting it to be taken — In absence of any foundation laid in written statement about the plea, Supreme Court cannot reopen it and explore its tangibility
(Para 3)
Appeals dismissedR/4868.CL