AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • limitation.12. Sec. 5 of the Limitation Act,
  • 15AA (3) of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955
  • 15AA(3) of Rajasthan Tenancy Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • limitation.12. Sec. 5 of the Limitation Act,
  • 15AA (3) of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955
  • 15AA(3) of Rajasthan Tenancy Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Rajesh Balia, J. heard learned counsel for the petitioner; no one was present for the respondent. The petitioner challenged (i) the order of the Board of Revenue dated 18.9.90 (Annex. 6) and (ii) the order of the Assistant Colonisation Commissioner, Indira Gandhi Canal Project, Chhatargarh dated 13.2.85 (Annex. 4), by which land forming part of Muraba No. 51/38 of Chak No. 14 LKD was allotted in favour of respondent No. 4, Bhagirath.

Relevant factual chronology as stated in the opinion: on 27.4.1983 Bhagirath was allotted 13 bighas 8 biswas as a land-less person (5 bighas 14 biswas in command area and 7 bighas 14 biswas in uncommand area). A subsequent allotment of 8 bighas (the land in dispute) was made to Bhagirath on 13.2.1985. The petitioner (Hiralal) filed an appeal before the Revenue Appellate Authority on 29.10.1987 challenging that allotment.

The Revenue Appellate Authority (order dated 23.05.1988) allowed the appeal on merits although it was found that Hiralal had come to know of the impugned allotment on 15.11.1985 and filed the appeal on 29.10.1987. The allottee Bhagirath challenged that order by revision before the Board of Revenue. The Board held that there was no sufficient cause for delay, that the Revenue Appellate Authority should not have condoned the delay, and on merits found the allotment in favour of Bhagirath was not void ab initio. Aggrieved by the Board's order dated 18.10.90, the petitioner filed the present petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Revenue Appellate Authority rightly exercised its power under Section 5 of the Limitation Act to condone delay in filing the appeal by the petitioner.
  2. Whether the allotment of the disputed land in favour of Bhagirath (13.2.1985) was void ab initio or could be set aside on the grounds advanced by the petitioner (including the petitioner's claim under Section 15AA(3) of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955, and the contention that the allotted land was not adjacent to lands already held by the allottee).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Petitioner's) Arguments

  • The petitioner appealed against the allotment of 8 bighas on the ground that he had applied for declaration of Khatedari rights under Section 15AA(3) of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955, and that the land allotted to Bhagirath was not adjacent to land already allotted to Bhagirath and therefore could not have been validly allotted under the Rules.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent/allottee's specific legal arguments in this Court beyond the fact that Bhagirath filed a revision before the Board of Revenue contesting the Revenue Appellate Authority's order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P.K Ramachandran v. State of Kerala (1) Condonation of delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act requires the court to record satisfaction that the explanation for the delay is reasonable/satisfactory; courts cannot extend limitation on equitable grounds without such satisfaction. The Court relied on this authority to support the Board of Revenue's conclusion that the Revenue Appellate Authority erred in condoning delay without sufficient objective material and that the condonation order could not be sustained.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court agreed with the Board of Revenue that the Revenue Appellate Authority should not have condoned the delay in filing the appeal. The court emphasized that Section 5 of the Limitation Act permits admitting an appeal after the limitation period only when the court is satisfied that there was a sufficient cause preventing filing within time, and that such satisfaction must rest on objective material rather than subjective conclusion. The opinion explained that satisfaction under Section 5 requires objective assessment of evidence after hearing both sides.

The court referred to P.K Ramachandran v. State of Kerala to illustrate that a condonation order must record satisfaction about the reasonableness of the delay and that courts cannot extend limitation on mere equitable grounds. Applying that principle, and given the finding that the petitioner knew of the impugned order on 15.11.1985 yet filed the appeal only on 29.10.1987 without sufficient explanation, the court held that the Revenue Appellate Authority's condonation was unjustified.

On the merits, the court concurred with the Board of Revenue's finding that the allotment in favour of Bhagirath was not void ab initio and therefore could not be ignored. The court accepted the Board's reasoning that the petitioner's application under Section 15AA(3) was not in respect of the particular land, that no application for allotment of that land by the petitioner under the Rules of 1975 was pending when the allotment was made, and that adjacency of land to holdings already held by the allottee was not an essential requirement rendering the later allotment invalid.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

Holding: The petition is dismissed. The Court held that (a) the Revenue Appellate Authority erred in condoning the delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act without sufficient objective material, and (b) on merits the allotment to Bhagirath was not void ab initio and the allottee's accrued rights could not be disturbed.

Implications: The direct consequence is that the Board of Revenue's order upholding the allotment to Bhagirath stands and the petitioner's challenge fails. The Court recorded no order as to costs. The opinion does not state that it establishes any new precedent beyond applying the settled principle regarding condonation of delay under Section 5 and affirming the Board's factual and legal conclusions.

    Hiralal Loonkaransar, Bikaner v. Board Of Revenue Ajmer & Others

    Rajesh Balia, J.:— Heard learned counsel for the petitioner.

    2. None present for the respondent.

    3. The petitioner challenges the order of Board of Revenue dt. 18.9.90 (Annex. 6) and order of Assistant Colonisation Commissioner, Indira Gandhi Canal Project, Chhatargarh dt. 13.2.85 (Annex. 4) by which land in question which is a part of Muraba No. 51/38 of Chak No. 14 LKD was allotted in favour of the respondent No. 4 Bhagirath.

    4. The brief facts necessary for the present purposes are that in the first instance by order dt. 27.4.1983, 13 bighas 8 biswas land was allotted in favour of Bhagirath as a land-less person. Out of these land 5 bighas 14 biswas land in command area and 7 bighas and 14 biswas land in uncommand area. On 27.03.1984 said Bhagirath Singh applied for being landless person and has been allotted land less than the measurement of land which he is entitled held additional allotment in favour of additional can be made whose land in dispute measuring 8 bighas was allotted to said Bhagirath on 13.2.1985 by the Competent Officer.

    5. Against this order of allotment of 8 bighas land on 13.2.85 the present petitioner preferred an appeal before the Revenue Appellate Authority on 29.10.87 inter alia on the ground that he has applied for being a Khatedar tenant of land u/S. 15AA (3) of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955 and excluding the land allotted vide impugned order because it was not adjacent to the land already allotted to the respondent-Bhagirath. The same could not be allotted to him under the Rules.

    6. The Revenue Appellate Authority vide its order dt. 23.05.1988 found that in fact present petitioner Hiralal had come to know about the order of impugned allotment on 15.11.85 and the appeal has been filed on 29.10.87, almost two years after he had come to know about the order. Yet for no reason he thought it fit not to dismiss the appeal on the grounds of limitation and allowed the appeal on merit.

    7. The order of the Revenue Appellate Authority was challenged by the allottee Bhagirath before the Board of Revenue by way of revision. Learned Member of the Board found there being no cause shown which prevented the present petitioner from filing appeal within time, much less sufficient cause for not filing the appeal within limitation, the exercise of power by the Revenue Appellate Authority in condoning the delay was not judicious but was on extraneous consideration.

    8. On this finding Board of Revenue was of the opinion that appeal of the petitioner-Hiralal ought to have been rejected on the ground of limitation alone.

    9. On the merit also it was found by the learned Member of the Board of Revenue that allotment made in favour of the said Bhagirath could not be said to be nullity which from the inception could be ignored. In these circumstances at the instance of the present petitioner said allotment could not have been set at naught. It was also found by the Board that application for declaration of his Khatedari rights by the applicant u/S. 15AA(3) was not in respect of particular land in question. Therefore his application could not come in the way of treating the application of another-applicant for allotment of additional land, which could be allotted to him under the Rules of 1975. It was also pointed out by the Revenue that while allowing the appeal no application for allotment of land in question on behalf of present petition was pending under the Rules of 1975 and therefore pendency of petitioner's application u/S. 15AA(3) of Rajasthan Tenancy Act could not come in the way of treating the application for allotment of the land which was recorded as ‘rakba-raj’ to the respondent-Bhagirath. It was also found that merely because land allotted to Bhagirath later on was not already adjacent to the allottee in 1983 would not affect the later allotment. Because it is not the essential requirement that land of which allotment is made to make good the holdings of landless person upto permissible limit, must be situated adjacent to lands already held by or allotted to such landless person or that allotment of distant land in favour of the said allottee to the extent permissible to hold under the Rules will make the allotment invalid.

    10. Aggrieved with the order of Board of Revenue dt. 18.10.90 the petitioner has filed this petition.

    11. Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and perused the material placed before the Court I am of the opinion that Board was right in holding that the application for condonation of delay u/S. 5 of the Limitation Act could not have been allowed by the Revenue Appellate Authority in the circumstances. Having come to the conclusion that appellant has come to know about the impugned order dt. 15.11.85 and has not filed until 29.1.87, there being no cause whatever explaining delay in filing the appeal after he has come to know about the impugned allotment order, the Revenue Appellate Authority could not have condoned the delay unless satisfied about existence of the sufficient cause which prevented the appellant from filing the appeal within limitation.

    12. Sec. 5 of the Limitation Act, which empowers a Court to admit any appeal or application after expiry of the period of limitation is pre-conditioned with satisfaction of that Court about existence of sufficient cause, that could have prevented the appellant/applicant from filing the appeal or application as the case may be. Such satisfaction can only be reached on existence of some objective material. When the Court is empowered to exercise certain discretion on satisfying itself about existence of certain circumstances it does not depend on subjective satisfaction of the Court but on objective material and objective assessment of material before it after hearing both the sides, lis between whom it has to decide. The Court does not enjoy the power of deciding the issue about admitting the appeal, application or suits beyond period of limitation unless and except subject to conditions prescribed under the law.

    13. In this connection reference may be made to P.K Ramachandran v. State of Kerala (1). It was a case in which State of Kerala filed a first appeal before the High Court, which was barred by limitation. An application for condonation of delay was also filed along with application. The High Court allowed the application for condonation of delay with the following order:

    “This is an application to condone the delay of 565 days in filing an appeal. The petition is seriously opposed by the respondent. But taking into consideration the averments contained in the affidavit filed in support of the petition condone the delay, we are inclined to allow the petition. The petition stands allowed.”

    14. The Apex Court reversed the order. It observed:

    “It would be noticed from a perusal of the impugned order that the court has not recorded any satisfaction that the explanation for the delay was either reasonable or satisfactory, which is an essential pre—requisite to condonation of delay…………………………………………. Law of limitation may harshly affect a particular party but it has to be applied with all its rigour when the statute so prescribes and the courts have no power to extend the period of limitation on equitable grounds. The discretion exercised by the High Court was, thus, neither proper nor judicious. The order condoning the delay cannot be sustained.”

    15. The petition deserves to be dismissed on this ground alone.

    16. Even on merit I am in agreement with the conclusion of the Board that order of allotment could not be said to be for any reason void ab initio so as could be ignored. Therefore, rights which have accrued to the allottee could not be disturbed at the instant of negligent litigant particularly when he does not himself has vested right to the land in question.

    17. Accordingly this petition fails and is hereby dismissed with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hiralal Loonkaransar, Bikaner v. Board Of Revenue Ajmer & Others
    (Aug 1, 2000)