Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Nanha, the petitioner, was the owner of land measuring 7 Kanals 1 marla and executed an agreement of sale dated 27.12.1991 in favour of Risala, respondent No. 1, for Rs. 1.5 lacs. The petitioner failed to execute the sale deed as per the agreement, prompting Risala to file a suit for specific performance. The Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kaithal, decreed the suit on 15.1.1999, granting possession and directing execution of the sale deed within one month upon receipt of the balance sale consideration of Rs. 30,000.

An appeal by the petitioner was dismissed on 2.5.1993. Subsequently, Risala sought and obtained permission on 15.11.2003 to deposit the balance sale consideration, which was deposited on 17.11.2003. The petitioner filed an application under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act to rescind the agreement for non-payment of the balance consideration within the stipulated period; this application was dismissed by the trial court on 4.6.2005, approving the deposit made by the decree holder.

The present petition challenges the dismissal of the rescission application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decree holder (respondent No. 1) was obliged to deposit the balance sale consideration within one month from the judgment dated 15.1.1999, and if failure to do so entitled the petitioner to rescind the agreement under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act.
  2. Whether the Court had the power to extend the time for deposit of the balance sale consideration beyond the stipulated period.
  3. The effect of the appellate stay and subsequent dismissal of the appeal on the timing and validity of the deposit of the balance sale consideration.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The decree holder was required to deposit the balance sale consideration within one month of the decree dated 15.1.1999 but failed to do so.
  • This failure constituted non-compliance with the decree, entitling the petitioner to rescind the agreement under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act.
  • Relied on precedents holding that non-deposit within the stipulated period results in the right to rescind the agreement (Onkar Nath v. Basheer and others; Chanda v. Rattni and another).

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The appeal filed by petitioner stayed the operation of the decree, and the decree holder deposited the balance sale consideration within the extended timeframe after dismissal of the appeal.
  • The Court has inherent power under Section 148 of the Code of Civil Procedure to extend time even if the balance sale consideration is not deposited within the original stipulated period.
  • Relied on Supreme Court and High Court judgments (Yeshoda and another v. K. Nagarajan; Harbans Singh Grewal v. Puran Singh; Gurbachan Singh v. Bachan Singh; Mohinder Singh v. Gurdial Singh) supporting the extension of time in such circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Onkar Nath v. Basheer and others (1985-2) 88 Punjab Law Reporter 432 Non-deposit of balance sale consideration within stipulated period entitles rescission of agreement. Referenced by petitioner to support rescission claim; court found it not applicable due to subsequent deposit and extension of time.
Chanda v. Rattni and another, 1999 (4) RCR (Civil) 621 Same principle as above regarding rescission for non-payment within stipulated time. Same as above.
Harbans Singh Grewal v. Puran Singh (1991 (1) R.R.R 332) In absence of default clause in decree, Court may extend time under Section 148 CPC. Applied to hold that since no dismissal clause was in decree, time could be extended.
Suraj Singh v. Rajnarain Lal and another, AIR 1984 Patna 155 Power of Court under Section 148 CPC to extend time when decree is silent on consequences of delay. Supported the principle of time extension in absence of default clause.
Yeshoda and another v. K. Nagarajan, 1997 (1) RCR (Civil) 583 : (1996) 11 SCC 228 Court has discretion to enlarge time for compliance with decree; non-compliance does not automatically entitle rescission. Held decisive by the Court to reject rescission claim and uphold time extension.
Gurbachan Singh v. Bachan Singh and others, 1997 (2) RCR (Civil) 130 Supports extension of time for deposit of balance sale consideration beyond stipulated period. Reinforced Court’s conclusion on discretionary power to extend time.
Mohinder Singh v. Gurdial Singh and another, 1996 (3) RCR (Civil) 679 Similar principle of Court’s power to extend time despite delay in deposit. Applied to affirm extension of time in present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the operative part of the decree dated 15.1.1999, noting that the decree granted one month for execution of the sale deed upon receipt of the balance sale consideration but did not include a default clause that non-payment would result in dismissal of the suit. The Court referred to Harbans Singh Grewal and Suraj Singh cases to establish that in the absence of such a clause, time granted in the decree can be extended under Section 148 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The Court then analyzed the effect of the appeal filed by the petitioner, which stayed the operation of the decree shortly after it was passed. Since the appeal was dismissed only in 2003, the Court found that the deposit made by the decree holder shortly thereafter was timely, considering the stay and the permission granted by the Court to deposit the balance sale consideration.

Relying heavily on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Yeshoda and another v. K. Nagarajan, the Court rejected the argument that non-compliance within the originally stipulated period automatically entitled rescission. The Court emphasized its discretionary power to extend time for compliance with decrees under Section 148 CPC.

Given the minimal delay before the stay and the subsequent timely deposit after dismissal of the appeal, the Court concluded that no abnormal delay occurred, and that the extension of time was justified.

Accordingly, the Court upheld the dismissal of the petitioner’s application under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act seeking rescission of the agreement.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed and the order dated 4.6.2005 passed by the learned trial Court dismissing the rescission application is upheld.

The direct effect of this decision is that the decree holder’s delay in depositing the balance sale consideration is excused by the Court’s discretion to extend time, especially in light of the appellate stay. The petitioner is not entitled to rescind the agreement under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act on the ground of delayed payment. No new precedent is established; the Court simply applied existing principles regarding time extension and discretionary relief under Section 148 CPC and the Specific Relief Act.

    Nanha v. Risala And Another .

    S.N Aggarwal, J. — Nanha petitioner was the owner of land measuring 7 Kanals 1 marla for which he had executed an agreement of sale dated 27.12.1991 in favour of Risala, respondent No. 1. The sale consideration was Rs. 1.5 lacs. The petitioner did not execute the sale deed in compliance with the agreement of sale dated 27.12.1991 on which Risala, respondent filed a civil suit for specific performance of agreement of sale dated 27.12.1991 The suit was decreed by the Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kaithal, vide judgment and decree dated 15.1.1999

    2. The following was the operative part of the judgment dated 15.12.1999 :—

    “It is ordered that the suit of the plaintiff succeeds and accordingly a decree for possession qua the suit land by way of specific performance of the aforesaid agreement, is hereby passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants with costs. The defendants are hereby granted one month time from the date of this judgment to get the sale deed executed in favour of the plaintiff qua the suit land subject to receipt of balance sale consideration of Rs. 30,000/-. However, the expenses regarding registration and stamp etc. shall be borne by the plaintiff. Since after the execution of the agreement to sell dated 27.12.1991, by dint of judgment and decree dated 28.2.1992 handed down in civil suit No. 279 of 1992, titled Smt. Krishan v. Nanha, defendant No. 2, Smt. Krishani wife of defendant No. 1, Nanha has become owner of the suit land, so she is also directed to join defendant No. 1 in due execution and registration of the sale deed.”

    3. An appeal was filed by the petitioner but it was dismissed on 2.5.1993

    4. Respondent No. 1 moved an application 29.5.2003 for permission to deposit the balance sale consideration. That application was allowed by the Court on 15.11.2003 The respondents had deposited the balance sale consideration on 17.11.2003

    5. The petitioner had also filed an application under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act with the prayer that agreement dated 27.11.1991 be rescinded because of non payment of balance sale consideration within the stipulated period. That application was dismissed by the learned trial Court vide impugned order dated 4.6.2005 and the balance sale consideration deposited by the decree holder on 19.11.2003 was approved.

    6. Hence, the present petition.

    7. The submission of learned counsel for the petitioner was that Risala, respondent No. 1 decree holder was required to deposit the balance sale consideration within a period of one month from the passing of judgment and decree dated 15.1.1999 but he failed to deposit the amount in the stipulated period. Therefore, he had failed to comply with the judgment and decree dated 15.1.1999 He is not entitled to the extension of time as a right had accrued to the petitioner under Section 28 of the Specific Relief to get the agreement of sale deed dated 4.6.2005 be set aside. Reliance was placed on the-judgments of this Court reported as Onkar Nath v. Basheer and others, (1985-2) 88 Punjab Law Reporter 432 and Chanda v. Rattni and another, 1999 (4) RCR (Civil) 621 : (1999-3) 123 Punjab Law Reporter 123 (135?). In both these judgments, it was held that if the balance sale consideration was not deposited within the stipulated period, the petitioner becomes entitled to get the agreement of sale rescinded.

    8. On the other hand, the submission of the learned counsel for respondent No. 1 decree holder was that the judgment and decree were passed on 15.1.999 The petitioner had filed the appeal on 15.2.1999 Operation of the judgment dated 15.1.1999 was stayed by the Appellate Court on 19.2.1999 The appeal was dismissed by the learned Appellate Court on 2.5.2003 The respondent had filed an application for permission to deposit the balance sale consideration on 29.5.1993 which was allowed by the Court on 15.11.2003 subject to risk and responsibility of the decree holder. The balance sale consideration was deposited by the decree holder on 17.11.2003

    9. It was submitted that the amount was deposited in the stipulated period. It was further submitted that the Court has a right to extend the time even if the balance sale consideration was not deposited within stipulated period. Reliance was placed on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported as Yeshoda and another v. K. Nagarajan, 1997 (1) RCR (Civil) 583 : (1996) 11 Supreme Court Cases 228 and the judgments of this Court reported as Harbans Singh Grewal v. Puran Singh (deceased) by his L.Rs, 1991 (1) R.R.R 332 : (1990-2) PLR 267. Gurbachan Singh v. Bachan Singh and others, 1997 (2) RCR (Civil) 130 : (1997-1) 115 Punjab Law Reporter 355 and Mohinder Singh v. Gurdial Singh and another, 1996 (3) RCR (Civil) 679 : (1997-1) 115 PLR 73. In all these cases, it was held that even if balance sale consideration is not deposited in the stipulated period, time can be extended.

    10. Submissions have been considered.

    11. It deserves notice that in the operative part of the judgment and decree dated 15.1.1999, one month time was specified within which the judgment debtors were to execute the sale deed in favour of the decree holder on receipt of balance sale consideration of Rs. 30,000/-. It was not stipulated that if the balance sale consideration was not deposited by the decree holder, then the suit should be deemed to have been dismissed. In other words, no defaulting clause was laid down. In Harbans Singh Grewal's case (supra), it was held by this Court as under :—

    “Furthermore, there was no direction in the decree that on failure to deposit the balance of the sale consideration of Rs. 36,000/- or a sum of Rs. 10,000/- towards expenses, the suit of the plaintiff was to be dismissed. In the absence of any such directions, time granted in the decree could be extended having resort to the provisions of Section 148 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In a such like matter Division Bench of the Patna High Court in Suraj Singh v. Rajnarain Lal and another, AIR 1984 Patna 155, held that power of the Court under Section 148 of the Code of Civil Procedure would be there to extend the time granted in the decree when there was nothing in the decree that non-payment of the amount within the time allowed would result in dismissal of the suit.”

    12. The other judgments relied upon by the counsel for respondent No. 1 also lay down the same view of law. In Yeshoda's case (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court was pleased to repel the argument that the Court cannot extend the time. It was observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as under :—

    “It is contended by Mr. Mahale, learned counsel for the petitioners, that after the expiry of the time prescribed by the Court, the petitioner has a right to seek rescission of the decree for specific performance for non-compliance. The Court, therefore, has no power to enlarge the time. We find no force in the contention. Section 148 CPC gives power to the Court to enlarge the time for complying with the orders of the Court from time to time. Under those circumstances, the court has correctly exercised the discretion since the amount came to be deposited within three months from the date of dismissal of the application under Section 28.”

    13. In view of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Yeshoda's case (supra), the judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner do not need discussion.

    14. In the present case, the judgment was passed by the trial Court on 15.1.1999 Appeal was filed by the petitioner on 15.2.1999 and the stay order was granted by the learned Lower Appellate Court on 19.2.1999 At the most, therefore, there was four days delay in depositing the balance sale consideration and thereafter the operation of the judgment and decree dated 15.1.1999 was stayed by the Appellate Court. The appeal was dismissed by the learned Lower Appellate Court on 2.5.2003 and the petitioner had filed an application on 29.5.2003 for permission to deposit the balance sale consideration. This application was accepted by the Court on 15.11.2003 at the risk and responsibility of the decree holder and the decree holder had deposited the balance sale consideration on 17.11.2003 i.e within two days when the order was passed by the Court. In these circumstances, therefore, no abnormal delay can be attributed to the respondent decree holder and it is a fit case where time deserves to be extended.

    15. Since proper case has been made out for extension of time, therefore, the application filed by the petitioner under Section 28 of the Specific Relief deserves to be dismissed. Therefore, there is no illegality or infirmity in the order dated 4.6.2005 passed by the learned trial Court in dismissing the application.

    No merit. Dismissed.

    Revision dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nanha v. Risala And Another .
    (Apr 27, 2007)